How Did Billy Budd Be Punished
Billy Budd Have you ever been punished in an unfair way? This was the case in Herman Melville's story Billy Budd: Sailor. Billy accidently killed a high ranking officer named John Claggart and was hanged for it. Both sides agree that Billy unthinkingly killed Claggart but disagree on whether Budd should have been punished. Billy Budd should not have accepted his punishment for three reasons. He could escape, he could mutiny, and Claggart deserved it. Firstly, Billy should not have accepted his punishment because he could escape. Billy was a smart sailor. He was no rocket scientist, but Budd is probably smarter than many of the brine-soaked sailors on board. Billy would have been halfway back to England by the time any of the crew got a whiff of his trail. Then there is the obvious notion that not one soul aboard the Bellipotent would expect such a daring felony from Billy Budd. Then the Bellipotent's gargantuan size comes into mind. On a ship that massive, Budd could easily lose the crew. Billy possessed the brains and reputation to give him an edge in attempting an escape. …show more content…
Billy was a peacemaker and a favorite among the crew. Every seadog one the seventy-four was fond of the Handsome Sailor, except for Claggart that is. Undoubtedly, a good number of them would follow Billy to the Gates of Hell if he requested it. Besides, several reports of mutinies had been heard. If other sailors could do it so could Billy Budd. If the mutiny failed, Billy could at least die fighting rather than die hanging by his neck. Either way was better than the noose. Billy could be a famous mutineer if he attempted the dread act rather than accept the
To Kill A Mockingbird Conflicts
337 Words | 2 PagesA conflict can be defined as a serious disagreement or argument. In the novel, To Kill A Mockingbird written by Harper Lee, there are many minor conflicts that occur. Some examples would be Miss Maudie Atkinson's house catching fire and Tim Johnson being put down. However, the major conflict of the novel is Tom Robinson's court case. It is important to understand that while Boo appears to be a strange, crazy neighbor to the townspeople, Scout, Jem and Dill seem to be intrigued by Boo because of the town's rumors about him.
The Most Heroic Hero In Billy Budd
120 Words | 1 PagesI believe that Billy was the most heroic character in “Billy Budd” than Captain Vere. He was a man that did not argue or be mad even though he was forced on a naval ship. He was generally kind and was liked by other sailors. Even when Captain Vere made him be hang, he accepted the situation, and sacrifice himself for other problems that could happen if he was not punished. While in the other hand.
Edward Britton Character Analysis
1034 Words | 5 PagesEdward Britton by Gary Crew and Philip Nielsen tells the story of young British boy, Edward Britton. Who he believes was wrongfully sent to Port Arthur. It illustrates the hardships and struggles of being transported to Port Arthur and living a convict life as a young boy. He was not afraid to tell people what he thought, and was very brave. He is very well educated, and is clearly far more smarter and talented than other convict boys.
Why Is Billy Budd's Punishment Undeserved
530 Words | 3 PagesIn the film Billy Budd, Billy gets hung in front of his shipmates. This happens because Billy is accused of murdering one of his superiors on the ship. Some view his punishment for killing Claggart as deserved, while others view it as undeserved. Both sides can give reasoning for their viewpoints. I believe that Billy’s punishment was undeserved.
Billy Bibbit's Character Analysis
213 Words | 1 PagesBilly Bibbit’s suicide is caused by Nurse Ratched as her constant threats frightened Billy to a point where he took his own life. Although McMurphy encouraged Billy to pursue his desires with Candy and initiated the entire incident, Nurse Ratched maliciously used his weak point to control Billy. She knew that Billy’s mother is his weakness so just as he began to become independent and defiant to her rules, she threatened to tell his mother despite his begging, as it states, “‘Nuh! Nuh!’
Lennie Justified In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men
395 Words | 2 PagesIn this essay I will be explaining why George was justified in shooting Lennie. You will read 3 reasons why I believe he is justified such as: Lennie wouldn’t have to face jail time, it would put Lennie out of his misery, and premeditation. To start off my essay I will begin with the reason of him not having to face jail time. Lennie wasn’t the brightest crayon in the box if you know what I mean so he didn’t really understand a lot.
Atticus Finch And Bob Ewell Analysis
706 Words | 3 PagesAt a first glance, Atticus Finch, and Bob Ewell, both characters from Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird” novel, don’t have a thing in common, but they do. Like most people, Atticus and Bob have similarities and differences in the way they live their lives and the way they treat others around them. The novel takes place in the “tired old town” of Maycomb Alabama in the years of 1933-1935. The way Atticus Finch and Bob Ewell treat the people around them, such as their family, and the people in town differs between the two of them, but there are some similarities Atticus treats his children, Calpurnia, and the town well, but the way he treats his sister is a little different from everyone else. Atticus is a lawyer and for that reason, he tries to treat everyone as fairly as he can, without race and social status.
