ipl-logo

Metareflexivity

1084 Words5 Pages

Yet what strikes the viewer most is neither the Wichís’ cultural difference nor the evidence of transculturation within the community, but John’s own remarkable assimilation into the Wichí language and culture. The film shows us how perfectly John has adopted the quiet, pausing speech and reticent manner of his Wichí companions. Rosell’s patient recording of everyday, unremarkable detail immerses us to such an extent in the new life John has chosen that the film succeeds in reversing the ethnographer’s gaze. John’s relationship with his home country is condensed into a single phone call with his mother, whose voice is left “suspended somewhere off-screen, just as it is for John.” The scene is wonderfully evocative of cultural distance, and acquires a particular poignancy for a British viewer who would immediately capture from the mother’s accent that the difference between their two environments is one of …show more content…

The visual anthropologist and ethnographic filmmaker David MacDougall (1939-) also rejects this form of reflexivity, which may be “completely at odds with the narrative or emotional logic of a work” and “act to block precisely those forms of understanding that visual anthropology makes possible.” In both Huellas y memoria and El etnógrafo, as we have seen, the interaction between filmmaker and subject is not the source of a methodological weakness that needs to be overcome with greater scientific rigor; rather, it is the very basis of intercultural

Show More
Related

  • Review Of Facing East From Indian Country By Daniel Richter

    1184 Words  | 5 Pages

    One may counter this quite controversial technique. These re-enactments of explanations are how Richter reasonably devised the Indians’ point of view. However, chapter-by-chapter, this stylistic approach laces together diverse material into a single narrative thread.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Locking Up Our Own By James Forman

    1412 Words  | 6 Pages

    The field notes position the reader right alongside Ralph, which provide a unique sense of positionality between the reader and Ralph. In the first field note, Ralph mentions how the passing of Mrs. Dickerson made him “want to understand the relationship between grandmothers, and their grandchildren in the gang.” (Ralph 20). This guides the reader through Ralph’s anthropological research from a very raw perspective. The positionality helps place both Ralph and the reader closer to the process of field work, as well as the subjects Ralph encounters during such work.

    Read More

  • Assimilation In Louise Erdrich's Tracks

    1545 Words  | 7 Pages

    As in life, throughout Louise Erdrich’s novel, Tracks, the Anishinaabe people suffer myriad violations inflicted upon them by the brutality inherent in settler colonialism: forced relocation to ever-shrinking land, environmental annihilation, depletion of life-sustaining fauna, rampant disease, taxation, bureaucracy, residential schools, false and racist narratives, the Catholic church, alcoholism, and so on. Hence, to suggest the book’s characters operate within a framework of trauma is an understatement. Amid the evolving disaster, although narrators Nanapush and Pauline Puyat often occupy the same spaces and share some characteristics, such as being talkative, sexual, and prone to visions, they perceive their worlds through disparate lenses, and develop along divergent trajectories. While Nanapush is nurturing, community driven, and generally life-affirming, Pauline is self-serving, opportunistic, and energized by death and violence. Whereas Pauline is the face of assimilation,

    Read More

  • Into The Beautiful North Character Analysis

    783 Words  | 4 Pages

    Culture is something that is important to everyone. When a person goes from one place to another, the shock of the different culture can be considerably large on a person’s character and their identity as a whole. In Into the Beautiful North, Urrea illuminates cultural collision and its affect on character’s sense of identity through Nayeli’s naivety and her reaction towards how America truly is throughout her journey. Nayeli’s naivety really stems from her home of Tres Camarones.

    Read More

  • Greg Sarris Essay

    420 Words  | 2 Pages

    Another, even though he was raised in a Pomo - Indian family, because of his blonde hair and blue eyes, and unidentified background he was unable to say / be truly apart of the Indian roots that molded him. Being a stereotype. Within emptiness he was able search and find more about himself than he expected. Learning about his lost Spanish Father, his

    Read More

  • Photographic Images And Identity Essay

    1699 Words  | 7 Pages

    Throughout history, photographs have been known to depict and represent culture, character, information, and ideology. Through specific elements of form, and close scrutiny, photographs give a representation of the “bigger picture” by providing content and invaluable information that text, on its own, does not produce. Dr. Carol Payne, a professor of art history at Carleton University, wrote an essay in 2012 for the Oxford University Press. This essay focused on the relationships between photographic images, Canadian culture and identity, and indigenous people. Her thesis was to discuss how an image can present a sense of national identity (Carol Payne 310).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of When My Mother Said We Are Blackfoot

    820 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the units studied this semester, in the face of life’s demands for actions, individuals find growth and inner strength by holding onto their identity and heritage. This can be shown clearly when the protagonist of the story Borders recounts an experience he had with his mother "My mother said we are Blackfoot. I knew we were. It didn't matter where the border was. " When the protagonist’s mother says, “My mother said we are Blackfoot.”

