ipl-logo

Incorporation Case Study

654 Words3 Pages

When James Madison drafted the Bill of Rights, he wanted some of the provisions to apply to both the states and the federal government, but the “states would not have ratified the document [Bill of Rights] had the limitations been seen as proscribing state action,” (Scheb, 28). As such, the first amendment reads: “Congress shall make no law…” (First Amendment). In other wordas, the Bill of Rights only provided protections from the federal government—the only government with a “Congress. The states could bypass these restrictions, and many did until the Incorporation Doctrine began to take shape after the Civil War. The Fourteenth Amendment (1868) “provided an opportunity for the Supreme Court to reconsider the relationship between the Bill …show more content…

California (1947) where “the Court refused to extend the Fifth Amendment privilege against compulsory self-incrimination to state criminal trials” (Scheb, 30). Case by Case Incorporation was used by Justice Reed in his opinion in Adamson v. California (1947), where he directly states, “protection against self-incrimination is not a privilege or immunity of national citizenship” (Scheb, 61). This method of incorporation therefore interprets “due process” to permit fairness assessment on a case-by-case basis. It is “flexible, dynamic, and sensitive to the costs of incorporation”, but is also very subjective and “affords inadequate protection to civil liberties” (Class Notes, March 2). Contrasting this, Total Incorporation Plus was used by Justices Murphy and Rutledge in their dissenting opinion of Adamson v. California (1947), as they described a time when “a proceeding falls so far short of conforming to fundamental standards of procedure as to warrant constitutional condemnation in terms of a lack of due process despite the absence of a specific provision in the Bill of Rights” (Scheb, 64). They thus interpreted the word “liberty” in the Fourteenth Amendment to “protect all the provisions of the first eight amendments and any others thought fundamental” (Class Notes, March 2). This method of incorporation “affords protection for civil liberties, but is very costly and provides no clear guides as to where protections stop” (Class Notes, March

Show More
Related

  • The Anti-Federalist No. 84

    392 Words  | 2 Pages

    I Agree… “The Federalist No. 84” and “The Anti-Federalist No.84”, both have their views on what should happen to our government. Whether it is to add a bill of rights or not, but I agree with the writer of “The Federalist No.84” because if the Constitution is adopted, then it will be our Bill of Rights, also based on other countries’ bill of rights then it may argue with a semblance of reason. Because I have read both sides of the discussion, I can see who is wrong and why.

    Read More

  • 14th Amendment Pros And Cons

    444 Words  | 2 Pages

    When the new constitution was put into effect in 1789, the federal government was actually given power and had more of a say in society. The constitution gave the federal government powers, and limited that states’ powers. There are two amendments in the constitution that explains what the federal and state governments have the right to do. The tenth and the fourteenth amendment lay down the line for what the states can do and not do. Even though the federal government tells them what to do through the constitution, they give them rights as well.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Three Fifths Compromise

    1157 Words  | 5 Pages

    To replace the problematic Articles of Confederation, Washington, Hamilton, Jay, Franklin, and others organized the 1787 Philadelphia Convention and started to compose a new law of the country, the United States Constitution. However, it wasn’t easy to make every state come into an agreement on things written in the Constitution, since all the state wanted to make sure they were equally and fairly treated. As a result, several major compromises in the ratified version of the Constitution, including the Great Compromise, Three-Fifths Compromise, Slave Trade Compromise and the compromise on the Bill of Rights. The Great Compromise is the a compromise about state representatives, and it was made between large states and small states.

    Read More

  • Ratification Of The Us Constitution Dbq Essay

    827 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Constitution of the United States was written in 1787, but there was a grapple for its ratification that went on until about two decades after the ratification. Members of Congress believed that the first government of the United States or the Articles of Confederation, needed to be adjusted while others did not want anything to change. After the Revolutionary War, the people did not want a strong central government, because it reminded them too much of what they were trying to escape from. Under the Articles, each state had their own laws, and the need for a new Constitution was desired by many. The Constitution of 1787 created huge debates, arguments and splits in the nation that lasted for several year after its ratification between people who

    Read More

  • Ratifying The Constitution Dbq Essay

    967 Words  | 4 Pages

    After writing the Constitution at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia, the journey to ratification began; however, not all states were eager to ratify it due to fear of a strong central government. In order to better convince each state to ratify the Constitution in place of the Articles of Confederation, the Bill of Rights was added as a barrier against the tyranny of a strong central government. The First Amendment includes protection of many civil liberties including freedom of speech, assembly, petition, religion, and the press. The Founding Fathers included the right of freedom of the press so as to ensure the spread of intellectual, and typically liberal, ideas among the citizens, just as was done in order to inspire the revolution.

