They argue that if more immigrants come to the United States, there will be less welfare, such as medical, economic and educational welfare from the government, for U.S. citizens. Nazario points out this view in her book,” Overall, the NRC said, immigrants use more government services than native-born Americans. They have more children, and therefore more kids in public schools. . .
In the first chapter of Jonas Pontusson’s book Inequality and Prosperity: Social Europe vs Liberal America, he raises an important question regarding if we are caught in a situation in which governments can no longer do much to improve the economic prospect of low-income workers and their families. Although the answer to his question varies in different countries, it is clear that the U.S. government CAN improve the lives of low-income citizens, but it often neglects to do so. The United States is a capitalist driven country. However, its quest for economic prosperity has come at the expense of those unable to reach the standard income. As much as Ronald Reagan have proclaimed the U.S. as the poster-boy of democracy and economic prosperity, the reality today is that many people are still deprived from the “American dream.” Despite occasional turmoil, there is no denying that the U.S. government has done an amazing job maintaining its economy.
One common myth that society has about poverty is that those who live at poverty level are uneducated individuals, this is just not true. In 2012, approximately 1.1 million people who made less than $25,000 a year, worked full time, and were heads of households has a bachelor’s degree (Eichelberger, 2014). Another common myth is that people who live at poverty level and receive assistance are bankrupting the nation, again this is another myth. In 2012, total welfare funding was 0.47% of the federal budget (Eichelberger, 2014). There are some in the society that even believe that we as a country are winning the war on poverty and that there are less American’s living at or below the poverty level.
Illegal immigrant’s residency in the U.S. negatively affects our economy. Their residency here leaves less housing for our legal citizens. They only have to pay less than half the normal cost for households and only pay one-fourth of the household taxes (Dudley 88). Since they are here and need money, they’re taking job opportunities away from U.S. citizens. There has been some cases when the illegal immigrants have been getting fake or copied others social security.
One can assume that when a child is raised in poverty they often do not have access to food and proper clothing these items can make it hard for children to focus in school. Lack of focus in school will lead to a lack of success, which contributes to the lack of poverty, and it becomes an ongoing cycle. In a research done by John Hopkins it was concluded that “They found that a child 's fate is in many ways fixed at birth — determined by family strength and the parents ' financial status.The kids who got a better start — because their parents were married and working — ended up better off. Most of the poor kids from single-parent families stayed poor.”
An opportunity of an adequate education, for example, can land their children on a decent job with a higher salary which can allow them to live comfortably. Statistics uphold that undocumented immigrants are contributing to this nation by paying their taxes and the only obstacle that does not encourage more immigrants to participate is the fear of being deported. By creating a pathway to citizenship, more money would be collected from immigrants by requiring them to pay taxes. The notion that undocumented immigrants are taking American jobs has also been discredited by the data showing that foreign-born and native-born employees’ unemployment rates are insignificantly different by a fraction of a percentage. In addition, undocumented immigrants are generally the only ones who are willing to accept arduous jobs.
Breaking down the data shows the contrast between different groups of immigrants and shows that while the average immigrant from a non-visible minority does average economically, immigrants from visible minorities are more likely to struggle. A disadvantage of the authors using only scientific data in their article is the lack of data on certain aspects of immigrants. They discuss that while data shows an interesting trend that people who immigrated at a younger age have higher poverty rates than those who immigrated when they were older there is no scientific research available to explain that phenomena. The article is appropriate to the presented research question because the authors suggest that visible minority groups are poor due to their ethnic origins rather than because they made poor choices in
The Christian Science Monitor, a newspaper, stated, “‘Between the steady, dependable, competent worker and the irregular, unreliable and incompetent one, the burden of taxes and benefits is disproportionately in favor of the later....’” (“Social Security Act Is Viewed As Jobs Diminisher” 1935). The benefits are in favor of the incompetent workers because of the taxes being imposed on the competent workers. The victims of the taxes imposed by the federal government were irate, yet they had little say in changing the Act. Nonetheless, they had a great impact on the U.S. economy. In time, the money that was collected and given to the elderly was passed on back to the economy.
These people are all living under the poverty line. The standard cost of living in America is $58,627. Too out of these 1.7 million Americans on minimum wage, only 21% of this number are teenagers, that leaves 79% being adults with families. Minimum wage should be raised because: some people could better support their family with more income, the economy could experience a boost , the quality of line could mean better workers, workers government program like social security food stamps and other government programs can be reduced and lastly taxes can lowered.
It is unethical that undocumented immigrants are treated like they are worthless. They should be provided the same rights as everyone else. We need to value that these undocumented immigrants bring so many benefits to our country. Their presence in our country, according to Eastman, “not only establish[es] their own new business which then creates jobs […] but also increase[s] demand for housing, food, services, and other forms of labor” (38). As a society, we do not think of these long-term effects that will benefit us because instead we are worried about not having strangers come take away what is “ours.” We need to be able to take into consideration all the outcomes of the decisions that are made before they affect our country
Many would argue that society’s high poverty and unemployment rates are branched from individual failure. It’s believed to be because of the schools in urban communities are failing to properly educate our children. Social class, the haves and have not’s are reasoning for the economic disparity in American. Some individuals are more fortunate than others. Social Class is ‘’a division of a society based on social and economic status: people from different social classes and walks of life” It’s said people living in poverty have lower graduation rates and are more likely to drop out of school.
Americans still think it is unfair that immigrants get financial benefits when US-born Americans worked hard for generations to earn their pay. As a result, millions of Americans cannot pay the bills, which leads the American economy to suffer more debt. However, America have humanitarian duties to invite immigrants who seek opportunities while protecting its own economy from thieves outside the United States. To state that immigrants do not create positive contribution to the economy is creating a single-centered story about immigrants. Legal immigrants have a desire to create the America dream come alive.
Odds are, they chose to come the U.S. because they were dissatisfied with their home country. Regarding illegal immigrants that reside in the United States, half of them are considered illegal because they have overstayed their temporary visa stays (Illegal Immigration 30). This does not make them criminals, this just means they do not wish to go back to their home country in hope for a better life in the United States. If an immigrant’s status is made legal, these workers could be just as easily absorbed into the economy. In conclusion, immigrants are unlikely to commit crimes, and more likely to devote to the American way of
Many people won 't not comprehend the motivation behind immigration appropriately. In this manner, they would most likely be along the edge that does not bolster immigration and begin to charge workers about things that would never do. However, Immigration is the action of leaving one place to others in order to study, work, or treat. Individuals should realize that immigration is going to improve their lives, whether they are the residents or the immigrants. As indicated by president Obama, the U.S is a nation of immigrants who have confidence in the American dream.