Use Of Punishment In Life Of Brian
1051 Words | 5 PagesLife of Brian is a British movie made by Monty Python in 1979. The film tell the story of a Jewish man, Brian Cohen who was been mistaken for the Messiah. The movie is a comedy that revolve about religion, its followers, colonization, political revolutionaries and the deformities of human connection. Life of Brian was first forbidden since it satires about religion and politics at the time of its release, religious groups accused the movie to be “once denounced as blasphemous and an insult to Christians” (Bingham).However, at the end it was accepted and got considered as one of the best British comedies. Among the topics that were criticized in the film, punishment is one of them; since there were two main ways of punishment allowed at that time: stoning and crucifixion.
To Kill A Mockingbird Values Essay
1328 Words | 6 PagesValues in To Kill a Mockingbird To Kill a Mockingbird shows that you should not judge a book by its cover, that actions speak louder than words, and that seemingly good people can be filled with exuberant flaws. There are several examples of characters in To Kill a Mockingbird that are portrayed as bad people in the beginning of the book that turn out to be heroes. Other characters such as Mrs. Merriweather and Aunt Alexandra criticise others and are generally hypocritical, even though they come across as pinnacles of politeness and wholesome values. Because characters such as Boo Radley and Mrs. Dubose are originally shown as bad people and then are shown as heroic and other supposedly good people like Mrs. Merriweather are shown to be hypocritical and callous, this book shows that it is of the utmost importance to thoroughly examine a person before you judge them, and that hypocrisy or other faults of character can be present in people with pious reputations.
The Guest By Daru Summary
768 Words | 4 Pages“The Guest” When it comes to making decisions, sometimes, one must fight with his or her conscience. Depending on the situation, the better decision could feel like the wrong action to take. But in some situations, like in the case of the protagonist in the story “The Guest,” no matter what decision is made, it could have unfortunate consequences. For Daru, it appeared to be a lose-lose situation no matter what decision he made, although he clearly made a bad one. Had he taken the prisoner to the jail himself, it would have weighed heavily on his conscience, while turning him loose could have meant capture or death anyway.
Of Mice And Men Justified Analysis
849 Words | 4 PagesWas George killing Lennie really justified, or should George be condemned? The reader discovers this in the plot of the story. When meeting the two main characters, George and Lennie, they are traveling to a new ranch, because at the last ranch they worked at Lennie was wanted for rap. George is a small man, who’s the caregiver of Lennie, and can have a very bad temper. While Lennie is a very large and strong man, who has mental
Bud Not Buddy Essay
508 Words | 3 PagesCan bud survive in the 21st century? "Whoop Zoop Sloop! " We are in the great depression. Bud, Not Buddy is a book written by Christopher Paul Curtis. Bud, Not Buddy is about a 10-year-old boy living in three foster homes.
Billy Budd Moral
986 Words | 4 PagesThrough the Story of Billy Budd Herman Melville shows the reader that logic overcomes morals as logical suppresses morals when dealing with Billy Budd. Melville throughout the story shows both moral and logical forces superseding each other but logic becomes the winner as Billy is found guilty. In society logic is the common thing to do and the logic of laws always win whether or not fair. Melville shows the unfairness of the world in how morals are not placed highly as they should be just as important as logic.
Civil Disobedience In The Shawshank Redemption
1096 Words | 5 PagesThe film Shawshank Redemption is about a banker, Andy Dufresne, who is convicted of murdering his wife and her lover in cold blood. He is sentenced to two consecutive life sentences in the Shawshank State Penitentiary. Andy makes a mistake of trusting the criminal justice system and agrees to cooperate fully. Despite the evidence placing him at the scene of the crime on the night of the murders, Andy has always maintained his innocence. It is at this prison where he meets a fellow inmate, Red, who was convicted and sentenced to life for planning and carrying out his wife's murder.
Ambiguous Morality In Billy Budd
956 Words | 4 PagesHe resolved that never...would he make himself liable to such a visitation...” His hard work for fear of further dehumanization, earns him the respect of his senior sailors, and the jealousy and attention of Claggart, yet another symbol for power suppressing identity. Claggart serves as an metaphorical extension of power, manifesting society’s repression of the individual, while Billy Budd represents individualism in itself. In conclusion, Billy Budd’s sense of self is stripped from him, and although he reacts to his bondage with conviction and work ethic in attempts to lay low, his actions only serve to make him more conspicuous to Claggart, fueling his resentment towards
More about How Did Billy Budd Be Punished
To Kill A Mockingbird Conflicts
337 Words | 2 PagesThe Most Heroic Hero In Billy Budd
120 Words | 1 PagesEdward Britton Character Analysis
1034 Words | 5 PagesWhy Is Billy Budd's Punishment Undeserved
530 Words | 3 PagesBilly Bibbit's Character Analysis
213 Words | 1 PagesLennie Justified In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men
395 Words | 2 PagesAtticus Finch And Bob Ewell Analysis
706 Words | 3 PagesUse Of Punishment In Life Of Brian
1051 Words | 5 PagesTo Kill A Mockingbird Values Essay
1328 Words | 6 PagesThe Guest By Daru Summary
768 Words | 4 PagesOf Mice And Men Justified Analysis
849 Words | 4 PagesBud Not Buddy Essay
508 Words | 3 PagesBilly Budd Moral
986 Words | 4 PagesCivil Disobedience In The Shawshank Redemption
1096 Words | 5 PagesAmbiguous Morality In Billy Budd
956 Words | 4 Pages