ipl-logo

Is Vimy Ridge A Defining Moment For Canada?

742 Words3 Pages

Vimy Ridge is a hill in France that was Germany’s key defence system which was captured by Canadian soldiers from Germany in World War 1. Since then, many people have argued about whether it was a successful and defining moment for Canada or not. One side argues that too many lives were lost at the cost of capturing Vimy. The other side argues that it was important because it was a defining moment and success due to the Canadians who conquered the hill when the British and French could not, they were prepared by their commander and trained very hard for the battle, which leads them to victory and earned many awards. Even though many lives were lost, it is highly unquestionable that the Battle of Vimy Ridge was a successful and defining moment …show more content…

The French and British tried to take control of Vimy from 1914 to 1916 but failed with about 150,000 casualties with no positive results. Compared to Canada, there were 3,598 dead out of 10,602 Canadian casualties. Which was why the French and British commanders thought it was impenetrable to capture Vimy from Germany. Canada proved them wrong and captured Vimy on their first try. This is because all the strategies the French and British tried failed and got more soldiers killed then Canada did. However, Canada had smart strategies such as the “ creeping barrage “ it was used to protect the attackers by keeping enemy troops sheltering in their bunkers which worked on the first try. In addition, Canada had captured more prisoners, guns and ground in Vimy Ridge then Britain ever did in the …show more content…

After the war, four Canadian soldiers William Milne, Ellis Sifton, John Pattison, and Thain Macdowell were rewarded with the Victoria Cross medal for their bravery and heroism in the battle. This medal is very significant because it was the highest military award you could get and only very few soldiers were given it. Canada also was awarded a spot in the League of Nations for their contribution to the battle. The League of Nations was an International organization created to keep peace in the world and prevent another war from happening. In addition, they won a separate signature on the Treaty Versailles Peace Treaty instead of being considered as one of Britain's colonies and having Britain signing for Canada. This was the first time Canada signed as an independent nation and not under

Show More
Related

  • Why Did Canada Win Ww2 Essay

    778 Words  | 4 Pages

    World War 2 also known as the Second World War started in 1939 and ended in 1945. Canada contributed and helped quite a bit during this war. Things that Canada did to help were attacking certain important targets through ground troops, they also had a good navy, and air force, which was useful. Canada helped win WW2 by their contributions of troops, air force, navy, and continuous supply of materials. Canada entered the war slightly after Britain so they could assert their independence.

    Read More

  • Chapter Summary Of The Source By Andrew Iarocci

    1109 Words  | 5 Pages

    The source written by Andrew Iarocci, examines the first year of the 1st Canadian Division in the First World War, and focuses exclusively on the soldiers' overseas experiences. In the book, Iarocci challenges the view that the 1st Canadian Division soldiers were poorly prepared for the First World War, and were not at all effective during some key battles in 1915. The book's focus is to look primarily at how Canadian's fought in the First World War, and with the help of the many sources the book incorporates, such as many research documents in the form of letters, diaries and the battlefields themselves, Iarocci is able to give the reader a solid perspective on how Canadian soldiers fared in the war. The book provides the Canadian soldiers'

    Read More

  • Historical Significance Of Canada's Involvement In The Liberation Of The Netherlands

    679 Words  | 3 Pages

    From September 1944 to April 1945, Canada fought the German soldiers starting in Normandy all the way to the Netherlands, successfully liberating the Scheldt estuary, the Netherlands, and driving the Nazis back into Germany. By examining historical significance, one can see that Canada’s involvement in the liberation of the Netherlands and Europe was highly important; it ended the war, cost many Canadians their lives, created an enduring friendship between Canada and the Netherlands, displayed Canada’s strength as a nation, and saved numerous innocent lives. Firstly, the campaign to liberate the Netherlands and Europe ended the War in Europe. In February 1945, the Allies launched the Rhine offensive that drove German forces back over the Rhine

    Read More

  • How The Battle Of Vimy Ridge And Its Impact On Canadian History

    759 Words  | 4 Pages

    Winning Vimy Ridge helped Canada gain its independence, considering its allies France and Great Britain tried capturing Vimy Ridge with more men and were both unsuccessful. Canada created new tactics which lead to its victory. It showed the world that Canada no longer needed Britain’s support in order to win a battle, or support its citizens. A military battle, made up of Canadian soldiers, created the collective pride that was used towards shaping Canadian independence. The Vimy Ridge monument was created 19 years later.

