ipl-logo

How California Became Unforgivable Summary

709 Words3 Pages

In the article, “How California Became Unforgivable” by Jerry Roberts and Phil Trounstine, they basically describe six key factors that made California impossible to govern. They claim that California wields a "power with the damaged machinery of a patchwork government system that lacks accountability, encourages stalemate and drifts but cannot be steered." Basically, elected representatives in California have no authority, yet still hold responsibility. The six factors mentioned earlier include Proposition 13, budget initiatives, gerrymandering, term limits, boom or bust taxation, and the two-thirds vote. But how do these factors make California impossible to govern? To start, Roberts and Trounstine briefly describe these six factors. Proposition 13 changed California's political landscape and takes power away from local services. It "tangled" the relationship between local and state governments by shifting control of the remaining property tax revenue in Sacramento, according to them. Next are …show more content…

In 1990, term limits were about eight years in the Senate and six years in the Assembly. However, in 2010, it went up to twelve years no matter where they are. There was a higher term expectancy, lower switching, and more institutional memory. Term limits allowed for more diversity by representatives and more new ideas to try out coalitions. The problem with short term limits is that there was a loss of “institutional memory” where there is a well-crafted policy and “splashy” policy, to look good in the process. This allowed for more power to lobbyists, special interest groups, and bureaucrats. These term limits were basically a “musical chairs of politics” between the Assembly, Senate, county, and city. How this affects California’s governability depends on perspective. It’s really up to whoever it looking at it because short term limits and long term limits each have their pros and

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast California's Model Compared To The Federal Government

    1185 Words  | 5 Pages

    The United States uses many different governance styles. California’s style has much diversity and a very large size. The size has led California to a more complex system. The California government has had many issues in their healthcare, transportation etc. This leads to California's model being more complex than any other state.

    Read More

  • Chimel Vs. California Case Study

    455 Words  | 2 Pages

    Title: Chimel v. California Date/Court: United States Supreme Court, 1969 Facts: This case deals with Ted Chimel, who they suspected robbed a local coin shop. On September 13, 1965, several officers from Santa Ana came to the home of Chimel with an arrest warrant for his expected involvement in the burglary. The officers arrived at the door and identified themselves to Chimel’s wife and asked if they could come into the home, she agreed and showed them into the house. While in the house the officers waited 10-15 minutes until Chimel came home from work.

    Read More

  • Primary Differences Between The California Constitution Of 1849 And 1879

    608 Words  | 3 Pages

    People in California wanted to have the right to vote for their leaders to represent them in the U.S. Congress. The California Constitution of 1849 was basically a copy of different

    Read More

  • Essay On Nevada Government

    851 Words  | 4 Pages

    Legislative amendments in Nevada must pass two-thirds votes in both houses, and then only earn a simple majority on a public ballot. This method of amending constitutional legislation creates a more volatile term cycle legislatively, yet provides Nevadan voters a form of fair representation in constitutional changes. This flexibility at the power of the current voting majority is hedged by federal constitutional minimums, though this simple majority power also allows Nevada to be easily influenced by foreign politics, whether state, country, or global influences. Nevada struggles to hold onto conservative policies while at the whim of a majority vote that can easily swing

    Read More

  • Term Limits Pros And Cons

    298 Words  | 2 Pages

    I believe that all members of the Texas legislature should be term-limited. I think that since the President of the United States has term-limited. It would only be fair that all branches within the government to practice term-limited as well. So far, there has only been fifteen states that practice term-limited (Maine, California, Colorado, Arkansas, Michigan, Florida, Ohio, South Dakota, Montana, Arizona, Missouri, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Louisiana, and Nevada). Term limits can be divided into two categories: consecutive and lifetime.

    Read More

  • Term Limits In Elections

    1226 Words  | 5 Pages

    There was an increase in the number of these seats from 25 to 32 between 1992 and 2002. This increase was a result of term limits, but when it came to Michigan, there is need to be cautious since the number of open seats increased at the same level. However, they occurred before the voters had decided to adopt term limits. This means that the rise of open seats in California may not be necessary because of term limits but there were other factors. Considering the fact that Michigan did not adopt term limits until election conducted in 1992 redistricting maybe a major reason why there was an increase in open seats and incumbents lost to

