ipl-logo

How Did Galileo Put An End To Galileo's Silence?

1441 Words6 Pages

Prior to the publication of Galileo Galilei’s (1564-1642) Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems (1632), the Congregation of the Index issued a public decree which condemned the heliocentric model along with any books supporting or seemingly supporting the tenets of the Copernican model. Consequently, Galileo, who was already in conflict with the church over letters he sent to the Grand Duchess Christina (1565-1637) and Benedetto Castelli (1578-1643) which depicted him as a supporter of the Copernican model, could no longer express his support or publish evidence supporting the Copernican model. The election of Cardinal Maffeo Barberini (1568-1644) as Pope Urban VIII in 1623, though, “put an end to Galileo’s silence” because he was …show more content…

There is no way that the earth was immobile. In fact, the entirety of Day 3 was a discussion about the earth’s motion in which he proves that a geokinetic universe makes much more sense than a geostatic universe which shows that Galileo was trying to show support for the Copernican world system. Galileo did not intend for everyone to read the Dialogue as support for the Copernican, though, and tried to use tactics that would hide the fact that he was supporting the Copernican view. One of the tactics he used was the dialogue form. The use of the dialogue form distances him from what the characters in the dialogue are claiming. It allows him to say things that would have immediately caused him trouble had he written them down as fact or opinion in a book. Although Galileo had no intention of explicitly expressing his opinion about the Copernican world system, the dialogue form allows for the author to clearly illustrate the ideas presented as opposed to them being compiled into a lengthy and complicated work. Stephan Clucas states that “what Galileo sought in his dialogues was the ability to present his reasonings outside of the more restrictive literary modes”. With the dialogue form, Galileo was able to present his arguments clearly while also distancing himself from what the characters in the Dialogue were

Show More
Related

  • Galileo Galilei Dbq Essay

    274 Words  | 2 Pages

    Galileo Galilei was believed to be a heretic for opposing the belief of the Catholic Church, despite him being scientifically correct. With the invention of the telescope, Galileo Galilei had the ability to study the function of the universe and publish his scientific observations, raising the attention of the Catholic Church. Heliocentrism and the Catholic Church Timeline, states “The Catholic Church told Galileo to stop sharing his theory in public in the year of 1615. Along with that, the Catholic Church added Copernicus’s work (and others supporting the heliocentric model to its list of banned books)” (Doc A :Timeline).

    Read More

  • Scientific Revolution Dbq Essay

    764 Words  | 4 Pages

    Galileo’s theories portrayed a heliocentric solar system while the Catholic Church had said it was geocentric; as a result, Galileo’s works were put on the Index of Prohibited Books and he was later put under house arrest by the Inquisition. A letter from an Italian monk in Document 3 depicts how religious figures would try to convince him to retract his discovery of the moon having craters in order to avoid confusion and contradiction of the Bible, which portrays how religious figures hindered the progress of the Scientific Revolution because these new ideas challenged the Bible and their old

    Read More

  • Galileo Trial Summary

    976 Words  | 4 Pages

    Autumn Stern Galileo Trial Summary + Copernicus Write Up In the early 17th century, there was no doubt that the Catholic church held extreme power throughout Europe. They also held to the geocentric theory (all planets, heavenly bodies and the sun revolving around the earth) put forth by Ptolemy and Aristotle because of how neatly it could fit into the current teachings. Unlike this theory, however, Galileo enforced Copernicus’ heliocentric theory with inductive reasoning rather than deductive. Galileo made observations about the moons of Jupiter and their orbit around Jupiter, which he likened to a smaller version of their solar system.

    Read More

  • Dbq Galileo Galilei

    249 Words  | 1 Pages

    Galileo Galilei was an Italian astronomer who disagreed with the Roman Catholic theory of geocentrism. He was not a heretic because he was a Christian and had similar beliefs to the Roman Catholics, but he did not agree with the Church’s theory of the position and movement of Earth in the Solar System. Document A is an excerpt of a letter to Duchess Christina of Tuscany written by Galilei, counter-arguing the heresy claims. In the letter, Galileo wrote, “Can an opinion be heretical and yet have no concern with the salvation of souls?” Although he did not believe in the astronomical theory of the Church, he believed that his scientific thoughts should not interfere with his religious beliefs.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Galileo's Letter To Grand-Duchess Christina '

    456 Words  | 2 Pages

    Analysis of Galileo’s Letter to Grand-Duchess Christina During the time that Galileo wrote the letter to Grand-Duchess Christina, there was much debate about the orientation of the universe. There were two different theories of thought at this time. One was the Heliocentric Universe, which believed the sun was the center of the universe and the Earth orbits it.

    Read More

  • Galileo Starry Messenger Essay

    757 Words  | 4 Pages

    Going against the Ptolemaic model of the universe, especially in the way Galileo articulated it, was highly offensive. However, in this statement, he is showing how confident he is of this hypothesis and he is willing to prove it with his experiments and figures. The passage also denies the idea of a “perfect” heavens and the notion that the moon is made of quintessence. It directly disproved the Ptolemaic view that the heavens are a perfect entity. He does this by describing how the moon looks at different stages of the moon cycle; you can see different variations as the sun casts shadows across the face of the moon.

