An individual's values help obtain an authentic understanding of who they are and what they want in life. In Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston the protagonist Janie was constantly influenced by her grandmother Nanny's worldview. She played a significant role in shaping who Janie was and her values which affected her evolution as she went through life. Nanny had grown up as a slave and had endured many hardships in her life and as a result, she placed a high value on security and stability. Her own life experiences had taught her that it was important especially as a black woman to find a good husband who could provide and take care of her. As a person who had little to no control over her own life, her desire to provide …show more content…
After she married Logan that had become “the end of her childhood” (Hurston, 1937/2013, p.12). Janie was not happy and although she did not love him she hoped she would after they got married like her grandmother had told her. Nevertheless, since she had no say in her marriage this caused Janie to desire a more fulfilling relationship that came with love and not just a “house bought and paid for and sixty acres [of] land” (Hurston, 1937/2013, p.23). She constantly felt trapped especially after Logan stopped pampering her and made her perform manual labor. However, once she had met Joe Starks she felt as though she had another opportunity in life. He had promised Janie a better life with the money he had saved up to move to a new town, Eatonville, that was run by people of color. Not only did Joe glamorize his dreams with her, Janie's hopes for love returned. However, her decision to run off with Joe had put her in a difficult situation especially after he became mayor of Eatonville. He was able to provide Janie with a comfortable life but became controlling and both mentally and physically abusive. He would speak out “without giving her a chance to say anything” (Hurston, 1937/2013, p.43) or he would go to the extent of hitting her or making her change the way she looked and acted to keep a status within their community. As time went on her love for Joe turned into
Joe was dominant among others and controlling towards Janie. Everyone had high expectations for Joe and Janie, and Joe knew Janie did not have the knowledge or intelligence he had, so Joe looked down upon Janie. Janie had no background, the only placed Janie seemed to have belonged was under control by a man, and that man happened to be Joe. “Thank yuh fuh yo’ compliments, but mah wife don’t know nothin’ ‘bout no speech-makin’. Ah never married her for nothin’ lak dat.
She desired appreciation and a reduction in the amount of work that Logan had assigned to her. Joe was Janie's second-longest marriage, but as time passed, nothing about it turned out the way she had hoped. Whenever Joe was elected mayor of the new town they were in, he would speak for her and put her in her place as a woman rather than a person. Joe had a lot of insecurities, and Janie didn't want a partner who exposed his insecurities on Janie. “But looking at it she saw that it never was the flesh and blood figure of her dreams.”
Janie at the age of 17, decides to end her unhappy marriage with Logan Killicks and get married to Joe Starks. Joe had a strong personality. Joe did not just talks the talk, but actually made it happen. This was what attracted Janie to Joe in the first place. Joe saw his marriage with Janie, as something he gotten with his package of success.
Her marriage with Joe was better than first, she even thought this was the" horizon" she looked for however, she was placed in a trophy case for display. Joe was as controlling as he was jealous. He prohibited her from showing her hair, as well as taking part in common things. Janie was basically isolated from the town. Everything between them went sour quickly after Janie stripped Joe of his manhood in front of people.
However, Thula’s decision to punish not Mike but Joe allows to reader to visualize the extent of her hatred towards Joe. Another example that portrays Thula’s hate towards Joe and how Joe persevered through his loss was when Joe was a mere ten years old. Joe’s father, swayed by Thula’s sharp tongue towards Joe, “told his son that he would have to move out of the house” (Brown 46). Despite the difficulties Joe faced, he had not yet lost hope and continued to work, learn, and sleep as best he could, which portrays his determined and optimistic
“She often spoke to the falling seeds and said, ‘Ah hope you fall on soft ground,’" (Hurston Pg, 25). In Their Eyes Were Watching God, Hurston uses language and imagery to define Janie's character development by showing Janie learning that marriage doesn't mean love. Janie believed that marriage meant love, but later on, she realized that marriage doesn't always mean love.
He is the man who fills the voids of loneliness and love, and continues her development as a woman. Joe’s impact on Janie’s emotional growth is that he emotionally abused her to the point where she wouldn’t talk anymore and he only wanted a pretty wife/show wife because he was the mayor of Eatonville. She felt like she had lost her identity because the people would call her Mrs. Mayor Starks and would never use her real name. She also feels like she lost her identity because she always listened to what Joe had to say about her appearance and whatever he suggested she would do it. Joe also had an impact on Janie’s physical growth is that he also physically abused her when every should would do the slightest thing wrong.
After hearing her say this about him Joe slaps Janie, which isn’t something a good husband would do. This situation is what causes the marriage to really go downhill, and soonafter Joe gets sick and he dies, while still fighting with Janie and overall being a bad
Janie tells Joe “And now you got tuh die tuh find out dat you got tuh pacify somebody besides yo’self if you wants any love and any sympathy in dis world. You ain’t tried tuh pacify nobody but yo’self. Too busy listening tuh yo’ own big voice.” (Pg 87) Janie thinks very little of Joe.
(46). Joe believes that he is doing Janie a favor by providing her with the life he thinks she wants, and this causes her to feel isolated. Although she is still unsure of herself, she knows that her vague idea of the life she expects does not align with Joe’s vision. Despite their conflicting viewpoints, she chooses to suffer in silence because of her fear and reliance on Joe for financial security. Janie allows him to create an uneven power dynamic in which she becomes simply a part of Joe’s image for the public eye.
Joe seen Janie as a trophy wife or someone he could show people off to, but Janie was taken by his charms and believed that he would be the one to give her the love she was looking for. She soon realized that it was nothing like that, “And one night he had caught Walter standing behind Janie and brushing the back of his hand back and forth across the loose end of her braid ever so lightly so as to enjoy the feel of it without Janie knowing what he was doing. Joe was at the back of the store and Walter didn’t see him. He felt like rushing forth with the meat knife and chopping off the offending hand. That night he ordered Janie to tie up her hair around the store” (Chapter 5).
Before she was going to get married and move in with Logan she told herself “Yes, she would love Logan after they were married.” (Hurston 21). Leading to, Janie and Logan getting married. Janie made herself believe that once you’re married you and your partner will be mutually in-love. As they were married, Janie waited to see if she has fallen in love with Logan, then she realized after all that time, this was false.
Janie shows determination as she persists and struggles to define love on her own terms through her marriages. First, her determination shows when Janie runs away with Jody. She becomes aware that her marriage with Logan does not satisfy her goals and dreams for love, so she takes a chance and marries Jody. Hurston states, “Janie hurried out of the front gate and turned south.
However, Joe is not the solution to Janie's problems. Joe is a domineering and controlling husband who believes that Janie's place is in the home. He wants her to be a trophy wife, a symbol of his power and success. Janie resists this role, and she begins to realize that her marriage to Joe is not fulfilling. She recognizes that she is not happy in this marriage when she says, "She had an inside and an outside now and suddenly she knew how not to mix them."
All Joe wanted to be was respected and liked, even if that meant hurting a couple of people. He was slapped with the knowledge that “Boys Don’t Cry” and that is heavily shown throughout his