How Does John Q Health Care Reform
John Q directed by Nick Cassavetes, is a film that came out in February 2002 that strongly argued for Healthcare reform in an era when it was not widely discussed. John Q follows the story of John Quincy Archibald a black middle-aged impoverished factory worker and his son, Michael, who had an enlarged heart and requires a heart transplant. The next hour of the film is spent battling Archibald’s hospital, insurance company, and government as he struggles desperately to get his son a heart despite his low income. And this war John Archibald is waging seems to be lost one until he dons the name “John Q” and takes an entire hospital and health system hostage. His terms, free healthcare for all: for his son, for his hostages, for his country, no more bureaucratic red tape between the people and healthcare. While Denzel Washington’s fictitious character does …show more content…
1 in the box office in its first weekend but it received mostly negative reviews amongst Rotten Tomatoes, IMDB, New York Times, and TIME magazine, despite receiving overwhelmingly positive reviews from the American populace. Critics argued that heart transplants are not regulated by cost and anyone can be placed on the transplant list if necessary, insurance companies do not work on annual caps but rather lifetime caps of around one million dollars, and the actual cost of heart transplant as of today without insurance average is 787,000 dollars not 250,000 but it is usually mostly covered by any insurance policy [Jeffrey Kruger, 2002], but that is aside the point. John Q’s controversy truly results from the questions it inspires: Could this story happen anywhere else? Could health care reform truly fix this issue? Did John Q’s race factor into the overall plot? Why has this not happened in reality? John Q poses as an excellent case study for the researcher looking to understand the state of American Healthcare today and will serve as the platform for this
Case Study Heritage Valley Medical Center
540 Words | 3 PagesBackground statement: Heritage Valley Medical Center has had a wonderful reputation for providing excellent health care services to their community. Initially, their community was 80% Caucasian, 40% African American, and 5% Hispanic. However, in the last 5 years, the population has changed to more minorities and the whites have moved out to the suburbs. This caused the Center’s occupancy rate to go down 40% because many of their traditional, more affluent, private-pay patients had left the neighborhood. To bring in revenue, they campaigned to bring in more Medicaid patients.
Summary Of Liberals Are Wrong
663 Words | 3 PagesMegan McCardle and Claudia Chaufan have brought many different opinions about healthcare reform. In “Liberals Are Wrong: Free Market Health Care is Possible" by Megan McCardle, she has argued that is not available for people to purchase the right and needed healthcare. Besides that, Claudia Chaufan has stated that people can purchase their own healthcare plans and also mentioned about the single-payer plan. Although having some shared ideas about health insurances, each of the authors had their significant concepts. Based on “Ken Arrow’s critique of healthcare markets”, Megan McCardle has indicated her opposition against him.
Henrietta Lacks Research Paper
974 Words | 4 PagesThe Journal of Primary Care and Community Health states, “Physicians delay diagnostic testing, prescribe more generic medications, and avoid referral to specialty care for their patients of low SES versus other patients.” With these staggering results this proves the separation and racism within the medical field. People of color and those who are not as well off, are forced to handle these poor conditions for treatment, while those who are white and with more money are more inclined to get better care and medication. This is the issue with today’s health care because it does not treat every person equally, there is a huge amount of favoritism within the
Single Payer Universal Healthcare System
1605 Words | 7 PagesIn addition to the dismay of many healthcare professionals, patients, and citizens who are uninsured, several flaws about the current healthcare system show the necessity for reform. The three flaws that exacerbate the current healthcare crisis are: the tax code and tax breaks, the lack of preventable care and adequate care of chronic diseases, and administrative costs. A single payer, universal healthcare system can resolve the major flaws of the
Antigone Movie And Play Comparison Essay
1363 Words | 6 PagesJohn Q goes up against the government so that the doctor will perform surgery on his dying son by holding the hospital hostage. These two events are so major that they are the cause the theme for the whole play and
Should The Canadian Health Care System Be Privatized
832 Words | 4 PagesThe one major difference between the Canadian health care system and the American health care system is that is that they have a privatized health care system. A documentary such as “Sicko directed by Michael Moore” demonstrates the crisis of American citizens without health care coverage. Canada’s universal health care system ensures those who cannot pay for health to not suffer, contrary to the Sicko
Pros And Cons Of Health Care
741 Words | 3 PagesThe real debate is how can we accomplish the goal of universal healthcare in the most affordable and sustainable way. The United States is evaluated as a wealthy country, yet there are more penurious countries who provide health maintenance, paid through higher taxes. “In the United Kingdom and other European countries, payroll taxes average 37% - much higher than the 15.3% payroll taxes paid by the average US worker” (Gregory). With this data, the only reform would be to end the private health insurance companies of dominant health services, and incorporate a single payer system. Conversely, it is factual that taxes will rise, but the implementation of universal healthcare will better the health of American citizens.
