Historical Revisionism In The Easter Rising
This essay will examine the centenary commemoration of the 1916 rising with particular focus placed on the RTE television series Rebellion.1 An analysis of this drama will allow this essay to examine the manner in which the anniversary of the rising contributes to contemporary Irish identity.
The Easter Rising is a rebellion which took place between the 24th and 30th of April 1916 and resulted in 450 deaths including the execution of the fifteen leaders of the rebellion. The rising itself consisted of members of the Irish Citizens Army, the Irish Volunteers and the women's group, Cuman na mBan. The events which led up to the rising and the storming of the GPO began in 1913 with the denial of home rule and the Lockout which sought to protect
…show more content…
Dublin City Council unveiled a banner celebrating 1916 which depicts supposed faces of the rising in the figures of Charles Stewart Parnell, John Redmond, Daniel O'Connell and Henry Grattan. One may be forgiven for believing these men are so called heroes of the struggle for Irish independence when in fact none of them took part in the rising and John Redmond adamantly condemned it. This can be seen as an example of blatant historical revisionism and one which was innocently defended by the council who stated that these figures were “as much a part of the historical narrative of Irish nationalism as anyone else”.6 Putting such an extreme emphasis on the rising now allows people to ignore the problems of the present, such as the fact that we have no government and that Ireland is still divided. Collective memory can also be blurred as the event was one hundred years ago and those who were directly involved with it are now dead. As such, people are encouraged to fondly reflect and create false memories and nostalgia. The narrative of Ireland that we are being presented with is one which is nationalist with reflections on the rising being used to solidify and encourage this. Essentially commemoration is welcome but only as long as it creates profit as can be seen in the tourist spin and invitation in relation to 1916, if it poses a …show more content…
Considering how little the rising was supported we are left to wonder was it indeed a rising or rather a bloody protest that the leaders did not believe would have any success. Did they even think that their deaths would result in the rise in nationalism which followed or were they merely unthinking in regards to the
Battle Of Pea Ridge Essay
444 Words | 2 PagesThe Battle of Pea Ridge was between the Union and Confederate armies, and they fought for two days straight near a highland which was known as Pea Ridge. The Union was under the control of General Curtis and was successful in regaining their land that they lost to the Confederates. Both forces suffered losses and even general lost their lives in the battle. “Confederates suffered 2,000 casualties, including General McCulloch, Brigadier General James McQueen Mclntosh, and Brigadier General William Slack” (Civil War Timeline).
How Did Australia Cause Ww1
1143 Words | 5 PagesThe Australian public now commemorate the sacrifice made for them by having ANZAC day every year. Today we commemorate the sacrifice by tending to their graves on foreign shores there are prayers said and wreaths laid on ANZAC day when we remember their sacrifice. There are walks across ANZAC cove with memorial scattered throughout. Though we commemorate Gallipoli more than the western front this is unjust to the 10’s of thousands of men who died on the western front as some of Australia’s most respected battles were fought on the western front
Gone To Americ Anti-Irish Sentiment Analysis
564 Words | 3 PagesIn “Gone to America: Anti-Irish Sentiment” The History Place tells of the difficulties and racism that the Irish faced as they immigrated to the United States in search of a living for themselves and their families. To begin, the author illustrates how many Irish were actually coming over from Ireland fleeing persecution and famine; they make up the majority of immigrants in the United States during the mid-1800’s, and, additionally, alludes to the swells of Irish arriving in the cities. Furthermore, the author continues to illustrate how the Irish tended to stay in close knit communities much like they had at home; this was partly due to the poverty of the Irish as well, the author states. The author states the differences between the Irish at home and the Irish
Irish Immigration To Canada Between 1840 And 1869
452 Words | 2 PagesThe Irish immigration is a story of a long and difficult process, that had eventually become one of the ethnicities that had been prominent in Canada’s population. Although this journey began in 1825, the focus of this paper will be from the years 1840 to 1869. In this era of history Ireland faced a serious problem. From 1847 to 1852, Ireland had, what is now called, the “Great Potato Famine”.
Australia Day Persuasive Speech
989 Words | 4 PagesAustralia Day is one of the most unique national day’s in the world throughout history, celebrating the day of when our ancestors first arrived on the borders of Australia, in 1788. Rather than unite people as one whole though, the spirited outcome of this event isn’t what as anticipated by everyone and has divided the Australian society for good. And so it should be held at an alternative date, where Australian citizens feel worthy of their identity and not cheated by it. However, the celebration shouldn’t be adapted to like that of other commemorations like ANZAC day. Essentially, this day will always be a tragic memory for the indigenous and be viewed as the invasion of their homeland.
Mythological Hero Cuchulain In Angela's Ashes
102 Words | 1 PagesSince that night Frankie took possession of the great hero of Ireland saying that it is his story.
The Importance Of The Past In Devil's Arithmetic
566 Words | 3 PagesPast, present, and future is what we are told to think about, but are we overlooking the past? We seem to get caught up in thinking about what we are doing now, and what we will be doing in ten years, but I think the most important thing is to know your past. It’s critical to understand what you, and other people’s ancestors did before. Remembrance is important to know your history and so you do not let the terrible things recur.
