Jakobsen's Essay 'Queers Are Like Jews, Aren' T They
Critical Paper: Judaism and Culture
In this essay, I will begin by introducing the functions of analogies and then I will analyze Janet Jakobsen’s argument of using analogies in the essay “Queer’s Are Like Jews, Aren’t They?” I will explain how Jews are both similar and also not similar to Barbie according to a statement made in the video, “The Tribe''. Finally, I will describe the effects of reversing the contexts of analogies.
Analogies explain the meaning of a word by comparing it to something of similar value. It is used for teaching purposes or for general clarification. Analogies compare two different things to describe shared qualities or characteristics. Analogies come with the implication that the two comparisons are of similar value.
…show more content…
Analogy and Alliance Politics” she delves deeper into comparing the analogy between two marginalized groups in society: Jews and Queers (Jakobsen, 64). The author argues that analogies can be effective and powerful when used in certain contexts, but also harmful when comparing two groups. She states that analogies diminishes relationships between two subjects when it comes to their distinct difficulties and “oppressions” by focusing on the similarities (Jakobsen, 67). She further argues that by creating analogies creates two separate groups, undermines the intersections between them, and overlooks the particular issues that the group experiences (Jakobsen, …show more content…
Barbies were initially created with the western features and characteristics which were desirable at the time: like blue eyes, blonde hair, and gentle curves. They represented the beauty standards which were considered ideal and favored by society. However, these unrealistic standards are difficult to achieve by the average woman. Similarly, Jews also do not fall into a category which represents the quintessential Jew. Jewish people have a wide variety of cultures, customs, traditions, and beliefs which may not fit into the ideal Jew represented by the Jewish faith. These different opinions and views can be demonstrated through the Jews in the United States today. Identifying as being Jewish today may have different meanings than what previous ancestors once
Holocaust Dbq Essay
883 Words | 4 PagesTo the reader the word “Jew” symbolizes pain, suffering, and enslavement. In the end, using hidden meaning behind words are essential when talking about the
Half Jewish, Just Jewish And The Oddities By Sarah Imhoff: Article Analysis
1158 Words | 5 PagesThe terms “half-Jewish” and “just-Jewish” are too simple and doesn’t fully capture the complex nature of Jewish identity. The author writes that “Jewishness is neither an either/ or proposition nor is it solely a matter of religious adherence. ” Jewish identity involves a complex involvement of religion, culture, history, and family. Imhoff also examines the difficulties that arise when identifying with a religion. She goes into detail and explains that religious labels can be restrictive and often leave people out, people often use these labels to navigate different social and cultural situations.
1950s Beauty Pageants
590 Words | 3 PagesMore specifically she represents the embodiment of the mainstream beauty standard (Klein). She became a very significant role in gender socialization among young girls and woman. In the first Barbie commercial ever, if you carefully scrutinize the lyrics, it says “…someday I’m going to be exactly like you, until then I know just what I’ll do, Barbie beautiful Barbie I’ll make believe I am you” these lyrics informs us that Barbie represents a dream to every little girl, how their future should look like. Barbie was able to remain popular in the conservative times of the 50’s by captivating the attention of little girls, they all aspired to look just like her. Barbie was able to uphold some of the messages that dominated that era by represents the gender roles that belong to woman, in the first Barbie commercial, you can see Barbie wearing a wedding dress, symbolizing that every girl/woman desires to become a
Similarities And Differences Among American Jewish Communities
226 Words | 1 PagesOne might ask how many Baltimore Jewish communities there are; whether The Associated represents one encompassing community, several communities, or one community among several; and, as the federation articulated its goal of Jewish continuity, how many communities this meant strengthening. Associated staff and lay leaders resist publicly recognizing differences. They describe the Baltimore Jewish community as uniquely homogeneous among American Jewish communities. It has long traditions and is both physically concentrated and socially cohesive. The generations in Baltimore Jewish families have grown up and done business together, they feel a strong attachment to the city, and the children stay in the community.
Barbie Doll Rhetorical Analysis
1144 Words | 5 Pages(Kramer and Nelson 1997). Using the idea that Barbie depicts a woman who can be whoever she wants to be gives a sense of ethos present in the advertisement. This will then influence the audience (young girls) that they too can be whoever they want to be. By giving the opportunity for emotional attachment and representation of the little girl holding the doll looking up to Barbie as someone much like themselves, it gives a sense of hope and inspiration for the young girl. With the use of pathos, advertisement of Barbie makes it appear as though she is very approachable because of her looks and the way she seems to “fit the standards of society.”
An Overview Of The First Division Of American Judaism
893 Words | 4 PagesAmerican Judaism is a diverse religious tradition with three basic divisions (denominations). These divisions of American Jews are Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform. All of these divisions reflect different approaches to Jewish tradition and outlooks towards modern culture and society as a whole. Orthodox Jews believe to stick to the authentic Jewish tradition, while Conservative Jews are balanced with sticking to tradition but are open to change. Lastly Reform Jews, take a modern approach to religion to keep in line with the rest of the culture.
Transgender People And Bathroom Summary
648 Words | 3 PagesBy looking past our differences, such as race, class, and gender, we can then form a connection among each other and rely less on adhering to comparing and ranking oppressions. By viewing oppression as a fight between domination and subordination, we can then lessen the impact in which race, class, and gender play, and focus on the inequality between the two structural bases. Changing our view on oppression is important, but we also need to change our view of people. Stereotypes of people based on their race, class-status, or gender is the problematic piece to this new vision of oppression, as it lessens emotional impact and may cause ill intentions toward certain individuals or groups. Collins states we need “new categories of connection, new visions of what our relationship with one another can be…”.(p.
