ipl-logo

How Do Some Historians Respond To The Same Facts

1197 Words5 Pages

Given access to the same facts, it is possible that there can be disagreement between experts in a discipline. Although I believe this statement holds true for history, I do not believe it is valid in regard to the natural sciences. In history, facts are events that have taken place in time and are accepted to have happened. It is then the responsibility of historians to interpret the significance of these facts. Similarly, in the natural sciences, facts are phenomena that are observed. Natural scientists then utilize facts in experimenting and developing theories, which are used to make sense of facts. With the scientific method and collaboration, scientists use facts in ultimately comprehending phenomena in the natural world. This is why I am led to believe that experts can possibly disagree in history but not …show more content…

In history, historians are entitled to their interpretations of past events which are based on factual evidence. Using primary sources, they are able to draw general conclusions about the past through inductive reasoning. A historian’s interpretation of historical events is dependent upon the historian’s beliefs and values. This means that historians, given the same facts, can arrive at different conclusions and disagree due to their distinct perspectives. For example, the New Deal was an economic program during Franklin D. Roosevelt’s presidential term. It was meant to improve the U.S. financial system, aid those that were unemployed, and improve the U.S. economy during the Great Depression. Historians like Jim Powell and Adam Cohen have opposing views about the effectiveness of Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal. While Cohen believes that the New Deal aided America in ending the Great Depression, Powell believes the New Deal elongated the period of the Great Depression(cnn.com). According to Powell, “The New Deal prolonged the Great Depression...because of a combination of

Show More
Related

  • How Successful Was The New Deal Dbq

    738 Words  | 3 Pages

    The New Deal included programs that would help average citizens find relief and provide recovery from the dire economic situation, helped farmers recover from foreclosures produce more crops and reduce the prices of crops for citizens and consequently expanded the role of gov’t because more people depended more on their gov’t in a time of need. The Great Depression started after the stock market crash of 1929, shortly thereafter companies started firing millions of workers (Document J) to save money because CEO’s are always greedy and always want to keep as much money as possible for themselves. FDR’s response to mass unemployment was to create agencies like the TVA (Document I) which employed unemployed workers in Tennessee for public projects such as bridges, roads, dams, parks etc. Anything that benefited the public was built so that people had jobs and were able to bring the economy out the depression.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq

    589 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1933, newly inaugurated, President Roosevelt launched the New Deal, a plan that took action to stop the crisis of the Great Depression. Although, his plan to restore the economy and welfare of the people helped America in Many ways, it created controversy. The New Deal was a good deal because it decreased

    Read More

  • The New Deal Pros And Cons

    60 Words  | 1 Pages

    The New Deal did not benefited the U.S.in the long term. The New Deal was created between 1933 and 1938 by Franklin Roosevelt. He created the New Deal for people that were unemployed. The New Deal provided old-age insurances and unemployment benefits. It was also was supposed to help the families that dependent children and for people that were disabled.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Essay

    1051 Words  | 5 Pages

    The New Deal helped clean up the mess of the stock market crash and helped stabilize banks but The New Deal didn’t just save those things it saved this American Democracy as we know it, We see many examples of this in document 3 when we see all the actions that took place like granted emergency loans to banks or even the employment of 8 millions people, but the greatest of this was when they established 40 cents minimum wage and 40 hours in the work week. The New Deal millions of jobs and hosted public works projects that reached most every county in the nation. Abuse of the stock market was more clearly defined and monitored to prevent collapses in the future. In less than a decade The New Deal gave jobs to many in every country, state, and city in the world, and because of its effects Franklin Roosevelt was known as one of the greatest presidents we have ever had, but we could also say that World War 2 ended the Great Depression and to this day we as people never want our stock market to crash as badly as it

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq

    628 Words  | 3 Pages

    Franklin D. Roosevelt introduced the New Deal to help many people that were affected by the depression that started in October 1929. The Wall Street crash in 1929 would be the crash that would cause a depression in America and that was the economic depression. After the depression that Wall Street market crashed. 12 million people were put out of work, which also caused 20,000 companies to go bankrupt. Many people were depressed and were looking for a way out.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Essay

