ipl-logo

Barbed Wire: The Fence That Changed The West

940 Words4 Pages

In the movie Shane, many characters are relying on individualism to get them through life and be successful. Joe Starrett’s family is a hard working frontier family living on a cattle farm in the west. Along with them are several other families who have settled around them in the country, around a small town. Conflict begins when the Rykers come and demand that Starrett has squatted on his land and that he need to give up is homestead. A stranger, Shane steps in and sides with Starrett. Starrett learns that Ryker and his gang have been threatening the other homesteads around him and they decide to get together to discuss what they are going to do. Meanwhile, Shane is being discriminated against in town for his background. The men decide that …show more content…

Turner wrote, “As has been indicated, the frontier is productive of individualism. Complex society is precipitated by the wilderness into a kind of primitive organization based on the family.” Starrett discusses in the movie how each of the homesteaders built up their lives around them with their own hands, relying on their own works provide for their families. Barbed Wire: The Fence That Changed the West by Joanne S. Liu also discusses this topic in the west, discussing on page twenty-six that when people came to the west, they immediately staked out their land for agriculture. Homesteaders wanted to make a life for themselves, everyone seeking their own success. Turner also discussed, “But the democracy born of free land, strong and selfishness and individualism, intolerant of administrative experience and education, and pressing individual liberty beyond its proper bounds, has its dangers as well as benefits.” Individualism both helped people and made struggles for the rough environment of the west …show more content…

Ways that they stuck up for themselves was physical fighting. They would punch each other and bring each other to the ground until one person was forced to give up. An example of this is when Shane and Starrett are fighting on who should go to the gunfight. Shane brings out his gun, knocking Starrett on the head and knocking him out cold. Shane had won.This also leads to another form of violence used to settle disputes in the west, which was gunfighting. This was part of who Shane was and what his past was lik. He wanted to go to the gunfight against Ryker because he was experienced in the business and wanted to stick up for what the homesteader’s wanted and needed. He killed all of Ryker’s gang, winning the dispute for the homesteaders and getting their rights back. Another form of violence was Ryker cutting Starrett’s fences, giving the message that he wanted him off of his homestead. Shane just repaired the fences and they ignored the threats. This was a major theme of violence to get a point across in many parts of the west, leading to large disputes.
Many of these disputes were settled because of personal issues, which should have been legal issues but the law was too far away to enforce. The movie quotes that “the law is three days from here” indicating that they would not be able to go get a government official to settle a dispute for them, leaving them to their own devices to settle any conflicts.

Show More
Related

  • Changes In The Land William Cronon Summary

    1677 Words  | 7 Pages

    In our textbook, Experiencing History, the settlers are portrayed as people whom, “established most of their settlements with an eye to stability and order” (page 89). However, in Changes in the Land,

    Read More

  • Dbq Turner's Frontier Thesis

    692 Words  | 3 Pages

    Faith Picotte History 310 (T-Th) Homework Ch. 8 1.Turner’s frontier thesis is deceptively draws and allure your inquisitive imagination into a grand scale visionary picture of settlements of specific regions, and the social societal processes. Americans realized the frontier formed and promoted a composite nationalist American society. The English dominated the coastal region. , later continental immigrants flowed towards the free lands of the frontier.

    Read More

  • Gilded Age Dbq Essay

    790 Words  | 4 Pages

    Most homesteaders returned home to large cities shortly after setting up their homesteads. Even with the promise of almost free land, people left their homesteads. Most were not cut out for the constant assault on them and their way of life. They moved back to New York, Pennsylvania, California, Illinois, and many other places. The document did influence the culture and population of the Midwest, but did not nullify the growth in the urban population of America.

    Read More

  • Fist Stick Knife Gun Analysis

    1045 Words  | 5 Pages

    Violence is an action that people despise but is mostly always used when one well being is threatened. The book “the outsiders” it is about a boy named ponyboy who is in a gang and struggles with his differences from the rest of the gang. The text “fist stick knife gun” talks of a boy and his brothers who use violence to get a jacket back from a boy who stole it from them. Both the authors use the protagonist conflict in their life to connect to the theme violence leads to more violence. In both “Outsiders” and “Fist stick knife gun” the authors uses POV of the characters to develop the theme of violence never ends it's like a cycle.

    Read More

  • Irrational Expectations In Long Way Down

    1536 Words  | 7 Pages

    They are crazy for thinking that these rules were reasonable and should be followed. This ties into the cycle of violence, because it describes its origin. The people in Will’s community who are often perceived as “cool'' or the ideal societal member, follow irrational societal expectations, and therefore, they are crazy. These people are often the ones to partake in lots of violence and then become a part of the cycle of violence. This comes to show that the cycle of violence in Will’s community is fueled by such people, who are thought to be role models but are

    Read More

  • Did The New Deal Strengthen Or Weaken The Usa Capitalism

    967 Words  | 4 Pages

    frontier to Turner was the promotion of democracy. He believed that the people were strong in individualism as farming communities were settled, railroads were created, and the nation’s dependence on England for trade lessened. George Appo, who was born into a poor family and lost both of his parents to death or jail, began working as a pickpocket in the 1860s and used his money to buy opium. He would attend opium dens, where many different classes and genders gathered to smoke. Appo participating in organized crime because he had to make his own money in order to survive, and had a much higher sense of freedom than most boys his age.

