Do you think that people can change their mentality? Arthur Miller’s play, "The Crucible", is based on the Salem witch trials, which happened in colonial Massachusetts between February 1692 and May 1693. More than 200 people were accused, and thirty people were found guilty—19 of whom were executed by hanging. During this time, many people ended up changing their mentality. In "The Crucible," we get introduced to a character named Reverend John Hale, who shows a lot of growth and change in his mentality throughout the whole play. A change I saw was that Hale started to grow a conscience. He started to feel guilty about everything. At first, it probably bothered him, but he never did anything to help. But once he quit the court, he kept trying …show more content…
At first, Hale took religion very seriously; he was completely shocked when he saw that John Proctor didn’t know all of the commandments. But soon he realized that just because someone sinned, it didn’t make them a bad person. For example, Cheever mentions that John Proctor isn’t a proper Christian man because he works on the Sabbath day. But Hales defends him, showing that he doesn’t care too much about the fact that John sinned. In ACT 3 of "The Crucible," Hale states, "Your honor, I cannot think you may judge the man on such evidence." (Miller, pg. 91) This quote shows how Hale defends John Proctor in court. It also shows how much Hale has changed. Before, Reverend Hale took religion and sins very seriously, and now he is defending a man who sinned. According to the 10 commandments, you must "remember the Sabbath Day and keep it holy". Another example is that Hale goes to the people in jail and tells them to confess to witchcraft even though he knows it is a lie, and lying is a pretty big sin to commit. Showing once again that he doesn’t care that they sin as long as it saves them from getting hanged. In ACT 4 of "The Crucible," Hale states, "I beg you, woman, prevail upon your husband to confess. Let him give his lie, Quail not before God’s judgment in this, for it may well be God damns a liar less than he that throws his life away for pride. Will you plead with him? I cannot think he will listen to another. (Miller, pg. 132) This quote shows that he doesn’t care if John Proctor has to lie in order to not get hanged, showing once again that he doesn’t care that he sins as long as it saves him and the rest of the accused from getting hanged. All of this goes to show that Reverend Hale’s morals have slightly changed since the beginning of the
In the last act Hale was speaking with John Proctor and began to realize that Proctor was lying. Though Hale is a reverend he realized how the
Reverend Hale is shown trying to give John the best representation he can get in order to have a chance to win the court. If Hale didn’t want John to succeed, he never would’ve offered Proctor this chance to Danforth. He starts to show his doubts in all the girls during this scene and the court's
He had almost an arrogant way about him in the search for the devil. He also states, “the devil can never overcome a minister.” (Miller 15) This quote shows Hale's arrogance and that he thought the devil could never overcome a minister such as himself. Hale made it clear that he was willing to hang any person that was unwilling to confess to witchcraft, therefore, he was in the middle of all this murder and
Hale’s Change Have you ever been so confident in your work you get blinded by all the glory and forget to do what's right? well In the play The Crucible by Arthur Miller. Hale is confident in his work at first but later on he feels guilty for not seeing that some people are actually telling the truth. Hale is confident about his work in the witch trials.
Later, Hale tells Elizabeth, “I beg you, woman, prevail upon your husband to confess. Let him give his lie” (Miller 131). Hale wanted to help Elizabeth get out of jail by trying to make her confess, since Hale knew she would be
When Hale entered the story he believed that he was going to be the savior of the town ridding them of witches. When Rebecca Nurse and John Proctor were arrested Reverend Hale was deeply shaken with his beliefs. Hale near the end of the story he tells Elizabeth that you should not have religion when it brings you harm but you should keep faith in God. Reverend Hale near ending of The Crucible is the complete opposite of the Reverend Hale that first entered the story, because he came in believing he was the authority on how to find witches, then he was shaken by arrest of Rebecca and John, and finally by him telling others to throw away religion when it brings harm to
Let him give his lie. Quail not before God’s judgement in this, for it may well be God damns a liar less than he that throws his life away for pride. Will you plead with him? I cannot think he will listen to another.” Reverend Hale pleads with Goody Proctor “ Let him give his lie.”