    618 Words  | 3 Pages

    The New was bargaining the money they did not have. FDR attempted to help better the situation but ultimately he only provide emotional support rather than financial support, “ ...made a lot of us feel a lot better even when there wasn’t much to eat in our homes” ( Doc. C) Roosevelt was a kind hearted man, he tried to help and he did help but at the end of the day the United States was still in Great Depression. His New Deals still left most Americans without food on their plate when it came at dinner time.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Essay

    980 Words  | 4 Pages

    People were desperate for a change during The Great Depression. Franklin Roosevelt, remembered as the one who successfully guided the nation through the Great Depression and World War Two, was able to pass a deal that would help the nation drastically. This deal became known as the New Deal. The components of the New Deal changed millions of lives for Americans struggling through the Great Depression, however, many people were still opposed to FDR’s program.

    Read More

  • New Deal DBQ

    949 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the 1930’s a group of government programs and policies were established under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, they were created with the intention to help the American people during The Great Depression. The Great Depression was a time were many banks failed, many businesses and factories went bankrupt, and millions of Americans are out of work, homeless, and hungry. Most New Deal programs gave American citizens economic relief, chances for employment and helped for the general good. The New Deal’s intention was to help Americans during these troubling times filled with economic uncertainty, and in that aspect, it was a success. After the New Deal was implemented, unemployment rates were gradually lowered.

    Read More

  • The Forgotten Man Amity Shlaes Summary

    623 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the Great Depression “the currency was becoming more valuable every day, rarer and scarcer” (Shlaes 108). The Great Depression was the reason to change and reform government. Even though Shlaes wrote Roosevelt and his New Deal made the Depression stay longer, but in reality to recover from the Great Depression, Roosevelt New Deal helped economy to get back in track. The New Deal made the government to be more involved in people’s life. New Deal used Government as an agent and started to intervene in the economic institution in order to recover from the failure.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Essay

    564 Words  | 3 Pages

    The programs created by the New Deal satisfied the needs of citizens, even though several thought Roosevelt was overstepping his power. Roosevelt’s administration was not very effective in ending the Great Depression, however, some of the programs did help relieve

    Read More

  • The Great Depression Research Paper Outline

    502 Words  | 3 Pages

    The New Deal also opened soup kitchens were the unemployed could go to get a free meal. The New Deal also managed banks so the banks couldn’t spend money that they didn’t even have, and it also helped end the depression and helps prevent new ones from happening in the

    Read More

  • Fdr Dbq Essay

    546 Words  | 3 Pages

    The new deal was a program that created jobs during the Great Depression. The New Deal was a program that created jobs for people during the depression. Some of the programs they made where the CCC, WPA and other programs (Doc B). The New Deal had a positive effect on the people during the great depression because it gave people jobs and a way to make money. The New Deal had employed many people giving them jobs for example, at the beginning of the Great Depression unemployment was at its highest 25% and when the new deal was put into action unemployment

    Read More

  • The New Deal: Positive Effects Of The Great Depression

    847 Words  | 4 Pages

    Many people wonder what the New Deal really did for the American people. The New Deal was a series of national programs proposed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt. The New Deal programs happened during 1933-1938, right after the Great Depression. The New Deal had a very positive effect on the people of America by creating new jobs, gaining trust in banking systems, and getting freedom from the effects of the Great Depression.

    Read More

  • Differences Between Science And Pseudoscience

    1410 Words  | 6 Pages

    Modern science is typically subdivided into the natural sciences, which study the material world, the social sciences which study people and societies, and the formal sciences like mathematics. The formal sciences are often excluded as they do not depend on empirical observations.[5] We have to keep in mind that science helps us describe how the world is, but it cannot make any judgments about whether that state of affairs is right, wrong, good, or bad and individual people must make moral judgments.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Natural Science And Mathematics

    1000 Words  | 4 Pages

    In mathematics the knowledge we obtain is justified with reason that have straightforward theories and laws. In natural science on the other hand the information we collect is firstly obtained with observations which can be perceived in the wrong manner and then carried out wrong after that, in the natural world things are always changing therefore the results we get now won’t necessarily be correct one hundred years down the line therefore the knowledge we have now of the natural sciences is correct until proven wrong. Knowledge is trustworthy in most of our subjects at school but we can never know if the information we are receiving is 100% accurate or not because in the future we may learn that the information we have is

    Read More

More about How Do Some Historians Respond To The Same Facts

Open Document