Jeopardizing Decisions: A Brief Analysis of 1984 The novel Nineteen Eighty-Four has received tremendous acclaim for its thought-provoking depiction of a society with a totalitarian government known as the Party, which suppresses individuals’ freedoms, autonomy, and means of expression. The novel’s protagonist Winston Smith works for the government in the Ministry of Truth, where his job is to rewrite historical records to fit the Party's current political agenda. This does not sit well with Winston, and throughout the first two sections of the novel, he takes measures to dissent from the Party, engaging in forms of self-expression, freedom, and rebellion. Ultimately there are two forms of risk-taking found within the novel, risks Winston …show more content…
A member of the inner Party, O’brian complimented Winston on his use of Newspeak, the language of the Party, during a hallway conversation at the Ministry of Love. At which, O’Brien also gave Winston his address, something profoundly unusual in this society, telling Winston he could get the latest and unreleased version of the newspeak dictionary from his home. Newspeak is the language of the Party, containing limited grammar and vocabulary designed deliberately to restrict free thinking. Winston takes their conversation to mean that O’Brien gave him the address with the intent of more than just acquiring the dictionary. “One thing was certain. The conspiracy that he had dreamed of did exist, and he had reached the outer edges of it” (Orwell …show more content…
He finds Julia attractive, although he hates her because he is suspicious that she is, like Katharine, a strong and trusting supporter of the Party. Later in the novel, Winston is hunting for truth, ventures to the prole’s (working class) quarters, and questions a random elderly prole about life before Big Brother. Unsatisfied with the prole’s answers, he continues his wanderings, entering a junk shop where he meets another older man named Mr. Charrington. Mr. Charrington sells Winston a glass paperweight and shows him a room upstairs that appears to be private. Winston considers renting the room for it has “a sort of ancestral memory,” but fear prevents him. While walking home from the shop, he recognizes Julia, assumes she is some sort of spy and considers smashing “her skill in with a cobblestone,” but relents. Winston’s subsequent encounter with Julia occurs at work, where she trips and falls - Winston’s humanity causes him to come to her aid. As he helped her up, she slipped a piece of paper into his hand that read I love you. Their relationship accelerated quickly, and they met again in the country to engage intimately with each other. The novel depicts their lovemaking: “Their embrace had been a battle, the climax a victory.
In the end, Winston and Julia are caught by
Immediately following this act, Julia states that she must return to work for the junior anti-sex league. This is ironic because Julia and Winston committed a crime, then right after Julia goes to help with the prevention of this crime. This shows us that Winston does not care to follow the rules of the party. He knows that Julia is part of an important movement, aiding the Party in maintaining control, but chooses to disobey anyway. This tells us that Winston does not agree with the party but is continuing to maintain a facade of agreeing with them in order
Together Winston and Julia separate themselves from societal norms by building a unique relationship that is rarely pursued in Oceania out of fear. The two gain individuality and alter their values as their love grows. When discussing punishments they may face for their actions Winston states “Only feelings matter. If they could make me stop loving you—that would be the real betrayal. ”(Orwell, 173) showing how his morals have changed.
To continue their affair, Winston had to find a place in which they could be together in complete privacy. He eventually locates a place in which the two of them should be safe. The room seems to be old and dirty. After Julia looks at the bed, she mentions, “‘It’s sure to be full of bugs, but who cares?’” (143).
This passage, the quote, and Winston’s early thoughts of Julia show the true purpose of Winston’s fantasy is not to have a sexual relationship with Julia, but to defile something of the party. At one-point Winston even thinks about raping Julia. This show how Winston’s hates Ingsoc, Big Brother, but even more their control over thought and their limit on individualism. This is
In the beginning of the book, while Winston was rebelling with thoughtcrime, he wished for more and Julia gave this to him. Winston described their intimacy as a “political act” against the party, because Julia gave Winston hope for a better future and more rebellion (Orwell 126). Without that, Winston had nothing and in return the party had nothing over Winston. In the end, his relationship with Julia is what kept him going. Winston described Julia as being “inside him” and part of “the texture of his skin”
Because of the omnipresence of the Party and threat of the Thought Police, Winston believes his rebellious acts were discovered from the beginning. This feeling of pessimism leads Winston to subconsciously make the decision to be less careful with covering up his rebellious acts. He takes risks with renting the room and meeting O’Brien which eventually leads to the failure of his resistance towards the government. The culture that the Party forces twisted Winston’s morals and invokes artificial feelings. Winston claims he will never betray Julia to the Party.
He begins his illegal love affair with Julia, once again defying the government. However, when he is taken by the police to the ministry of love and punished for this crime, he betrays his lover. Julia and Winston built a trustworthy secret relationship via their mutual hate for the government, but Winston gives it all up when he is threatened in room 101. Big Brother succeeds in pushing Winston to his breaking point, in which he exposes Julia to save himself. He yells to his torturers, “Do it to Julia!
Although Winston is able to grasp the concept of love, he truly understands love when he is with Julia. Initially, Winston sees being with Julia as a political act against the Party. He believes that sex and intimacy goes against the constitutional beliefs of the Party and is therefore an act of defiance. However, as Winston spends more time with Julia, he falls in love. When Winston is caught by O’Brien, he endures prolonged torture without betraying Julia.
George Orwell’s novel, 1984, thoroughly outlines the aspects of dystopian society, dictated by a totalitarian government of English Socialism. This novel preludes to a meaning much deeper than what is perceived from the events of the protagonist, Winston Smith, and his acquiesce against Big Brother. In order to decipher the uprooted meaning of this text, a formalist perspective can be used to analyze the literal aspects of a novel - particularly, in accordance to tension and ambiguity within a setting. Winston Smith was soundly proficient at his job in the Ministry of Truth. The Records Department “is connected with the happenings of the story” as it is a crucial location for conflict to arise, ultimately adding to the plot of the story (Bloom, Edward.
Julia betrays Winston, however, Winston does not betray Julia. In the end, he cannot hold up against the brainwashing and comes to love Big Brother, the leader of the party. After he is released, he and Julia no longer have feelings for each other. He goes on to live an easy and mindless life. The only thing he has left is a few memories of a time before the Party.
Charrington, the apparent sixty-three year old widow who owns an antique shop, offers Winston an “utterly secure” room, with “no voice pursuing” and “ no telescreen” watching over him (97). This room symbolizes Winston's hope to obtain freedom for his needs and a private get away. However, Charrington sets Winston up for a trap when Winston decides to rebel and have a clandestine love affair with Julia. Charrington willingly provides a room for Winston and gives the impression that he supports Winston’s actions against the Government. While Charrington was giving a tour of the room to Winston, they discuss the frame of St. Clement’s Dane and the rhyme behind it.
Winston and Julia’s relationship began with physical attraction, and for Winston, slowly evolved into an emotional attachment. Winston was certain that he loved Julia more than anything in the world, and that he had finally found someone that he could be happy with. Unfortunately, the government eventually manipulates Winston’s love for Julia into a love for the Party and Big Brother. After a tremendous amount of relentless torment, the party eventually makes Winston say “‘Do it to Julia! Not me!
After meeting her, Winston realizes that he rebels because it is the only way to gain freedom. “The sexual act, successfully preformed, was rebellion. Desire was a thought crime” (Orwell, 68). In a way, Julia gives him the strength he needs to continue to fight for freedom. “I have not betrayed Julia” (Orwell, 273.)
Winston eventually meets a woman named Julia who he is both enamored and repulsed by. His feelings of lust come from her striking and unusual beauty, while the feelings of disgust stem from the abolition of sex within Oceania.