    Read More

  • Identity In Thomas King's Short Story 'Borders'

    1141 Words  | 5 Pages

    The group I was a part of was assigned a passage from Thomas King’s short story “Borders”. The short story followed a mother and son as they attempted to cross the border to visit the sister, who lived in Utah. The passage focused on the time that the mother and son spent at the border, due to their identification as being Blackfoot, and refusal to conform to identifying as Canadian or American. This passage is a central part of the story, since it addresses the issues of identity that the mother and son face regarding their identity of being Blackfoot. The assigned passage contained a prevailing number of linguistic elements, as well as symbolism.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Drifters Poem By Bruce Dawe

    1526 Words  | 7 Pages

    Title? Belonging is the pivotal axis around which human life revolves. Genuine poetry reflects directly or indirectly an awareness of the social problems of a country. Belonging and poetry, Miss Lawlor and my fellow students is one of the most curious combinations and this is what we see in the genre of poetry produced by the Australian poets in the 1960’s when……... Bruce Dawe was a vernacular poet known for his extraordinary empathy with people which characterises his poetry and gives a voice to the ordinary Australians.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Keeper N Me By Richard Wagamese

    624 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Traditions, Silence, and Life Within Everyone has new things to listen and learn from on a daily basis. Silence is important in both, but to ask questions is more important. To be thankful for the life we live is greater. In Richard Wagamese’s novel, Keeper ‘N Me, it teaches about the importance of learning, listening, silence, and every life within the land of the Ojibwe people.

    Read More

  • Cultural Symbolism In Madeleine Thien's Simple Recipes

    1223 Words  | 5 Pages

    Like the narrator’s father, he notices the family’s cultural identity is slowly dying. His wife, a native Malaysian, is adopting a new identity as a “sales clerk at [Woodworks]” (340) in Canada. In marriage, a couple is supposed to share the responsibility to raise their children and support each other. However, she may have given up on the teaching responsibility from the moment the language “never came easily to [the daughter]” (340). Ultimately, the father is solely responsible handing down his family’s cultural and social roots to his children.

    Read More

  • Brave New World Belonging Quotes

    930 Words  | 4 Pages

    John never quite settled down into a true home in Brave New World. The meaningful relationships he tried to establish with Linda, Lenina, and his Indian tribe didn’t work out. Without true connections to people, John’s real home was within himself in a place where he could be by himself. When John finally had hopes of living this way in the lighthouse, he had his hopes ruined by the people responsible for his lifelong solitude. The tragic story of John illustrates many of the author’s most important messages.

    Read More

  • Richard Wagamese's Keeper N Me

    1727 Words  | 7 Pages

    Richard Wagamese’s semi-autobiographical novel Keeper’n Me paints the portrait of a young man’s experience—one shared by many Indigenous peoples across Canada—revealing a new perspective on Aboriginal life. First Nations have often been romanticized and the subject of Western fantasies rather than Indigenous truth concerning Aboriginal ways rooted in “respect, honor, kindness, sharing and much, much love” (Wagamese, 1993 quote). Keeper’n Me tells the story of Garnet Raven, an Ojibway, who is taken from his family as a child by the Children’s Aid Society, and placed in a number of (white) foster families, where his Indigenous identity is stripped away. He serves time for drug charges, during which he receives a letter from his brother, inviting him back to the White Dog Reserve to rekindle ties with his people and learn about Ojibway culture, traditions, spirituality, and philosophy with the help of his community and his teacher, Keeper, an elder and recovering alcoholic who was instructed in his earlier years by Raven’s grandfather. In viewing the novel through the theoretical frameworks of the “Middle Ground”, “Orientalism”, and “Agency”, Keeper’n Me explores Canadian-Indigenous relations in a moving, yet humorous way, as well as the meaning of “being” a First Nation in modern society,

    Read More

  • Indian Education Sherman Alexie Summary

    490 Words  | 2 Pages

    When his second grade teacher calls him “indian, indian, indian,” Victor says, “Yes, I am. I am Indian. Indian, I am” (Alexei 173). The conversation portrays parallelism in that Victor’s repetition echoes the way his teacher repeats “Indian”. Alexei’s use of a capitalization change portrays Victor’s desire to identify as Indian while the white community tries to assimilate him.

    Read More

  • Themes In The Absolutely True Diary Of A Part-Time Indian

    702 Words  | 3 Pages

    Overcoming a challenge, not giving up, and not being afraid of change are a few themes demonstrated in The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Perhaps the most prominent theme derived from the novel is defying the odds, or in other words rising above the expectations of others. Junior Spirit exemplifies this theme throughout the entirety of the book. As Junior is an Indian, he almost expects that he will never leave the reservation, become an alcoholic, and live in poverty like the other Indians on the reservation—only if he sits around and does not endeavor to change his fate. When Junior shares the backstory of his parents, he says that his mother and father came from “poor people who came from poor people who came from poor people, all the way back to the very first poor people” (11).

    Read More

More about Metareflexivity

Open Document