How Did The Official Version Of My Lai Assault Differ From Testimonies
Alecia Moore
Chapter 13
How did the official version of the My Lai assault differ from the soldiers’ testimonies? Why were they so different from each other?
On March 16, 1968 in a village called My Lai “U.S. forces killed 128 enemy troops” (Gorn et al 2010), this is what the Army’s Public Information Department released. The official version of My Lai made the massacre sound as if it was an effective search-and-destroy mission that had killed suspected enemy soldiers of the Vietcong.
“[Leader of the operation, Lieutenant Colonel Frank] Barker said to his superiors in his combat action report, noting that the ‘operation was well planned, well executed and successful.’” (Gorn et al 2010) In reality this was a massacre of over 500 innocent
…show more content…
But then the orders were given to kill the civilians, and some soldiers went on a rampage. There were mass murders, rapes and torture.” (Gorn et al 2010). This proves that My Lai Massacre was not “executed” properly because the purpose of going into My Lai was not to kill everything in sight. The intent of going into My Lai was so the enemies would be dealt with properly, “successful” is the complete opposite word of how the operation ended. Barker also stated that “the infantry unit on the ground and helicopters were able to assist civilians in leaving the area and in caring for and/or evacuating the wounded.” (Gorn et al 2010) Captain Brian Livingston’s testimony contradicts Barker’s claims completely; “…Livingston, a helicopter commander wrote his wife …show more content…
The official document also made it appear that the officers gave the soldiers the commands and that they were executed correctly. Most likely Officers lied about the massacre to make it look like they did what the United States Government expected them to do in My Lai, I suspect that they did this to keep their jobs. The soldier’s testimonies later revealed that the official story told was completely just the opposite. The testimonies showed that the officers lacked communication with the soldiers of the rules that were in place for this mission. If the soldiers would have been aware of the rules most likely My Lai wouldn’t have turned out the way it
Brownsville Raid Summary
170 Words | 1 PagesThe Brownsville Raid of 1906 is a historic but tragic moment in our nation’s history. It was the center of national controversy at the time. Occurring in Brownsville Texas, this event saw the racial injustice of African American soldiers, and the “dishonorable” discharge of 167 men of the 25th Infantry Regiment. This caused outrage but was long forgotten by history until 1970, when historian John D. Weaver published a book titled “The Brownsville Raid”. His investigations concluded that the accused members of the 25th Infantry Regiment were innocent.
Summary Of The Indiens Was Upon Us
1455 Words | 6 PagesDealing with the historical record can be challenging at times, especially for scholars and historians. Most information about past events have either been lost or have been tampered with over the years. Some information has also been exaggerated or some have been too vague. The chapter, “The Indiens Was Upon Us!” from Paul E. Kopperman’s book, “Braddock at the Monongahela,” is any example of how challenging it is for scholars to deal with the historical record.
Summary Of Chapter Nine Of Lies My Teacher Told Me
518 Words | 3 PagesCountless Americans lack education of the Vietnam War and what treatment the Vietnamese population received during the war. Many times the behavior conducted towards the Vietnamese portrayed American soldiers mistreating the noncombatants. James W. Loewen’s chapter nine of Lies My Teacher Told Me leads readers through the occurrences in the Vietnam War by elaborating the war crimes enacted by American soldiers, examining the intervention of America in the war, and describing pictures that were taken during the war. One subject Loewen uncovers is the analysis of the war crimes throughout the Vietnam War.
Rhetorical Analysis Of The Invisible War
861 Words | 4 PagesClaims are made throughout the entire documentary by various people surrounding sexual assault in the military. The United States military works around hidden corners to avoid having a bad reputation due to assault or rape, was the first claim made. This is revealed by victims willing to share their stories. They were all told to “stop crying and realize that they brought this onto themselves”by their commanders. Therefore, his gives insight into the larger picture because the commander did not stop the sexual assault nor did they receive empathy after surviving a life changing event.
American Tunnel Rat Essay
1001 Words | 5 PagesOn 18 January 1967, the tunnel rats had discovered a tunnel complex that had over half a million enemy documents. When the operation was complete, there were 750 confirmed enemy kills, as opposed to 72 American casualties. The U.S. Army destroyed over 525 tunnels and knocked out all of the Viet Cong’s medical facilities. (Mangold, 1985) These Soldiers earned the respect of the Viet
Truong's A Viet Cong Memoir
937 Words | 4 PagesIn A Viet Cong Memoir, we receive excellent first hands accounts of events that unfolded in Vietnam during the Vietnam War from the author of this autobiography: Truong Nhu Tang. Truong was Vietnamese at heart, growing up in Saigon, but he studied in Paris for a time where he met and learned from the future leader Ho Chi Minh. Truong was able to learn from Ho Chi Minh’s revolutionary ideas and gain a great political perspective of the conflicts arising in Vietnam during the war. His autobiography shows the readers the perspective of the average Vietnamese citizen (especially those involved with the NLF) and the attitudes towards war with the United States. In the book, Truong exclaims that although many people may say the Americans never lost on the battlefield in Vietnam — it is irrelevant.