    Read More

  • 14th Amendment Dbq

    1079 Words  | 5 Pages

    The 14th amendment ensures that all citizens of the U.S are protected by the Civil Rights Act of 1964.This expanded civil liberties through the Equal Protection clause. Since the equal protection clause guarantees that states must protect the fundamental rights, which includes the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The 14th amendment expanded civil liberties because it protected African Americans fundamental rights by ensuring that states protected them through the Equal Protection

    Read More

  • Imperial Rivalry: The Imperial Revolution

    1447 Words  | 6 Pages

    Entry 1 What was A New World all about? The settlement of Americans was characterized by Indian societies, who settled in the south, north, east and southern America. They engage in various economic activities, religious activities, and gender relations that affected their interaction. This later influenced both the European and Indian freedom.

    Read More

  • Heller V. Chicago Case

    604 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dick Anthony Heller was a D.C. special police officer who was authorized to carry a handgun while on duty. He applied for a one-year license for a handgun he wished to keep at home, but his application was denied. Once Heller received his denial, he took to the District of Columbia stating that they violated his Second Amendment right to keep a functional firearm in his home without a license. The district court dismissed the complaint. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed and held that the Second Amendment protects the right to keep firearms in the home for the purpose of self-defense, and the District of Columbia’s requirement that firearms kept in the home be nonfunctional violated that right.

    Read More

  • Differences Between The Articles Of Confederation And The Anti-Federalists

    1100 Words  | 5 Pages

    They believed it was essential that individual rights were explicitly stated so that citizens were informed and could defend their own liberty (Cornell, 2012). The Federalists initially believed that a Bill of Rights was not necessary, as the states retained any rights and powers not explicitly granted to the federal government. Seeking to get the Constitution ratified, the Federalists agreed to write a Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights Institute, a non-profit foundation that aims to educate students, explains: The Bill of Rights is a list of limits on government power. For example, what the Founders saw as the natural right of individuals to speak and worship freely was protected by the First Amendment’s prohibitions on Congress from making laws establishing a religion or abridging freedom of speech.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Anti Federalist Structure Of The Government

    678 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Federalist Paper No. 84, Alexander Hamilton wrote, “For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do? Why for instance, should it be said, that the liberty of the press shall not be restrained, when no power is given by which restrictions may be imposed?”. The Federalists stating that they will limit the government so it doesn’t impose on the peoples rights, therefor stating that this makes the bill of rights

    Read More

  • Bill Of Rights Dbq

    1038 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Constitution, which was written in 1787, was not fully supported by the citizens of the United States (Buescher). Citizens of the United States felt that their natural rights regarding life and property were not being upheld or protected by the United States Constitution. From a response to these complaints came the Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights, written by James Madison in 1789, holds the first 10 amendments, or alterations, to the United States Constitution. Madison, a member of the United States House of Representatives, proposed the Bill of Rights in response to requests from states and citizens who believed that the Constitution did not protect basic human individual liberties (Bobb).

    Read More

  • Essay On 14th Amendment

    662 Words  | 3 Pages

    The 14th Amendment is one of the most influential Amendments in the history of our nation. The amendment defines what it means to be a US citizen and protects certain rights of the people. There are three important “clauses” in the 14th amendment, each of which are still important today. The clauses are; the Citizenship Clause, which gave individuals who were born in the United States, especially African Americans at the time Citizenship, the Due Process Clause, which protects the first amendment rights of the people from being taken away by any government without due process, the third and final clause is the Equal protection clause, this clause states that there may be no discrimination against people by the law. The 14th amendment was important

    Read More

  • Essay On First Ten Amendments

    462 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the late 1700’s, James Madison wrote the first Ten Amendments that are listed in the United States Constitution. The Bill of Rights were written to ensure American citizens that they have freedoms and rights that the government can 't infringe. Out of the Ten Amendments, I believe that the First and Eighth Amendment are the most significant. The First Amendment grants us freedom of speech, religion, press, petition, and for people to assemble peaceably.

    Read More

  • Key Constitutional Concepts By Leonore Annemore Annenberg Institute For Civics

    644 Words  | 3 Pages

    This landmark case affirmed that the 6th Amendment applies to all states under the 14th Amendment. Not only did the video show the importance of the amendments to the constitution, it also demonstrated the possible pitfalls of judicial review, but also its ability to ensure the personal rights provided by the constitution are not

    Read More

  • Censorship Of The First Amendment Essay

    865 Words  | 4 Pages

    The First Amendment was written because American citizens demanded a guarantee of their freedom. This led to James Madison writing the First Amendment. The First Amendment was established when the Founding Fathers wanted to guarantee that the Americans ' basic civil liberties would not be threatened by the government. The First Amendment was confirmed, along with nine other amendments,to the constitution of the United States. The First Amendment states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.”

    Read More

More about Incorporation Case Study

Open Document