ipl-logo

Jack Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

1164 Words5 Pages

In the book Lord of the Flies there are two boy who try and fight for the role as chief one who is voted into power and another who pushes others into accepting him as their leader. Ralph the chief who is intent on being rescued and Jack the boy who believes that he is a strong warrior that can face anything. As the story goes along, both boys face trying times that show that almost anyone can become savage when abandoned by society. The two boys show strengths and weakness throughout the story, showing you that everyone when put in a situation can be a leader, whether it be good or bad.
Ralph and Jack both have two very different ways of looking at the situation of being stranded on an island. Jack at first think that they need rule saying …show more content…

Jack rushes into things and is a harsher ruler, but in the beginning of the book when we first meet Jack he seems well thought out and put together. Jack personality changes throughout the book as we see him go from a good english schoolboy to the savage hunter who thirst for the kill. When we first meet Ralph he is a lot kinder to Piggy, then most the other boys. Ralph is the boy who really want to be rescued, and suggested that they build a fire so that passing ships can see them. The boy's desice that they should build the fire up on the high mountain, Jack and his choir volunteers to take care of it and make sure that it always lit. Jack on the other hand only cares about getting his meat; when Jack learns that there are pigs on the island he becomes more excited and start to form a hunt. While Jack is of hunting, a ship passes by and Ralph see it, but sadly the fire is out because Jack and his choir were out hunting. This cause a fight between Jack and Ralph due to Jack thinking that it was fine because he got meat. Jack and Ralph are motivated by different things, Ralph is so focused on the fire and being rescued, while Jack is more focused on having fun and enjoying his time on the island that they tend to clash and disagree on way to go about

Show More
Related

  • Ralph Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

    627 Words  | 3 Pages

    These boys, Jack and Ralph, both fight for dominance during this novel, whilst grappling with their egos and desires. Ralph is the superior leader in, “Lord of the Flies,” due to his prioritizing the group’s welfare and emphasizing reason over primal instinct. Ralph's leadership prioritizes the group's welfare, he says “We've got to have special people for looking after the fire. Any day there may be a ship out there... ”(Golding 33)

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Lord Of The Flies

    956 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ralph is looking out for all the boys by mentioning the fire and rescue, Jack using the feast to lure all of the boys in one gathering cast a vote to have the leader of the island. Jack isn’t concerned about rescue or getting off the island but instead wants leadership over the whole island. In short, Jack is leading the boys away from the main objective, putting a carrot on the stick and the pig follows as they slowly devolve into savages. However, some readers consider Ralph to be responsible for the chaos and destruction because Ralph wasn’t a fit leader who could properly control the boys on the island.

    Read More

  • Ralph Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

    755 Words  | 4 Pages

    They chose a leader who calamitously failed. A leader who was favored by society. A leader who the stranded boys put their trust in. If only the boys ignored social standards, their situation could have been exceptionally different. William Golding’s, Lord of the Flies, reveals that leadership is not limited to those who are popular; other factors, aside from social status, should be considered, as demonstrated through the archetype of the characters, the author’s point of view, and the resolution of the story.

    Read More

  • Dialectical Journal For Lord Of The Flies

    841 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ralph wants to build shelter incase it rains and create a fire to create smoke in order to be rescued, both of those points I agree with. However Jacks main focus was hunting, he wants to hunt pigs. I agree that they need meat, but I don’t think that he should only be

    Read More

  • Who Is The Better Chief In Lord Of The Flies

    538 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ralph cared more about the safety and rescue of the boys than Jack. When Jack and the hunters return to the extinguished fire, Ralph berates him, telling him that there was a boat and “we could’ve been rescued!” (Golding 70) This shows that while Jack’s tribe focused on hunting and immediate gratification, Ralph is still considering the big picture and has his priorities straight. “If it rains like when we dropped in we’ll need shelters all right.

    Read More

  • Jack As A Leader In Lord Of The Flies, By William Golding

    633 Words  | 3 Pages

    Why elect a leader if you’re not going to follow their rules? In Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the majority of the book takes place without adults. This leaves the boys stranded with no supervision of help from anyone but themselves. Without adults or resources, they must start from scratch to build their society. Even though many may see Jack as a strong leader, he prevents the boys from creating a perfect society and getting off the island efficiently.

