Miss Representation, written, directed, and produced by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, claims that mainstream media contributes to the underrepresentation of females in influential positions which limit and often disparaged the portrayals of women. The film underscores and implicits messages that young women need and want positive role models, and that the media has thus far neglected its obligation to provide them. Miss Representation included a social campaign to address the change in the media’s representation and advertising. The film expresses the need for enhanced media censorship in the American culture; especially when children are exposed to this explicit advertising. The movie indicates that the advertising industry that governs the content …show more content…
The media targets both female and male recipients, it is not just toward women (Fell 1). Miss Representation fails to recognize that the media objectifies and sexualizes both genders. Fell asserts that Magazines and tabloids hold photoshopped images of males that when compared to a normal american male’s body, can cause a major loss of self-esteem. Women in media are often portrayed a sexual objects, however, the same applies to the men. It appears that “[men] are targeted for being ‘too thin’ and some say bodybuilders ‘look gross’ and ‘must be on steroids’” (Fell 2). There is no winning for Americans, their bodies are either “too fat”, “too thin”, or “gross.” Miss Representation states that women are overly objectified and sexualized creating a mass insecurity for women. Additionally, Noah Berlatsky, the illustrations editor for The Atlantic, quotes in his article “Women’s Magazines Objectify Women Just as Much as Men’s Magazines Do” that most magazines are based around eroticized images of women, so therefore, male centered magazines are not the only ones to blame for the sexualization of women (Berlatsky 3). He ventilates that “women’s magazines...are providing female bodies for women, and telling women that (other) female bodies are objects to be used for their enjoyment” this contradicts Miss Representation’s …show more content…
According to Liza Mundy, a female activist, the media is biased under a man’s eye. Men in the media dominate over women a in a ratio of almost to ten to one (Mundy 1). The male’s influence in media makes women portray what the men want in a female. According to Miss Representation, this is because women in the media account for a mere twenty percent of employees in media production. This limits American’s exposure to female produced ideals in media. Moreover, Adrienne LaFrance, a staff reporter for the Atlantic, and her article, “I Analyzed a Year of My Reporting for Gender Bias (Again)”, proves to the reader that gender bias in media happens a lot more than one may think. LaFrance’s article examines her work using graphs and charts comparing the mentions of men compared to women. The analysis shows that only twenty-two percent of women were quoted or mentioned in her work (LaFrance 3). This supports the claim used by Miss Representation that women are thought of as secondary citizens in America and that most are “thrown under the bus” by media representation. Ultimately, The film focuses specifically on the depictions that trivialize women, it does not explore the counter argument that men are targeted,
“In America, almost one in every three women experienced food insecurity in 2021” ( USDA ERS 2). This shocking statistic directly relates to the negative outlook on women in power in all media sources by degrading them. In a documentary called Miss Representation, Jennifer Siebel Newson details how media negatively portrays women and how it harms them. In the documentary, Jennifer Siebel Newsom successfully exposes the lack of representation of women influencing and holding power in the Media. Newson uses Logos, Pathos, and Ethos to highlight the logic, emotion, credibility, and cinematics of the audience's desire to change and call out the wrongdoings of media.
Hi Tuyen, good job on rhetorical analysis since you did points out many significant points of the issue presented in the documentary Miss Representation. I agree with you that “Newsom effectively convinces the audience of Miss Representation that the media portrays women in society simply through the value of women’s look” based on the statistics and her persuasive evidence. Photoshop is mostly used to retouch models’ figure in advertisements in order to bring perfect female images to the public. That the media’s extreme focus on how a girl or a woman should look like creates a misleading thought that women’s value is portrayed by their outward appearance. It is absolutely inaccurate since advertisers just tend to manipulate consuming behaviors;
In this sincere essay, Teal Pfeifer creates an logical appeal that enlightens readers about the desperate need to boycott the magazines that use impractical female bodies, causing damage to young women. Pfeifer’s analytical evidence promotes an informative tone that makes her more trustworthy. Pfeifer states that according to research of Liz Dittrich, “twenty-seven percent reported that the images of models exerted direct pressure on them to lose weight” (Pfeifer 255). Pfeifer creates reasonable appeal with specific evidence based on studies that have been performed supporting her purpose to inform the reader. This creates an informative tone by including evidence of the situation at hand relating to the amount of women suffrage through the images exposed to them.
