ipl-logo

Hungar Case Study Essay

781 Words4 Pages

Nasir Haque lodged her application for Skilled Sponsored subclass 886 visa and she has two dependent children. Her 12 years old daughter (second applicant) was suffering from “autistic spectrum disorder”. They all are citizens of Hungary. At the time the applicants made their visa application, the primary applicants and her family members has to satisfy the public interest criteria. As part of visa process, all the applicants has to go through the medical assessment to make sure that they are free from a disease or condition that may result the applicant being, a threat to public health in Australia or a danger to Australian community and free from disease which might require community services and would cause a significant cost to Australian community. …show more content…

Whether or not an applicant meets the health requirement is a totally arbitrary decision of Medical Officer of Commonwealth alone, based on documents supplied via Panel Doctor. One of the more controversial elements of assessments made under the health requirements is the standard of the ‘hypothetical person’. This test basically assesses the level of a visa applicant’s disability and measures that against the health and community services which a person currently in Australia with the same condition would be eligible to access. In this case, majority of pediatrician’s medical report stated that girl was functioning fairly well and attending to all her personal hygiene and activities of daily living. But RMOC gave totally different opinion that she is totally dependent and it was based on hypothetical person with similar disability. Tribunal thought that it was bound to accept the Medical Officer’s opinion but in reality it is not. The Tribunal is not bound by technicalities, legal forms or rules of evidence and shall act according to substantial justice and the merits of the

Show More
Related

  • Ferjo V Ontario Human Rights Tribunal Case Study

    1511 Words  | 7 Pages

    Mrs. Ferjo’s application against the tribunal stated that she believed that the tribunal discriminated against her at the previous hearing when they denied her legal representation. Mrs. Ferjo checked off sexual discrimination on the application form but could not provide any factual evidence that she faced discrimination on those grounds. Mrs. Ferjo was therefore unable to establish prima facie case. [2] The tribunal argued the doctrine of judicial immunity prevented legal proceedings against judicial members based on their actions as an adjudicator or decision maker. This is so that judicial members can make decisions without fear of consequences.

    Read More

  • Habrzyk Case Analysis

    1142 Words  | 5 Pages

    It is further detailed in this legal issue that Gomez petition for the “settled” exceptions because Gomez could no longer file the petition on “wrongful removal” of the twins as it have already lapsed the 12 months provision of the Hague Convention, the Article 12 of the Hague Convention is put in question as “it is demonstrated that child is now settled in its new environment.” Habrzyk. Under the settlement issue, the factors courts consider in determining if a child has “significant connections” to the new country: “(1) the child’s age; (2) the stability and duration of the child’s residence in the new environment; (3) whether the child attends school or day care consistently; (4) whether the child has friends and relatives in the new area; (5) the child’s participation in community or extracurricular school activities, such as team sports (6) the respondent’s employment and financial stability.” Habrzyk. The Hague Convention further cannot tackle the issue on who has the right on custody of the child with wrongful removal of the child from the petitioner’s country.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Australia And Ethiopia

    1232 Words  | 5 Pages

    Developing countries, such as Ethiopia, are not yet advanced agriculturally and economically. Developed countries, such as Australia, are economically, agriculturally and technologically advanced. This booklet focuses on the health status of Australian children and children from the developing country Ethiopia. Health indicators and determinants are used to compare the children’s health status from both of these countries. Australia is a country and a continent.

    Read More

  • Mental Capacity Act

    1886 Words  | 8 Pages

    The person’s behaviour. • Their circumstances. • Concerns raised by someone else. However, age, appearance and condition do not by themselves establish lack of capacity.

    Read More

  • Gillick V. Justice Woolf's Lack Of Care

    944 Words  | 4 Pages

    However, this did not seem to shift the views of the local authority and they could not promise that no advice would be given. As a result, Mrs Gillick petitioned across the country and took her case to the High Court. Mr Justice Woolf held that she was not entitled to the declaration she sought because “in order to obtain the relief the plaintiff had to establish… that lack of parental consent would render the doctor’s conduct unlawful” however Woolf decided that the plaintiff did not establish this and a doctor would make an effort to ensure that nothing happened

    Read More

  • Describe The Causes And Effects Of Complex Disability And Conditions

    1267 Words  | 6 Pages

    1.1 Describe the causes and effects of complex disabilities and conditions. Mental health issues ranging from the doubts and uncertainties have become a part of daily routine, towards serious long term situation which can be very complex for managing and having a diversifying impact on the overall live of the people. The usual child health leads to contribute towards overall development (Watson & Le Couteur, 2011). Therefore it is important to take special care of people with complex disability as they turn out to be sensitive enough about the situation and environment they are living in.