    Read More

  • Jack Lord Of The Flies Argumentative Essay

    882 Words  | 4 Pages

    Every child comes into this world as a selfish, manipulative, cruel and stubborn being. It is the parents and society that teaches children how to function in a civilized world, and societal laws that keeps them under control. William Golding wrote this novel in the early years of the cold war and the atomic age. In William Golding's classic novel Lord of the Flies, Golding uses Jack, a young savage who looks to lead a group of stranded kids on an island with no food, no rules, and no adults. The effect freedom has on Jack has turned him into a savage because he does not have to listen to anyone since there are no adults on the island.

    Read More

  • Jack Merridew Lord Of The Flies Essay

    855 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Case of Jack Merridew The murders of Piggy and Simon have not gone unnoticed, and the kids from the island are all under question for their untimely deaths. The main suspect for their murders is Jack Merridew, one of the older boys on the island. The story originates in a book called The Lord of the Flies written by William Golding, about young boys who are stranded on the island. Jack is one of the older, more savage of the bunch, but he seems to be ill in the brain.

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies Dialectical Journal

    1998 Words  | 8 Pages

    When it came time to choose a Chief for the island, Jack believed there was no competition for leader of the tribe. Ralph believed in rules, his overall goal was to have the boys create a society similar to the one they had known before they crashed onto the island. He was constantly trying to get the boys to build shelter, gather food, and perform other jobs necessary for their survival. Every day Ralph was commanding the boys to keep the fire going. In Ralphs eyes this was the only way they were going to be rescued.

    Read More

  • Power In Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

    496 Words  | 2 Pages

    Near the end of their time on the island, Piggy, Sam, and Eric are the only ones left with Ralph, and Jack, who appears as “a chief now in truth; and he made stabbing motions with his spear” (Golding 168). Jack starts to get violent, and what was fun when they first got to the island become attempts to kill. At this point, Jack has fully taken over, and the only thing left for him to do is kill Ralph. Lord of the Flies exemplifies how when one person has all of the power, there is always somebody else that wants it more than that person. Ralph is not against Jack, nor does he want to fight with him for the chief position, but ambition and violence overtakes Jack, and he turns into a dangerous savage.

    Read More

  • Movie Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

    970 Words  | 4 Pages

    The theme in William Golding’s Novel Lord of the Flies is to portray the image of this inner evil that lives inside of everyone. When comparing the novel to the film we can see this theme weakened in many ways. Instead of English choir boys like the novel the director replaces these choir boys with American cadets in the film. There is also the image of the ‘beast’ which is portrayed very differently than in the novel, and causes confusion on what the actual ‘beast’ is. The film is also not able to give us the in depth character analysis that we see in the book, and can make it hard to understand the role of each character, and there purpose in the story.

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies Power Quotes

    504 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the novel The Lord of The Flies by William Golding there are two characters. Both 12 years old, Ralph the son of a naval officer and Jack a redhead with freckles and the head of the choir. Both with leadership characteristics but one siding with reason and the other with Power. First, after the boys landed on the island and found each other, Both boys had a craving for power so they nominated themselves to be leader, Jack saying “I ought to be chief”, “because I'm chapter chorister and head boy”.

    Read More

  • Essay On Lord Of The Flies Ralph And Jack Relationship

    574 Words  | 3 Pages

    After Jack and his choir agree to tend to the signal fire, Ralph spots a potential rescue ship but finds that Jack’s group let the fire go out as they went on a pig hunt, making Ralph extremely enraged and disappointed. Whereas previously there were only minor arguments that resolved quickly and easily that did not damage their relationship much, this marks the official beginning of the conflict of Ralph against Jack.    After this incident was yet another turning point. What started off as an assembly “to put things straight” resulted in Jack disputing Ralph’s authority and leading everyone away in a show of clear mutiny. This shows that Jack is distancing himself and the group away from Jack.

    Read More

  • Jack Lord Of The Flies Character Analysis

    818 Words  | 4 Pages

    Jack lost his sanity and civility and this changed him in more ways than imaginable. Jack was a natural leader when the boys first came onto the island, but as time continued he became a horrible dictator. On the first day on the island, Ralph and Jack competed for chief of the island. Ralph won. Jack was unhappy with this result, but it didn’t yet throw him into a spiral of craze and anger.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Ralph And Jack In Lord Of The Flies

    773 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first difference between Ralph and Jack is that they have different ways of organizing things on the island. Ralph wants to lead everyone to work together to get off the island in a civilized order. Jack also wants to lead everyone but not in the same, properly ordered way as Ralph. When they first meet on the island, everyone who was stranded on the island wanted to be organized into some type of governing body so that they were ordered.

    Read More

More about Jack Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

Open Document