Holes- The Similarities and Differences between a Beloved Piece of Literature
Holes is a 1998 award-winning book written by Louis Sachar. The protagonist of this story is Stanley Yelnats, an overweight boy who was sent to a juvenile deserted camp called Camp Green Lake for a false accusation; authorities thought that he stole a pair of shoes that once belonged to a baseball player named Clyde Livingston. '“I was walking home, and the sneakers fell from the sky," he had told the judge.' (Sachar 6). The camp leaders forced him and his fellow juveniles to dig holes daily, but soon he found it was not just to "build character". It became a classic almost instantly, and the film adaptation of it was released only five years later, in 2003. Though they were vaguely different, the producers made changes that would only benefit the motion picture. But what were these differences and similarities? Why were they necessary to be changed or kept?
…show more content…
The author himself adapted the film, so it is reasonable to assume that most of the scenes are alike because of that. One of these similarities was how they all had the same nicknames. “They called themselves Magnet, Armpit, and Zigzag.” (Sachar 5). That was key to their personalities or traits, so it was somewhat unnecessary for their nicknames to be removed. Another similarity (and a major one) is how they broke the 'curse' that Madame Zeroni put on Stanley's family nearly in the same way. Stanley carries Zero up God's Thumb, lets him drink the water they found on top, and sings ‘If only if only, the woodpecker sighs’ to him. (Sachar 38-39) This was one of the most important parts of Holes; the whole plot would change if that was not included. There is even a similar dialogue between the two characters. These and many other things were kept in the movie because they were the main, important
In the movie, a scene was added to the book, the scene when Mrs. Foster and Winnie go to the bread shop. Another difference in the scene is that the book doesn’t include the scene at the bar were Miles is playing cards with another person. As well as the scene of the campfire and the dancing with Jesse and Winnie. Differences can also be in actions and what the actors say just like when Jesse and Winnie jump into the lake in the movie, and in the book Miles and Jesse jump into the lake, Jesse also tell Winnie the secret and Miles tells the story in detail instead of Mae, they didn’t discuss who takes Winnie to the lake, but in the book they do, the constable doesn’t go with the man in the yellow suit but Mr. Foster and his people do and on the other hand the constable went. Another Jesse never gives the bottle to Winnie but in the book he does, also the man in the yellow suit shoots Jesse with a gun and Jesse shows him he has everlasting life.
These differences may confuse people that have read the book before they have watched the movie. For example, the Greasers and Socs live in the North and South sides, instead of the West and East sides. In the book, the intro started with Ponyboy going out of the movie theater, but in the movie, we know in the very beginning that Ponyboy is writing a composition. In the scene where Ponyboy sleeps in the lot, instead of dreaming about the country and how life would be if his parents were still alive like in the book, the movie shows how his parents died: in a car and train accident (which in the book Ponyboy says is a car-to-car accident). As you can see, the movie for some reason tweaks some aspects of the book and these changes may confuse some
Even though the book and movie and the movie have similarities they also have lots of differences
As I said before, there were many similarities that were important in this story. For example one big one was that Johnny killed Bob in the park in both the movie and the book. This one is important because the story would have changed a lot if it didn’t happen
In the book, Mockingbird, Caitlin and her brother Devon have a strong connection to the movie, To Kill a Mockingbird. This is evident because Devon likes to call Caitlin “Scout”, because she’s like the character Scout in the movie. Just like in the movie, where Scout and Jem live with their father, Atticus, Devon and Caitlin live alone with their dad. On page 78, it says, “It’s Devon’s name for me which is Scout. It’s from To Kill a Mockingbird because he loves that movie.
One of the things that differed between the book and the movie was the
It had more narration so the reader could understand what is happening. Secondly, the movie. The movie was different than the book. It had some parts that were in the book, but it lacked some details.
They were different because in the book Billy had 3 sisters and Billy had a scarecrow as a trap to trick the raccoon. The movie skipped all those things and I thought that that was important because they removed one of the family. In the book Billy didn't do school work and in the movie Billy did. When Billy got his dog, They all slept in a cave and in the movie they slept on the
In the movie it there are two sister. The movie was a lot like the book and a lot different at the same time but that for the next paragraph. In the movie billy was given the gold cup and he never won the silver cup. Little ann and Old dan weren't running around and they didn't have snow on them during the blizzard. Finally i will be talking about the similarities and differences between the book and movie.
The movie mostly stayed true to the book but in some instances it did not. While their was many similarities between the book, there are still many differences to the movie. There are multiple things in the book that are not in the movie. The most obvious is that the book is longer. Also in the book he introduces the members of his gang before the story starts.
There are many simularities and differences in the book and movie " The
Furthermore, these characters existences in the film make the film good because it all
The characters in Holes also highlight the negative impact of the justice system on young people. We see how the system has failed Stanley Yelnats, the main character. He is sent to Camp Green Lake
To summarize this essay, there are several points that highlight differences between the two films, yet the overall context of the film remains the same. One common theme that tends to drive the force between the reasoning in why the two films have varying aspects is because they were made for slightly different audiences at different times in society. Though both versions of the movie have small portions that vary from one another, the main emphasis is the same and both versions are loved by the
One comparison between the movie and book version is the darkness of the setting and the time in which it takes place. In both versions, the story takes place mostly at night, which is when all the action happens. The book also characterizes the setting as dark and the movie shows the darkness. The book and movie versions of