ipl-logo

Industrial Labor During The 1830s: A Comparative Analysis

586 Words3 Pages

Throughout both sources they go through inside their own opinions on Industrial labor during the 1830s. the primary source states to three testimonials of three different piers and their field they have mixed opinions on the situation staying their own alternatives towards child labor and the factory Act. While the secondary source stated if the early industrial society during the thirties was in a progress or in the decline. One could compare in contrast these two writings about Poor conditions and the industrial society.

My perspective on both writings are that I agree with what they are saying and both terms. The primary source States testimonials have three different areas. The first one explains how labor for children starts at a young age and it is poor conditions …show more content…

His argument also States how they should limit the ages and the hours to prevent injuries. I agree with this testimonial because the commissioner does see the pain and injury is coming from Labour but he want to stop child labor but he wants the Limited in certain areas. Some children and families cannot afford to let their children stop working at a young age and long hours just based on their financial problems but also to the uneducated untrained child of a young age this labor may be too hard for them. By cutting the age families are safer but also overtime will have their children working. At this time in history that sounds reasonable. The second testimonial explains the poorest conditions Through The Eyes of a labor workers during that time. My opinion on this matter is that it hurts to hear these conditions before they were limited or changed. In the testimonial it states opinions from the writer saying how bad conditions

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Speech By Florence Kelley

    412 Words  | 2 Pages

    At this time in history, there were “two million children under the age of sixteen” working to provide for their families, and some kids beginning labor at the tender ages of “six and seven years (in the cotton

    Read More

  • How Did Americans Grow So Quickly Dbq

    834 Words  | 4 Pages

    The conditions were expressed very negative and unjust for they’d work for absolutely any wage. Men, women, boys, and girls, were put to work in harsh conditions that are treated as slaves doc 1. Living conditions are very alike to those depicted in doc 4 where immigrants were staying. They are very humble and they dress very cheaply and eat rice from China while sleeping 20 in a room treated very poorly. They used them to find success in business’s for they’d work continuously and would pay them whatever they wished.

    Read More

  • Chapter Summary Of Scraping By By Seth Rockman

    706 Words  | 3 Pages

    Chapter two “A Job for the Working Man” focuses on the working men experience in the city of Baltimore. Rockman does a good job of illustrates the variety of jobs and experiences within the city. Rockman also begins to explain the difference between the low wage labors and hired-out slaves. Chapter 3 “Dredging and Drudgery” goes in to detail about busy harbor of Baltimore and how it operates off of the wage labors, and how harsh life was working on the

    Read More

  • Research Paper On Factory Working In The 1800s

    271 Words  | 2 Pages

    Factory Working Working in the 1800’s was hard and was very dangerous, by the mid 1800’s America was using machines to produce most things such as clothing, shoes, watches, , guns, and farming machines. The workers would work an average of 11.4 hours a day. The workers were very tired. The factories were very rugged and dangerous, there were fast rapidly moving parts exposed and that cuased many accidents with adults and children.

    Read More

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of Florence Kelley's Speech

    623 Words  | 3 Pages

    Florence Kelley Speech Florence Kelley conveys her message about child labor in her speech. Through the use of different rhetorical strategies, she shows us how each state’s child labor laws are different. Each state has their own law of how long the child should work and an age. The children are expected to be working while the adults are buying.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Made In Hell By Dana Liebelson

    1296 Words  | 6 Pages

    However, in a way, she is telling the reader to think rationally and that there is no need for a case to be made - the factories are intrinsically evil. To support her article, Liebelson often cites statistics and uses numbers to aptly describe the nature of the situation. Most notably she cites the ages of the sumangali workers and statistics regarding money. She states that the girls can begin working as young as 13 and this number is repeated in different contexts multiple times to nail home the point of child labor. Making a child work all day long at such a young age, in an extremely dangerous environment to boot, paints a picture that Liebelson uses to her advantage.

    Read More

  • Progressive Era Dbq

    1098 Words  | 5 Pages

    Many parents needed their wages to make ends meet. In Document C from The Spirit of Youth and the City Streets by Jane Adams 1909, Jane states how children enter factory life when the law allows them to, and children end up not having childhoods. She writes that people are so caught up with the marvelous achievements of their industry and end up forgetting the children who have to work to help out as well. In Document G, a court case Hammer v. Dagenhart 1918, the father of two sons one under fourteen years old and another one between fourteen and sixteen explains his concern about the exploitation of his children in a cotton mill. He says its concerning that children are allowed to work more than eight hours a day and six days a week.

