In a study about mental illness and isolation it was found that “perhaps the thing that can happen to someone in isolation is the experience of the ‘sensed presence,’ or the feeling that another person or even a supernatural being is with us”(Frank McAndrew, psypost.org). When trapped on a island and being unable to trust anything or anybody around himself, he is sure to develop these signs of insanity. In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, all of the boys that feel like the Beastie is a real thing have revealed to the reader that they have completely lost their sanity. Jack, along with all of his hunter feel this way. After crashing on a deserted island with no parents left alive, a group of only boys ages twelve through six have to learn to …show more content…
Some boys are born natural leaders and some are natural followers, but one big problem is that two boys , Jack and Ralph, want to lead the group. Ralph would be a better leader than Jack because he has better qualities for leading and has not completely lost his sanity. To begin with, Ralph would be a better leader than Jack because throughout the book he wants to focus on the boys main goal of being rescued along with being able to listen to ideas from other boys. Jack wants to do other less important actions like hunting pigs, stealing from others, and killing the beast. For example, when Jack lets the fire go out because he is hunting Ralph says “There was a ship. Out there. You said you’d keep the fire going and you let it out. They might have seen us. We might have gone home”(Golding 70). Ralph’s main focus is to keep the fire going so that passing ships will see the smoke resulting in the boys getting rescued. Jack's love for hunting pigs and lack wanting to get rescued show that he is turning more savage by the day. This is just another reason why Ralph would make a better leader than Jack would. This also shows that Ralph has better priorities than Jack does. The boys first reaction
Rescue is what will truly make the boys happy, seeing their families and parents, getting back to civilization, and school, eating healthy, being clean. This is all what the boys really needed. A second reason why Ralph’s style of leadership was better than Jack’s is because Ralph was concerned about the boy’s safety, and earnestly cared about them. Unlike Jack who only cared for himself like a dictator, which is not good leadership because then boys could get hurt, lost, left behind, forgotten about, and much more things. It's evident in the novel that Jack didn't care for the boys because it says he hated the littluns, and everyone who wasn't of use to him.
(Golding, 61) Ralph influenced many people to also have hope. Piggy and Simon (without Ralph) would have easily just gone with Jack and nothing would have happened. Jack wouldn’t (and didn’t) even have the intellect to connect fire with rescue without Ralph. Jack could care less about the fire, unless for cooking his meat of course. Ralph keep everyone on track as long as he could.
The boys could have easily chosen Jack instead of Ralph, especially given the fact that Jack had previous experience as a leader; he is first seen surrounded by a group of faithful followers, his choir group, that continue to obey him on the island. Even Piggy, who showed support towards Ralph from the beginning, is intimidated by Jack's authoritative demeanor. However, Jack is missing that key characteristic that made Ralph so appealing: the symbol of power and strength. Any sense of leadership that Jack held was overshadowed by the image of Ralph standing confidently with the conch shell in hand. Ultimately, the young boys identified Ralph as their leader based on the power they believed he symbolized.
He got upset with them because keeping a fire burning was more important than hunting for pigs. This was more important to their survival because the smoke from the fire was a signal so they could be rescued. Ralph was mad how they hunters weren’t able to keep the fire going when the ship was near since that was an opportunity to get off the island. Ralph believed that if the fire was still burning, the ship would see them and rescue them. “Neither of the boys screamed but the grip of their arms tightened and their mouths grew peaked.”
How can we ever be rescued except by luck, if we don’t keep a fire going? Is a fire too much for us to make?” This shows that Ralph used the conch to call for a meeting for the kids to discuss things and used his deep concerns for the fire to try to drive the other kids to work harder on it. Jack’s leadership however is, “I’m not going to be part of Ralph’s lot-… Anyone who wants to hunt when I do can come too.”
The boys thought SImon was the beast emerging through the bushes within the island. The boys had so much fear present; they couldn’t think of anything else other than
Throughout the story Ralph wants everyone to stay civilized, But alternatively Jack becomes obsessed with becoming the leader and starts to lose his way of society. Ralph tries to keep everyone in their right mind, but by the end of the story he realizes that people react differently and it is difficult to maintain society. Ralph tries to maintain the fire and keep it going additionally, he knows if he gives up the fire that he will start to think and act like Jack’s tribe. Golding lets us know that Ralph still tries to maintain society by saying, “He put the conch to his lips and began to blow. Savages appeared, painted out of recognition edging round the ledge toward the neck”(Golding 159).
Ralph is one of the oldest boys on the islands, he was elected as leader at the beginning of the book. Ralph treats all the boys with respect throughout the book even when he begins to lose sanity himself. Ralph organizes all the boys in hope to keep them alive until they get saved, he makes them build shelters, keep the fire burning, and keep them all fed. Constantly throughout the book Ralph tries to keep the boys civilized whereas Jack does the opposite.
Although Jack expresses strong desire to become chief, the boys elect Ralph as a leader, suggesting an air of charisma that made him worthy of his position. He believes a leader has to “think, be wise… grab at a decision”, someone who can look after others and keep the group in
For instance, throughout the novel, Ralph presses the importance of the signal fire, which Jack eventually ends up using as a weapon to hunt Ralph down (Golding 198). This could be interpreted as Ralph's logic backfiring on himself, therefore landing himself into trouble among the boys. His idea for being rescued turns into a life-threatening situation for himself. However, the fire that Jack set is how the naval ship comes to the boys' rescue (Golding 200). Without Ralph stressing the importance of fires throughout the novel, Jack would not have been able to execute this fire that led to the boys' rescue.
“Well, we won’t be painted,” said Ralph, “because we aren’t savages” (172). There are many great leaders all over the world. To be a great leader one must have certain qualities including, being courageous, being responsible, willing to take charge, having all priorities straight on the important things, have determination, and many more. In Lord of the Flies, Ralph shows all of these characteristics and a few more. Out of every boy on the island, Ralph would be the best choice as leader.
After Jack and his choir agree to tend to the signal fire, Ralph spots a potential rescue ship but finds that Jack’s group let the fire go out as they went on a pig hunt, making Ralph extremely enraged and disappointed. Whereas previously there were only minor arguments that resolved quickly and easily that did not damage their relationship much, this marks the official beginning of the conflict of Ralph against Jack. After this incident was yet another turning point. What started off as an assembly “to put things straight” resulted in Jack disputing Ralph’s authority and leading everyone away in a show of clear mutiny. This shows that Jack is distancing himself and the group away from Jack.
Did you ever think that one day you will get stuck on an island with control over two boys that are no older than eleven years old? In the book Lord of the Flies by William Golding tells all about this. When many boys are stuck on an island they have to try and fight for their lives. Sometimes the characters disagree because they all have different opinions. Being isolated on an island causes them to fight and not get along with each other because of the decisions that are made.
Jack is enthusiastic because eventually everyone is listening to him. However Ralph is still a better leader. All in all, Ralph is a better leader. Some reasons include, Ralph having an clear vision, having communication skills, and him being confident and dedicated to being an leader. However being a better leader is not about having the most power.
Lord Of The Flies Jaedyn Clavelle Per 3 Lit comp 1. Imagine you're on an Island stranded, filled with fear trying to survive. Do you feel you could stay calm and handle it in way an “adult” would or could the fear bring out the inner beast which hides deep down inside all of us. The novella Lord of The Flies by George Orwell, tells a story about a group of british boys who crash a plane on an inhabited island. These kids have to work together with the help of a leader to govern themselves yet they find the results to be disastrous.