Comparing War In 'Bloody Sunday And Imagine'
841 Words | 4 PagesNixon’s “Vietnamization” policy and resolution to increase the number of troops in the air and on the ground were all in response to the Vietnam War. Consequently, few positive results came of this decision, and the nation’s dissent only ballooned. U2’s song “Bloody Sunday” also addresses the comparably violent and atrocious conflict that came as a result of war within Northern Ireland. According to Aiken (2015), Northern Ireland suffered from a prolonged and troubling conflict between Irish “nationalists” and pro-British “unionists” which sparked violent confrontations between both groups for the latter half of the twentieth
How Did Gallipoli Affect Australia
1015 Words | 5 PagesThe Gallipoli campaign had supplied for the first time a self named identity seen by many. 100 years later after the cease fire on November 11, 1918, we as a proud nation commemorate the ANZAC character every year on the 25th of April. We see that in source 12 that not only our own nation commemorates the ANZAC spirit but others also recognise the ANZAC 's. The photograph shows the Queen and the Royal Family with Prime Minister Menzies showing tribute to the ANZAC troops on the 50th Anniversary. (1923 poem by Joan Torrance source 10) this source shows the excessive emotions of dignity, and heightened awareness of fanaticism in Australia.
Causes Of The Anglo-Irish Treaty
2065 Words | 9 PagesIntroduction The signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty on December 6, 1921 brought the Irish War of Independence to conclusion, halting the guerrilla warfare between forces from the Irish Republic and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Unfortunately, the explicit terms of the Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921 generated a mass amount of tension within Ireland, specifically between Irish Republicans. Ultimately, I believe the Irish Civil War came about as a conflict over whether or not to accept the terms of the Anglo-Irish Treaty. The war engaged in two forms of warfare—conventional and guerrilla—the first lasting from June to August of 1922 and the latter from September 1922 to April of 1923.
Gender Roles In Pat Barker's Regeneration
1779 Words | 8 PagesWith that being said, World War I was a time of great change in the United Kingdom, and we see it very clearly in Regeneration.
Seamus Heaney Act Of Union Essay
1440 Words | 6 PagesRelationships in Seamus Heaney’s Act of Union In my essay I am going to analyse Seamus Heaney’s poem, Act of Union. It is important to know the background of the author in order to understand the poem. Seamus Heaney was one of the major poets of the 20th century. He was from Northern Ireland.
Causes Of The 1641 Rebellion
991 Words | 4 PagesThe planners of the rebellion were Irish landowners that included Gaelic Irish and Old English. In examining the depositions taken at the time, the issues surrounding land is an integral determinant for the outbreak of
Bloody Sunday Film Analysis
998 Words | 4 PagesThe film based its version of events on a book which challenges the myths surrounding the day, entitled ‘Eyewitness Bloody Sunday: The Truth’ by Don Mullen, who participated in the March when he was fifteen years old. Roy Foster observes how important it is to observe the contradictions and rejections of certain myths, as there is “a growing interest in pinpointing discontinuities rather than ironing out elisions.”(pg. 36) Greengrass incorporates both old and
British Nationalism In Linda Colley's Britons: Forging The Nation
1333 Words | 6 PagesLinda Colley’s novel Britons: Forging the Nation 1707-1837 explores how British Nationalism developed in the period between the Act of Union in 1707 and the coronation of Queen Victoria. The Act of Union was the official document the united Scotland with the Kingdom of England, which at the time consisted of England and Wales, to form the Kingdom of Great Britain. Colley then goes into detail about different historical events that formed British nationalism including, but not limited to, various wars and religious movements. Colley’s thesis is that despite being a part of the larger Kingdom of Great Britain (and later Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland) England was able to maintain its own sense of nationalism due their shared religion of
More about Historical Revisionism In The Easter Rising
Battle Of Pea Ridge Essay
444 Words | 2 PagesHow Did Australia Cause Ww1
1143 Words | 5 PagesGone To Americ Anti-Irish Sentiment Analysis
564 Words | 3 PagesIrish Immigration To Canada Between 1840 And 1869
452 Words | 2 PagesAustralia Day Persuasive Speech
989 Words | 4 PagesMythological Hero Cuchulain In Angela's Ashes
102 Words | 1 PagesThe Importance Of The Past In Devil's Arithmetic
566 Words | 3 PagesComparing War In 'Bloody Sunday And Imagine'
841 Words | 4 PagesHow Did Gallipoli Affect Australia
1015 Words | 5 PagesCauses Of The Anglo-Irish Treaty
2065 Words | 9 PagesGender Roles In Pat Barker's Regeneration
1779 Words | 8 PagesSeamus Heaney Act Of Union Essay
1440 Words | 6 PagesCauses Of The 1641 Rebellion
991 Words | 4 PagesBloody Sunday Film Analysis
998 Words | 4 PagesBritish Nationalism In Linda Colley's Britons: Forging The Nation
1333 Words | 6 Pages