Summary Of We Are Many And Katz Why Is America Different
1664 Words | 7 PagesEuropean Jews faced years of anti-Semitism, leading to mass emigration from their home counties many coming to America. Many Jewish historians question whether the anti-Semitism differed from Europe to America and whether today if anti-semitism still exists for American Jews. Both Shapiro’s We Are Many and Katz’s Why is America Different discuss the issue of American Anti-Semitism and prove that there is still Anti-Semitism within the American community.
Letter From Birmingham Jail Rhetorical Analysis
1341 Words | 6 PagesIn Martin Luther King, Jr's “I Have a Dream” speech he uses the analogy quite often. Analogies are used to try and get at a reader's emotions. They are also used to try and exaggerate a point so that it either looks
Last Moments Of Al Tifrosh Min Ha Tzibur
597 Words | 3 PagesThe Jewish community is rooted in those who came before us, our future being shaped by past generations. In the Amidah, every day we remind God and ourselves that, whether by birth or by choice, we are connected to an intricate family spanning many generations. We are all in some way descendants of Abraham & Sarah, Isaac & Rebecca, Jacob, Leah, and Rachel. All of us are connected to our ancestors, and most importantly, we are all children of an infinitely loving, infinitely merciful, and infinitely amazing God. We are never
Jewish Stereotypes In Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, And Edith Wharton
864 Words | 4 PagesIn early-twentieth century American fiction, Jewish stereotypes often focused on Jewishness as a racial phenomenon. Texts attributed distinct personality traits and physical characteristics to Jews on account of their biological difference from gentiles. Further, Jewish stereotypes frequently portrayed Jews as social infiltrators and outsiders who threatened the status quo. Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, and Edith Wharton, among other early-twentieth century American authors, also used Jewish stereotypes as a device to accentuate their works’ social commentary and to emphasize their protagonists’ desirable, American traits. Taken together, these three writers’ Jewish stereotypes exhibited patterns in their presentation of Jewishness, in their tropes’ focus on Jewish physical and social attributes, and in their text’s differentiation between Jewish and gentile characters.
Meaning Of Barbie Q By Sandra Cisneros
606 Words | 3 PagesBarbie dolls extend girls an invitation to a ‘‘plastic society’’ that doesn't accept the genuineness each of us possesses. They present a role model impossible to accomplish. The characters didn't have names, they could hold a symbolic representation of society’s judgment. The girls had the first dolls just like they wanted, but they desired to cover all of the imperfections on the dolls damaged in the fire with new clothes such as the ‘‘Prom Pink outfit’’ (Cisneros). Thereupon, no one would notice the
Analysis Of Marge Piercy's A Barbie Doll
1480 Words | 6 PagesPiercy’s “Barbie Doll” takes a sarcastic approach to backlash at society and send the reader a message about what beauty really is. In “Barbie Doll”, A Barbie doll is used to show and symbolize what society views as what a female should aspire to become “perfect”. “Barbie's unrealistic body type…busty with a tiny waist, thin thighs and long legs…is reflective of our culture's feminine ideal. Yet less than two percent of American women can ever hope to achieve such dreamy measurements.”
Why Is Barbie A Bad Role Model
683 Words | 3 PagesBarbie is a bad role model for young girls. Barbie has a perfect appearance, she is very stereotypical, and she causes girls to have poor mental health. To begin with, Barbie is a bad role model, because she has a perfect appearance. She has flawless skin and this causes many girls to have low self-esteem. She is also usually tan and this has led many girls to go tanning at the beach.
Compare And Contrast The Various Forms Of Judaism
705 Words | 3 PagesJewish socialism, ethnic (Yiddish) Judaism, and Zionism were all responses to the challenge of devising a strategy for surviving in societies that were replacing religious anti-Judaism with secular anti-Semitism. In North America, with its more tolerant attitude towards diversity, Jews were better able to build a life for themselves, and all forms of modern Judaism have had to make decisions about how to relate to the larger secular society and how to determine what belongs to the essence of Judaism and what elements are
More about Jakobsen's Essay 'Queers Are Like Jews, Aren' T They
Holocaust Dbq Essay
883 Words | 4 PagesHalf Jewish, Just Jewish And The Oddities By Sarah Imhoff: Article Analysis
1158 Words | 5 Pages1950s Beauty Pageants
590 Words | 3 PagesSimilarities And Differences Among American Jewish Communities
226 Words | 1 PagesBarbie Doll Rhetorical Analysis
1144 Words | 5 PagesAn Overview Of The First Division Of American Judaism
893 Words | 4 PagesTransgender People And Bathroom Summary
648 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of We Are Many And Katz Why Is America Different
1664 Words | 7 PagesLetter From Birmingham Jail Rhetorical Analysis
1341 Words | 6 PagesLast Moments Of Al Tifrosh Min Ha Tzibur
597 Words | 3 PagesJewish Stereotypes In Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, And Edith Wharton
864 Words | 4 PagesMeaning Of Barbie Q By Sandra Cisneros
606 Words | 3 PagesAnalysis Of Marge Piercy's A Barbie Doll
1480 Words | 6 PagesWhy Is Barbie A Bad Role Model
683 Words | 3 PagesCompare And Contrast The Various Forms Of Judaism
705 Words | 3 Pages