    Read More

  • Ap Euro Dbq Individualism

    675 Words  | 3 Pages

    Copernicus’ previous statement is continued with, “...although I know that the meditations of a philosopher are far removed from the judgement of the laity, because his endeavor is to seek out the truth in all things, so far as this is permitted by God to the human reason I still believe that one must avoid theories altogether foreign to orthodoxy.” (Doc 6.) Copernicus did not need validation from the Church for his ideas. He knew his scientific ideas could be proved without religion endorsing them. Another rationalist thinker, Francesco Petrarch, felt as if he should form opinions after looking at things rationally and from different perspectives.

    Read More

  • How Does Galileo Discover The Moons Of Jupiter

    1120 Words  | 5 Pages

    Galileo Discovers the Moons of Jupiter (1610) Galileo Galilei Introduction Galileo Galilei, (1564-1642) the gifted and extremely curious Italian scientist, made great use of the telescope to discover such unsettling things as the irregularities of the moon's surface; it was believed at the time to be perfectly smooth, a belief which conformed to Catholic dogma. Moreover, Galileo's observations with the telescope led him to the conclusion that Nicolas Copernicus (1473-1543) was right: the earth did indeed orbit around the sun and not vice versa. Such a viewpoint cast great doubt on the accepted natural philosophy (first enunciated by Aristotle) of a geocentric universe and thus of human beings' centrality in the universe. Thus the conflict between religion and science in the seventeenth century was begun.

    Read More

  • How Did Religion Change During The Scientific Revolution

    1558 Words  | 7 Pages

    By using his eyes, Galileo confirmed the heliocentric theory and created his own in reply: the Copernican theory. His theory stated that the sun was at the center of the universe, with the earth and other planets rotating around it in elliptical paths and at uniform speeds. Copernicus had used Bacon’s implications that “seeing is believing.” He also theorized that the other planets were made of substances similar to those found on earth. These two ideas even furthered the notion that humans were not special to God because they inhabited an earth that looked like all the other planets.

    Read More

  • Essay On Galileo Heretic

    1415 Words  | 6 Pages

    For example, the New York Times Article “Vatican Science Panel Told by Pope: Galileo was Right” mentions, “Moving formally to rectify a wrong, Pope John Paul II acknowledged in a speech today that the Roman Catholic Church had erred in condemning Galileo 359 years ago for asserting that the Earth revolves around the Sun.” This excerpt states that Galileo’s theories about the sun centered universe was correct. The church admits to their mistake and have recognized the truth in Galileo’s beliefs. In addition, the article includes a comment form Pope John Paul, “This led them to unduly transpose into the realm of the doctrine of faith, a question which in fact pertained to scientific investigation.” This means that the Roman Catholic Church at the time was in the wrong and had interpreted the scriptures incorrectly.

    Read More

  • Galileo's Argument Essay

    500 Words  | 2 Pages

    In a letter to Cristina of Lorraine, the Grand Duchess of Tuscany, Galileo gives a perfectly sound and rational argument as to why the church should not be charging him as a heretic for his belief in the heliocentric model when the bible is going against what they see with their own eyes. Furthermore, Galileo argues that, contrary to popular belief at the time, the bible should only be used to help us understand abstruse concepts and what is needed for salvation, not to explain the natural world. In a lot of ways, Galileo’s argument paves the way for separation between church and state, as well as the age-old conflict between science and religion that is still discussed even till today. However, what I found interesting here is that Galileo actually believed that his beliefs went hand in hand with the bible. He tries to justify his beliefs according to the bible by arguing that God gave us a brain in order

    Read More

  • Truth In Shirley Jackson's The Lottery

    1386 Words  | 6 Pages

    The open-minded Galileo advocated that the earth revolves around the sun, with which few agreed during his lifetime,

    Read More

  • The Relationship Between The Scientific Revolution And The Enlightenment

    745 Words  | 3 Pages

    Copernicus developed the heliocentric theory which claimed that the earth revolved around the sun. This immediately challenged the authorities who believed the opposite. Galileo furthered Copernicus’ argument and promoted that the Bible, that God

    Read More

  • Galileo: Jupiter's Four Moons

    373 Words  | 2 Pages

    From Galileo's observations, it strengthened his belief in Copernicus’s theory that Earth as well as other planets revolve around the Sun. People in Galileo’s time believed that the Earth was the center of the universe and that the Sun and planets revolved around it. Newton was taught the standard curriculum but was fascinated

    Read More

  • Galileo Galilei Research Paper

    241 Words  | 1 Pages

    He also discovered that objects move with a parabolic curve. Finally, He also observed the moons of Jupiter with his invention, The Telescope. He never gave up even once because he still felt like there is a way he can help out even more. . Galileo

    Read More

More about How Did Galileo Put An End To Galileo's Silence?

Open Document