    Read More

  • Why Is The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Important

    369 Words  | 2 Pages

    Another reason why the Battle of Vimy Ridge is so important is because it allowed Canada

    Read More

  • Canada's Commitment To War

    175 Words  | 1 Pages

    Canada’s dedication to the war, one of the biggest mission failures, and affecting the outcome of future battles are the reasons the battle of Dieppe was a defining moment during World War Two. Canada demonstrated their courage and commitment to the war by assisting the Allies to defeat German forces despite losing so many troops. The battle itself was a total failure with many dead, wounded and taken prisoner, due to the poor planning and execution of the battle. Even though it was not a success, there were some important lessons learned such as they needed to change their strategy, equipment, and communications. Canada's dedication and commitment to the war especially to the battle of Dieppe proved to be a major failure and a huge success

    Read More

  • A Note On The Battle Of Vimy Ridge

    669 Words  | 3 Pages

    Located in France near the Belgian border was the strategically important highground of Vimy Ridge. In April of 1917, Canada defeated the Germans who had occupied the area since their first offensive in 1914. Canada's victory at Vimy Ridge not only outlined the unique aspect of their win, but created the foundation for Canada's autonomy internationally. “They said it couldn't be done and we did it.” (-Historian, Pierre

    Read More

  • Why Is The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Important For Canada

    573 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many Historians believed that the victory of Vimy Ridge was a memorable and unreal moment for Canadians. At that time, Canada was known to be a part of the British Empire. This meant that if Britain was to go to war, then Canada would automatically have to go to war as well.1 The Battle took place on April 9, 1917 and it was a huge victory for the Canadians.2 The significance of the battle of Vimy Ridge to Canadian history was that Canada became famous for its heroic soldiers, its large sacrifice and it was the birth of Canadian patriotism.3 To begin, the battle of Vimy Ridge was not just considered to be the greatest achievement for Canadians, but it became famous for the clever tactics which the Canadian troops used during the war.4 To start off with, The Battle of Vimy Ridge was the first battle in which Canadians from all over the land fought as a united team.5 This gave them an advantage and brought them much success during the war because they outnumbered the Germans.6 This is witnessed when Brigadier General A.E.Ross announced, "In those few minutes I witnessed the birth of a nation.

    Read More

  • Canada's Level Of Unity In 1918

    1095 Words  | 5 Pages

    Canadians became an independent nation in 1918; however, they were not much more united than they were in 1914. One of the events that brought Canadians together was the battle at Vimy Ridge. Vimy Ridge was a piece of land covered in trenches and machine guns, which were occupied by the Germans. Canadians soldiers went under special training weeks before

    Read More

  • The Battle At Vimy Ridge

    214 Words  | 1 Pages

    The battle at Vimy Ridge was a defining moment in Canadian History because it gave Canada a sense of nationhood “The Battle of Vimy Ridge marked ‘the birth of a nation’ for Canada, says Governor-General David Johnston” (Postmedia news). It was the first time all four Canadian Corps fought together in the history of the war. The victory of ‘taking Vimy Ridge’ was celebrated, and two months later Viscount Julian Byng was promoted out of the Corps and Arthur Currie became the first commander of the Corps. The 60’000 casualties in the war, made Vimy the most symbolic of Canada’s overall sacrifices. This pushed Prime Minister Borden to ensure a separate representation at the Paris Peace Talks after the war.

    Read More

  • Why Is The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Significant

    1283 Words  | 6 Pages

    The amount of time and planning put into the Vimy Ridge battle strategy led to better planning for future battles. One of the biggest techniques used was the creeping barrage. This was when men would move and bombs would be dropped in a set period of time. This strategy left the Germans surprised when many Canadians appeared expectantly in their trenches (11). This was just one of many techniques the Canadians used while taking over the Ridge.

    Read More

  • How Did The War Of 1812 Cause And Effect Essay

    1747 Words  | 7 Pages

    On 18 June 1812, president James Madison signed a declaration of war for what is now known as the War of 1812. There were many actions that led to the cause of this war, mainly including the maritime, economic, and territorial issues. Once the war had begun, there were many actions taken and lives lost during the invasions and battles until the war finally came to an end merely three year later. This war has been viewed as a lesson more than anything and even though it was not a very long war, it has impacted the countries that were involved, including Canada, and has helped bring us to where we are today. There were many causes known to start the War of 1812, the main one was thought to be the maritime issues.

    Read More

  • Role Of War In Canada

    963 Words  | 4 Pages

    During WWII, Canada played a crucial role in the Battle of the Atlantic and the air war over Germany. They contributed troops to the allied forces and punched far above their weight for a small nation of then only 11 million people. Because of Canada’s oversized role in the War, it established itself as a middle power. This position helped define Canada in a number of ways, primarily being one of the first non-great powers to help build the United Nations. It earned respect from other countries and with The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO).

    Read More

  • Conscription In Canada During Ww1 Essay

    1125 Words  | 5 Pages

    As a country Canada’s strengths included, gaining autonomy through persevering and showing just how mature and ready Canadians were to be in charge of their own army; and be recognized as a separate country from Britain. Another one of Canada’s strengths was how calmly autonomy was achieved after the war. Canada did not need to make a fuss about becoming their own country because it was obvious that they were already ready for that. Their proof was presented in how they planned and executed their battles, and fought alongside Britain to successfully defeat

    Read More

  • How Did World War 1 Affect Canada

    1266 Words  | 6 Pages

    This was the first ever battle where gas was introduced. It was brought by the Germans and swept the French trenches (Christie, 9). The French retreated and the Canadians had to hold down the trenches. Germans attacked when the gas cleared and the position was held by The Royal Highlanders from Montréal. Because of Canada’s selfishness, they helped win this battle.

    Read More

More about Is Vimy Ridge A Defining Moment For Canada?

Open Document