Improve American Democracy Essay
803 Words | 4 PagesThe U.S. could follow models of universal healthcare that have been proven to work in other countries, like Canada and Sweden, in which to lay the framework of a new system of universal healthcare. It would provide coverage for citizens of every economic class via whichever avenue of funding proves to be most efficient. The success of universal healthcare in other nations proves that this is an achievable goal, well within the realm of
Health Care Disparities
570 Words | 3 PagesHealth Care in the US is arguably available to all who seek it but not everybody has had the same experience and treatment when walking through the doors of a healthcare facility. In many cases, people are discriminated against due to their gender, race/ethnicity, age, and income and are often provided with minimal service. Differences between groups in health coverage, access to care, and quality of care is majorly affected through these disparities. Income is a major factor and can cause groups of people to experience higher burden of illness, injury, disability, or mortality relative to another group.
Medicaid Reforms
1437 Words | 6 PagesThe expansion of Medicaid through the implementation of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has initiated many states to try innovative ideas to improve their Medicaid programs. Many states, like Minnesota, had started the reform process prior to the passage of the ACA with the purpose of improving the quality of care for Medicaid beneficiaries and to utilize a more cost-effective system to provide Medicaid benefits. One of the innovative ideas that states like Minnesota is implementing is the use of accountable care organizations (ACOs). This paper will explore ACOs by studying the reforms within the Minnesota Medicaid program. Background Medicaid was originally established by the government to provide medical services and payment for individuals
Universal Health Care Argumentative Essay
727 Words | 3 PagesHealth care should not be considered a political argument in America; it is a matter of basic human rights. Something that many people seem to forget is that the US is the only industrialized western nation that lacks a universal health care system. The National Health Care Disparities Report, as well as author and health care worker Nicholas Conley and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), strongly suggest that the US needs a universal health care system. The most secure solution for many problems in America, such as wasted spending on a flawed non-universal health care system and 46.8 million Americans being uninsured, is to organize a national health care program in the US that covers all citizens for medical necessities.
Disparities In Health Care Essay
367 Words | 2 PagesMany Americans were led to believe that the introduction of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in 2009 would put an end to disparities in health care access. While it did improve the situation for a small percentage of the population there are still many Americans who lack access to good quality health care. Health care access in America is determined by money and those in lower socioeconomic groups frequently tend to miss out on adequate care. In a recent health care report by the national health research foundation Kaiser Family Foundation, it was noted “health care disparities remain a persistent problem in the United States, leading to certain groups being at higher risk of being uninsured, having limited access to care, and experiencing poorer quality of care” (Kaiser Family Foundation). The current health care
Sicko Film Summary
811 Words | 4 PagesSicko is an accusation of the United States’ health care structure, emphasizing insurance horror tales and profiling states/countries with complete health attention. Moore has used an emotional appeal in the documentary. (Marmor, 2007) The two issues Moore has discussed are the health system and political conditions. However, “Sicko,” struggles to convey the fact that the American scheme of private medical protection is a cataclysm, and also that a state-run scheme, like one that is present almost everywhere else in the developed world, would be the best.
Health Care In Canada Essay
895 Words | 4 PagesCanada enjoys the benefits of a “universal” insurance plan funded by the federal government. The idea of having a publicly administered, accessible hospital and medical services with comprehensive coverage, universality and portability has its own complex history, more so, than the many challenges in trying to accommodate the responsibility of a shared-cost agreement between federal and provincial governments. (Tiedemann, 2008) Canada’s health care system has gone through many reforms, always with the intent to deliver the most adequate health care to Canadians. The British North American Act, Hospital Insurance and Diagnostic Services Act, Saskatchewan’s Medical Care Act, and the Canada Health Act are four Acts that have played an important
Distributive Justice In Health Care
418 Words | 2 PagesEthical Complexity of Distribute Justice and Rationing Medicine is a practice based on moral standards applied to clinical values and judgments, also known as medical ethics. Ethical values consists of beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy and justice. However, these ethical principles are affected when distributive justice and rationing of health care resources are implemented “…in a world in which need is boundless but resources are not…” (Scheunemann & White, 2011, p. 1630). The historic Hippocratic Oath described the four main principles of medical practice and established a moral conduct for clinicians. Beneficence demands that health care providers develop and maintain skills and knowledge, consider individual circumstances of all patients, and strive for the patient’s benefit.
More about How Does John Q Health Care Reform
Case Study Heritage Valley Medical Center
540 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Liberals Are Wrong
663 Words | 3 PagesHenrietta Lacks Research Paper
974 Words | 4 PagesSingle Payer Universal Healthcare System
1605 Words | 7 PagesAntigone Movie And Play Comparison Essay
1363 Words | 6 PagesShould The Canadian Health Care System Be Privatized
832 Words | 4 PagesPros And Cons Of Health Care
741 Words | 3 PagesImprove American Democracy Essay
803 Words | 4 PagesHealth Care Disparities
570 Words | 3 PagesMedicaid Reforms
1437 Words | 6 PagesUniversal Health Care Argumentative Essay
727 Words | 3 PagesDisparities In Health Care Essay
367 Words | 2 PagesSicko Film Summary
811 Words | 4 PagesHealth Care In Canada Essay
895 Words | 4 PagesDistributive Justice In Health Care
418 Words | 2 Pages