    Read More

  • Labor In The Gilded Age

    762 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the Gilded age or the start of the industrial era, women and children were forced to leave their homes and try and get jobs in factories that were fit for them. This era created many new job opportunities than before. The number of women who now had actual jobs had increased drastically. Even though all these jobs had opened up women were only seen fit to do small tasks such as desk jobs that require little knowledge and skill to be able to do. Women forced into the work force tended to be poorer struggling individuals whose children were bound to labor as well.

    Read More

  • Changing Society Dbq Analysis

    873 Words  | 4 Pages

    Another critical grievance against society performed by many affluent employers was the exploitation of the new generations. Not only were fully adult workers being brutalized through an abhorrent working environment, children as young as six years old were exposed to many of the same or similar conditions. Document three is a photograph of two little boys who look to be no older than nine years of age changing the bobbins in a giant machine without any safety equipment while the machine is running. Not only are these kids forced to work in danger of losing digits or other body parts to the hazardous contraptions they worked with all day, this eliminates any chance they have to complete much, if any amount of education that might have helped them rise up in society and break the vicious circle that makes and keeps the poor the way they are, impeding any hierarchical progress. After a grueling day of hard work with little income to show for it, as people went home to their families to eat, they were presented with virtually inedible meat that was then compounded with rat hair, and feces.

    Read More

  • Industrial Workers In The Gilded Age

    1038 Words  | 5 Pages

    Farmers and Industrial Workers in the Gilded Age In a time when industrialization was booming, immigrants were racing towards the “American Dream”, and cities were growing towards the sky, the United States was thriving. As a country, the United States went from rural, to mostly urban, which made America “the world’s largest industrial power” as stated by John Green. Since the U.S. had become mostly urban, this left the very few rural workers (farmers), and even some of the industrial workers unhappy. This period of industrialization is called the Gilded Age than spans from 1865 to 1900.The farmers and industrial workers responded to the Gilded Age in significantly negative ways including unions against their authority, strikes and political

    Read More

  • Child Labor In The 1800s

    1560 Words  | 7 Pages

    Child labor during the 18th and 19th century did not only rapidly develop an industrial revolution, but it also created a situation of difficulty and abuse by depriving children of edjucation, good physical health, and the proper emotional wellness and stability. In the late 1700 's and early 1800 's, power-driven machines replaced hand labor for making most manufactured items. Many of America 's factories needed a numerous amount of workers for a cheap salary. Because of this, the amount of child laborers have been growing rapidly over the early 1800s.

    Read More

  • Dbq William Cooper's Testimony

    258 Words  | 2 Pages

    The origin of document 1 is from William Cooper's testimony before the Sadler Committee in 1832 in Great Britain. Based on the format (question and answer), it is most likely from a court transcript. The main point of this testimony is to show that children were forced to work long hours and because of this, they had no time to attend school. He states in the testimony that he had to work 16 hours a day, and of those 16 hours he had only one forty minute break. William Cooper's testimony tells us that he did not enjoy working in the factories.

    Read More

  • Child Labor Testimonies

    1538 Words  | 7 Pages

    1. How do these testimonies present the realities of child labor? Give specific examples. The testimonies give us a brief snapshot of the condition in which children worked.

    Read More

  • Child Labor During The Industrial Revolution Essay

    855 Words  | 4 Pages

    Child labor was a great problem in the Industrial Revolution. Factory owners usually hired women and children rather than men. They said that men expected higher wages, and they suspected that they were more likely to rebel against the company. Women and children were forced to work from six in the morning to seven at night, and this was when they were not so busy. They were forced to arrive on time and they couldn’t fall behind with their work because if they did they were whipped and punished.

    Read More

  • Child Labour Is Wrong

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    21.4% of children are involved in child labor, with more than half working under hazardous conditions, such as the children working seventy six hour weeks under the Disney corporation. The international labor organization defines child labor as “work that deprives children of their childhood, their potential and their dignity, and that is harmful to physical and mental development.” The implementation of child labor has several negative consequences, such as a detrimental economic effect and the question as to whether its application is moral. Child labor has both a negative effect on the economic standing of a family, and that of a nation. Corporations like Disney promote the exploitation of children for labor; therefore, companies

    Read More

More about Industrial Labor During The 1830s: A Comparative Analysis

Open Document