Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging Summary
Jeff Jacoby, “Bring Back Flogging,” in Sylvan Barnet and Others, eds. Critical Thinking, Reading, and Writing: A Brief Guide to Argument, 9th ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2017. 196-198.
Paola Zamarripa October 19, 2017
In “Bring Back Flogging,” Jeff Jacoby argues that the need of bringing back flogging is an excellent way of punishment for modern society. Jacoby also states how crime has gotten out of hand over the past few decades, which has lead for the government to establish more prisons to lock up more criminals. Jacoby gives three arguments in defense to his position: first, he expresses how flogging is cheaper; second, people who go into trial do not get sentenced anyway or takes a long time; third, inmates in prisons will
…show more content…
Jacoby starts off informing the reader about different scenarios on how the Boston Puritan forefathers went about flogging. For example, he states that in 1632, Richard Hopkins was sentenced to be “whipt, branded with a hott iron on one of his cheeks” (196). However, in modern society this method is not humane, therefore, “ lock them up in cages” (197). Locking inmates in cages is a “sign of manhood, a status symbol” (197). According to Jacoby flogging is cheaper due to the excessive amount of money each inmate cost. “The price of keeping criminals in cages is appalling – a common estimate is 30,00 dollars per inmate per year” (197). There are nearly 1.6 million Americans behind bars today, which is approximately forty-eight billion dollars per year. Another of Jacoby’s argument is that those who commit a crime a lot of the times are of the hook because the procedures take a long time. Therefore, allowing these criminals to be freed with any punishment. Allowing flogging in this situation whether they committed the crime or not, it will remind them to go in the correct path. Finally, due to the excessive amount of inmates in jails, there are many setbacks like rape and murdered. In the case of flogging there is no danger, but the punishment that the criminal will have is because of the decisions he has taken. Not to mention, many offenders in prison are there for non-violent crimes.
Summary Of Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging
350 Words | 2 PagesIn “Bring Back Flogging” the author, Jeff Jacoby suggests that maybe we should adopt some of the punishments of the puritans. He says that Puritan forefathers punished crimes with whipping and branding, but in current times we tend to put someone in jail, no matter the degree of the crime. Jacoby also tells how often, first and second time offenders don’t get jail time, and if one does wind up in jail, it proves rather dangerous. (Jeff Jacoby 196-198)
Summary Of Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging
344 Words | 2 PagesFlogging should definitely be brought back. One may disagree because it’s too degrading. Jacoby is trying to persuade the reader, the general public, that Flogging is a better consequence than imprisonment in certain cases. He implies throughout his essay that adopting the Puritans punishment flogging would be better than imprisonment.
Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging Summary
974 Words | 4 PagesSell cocaine; go to prison. Kite checks; go to prison. It is an all-purpose punishment, suitable -- or so it would seem -- for crimes violent and nonviolent,” Jacoby does this for every point he makes to persuade a skeptical reader to reconsider the punishment of flogging. Jacoby also uses statistics to prove that flogging is quicker, better and cheaper than incarceration. For example, Jacoby states that, “the price of keeping criminals in cages is appalling -- a common estimate is $30,000 per inmate per year.”
The Overall Message Of Marcus Rediker
1498 Words | 6 PagesFor many, death was the only option to end their misery. Likewise, the repercussions of resistance were bearable, but so brutal. “The rising was suppressed, bloody punishments dispensed,” Rediker stated (Rediker, 19). The moment they were caught jumping overboard or trying to rebel against the ship’s company was the moment the punishment began. Whippings lasted until some slaves were dead, or captives were flogged for punishment.
Rum Sodomy And The Lash Chapter Summary
1651 Words | 7 PagesIn 1757, a sailor who was convicted of sexually assaulting a young male received a beating of 500 lashes, while in 1762, two men received 1000 lashes each for engaging in consensual sex, and in 1806, there were more hangings in England for sodomy than there were for murder offences. Chapter 3 of Rum, Sodomy and the Lash stresses the differences between a pirate’s trial versus a sodomist’s trial in court. Turley explains that pirates are economic criminals, and their crimes directly threaten property. At the same time, sodomites do not put the public in danger but rather challenge the separation between males and females and are no longer a part of the domestic economy and are instead a threat to society’s economic order. It is evident that sodomy was viewed as the worst offence and did not protect the public from real, dangerous
Rhetorical Analysis Of Frederick Douglass
444 Words | 2 PagesDiction such as “mangled” and phrases such as “lashed me till he had worn out his switches.” (pg. 68) are written in such a way that emotions form in the reader to feel the horrors of the act of slavery. Throughout his autobiography, Douglass contrasts the images of slaveholders and overseers with monsters and slaves with
Jeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging
545 Words | 3 PagesHe mentions that those who oppose using flogging likely disagree with its use because they feel flogging is degrading or brutal (Jacoby 198). To this, he counter argues by mentioning how jail is just as brutal, if not more brutal than flogging. (Jacoby 198) Consequently, Jacoby explains how being in jail can be brutal, saying that in 1994 it was reported by the Globe that the number of raped inmates each year was more than two hundred thousand (Jacoby 198). This information makes the reader weigh out how they feel about flogging verses jailing using the information just given and the information given in the beginning of the argument.