It is mistaken law that leads you to sacrifice. Life, woman, life is God 's most precious gift; no principle, however glorious, may justify the taking of it” (Act 4, 132). In fact, Hale doesn’t suggest Elizabeth to use religion to get Proctor to confess, but rather just a simple word of telling him to survive. In conclusion, Reverend Hale finds that going against the court is obligation that is needed to be done because no one has done that and the society needs rebellion
He said, "I dare not take a life without there be a proof no immaculate no slightest qualm of conscience may doubt it" (Miller 188). He did not want anyone to hang for a crime they did not commit, and he did not want any guilty conscience of it afterward. He started to realize that people are accusing others for their own gain, and when no one would listen, Hale quit the court. In Act 4, Hale tries to save people's lives by convincing them to confess. He doubts his own Puritan faith and pursues the falsely accused on his own.
As the play progress and people confess he starts to notice that what people are saying and accusing people of is not true but just getting to people they do not like. Lastly, At the end of act 3, Hale quits the court. Hale quit the court because he knew that a lot of innocent people were getting killed for not confessing to a crime they did not
Hale acknowledges human’s mortality more so than Danforth who believes his word is the final say. Furthermore, Judge Danforth appears to only be concerned with having those who were jailed, confess to being witches whether they were or not. All those who do not confess to conspiring with the devil in his eyes are evil and those “who weep for [them, therefore] weep for corruption” (134). In contrast, Hale is desperate to save the innocent from their inevitable doom because he believes “life is God’s most precious gift” and “no principle [] may justify taking it” (122). He even encourages Elizabeth Proctor to “prevail upon [her] husband to confess” because “God damns a liar less than he that throws his life away for pride” (122).
Reverend Hale is the character that changes the most in Arthur Miller’s play The Crucible because his feelings on witchcraft turns from full belief to unbelievable doubt, his thoughts on Proctor changes from thinking that he is evil to thinking that he is a good and honest man, and he switches from doing God’s work to doing the Devil’s. Reverend Hale makes a huge change on his claim of witchcraft. In the beginning of the play when Reverend is called to the town of Salem to see if the reason why Betty and Ruth are unconscious is due to witchcraft he brings with him many books. When Reverend Parris sees this he makes a comment that Hale responds to him explaining his expectations. This shows that Reverend Hale is focused on one thing, finding
At this point in the story, fourteen people had been accused and arrested for witchcraft allegations, all of these people were sentenced to be arrested by Reverend Hale and after that sentenced to be hanged. While talking to John Proctor, a man who is skeptical of the false accusations, Reverend Hale says to John “Man, remember, until an hour before the Devil fell, God thought him beautiful”(68) This is a reflection of how Reverend Hale can not deny any accusation because, as an ordained minister he is obligated to follow every bit of the Bible which states that anyone can change due to the Devil. As we see Reverend Hale progress as a character we see him progress to moving away from the Bible for evidence. Prior to the conversation he had with John, he was talking to Goody Proctor, John’s wife who is considered a very godly woman.
In the beginning acts, Hale was trusting the court more than John and was a big part of handling warrants of the accused individuals along with having much confidence in himself, his knowledge of witchcraft, and knowledge of witches in Salem. In Act 2 and 3 in the play, The Crucible by Arthur Miller, the character Reverend Hale was changing a lot. Throughout the first act of this play Reverend Hale had much of his trust in the court and fully believed the devil is in Salem but as the trial begins and goes on things start to change when Hale starts to question the court shown when he pleads
He then explains how “no crack in a fortress may be accounted small” (II.573-574.) after John could not remember his last commandment. Meaning that Puritans should be perfect, and any small crack in their faith makes them susceptible to going against their religion. Hale does not want to turn against his religion, so he continues to agree with the court, whereas more innocent people are being accused and hanged.