Evie Bedrick
Ms. Leininger
Language Arts Period 7
2 February 2018
Poetry Assessment
For many people the American dream is to pursue happiness. Something that has been in the country for decades. It gives people the hope and an optimistic attitude toward the brighter future. In “I Hear America Singing” by Walt Whitman and “I, Too, Sing America” by Langston Hughes, both explore the theme of the American dream. Both poets use literary devices such as allusion, extended metaphor, symbolism, and repetition to display that America is a song in which where the people have an important part to sing. Both authors use figurative language however Walt Whitman praises the situation of individual efforts of Americans whereas Langston Hugh focuses on the collective struggle by African Americans.
…show more content…
He establishes this through metaphor in the first line when he says, “varied carols” which represents the different voices of people singing in America. When Whitman writes about the carpenter singing “as he measures his plank or beam or the mason, boatman, the shoe maker, the wood cutter, the mother are all singing as they work throughout the day. By writing this he illustrates that each singing worked is different; no two people are doing the same thing. This suggest that the people are not singing the same song, but they do all share one thing- a dream of a better future. Whitman also use repetition by beginning every line with the working class folks “singing” in his or her unique way and repeats the structure to suggest the feeling of harmony. The chorus shows how everyone is ultimately working towards their American
Walt Whitman, in “I Hear America Singing,” describes America as a place with diverse opportunities and freedoms; in Langston Hughes’s poem “I, Too” he describes how America is divided; however, he is hopeful for a better America. In “I Hear America Singing”, Whitman describes America as harmonious, beautiful, and full of hardworking people. America
The poems also have different points of views. Whitman's refers to I Hear America singing as a varied carol with nine different workers. He talks about in line three a carpenter then in line four a mason and the boatman. Whitman also talks about a shoe maker and a hatter. Whitman identifies people as his or her talking.
What is the American Dream? Many people have tried to explain the dream, or how they feel about the dream. Most try to be all patriotic and country loving like Walt Whitman... But others like Langston Hughes reveal a darker side of the dream. Whitman hears America Singing.
Thus giving a small part of the American Dream. In comparison reading the poem "I hear America singing by Walt Whitman the tone
agree with. Time plays a crucial role in the role of the meaning of “America” and the American dream. Not all outlooks on America are positive and inspirational. Although America thought of as this land of unlimited resources, jobs, and happiness; the harsh reality is that it is a place of unequal ‘equal’ opportunities. Langston Hughes’ poem “I, Too” highlights how the oppressed can hold onto hope for a more equal future.
Claim: "I Hear America Singing" by Walt Whitman and "I, Too, Sing America" by Langston Hughes, seem as though they would be similar poems, and in some aspects they are, but overall they are incredibly different. Whitman talks about America in general and what makes America, America. Hughes speaks about segregation and racism that is America, but that someday they'll be accepted as part of America too. Support 1: "I Hear America Singing" speaks about the industrial revolution, carpenters, and boat man. The use of the steamboat, big cities, rural areas, and housewives and children.
In the beginning of the poem, Langston Hughes converses about what the American Dream is to him and who believed it. Let it be the dream it used to be (2) The American Dream was noted to be, the land where you obtained complete peace and equality
The tone of Langston Hughes’ poem “I, Too, Sing America” is determined and talks about how “tomorrow” he will do what he pleases instead of doing what his master
In “I hear America singing” by Langston Hughes we see the American dream depicted as the American Dream for Blacks in a time of segregation and
We are able to see this when Whitman says “The boatman singing what belongs to him in his boat, the deckhand singing on the steamboat deck, The shoemaker singing as he sits on his bench, the hatter singing as he stands”(Whitman, 5-7). That quote shows how the people like doing there job. But in the poem “I, Too” it talks about racism and how he is going to overcome it, we can see this when Hughes states “Besides, They’ll see how beautiful I am And be ashamed(15-17)” this shows that he doesn 't care about what they think about him because he know that he is beautiful. This shows how the two poems are different by how they both have different stories and meanings behind the writing. They are different stories because the two talk about two different things like in “I Hear America Singing,” Whitman talks about how everyone loves what they do and want to sing because of it while in the poem “I, Too,” Hughes writes about racism and how he can overcome it, which shows how different the two poems
At this time, the dream was equality and being accepted as citizens of the United States. Hughes felt that this goal of liberty and quality for African Americans was very hard to reach or match. A poem that resembles this thought well is titled “Youth”, where Hughes writes, “We have tomorrow… Bright before us… Like a flame” (Hughes 39). This poem has a lot of analysis towards the American Dream.
"I Hear America Singing" focuses on the glories of America, showcasing the happiness and joy that is present on a daily basis. This is clearly evidenced in one of the lines from Whitman's poem: "Singing with open mouths their strong melodious songs." However, "I, Too, Sing America highlights the darker side of American life during this era. Unlike Whitman, Hughes' poem takes a much more serious tone, that forces the reader to consider the other side of the coin. This is poignately illustrated in the line, "And be ashamed -" which points to the "they" that will be ashamed in the future for how "they" treated the African American
One way that Whitman conveys his poetry is through the eyes of the everyday man. In this period of American history, the civil war was ongoing, and his poetry did not shy away from the everyday
In this grand poem, Whitman glorifies the unity of all people and life. He embraces the geographical diversity as well as the diversity of culture, work, as well as sexuality or beliefs. Whitman’s influence sets American dreams of freedom, independence, and self-fulfillment, and changes them for larger spiritual meaning. Whitman appreciates hard work as well as being simple and non-egotistical. His major ideas are things such as soul, good health, as well as the love of nature.
A Song Without Lyrics * The American Dream is like “a song without lyrics.” * Every American Dream is different. In both John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men and in S.E Hinton’s