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Presidential Term Limits

    743 Words  | 3 Pages

    Former President James Madison talked about a rotation of offices, a coolness within the senate, and how the lack of limitations would lead to the rise in career politicians while making legislators live as citizens under their own laws. Madison wanted to keep “Career Politicians” from holding a seat of power and becoming corrupt and wrote many speeches and papers regarding the subject. As one of the most powerful appointed titles in the world, term limits will always be

    Read More

  • What Are The Conditions That Led To The Calling Of The Convention In 1849

    920 Words  | 4 Pages

    In 1849, California was a territory of the United States, and its leaders were faced with the daunting task of drafting a state constitution that would guide its government once it was granted statehood. This led to the calling of the constitutional convention in Monterey, where delegates from across the territory came together to draft a new constitution. This essay will explore the conditions that led to the calling of the convention, examine the backgrounds of the delegates, look at the major issues at the convention and how they were resolved, and discuss the important characteristics of the government created by the 1849 convention. There were many factors present when the Monterey constitutional conference was called in 1849. California saw a population explosion as a result of the huge influx of people that followed the finding of gold there in 1848.

    Read More

  • California Gold Rush Research Paper

    827 Words  | 4 Pages

    A. Since most of the people were 49ers, they did not have any source of food that are grown there so food was tripled in price. 2. Because California was so new to the U.S., there was no government for any thing even murder also that meant that robberies were common and there was not much the people could do about it. V. Working conditions for the miners was not grate and took a lot of time and effort.

    Read More

  • The California Gold Rush: A Positive Impact On American History

    298 Words  | 2 Pages

    Americans were able to make thousands of dollars off of gold and immagrants and foreigners from all over the world came to California. Citizens became richer and all different cultures learned to

    Read More

  • The California Dream

    1121 Words  | 5 Pages

    California is the “beauty of the eye of the beholder” since all people who come from different background, race, and religion are able to set their own dreams without being criticized. People especially immigrants have viewed California as the “land of opportunity,” which influenced them to leave everything behind in their hometown, to sacrifice their time and to focus on their dreams. Despite the fact that California was lauded as a utopian society, people soon found out that they were going through endeavors and couldn’t overcome them quickly as possible. In fact, Mr. Rawls wanted to express the grievances, struggles, and success that people endure in their rise to the California dream in his short essay, “California: A Place, A People,

    Read More

  • The Progressive Era In John Spargo's The Bitter Cry Of Children

    576 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Railroads had been taking land from people trying to gain financial footing through farming in California. Frank Norris brought about change by exposing what four robber barons were doing to the people. The robber barons would make the cost of shipping to much to bayor and would make farmers go bankrupt and lose all their money, while the railroad got richer and richer. This corruption would be silenced by the courts corrupt officials. This meant that people would starve and die because they can't afford to eat.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The Compromise Of 1850

    328 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Compromise of 1850 was an effort by the United States Congress that was drafted by Henry Clay, who was both the U.S. Senator and the House Representative of Kentucky. This compromise was a series of acts passed in 1850, attempted to reconcile Northern and Southern interests to preserve the Civil War. After the start of the Mexican-American War, conflicts about whether to allow slavery in those new territories to polarized Northern and Southern of the United States raised up. Northerners were in favor the Compromise, since they thought it’s a good chance to stop slavery. On the other hand, Southerners were against it, they thought it threatened their political power because the join of territory--California would disturb the balance of 15 free states and 15 slave states.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Representative Kevin Mccarthy

    1230 Words  | 5 Pages

    Representative Kevin McCarthy is one of fifteen Republican members in Congress in the state of California, which is highly outnumbered by thirty-eight democrats. After four years of getting reelected as the representative for the 22nd district in California, redistricting retitled it the 23rd district. The newly numbered district became more compact, losing the central coast while adding a chunk of Tulare County. This did not change the fact that McCarthy’s district was still heavily Republican. The redistricting of 2012 in California showcased a new way to redistrict as the citizens of California chose the district lines, providing one of the most competitive elections in the country.

    Read More

  • Negative Effects Of The California Gold Rush

    744 Words  | 3 Pages

    C. The gold rush affected many other things in California as well. a. San Francisco’s newspaper was closed due to all the employees quitting their jobs to gold mine. b. California became a state of the U.S. after the California Gold Rush occurred. c. Because California was so new to the U.S., there was no governing rule in the state, this meant that robberies were common and there was not much the people could do about it.

    Read More

More about How California Became Unforgivable Summary

Open Document