Theme Of Abuse In Frederick Douglass
1838 Words | 8 PagesPAGE 2 In the Narrative Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass by Frederick Douglass, he uses this text to explain his purpose in “throwing light on the American slave system”, or show it for what it really is, as well as show his position on how he strongly believes slavery is an issue that needs to be addressed and how it differs from those who defended slavery, with experiences from his own life to support his argument. Douglass uses experience from his early days as a young slave to throw light on the aspect of physical abuse. According to his narrative, Douglass states, “Master, however, was not a humane slaveholder.
13th: Documentary Summary
492 Words | 2 PagesThe “13th” is a documentary about the American system of incarceration and the economic forces behind racism in America especially in people of color. One of the claims that the author mentioned is that today incarceration is an extension of slavery. It is also mentioned that most of the time in society we are defined by race. In the documentary, we can see how African Americans are sentenced for many years since they are too poor to pay their fines or sometimes most of these people plead guilty to get out of jail fast. However, African Americans are separated from their families and also treated inhumanly in prisons just because they are of a particular race.
Analysis Of Jeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging
502 Words | 3 PagesThe action to avoid pain is even natural to the human nervous system and occurs subconsciously. For example, if one were to put his or her hand on a hot object, the innate reaction would be to pull his or her hand away. A “timeout” (imprisonment) would not deter a future offense as effectively as a physical correction (flogging) would. Imprisonment can also be ineffective because the convicts may not see it as a form of punishment, but rather, as “a sign of manhood, a status symbol” in their criminal, social circles, a.k.a. “street cred.”
George Orwell A Hanging Rhetorical Analysis
1124 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis of “A Hanging” In his personal narrative, “A Hanging”, George Orwell, a renowned British author, who often used his talents to criticize injustice and totalitarianism, describes an execution he witnessed in Burma while serving as an officer in the British Imperial Police. Originally published in The Adelphi, a British magazine, in 1931, the piece was written for educated, politically aware people in England, in hopes of provoking questions regarding the morality of capital punishment, and perhaps imperialist society overall, in those benefitting from such a system. Although he died nearly seventy years ago, his works are still influential and relevant today. Using vivid descriptions and a somber tone, Orwell recreates his experience in a tense narration that clearly shows his thesis concerning the value of human life and the wrongness inherent to a system that dismisses it so casually.
Disadvantages Of Rehabilitation State Prison
1678 Words | 7 PagesHowever, crimes are committed whilst in prison, such as drugs and assaults. Some critics say the ‘three strikes and you are out’ law where repeat offenders get a longer sentence are wrong, as the third strike could be a lesser crime such as public disorder. Nevertheless, if just incapacitation and no rehabilitation some critics say will be costlier to society as they will go out and reoffend and, they are not employed and pay taxes. Rehabilitation is also a punishment which should improve the offender's behaviour and stop them committing crimes. Advocates of rehabilitation state prison does not work; however, critics of rehabilitation state prison does work as the criminal cannot commit a crime against the public while incarcerated (Cavadino, 2007 p 36/56).
Similes In A Hanging By George Orwell
1113 Words | 5 PagesIf sending people off to get hanged was your job how do you think you would feel about it? In George Orwell’s personal essay “A Hanging,” Orwell designates the true impact hanging a person could have on someone’s soul. He ingeniously expresses how his view on taking someone’s life, while they are perfectly healthy is truly wrong. Orwell skillfully does this by using similes, describing scenes or people, and by his way of expressing the tone he wants to give. When reading this personal essay you notice a variety of similes.
Argumentative Essay On Capital Punishment
1383 Words | 6 PagesNot only for the criminal, but for the executioner. This has been a long issue over many years. Hanging was the way to execute a criminal starting in the 1800‘s then there was the gas chamber, firing squad, electrocution, and lethal injection. Over the years they keep chaning due to the inhumanity of each of them. The effect they have on the
Essay On Harsh Punishment
1048 Words | 5 PagesThere is a worldwide trend in the use of penal imprisonment for serious offenses as capital punishment has been renounced by an increasing number of countries. Harsh punishments include capital punishment, life imprisonment and long-term incarceration. These forms of punishments are usually used against serious crimes that are seen as unethical, such as murder, assault and robbery. Many people believe that harsher punishments are more effective as they deter would-be criminals and ensure justice is served. Opposition towards harsh punishments have argued that harsher punishments does not necessarily increase effectiveness because they do not have a deterrent effect, do not decrease recidivism rates and do not provide rehabilitation.
More about Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging Summary
Summary Of Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging
350 Words | 2 PagesSummary Of Jeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging
344 Words | 2 PagesJeff Jacoby Bring Back Flogging Summary
974 Words | 4 PagesThe Overall Message Of Marcus Rediker
1498 Words | 6 PagesRum Sodomy And The Lash Chapter Summary
1651 Words | 7 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Frederick Douglass
444 Words | 2 PagesJeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging
545 Words | 3 PagesTheme Of Abuse In Frederick Douglass
1838 Words | 8 Pages13th: Documentary Summary
492 Words | 2 PagesAnalysis Of Jeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging
502 Words | 3 PagesGeorge Orwell A Hanging Rhetorical Analysis
1124 Words | 5 PagesDisadvantages Of Rehabilitation State Prison
1678 Words | 7 PagesSimiles In A Hanging By George Orwell
1113 Words | 5 PagesArgumentative Essay On Capital Punishment
1383 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Harsh Punishment
1048 Words | 5 Pages