Influence of the American healthcare system on Indian health services
USA is the world’s largest economy. Its dominance in the sphere of arts, science, technology, culture and medicine is unparalleled today. Given its dominant socio-political and economic status, no country on earth can be said to be beyond the sphere of American influence in almost all aspects of life. While the pervasiveness of such American hegemony is a matter of debate today in many sociological discourses today, for the purpose of this paper, we will concentrate on influence of American healthcare on the healthcare system of India.
The American way of life is typified by the example of “rugged individualism,” where each individual works to secure their own interest.
…show more content…
The US influence on the Indian health care system has been immense ever since the 1980s and particularly after the 1990s, in which the structural adjustment programmes (SAP) played an important role. SAP, implemented in India in the early 1990s, introduced a new era of economic liberalisation into the economy. Healthcare structure was not left untouched by the new reform economy. Though the implementation of these SAP in India were at the behest of the World Bank (WB) and International Monetary Fund (IMF), yet the neoliberalist agenda underlining these reforms was unmistakable. The nature of these reforms also made it clear that Indian health service sector was moving towards an era of privatisation and de-regulation, the very hallmarks of the US health service system. Thus a look at the evolution of the healthcare system in the India since the 1980s and 1990s shows a definite US imprint.
Baru (1998: 37-38) states that the extent of US influence on Indian health services may be understood at the following levels – the role of the multinational companies in pharmaceuticals and medical equipment industries, the influence of the NRI doctors some of whom began returning to
…show more content…
They have contributed to a decrease in public expenditure on social sectors, including health services. This has brought in an era of stagnation of the growth of public health service system infrastructure in the country. The result has been that the private sector has had to fill in this void left by the government. Government too has accorded recognition to the private sector to plug the gap in services and has even extended its support to them. In 2008, it launched the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) or the National Health Insurance Scheme, which provided government-funded health insurance to the country’s vast below-poverty-line (BPL) population. Both private and public hospitals were empanelled under the scheme. In effect, the scheme represents a subsidisation of the private sector through public money. However lack of proper monitoring and governmental regulation has meant that such provisioning has not resulted in significantly increased access to the services for the population (Sodhi and Rabbani,
The basis of American society has been built upon the individual
In other words, Americans want money in life, and less focus is on the quality of life. I have seen a real example of materialism, my uncle who was very much intended for making money that today he is alone and has no one to share his success. The America is an individualistic society from teenagers to adults; everyone is living their life in making money and getting wealthier, and no one emphasized on having a family, social life or friends. From my uncle’s example, I learned a lesson that money is not everything, today he is alone, wandering in a big house and no one to share his feeling, money is a key but most important is family and your
improving quality of American health care system and curbing the care costs, at the moment numerous ways of restructuring care supply are being evaluated by CMS. Accompanying Medicare shared savings program, initiatives like Advanced Payment Incentive and Pioneer ACO demonstrations are being commenced. Other global health service organizations such as Cigna, Aetna and Anthem are also supporting this health reform model and endeavoring to improve health service system by acquiring health service providers to raise the level and quality of care supply. As well as this kind of health insurance companies provide other incentives to healthily systematized care provider
Before the mid-nineteenth century, an ideal American was defined as a yeoman farmer who owned modest farm and worked primarily with family labor, and who was honest, virtuous, hardworking, and independent. The market revolution of the mid-nineteenth century changed this modest definition, and Americans can be many things in life and not just a farmer. The market shifted from slave trading toward an economy based on commerce, manufacturing, and larger scale agricultural endeavors. The change toward this economy was the result of non-stop population growth, new ideas/products invented from industrial revolution, and a needed change after such growth without development during the start of the nineteenth century.
America is known as the “Land of the free, home of the brave,” and as Americans, we are both free and brave. Americans take a stand, sticking to their values no matter the consequences. Their unbridled willpower makes Americans a force to be reckoned with and the forerunners of change, good and bad. This change appears as feminism, activism, free speech, capitalism, civil rights, and social justice.
Patients have the option for treatment as private patients in public hospitals, so that they can choose the physician caring for them and their private insurance
(Sy Mukherjee). Apparently not giving medical rights to immigrants makes the U.S. look pretty
Chicago, Illinois: American Health Information Management Association. Retrieved from http://www.amcp.org/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=12724 Health Care Reform. (2014, January 1). Retrieved October 18, 2014. http://www.hca.wa.gov/hcr/Pages/default.aspx Indian Health Service
America has had a tumultuous existence, replete with war, progress, and ideologies. The most formidable of these is individualism, or the shift of society’s focus from the group to the individual and a growing emphasis on their personal needs and desires. Despite wide criticism, it has become the societal norm, spanning all generations, genders, races, and walks of life. Individualism, while indeed centered on the individual, is more accurately described as the changing and shifting relationship between the individual and society.
Sir Michael Marmot put into perspective how serious social disparities are and how they influence health not only between countries but also, within countries. The issue is not medical care; in fact the United States spends the most on medical care. You would initially think the country in which spends the most on medical care must have higher health rates. Well, believe it or not, this is actually false, for instance, sixty-two countries had higher maternal health rates than the United States. This displays that a lack of medical care fundamentally is not the conflict, whereas social inequality is.
American Exceptionalism was coined by Alexis de Tocqueville in his book Democracy in America. To illustrate how the American way of thought is superior to the other ways of the world, Tocqueville expresses that the American way of thought is distinctively unique and special. This distinction is exemplified through liberty, egalitarianism, individualism, populism, and Laissez-Faire Economics. These qualities prove America’s exceptionality and difference from other countries. Although American Exceptionalism originated in the early 1800s, the idyllic values Tocqueville paints in his book can be seen throughout American history.
America’s society has some distinctive characteristics that separate it from that of the rest of the world. Although diverse, the American society is unified in the number of traits that they all share. All American citizens value their individuality as well as their equality. Americans are not afraid to voice their opinions or to oppose something that they disagree with. If there is something that is not right, Americans will not hesitate to work towards positive change of that cause.
The author really did not mention any positive examples of American medical insurance system’s work. It creates a feeling of prejudice as the system should have positive results to exist for so many years. However, Moore gave enough examples to show there are severe problems in the American medical insurance. Mentions of numbers, historical recordings and people, who decided to share personal experience, support author’s
Public health insurance assures that, since it decreases the gap between social levels as there is no discrimination between rich and poor. According to article (12) in the library of human rights session number (22) “it's the right for every citizen to enjoy the luxury health and receive the highest medication”. Public hospitals provide that by making its number one aim to treat the patient and make sure that the patient has received proper medication without caring about what payments will be paid and what luxuries will be provided according to the paid amount. “The right of each citizen to have an appropriate acces to health care should be based on their needs and not on their ability to pay costs for such care” confirmed by the paper of health and population provided in the eighth national
hospitals than the private clinics Even though the cost of physician in govt hospitals are almost nil, the opportunity cost could