Black Hearts By Jim Frederick Sparknotes
1230 Words | 5 PagesThe Effective Military Leader Warrant Officer Romero, Philip T. SPC: Captain Dearth, 1st Platoon The book “Black Hearts One Platoons Descent into Madness in Iraq’s Triangle of Death” by Jim Frederick is a true story about multiple leadership failures and six United States Soldiers from 1st Platoon, Bravo Company, 1st Battalion, 502nd Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne Division who were convicted for their involvement in horrible crimes while deployed to Iraq. The horrific acts including rape as well as murder committed by the soldiers of 1st platoon were a direct result of poor military leadership. Bad leadership will corrupt any military unit.
My Lai Massacre Research Paper
1185 Words | 5 PagesThe responsibility was laid out to them clearly, but the decision to downplay this massacre would lead to events soldiers wished never happened. By omission and commission, they suppressed reports of the incident and submitted false or misleading accounts to higher headquarters. (My Lai Massacre) By suppressing the news of the massacre, Calley and his fellow officers just dug themselves a deep hole. Surely they should have expected the cause and effect from this small decision.
Ethical Issues In The Vietnam War
1101 Words | 5 PagesThe Vietnam war took a major death toll in Vietnam, United States, South Korea, Thailand, New Zealand, and Australia. Just in the U.S., “more than 58,000 American soldiers were killed while more than 150,000 others wounded”. On both sides, there were almost 2 million civilians dead and 1.1 simply on the Vietnamese side. The My Lai Massacre, where soldiers brutally killed Vietnamese children and mothers, presents an example where the war mentally changed the soldiers in the war in a very horrendous way. On the other hand, the United States took brutal losses in the Tet Offensive, where the Vietcong slaughtered over 100 towns and twelve United States air bases.
Summary Of Black Hearts By Jim Frederick
1156 Words | 5 PagesJim Frederick’s book Black Hearts: One Platoon’s Descent Into Madness in Iraq’s Triangle of Death is focused on a crime and all the events that had led up to it. By the fall of 2005, 2nd Brigade of the 101st Airborne Division was approaching deployment to Iraq. The book talks about the soldiers deployed to the Triangle of Death during a very dangerous time. 101st Battalion, 502nd Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne Division was taken over by insurgents at a checkpoint just southwest of Mahmudiyah.
A Summary Of Philip Caputo's A Rumor Of War
1500 Words | 6 PagesThe two Viet Cong men were found and killed. Caputo and his men would go to court to possibly be put in prison for murder. They were not found guilty and were
My Lai Massacre In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien
831 Words | 4 PagesOn March 16, 1968, American soldiers invaded Vietnam resulting in roughly 350 unarmed Vietnamese deaths (Yanak, Ted, and Pam Cornelison). They demolished the village of My Lai killing and destroying anything in sight. At first, this horrific event was kept a secret, but when information was leaked, America’s character was at risk. This horrific procedure
The Warrior King
641 Words | 3 PagesA Commander sustains an ethical command climate in war by establishing clear intent and purpose for their organization, accentuated through his vision. The Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) and the Law of War are the military guidelines and penalties for soldiers to act accordingly. Distinctively, the majority of people know the difference between right and wrong. Command team (i.e. Commander and NCOs) are role models for the organization and set the example for their subordinates, which led to sustaining an ethical climate. Discipline organization exhibits high physical fitness, technical competence and successfully accomplish the mission.
13 Hours Analysis
979 Words | 4 PagesMichael Bay brings yet another thrilling cinematic masterpiece back to the big screen in his new movie 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi. The film is based on the book 13 Hours by Mitchell Zuckoff, which depicts the terrorist attack by Islamic militants at the American diplomatic compound in Benghazi, Libya on September 11, 2012. The story is told from the perspective of the compound’s defenders, and aside from some character development, holds true to the actual events. Benghazi, Libya is named one of the most dangerous places in the world. However, the United States has a diplomatic compound in the city called the Special Mission and a CIA outpost called the Annex about a mile away.
Telling A True War Story Analysis
1032 Words | 5 PagesTelling a true war story can be hard to do, because soldiers are tempted to change some traumatic aspects to make the story easier to comprehend, and not so traumatic for the listener. For the readers who prefer the brutal and gruesome stories,
More about How Did The Official Version Of My Lai Assault Differ From Testimonies
Brownsville Raid Summary
170 Words | 1 PagesSummary Of The Indiens Was Upon Us
1455 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of Chapter Nine Of Lies My Teacher Told Me
518 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of The Invisible War
861 Words | 4 PagesAmerican Tunnel Rat Essay
1001 Words | 5 PagesTruong's A Viet Cong Memoir
937 Words | 4 PagesBlack Hearts By Jim Frederick Sparknotes
1230 Words | 5 PagesMy Lai Massacre Research Paper
1185 Words | 5 PagesEthical Issues In The Vietnam War
1101 Words | 5 PagesSummary Of Black Hearts By Jim Frederick
1156 Words | 5 PagesA Summary Of Philip Caputo's A Rumor Of War
1500 Words | 6 PagesMy Lai Massacre In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien
831 Words | 4 PagesThe Warrior King
641 Words | 3 Pages13 Hours Analysis
979 Words | 4 PagesTelling A True War Story Analysis
1032 Words | 5 Pages