    Read More

  • Frederick Jackson Turner Frontier Thesis

    718 Words  | 3 Pages

    One man saw this time and its significance and wrote a thesis that has earned the reputation of one of the most influential papers in American history. His name was Frederick Jackson Turner, and his paper was called “The Significance of the Frontier in American History”. Labeled the “Frontier Thesis”, many can read and see Turner had a well understanding of what makes American culture and individualism what it is, giving him much understanding of what challenges the nation was facing at the time. He saw these unique differences that America had versus other booming civilizations. He knew that with the rapid growth of the U.S. those challenges it faced would be keeping true to the image of the frontier, to continue in the spirit of the U.S. and what it represents.

    Read More

  • Cesar Chavez Nonviolent Resistance Analysis

    651 Words  | 3 Pages

    On lines 17-21, Chavez presents the unwanted outcomes of violence. He argues that once violence begins, it will escalate and result in injury or death on both sides. And, if somehow the violence does not escalate to that point, total

    Read More

  • Violence In A Long Way Gone

    505 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the beginning of the boy's rehabilitation, they caused chaos. Ishmael wrote, “It hadn't crossed their mind that a change in environment wouldn't immediately make us normal boys; we were dangerous and brainwashed to kill.” (Chapter 15, page 135) They became accustomed to committing horrific killings so when they were taking out of the war they did what they been doing for the duration of it.

    Read More

  • The Strenuous Life Speech Analysis

    1123 Words  | 5 Pages

    Farmers in the West, both before and as the Depression hit, frivolously worked to farm their land and produce as much agriculture as possible, aiming to fulfil their duty as a “proper” American citizen in fulfilling their role as a hard and productive worker. The ideas of hard work ultimately led to over-working the American farmland in the western United States. As the overworked land was uprooted, displacing these farmers, the ideas of a strenuous American work ethic continued to remain in the minds of these

    Read More

  • Late Nineteenth Century: Contrast To The American West

    842 Words  | 4 Pages

    The contrasts between the American West and East in the nineteenth century range from a new start to the adventure of the living in the Wild West. The east had become overcrowded and did not allow much opportunity for people of lesser wealth. “In 1893, the historian Frederick Jackson Turner gave a celebrated lecture, “The Significance of the Frontier in American History,” in which he argued that on the western frontier the distinctive qualities of American culture were forged: individual freedom, political democracy, and economic mobility. The West, he added, acted as a “safety

    Read More

  • The Trans-Mississippi West

    784 Words  | 4 Pages

    During the “Gilded Age” period of American history, development of the Trans-Mississippi west was crucial to fulfilling the American dream of manifest destiny and creating an identity which was distinctly American. Since the west is often associated with rugged pioneers and frontiersmen, there is an overarching idea of hardy American individualism. However, although these settlers were brave and helped to make America into what it is today, they heavily relied on federal support. It would not have been possible for white Americans to settle the Trans-Mississippi west without the US government removing Native Americans from their lands and placing them on reservations, offering land grants and incentives for people to move out west, and the

    Read More

  • Frontier Myth In American Culture

    1594 Words  | 7 Pages

    Perhaps the most significant myth in American culture is that of the American frontier generated by the European encounters with the American West. The most noticeable part of the frontier myth is the mythic struggle between modern civilization and wilderness. Frontier is defined as “the meeting point between savagery and civilization”. Turner believes that the American frontier is closely related to American civilization and that frontier

    Read More

  • Crevecoeur's Impact On The American Identity

    1756 Words  | 8 Pages

    The frontier is the raw uncharted and undeveloped land in America. When America was founded individuals claimed land. Some argue that the frontier impacted the American identity such as De Crevecoeur, Quinney, and Turner. J. Hector ST. John De Crevecoeur was an author who wrote the Farmer Letters.

    Read More

  • Why Did The Homestead Act Fail

    1499 Words  | 6 Pages

    Not only were the land sales out in the west was a major problem but also the physical land held major problems for farmers. Many people bought land from the government like they were supposed to while many did not purchase the legitimate way, in The American Pageant it states, “about half a million families took advantage of the Homestead Act … Yet five times that many families purchased their lands from railroads” (Kennedy 645), the people were cheating the system. This quote is showing how the railroads were wrongfully benefiting from the West lands and how people could get around the requirements the Act stated, for example the five year limit and in those years the lands must be improved. Another problem with the land sales was that naked fraud occurred; this meant that the public lands were owned by “land-grabbing promoters” than regular farmers this was cheating the farmers and the government of proper land development. On the topic of land development a large problem with the farming life in the west was that the lands were unfit for farming.

    Read More

More about Barbed Wire: The Fence That Changed The West

Open Document