The movie Miss representation shows a trumendce amout of imfromation on how medias focuses more on looks than showing power for women. There is media clips and advertisments that show women more in how they look than they do showing a congress woman. The speakers atlk about their thought about how the media shows women, not showing power, and personal experiences. There are speakers talking about how the media wants women are never beautiful enough so they spend more money. Also how there are women in power in other countries and if people knew that infromation here it would become an issue.
Babes in Boyland: Women in Modern Media Oftentimes media portrays women as objects. During boxing matches my mother would always point out the fact that men always get to be this “skilled heroic athletes”, while women are always depicted as a “pretty pleasant eye candy”. Gender role has been an issue ever since the invention of modern media, for modern advertising techniques focus on humor, satire, sex, and very often the objectification of women. Carl’s Jr./
Jennifer Siebel Newsom’s Miss Representation successfully conveys the dangers that are associated with the demeaning methods the media uses to displace women from inspiring, valued positions and the effects of it on the American female population. The documentary explores the negative portrayal of women in the press and Hollywood, lack of female participation in major fields, and the side effects of the antifeminist movements on impressionable, young girls that have become highly visible through the media. The documentary reports of how even the most casual hints of misogyny distort the public’s values and expectations for women. The targeted audience is everyone because society can only right its wrongs by working and empowering together. However, Miss Representation does emphasize that young women in particular were the most important group of their intended audience.
She discusses misrepresentation with a list of “ten enlightened sexism…pretense of simple, depicting reality.” (198) which reinforces these pop culture into own ideals of what gender roles should be in our society.
The purpose of this is to show how common it is for women to be misrepresented in today’s society, and how it affects women of all ages. The documentary Miss Representation argues that the media needs to change its perception of women. To draw attention to this issue the documentary uses rhetorical devices to effectively get the point across. Although the documentary effectively
Being a young woman in America, I have stared eye to eye with the guidelines that the media has handed to me. The documentary, Miss Representation, directed by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, discusses how the media’s objectification of women impacts the lives of girls and women across America. Miss Representation shows that as a girl watches other women
Today's society is constantly besieged by the media, through advertisements and extolling the importance of female beauty and discrediting other virtues such as
In regards to race and class, there isn't that much diversity in their community, but the minorities face issues similar to what they might face in reality. Women took many roles in the show similar to the 90's there were lawyers, doctors, store owners even hints at Lisa becoming president one day. This leads one of the most vital points of this essay, It goes to show how much we can evolve as a society, a country and eventually a planet by changing something that we view as so minuscule but in reality is a part of the fabric that will allow us to change for the betterment of all. Adversely critics might view the idea of changing women's roles in the media as unimportant and we can attack the problem from an alternate angle. This can be argued but the "proof is in the pudding" whatever alternative methods that may be implemented to provoke "change" has garnered little to no
Women has greatly suffered in society from the beginning until now and no one seems to notice this prolonged issue that women have to endure in their daily lives. The media played a major role to how women are perceived in todays society. Nevertheless, in todays world more and more individuals are attempting to address the problem to solve this issue once and for all. Jennifer Newsom effectively convince her audience in an American documentary film: “Miss representation” to embellish the denigration of women in society and persuade the audience through the use of logos, pathos, and explicit visual images.
Countless advertisements feature thin, beautiful women as either over-sexualized objects, or as subordinates to their male counterparts. The mold created by society and advertisers for women to fit into is not entirely attainable. More often than not, models are Photoshopped and altered to the point that they don’t even resemble themselves. W. Charisse Goodman suggests, “The mass media do not
Introduction The documentary, Miss Representation was written, directed and produced by Jennifer Siebel Newsom. Miss Representation highlights how the media and our culture objectify and belittle women and girls in society. The documentary begins with Newsom’s childhood story and the life and future, she wants for her daughter. The media is used as the main source of information.
The representation of gender in mass communications has been a hugely debated topic for years and will continue to be one for many more years to come. The media plays a big role in how they want to portray a gender to the public. They create certain stereotypes through the role of a gender in order to attract a large audience and interest to sell a product, brand or image. Media is so important in today’s society, people spend hours and hours each day watching TV, browsing the Internet and reading magazines. There are so many images of men and women in the media today that it certainly has an impact on the viewer’s thoughts and sense of identity.