    Read More

  • Citizenship: What Does It Means To Be Australian Citizens

    419 Words  | 2 Pages

    Start Your Visa Assessment Here Security Due to security concerns subsequent to threat of terrorism from abroad, anew provision has been drawn which prohibits the approval of an Australian citizenship application if that person is identified as a risk to Australia 's security. The prohibition applies to all applications including those for Australian citizenship by descent, Australian citizenship by conferral, and applications for the resumption of Australian

    Read More

  • Barriers In Health And Social Care Essay

    450 Words  | 2 Pages

    The NHS and their facilities and health professionals ensure that Ruth receives the physical care that is needed, which is crucial for her health and wellbeing. From the services of the NHS, I see that they are effective in providing Ruth’s needs and ensures that Ruth visits her GP regularly. Furthermore, the GP ensures that Ruth’s needs are met by ensuring there are no physical barriers that prevent Ruth from receiving care and make sure that she has her regular health checks so that her physical development and wellbeing is monitored and under control. The GP’s strength in minimising this barrier encourages Ruth’s positive development by allowing her and her family to be more aware of her condition and making sure her needs are

    Read More

  • Support Observation: A Case Study

    432 Words  | 2 Pages

    SP also went over the DMS service and the participant stated that she received it only one time and stated that she does not need it for now and she will request when she needs it. SP went the personal assistance service and the participant stated that she doesn’t need any personal assistance. Then SP explained to her that she need to get a personal assistance in order to get other services and the participant stated that her husband helping her based on her daily life and also she stated that when the participant’s husband not home, the participant’s friends and neighborhood help her. SP explained to the participant that in order to get services at least to pick 4 or 5 hours for personal assistance but the participant refused the personal assistance services. Also, she stated that she will be in the Medical Day Care and the time when she got home her husband will be home

    Read More

  • Essay On Wrongful Life

    1607 Words  | 7 Pages

    A claim of wrongful life on the other hand is brought by the child or on behalf of the child based on the doctor’s negligence that resulted in the birth of the disabled child and his failure to sufficiently inform the parents of the risk . Wrongful life claims involve the disabled claiming that they have been born into a miserable life that was unwanted and seek financial relief . In both wrongful conception claims and wrongful birth claims it is the parents who bring up the claim against a doctor’s negligence. However, in a wrongful life claim it is the disabled child who brings up the claim. In the given case, it is said that Llyod and Maya “want to bring a delictual action against the physician on Lulu’s behalf”, this means that a wrongful life action would be the action that is the most applicable in this scenario.

    Read More

  • Definition Of Destitution In Glory

    421 Words  | 2 Pages

    The government definition of destitution is set out in the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 and the Nationality Immigration and Asylum Act 2002. The later definition states that a person and their dependants are destitute if they do not have and cannot obtain both (A) Adequate accommodation, (b) food and other essential items. Children’ society states that destitution encompasses more than economic or material hardship but it includes those without any legitimate status, basic rights or entitlements. The important aspect of destitution is when people lack security and are limited in the degree to which they can plan and hope as in the case of Glory and her children cited in the case study below, due to their unstable accommodation the children

    Read More

  • Observation In Foster Care

    1720 Words  | 7 Pages

    Additionally, the intake form asks if parents would like to have an interpreter at the assessment visit at the Child Development

    Read More

  • What Is The Declaration Of Children's Rights Between 1948 And 1979

    174 Words  | 1 Pages

    The 1948 and 1959 documents’ main purpose was to protect the child and to emphasize the child’s right to be provided welfare. In 1979, after a proposal from Poland, a working group was set

    Read More

  • 1.1 Explain The Importance Of Effective Hand Washing In Schools

    437 Words  | 2 Pages

    (http://www.nhmrc.gov.au, Page 11,2012) *Exclusion of ill children, educators and staff- excluding ill children, staff and educators is an effective way to limit the spread of infection in childcare services. Giving clear policy to all parents and staff explaining why the centre has an exclusion policy will prevent any conflicts in the future. The policy would state that all children unwell with contagious disease or illness should be excluded from the centre until they get the all clear from doctor and provide a doctors certificate. Also encouraging parents to teach their children the importance of hygiene by using the same routine that the child uses at childcare. If a child

    Read More

  • Border Force Act 2015

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    This may require reform of section 42, which enables secretaires to restrict employees from discussing health concerns in detention centres. Furthermore, the Australian government should ensure the standard of care provided to Asylum seekers at Nauru and Manus Island complies with the “Australian codes of medical practices and clinical standards”. This will require an increase of medical supplies and a greater number of medical staff to provide a high standard of care. Additionally, new policies should be introduced that would enable Asylum seekers to receive medical care beyond the borders of a detention centre when required this should also include those who are experiencing physiological

    Read More

More about Hungar Case Study Essay

Open Document