Noah Beaton Ms. Korey Advanced Honors English II 1 March, 2023 Caesar Essay Exam Not every villain knows that he is at fault. In Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Brutus is the villain of the play even though he believes his cause is just. His naivety allows him to trust others too easily as well as discard the thought of a possible ulterior motive. On multiple occasions, Brutus’ lack of self awareness led him to a path of villainy. A weak mind can be easily manipulated. Brutus shows qualities of a weak mindset when Cassius is confident that he can change Brutus’ mind. Unlike Caesar, Brutus chooses not to think about the possibilities that why Cassuis was saying could be false. He also keeps a very low guard around strangers he just met. With only a few words exchanged between the two, Cassius was able to use Brutus’ devotion towards the people of Rome and turn it into a weapon through the use of flattery. By telling Brutus that he is …show more content…
Some characters argued that he was too ambitious and deserved to be slain while others thought that he was the best thing to ever happen to Rome. Brutus made the decision to kill his friend because he thought that it would better the nation. While the conspirators thought that this would make them heroes, it only brought turmoil in the country. Brutus tried to use his credibility to prove that he and the conspirators were correct, but the facts had stated otherwise. Mark Antony had used logic and reasoning to appeal to the crowd. Mark Antony states that Caesar was not ambitious because he brought Rome wealth, was generous to the people in his will, cared about the poor citizens, and won many battles for Rome. Brutus has no evidence to support that Caesar was ambitious besides the fact that he might be a tyrant one day. Mark Antony claims “ When the poor had cried, Caesar had wept; Ambition should be made of sterner stuff. Yet Brutus says he was
In the play Julius Caesar, written by William Shakespeare, the emperor of Rome is killed by his best friend, Brutus. At the funeral of the fallen ruler, Brutus gives a big speech to the crowd. He tries to explain why he and the other senators had to kill the emperor, Julius Caesar. In the speech, he informs them that Caesar was too ambitious, and says he chose Rome over his dear friend. Once Brutus was done, Marc Antony gave his speech to persuade the crowd that Julius wasn’t ambitious at all.
As well as a great friend of Caesars, which meant he could also trust him. Moreover, Brutus felt like the only way to make sure Rome was safe was to kill Caesar. He felt that for the freedom and wealth of the people, it was the most logical and ethical thing to do. In addition, which led to him being the leader of the conspirators and taking over. Brutus had known the people of Rome admired him, they also loved him.
The beginning to Brutus’s inner thoughts reveal that he is questionable of his ambitions, meaning that he believes that Caesar’s plan for Rome and its people is wrong, but never knowing for sure. In the beginning of Brutus’s soliloquy (Act II, Scene i, Lines 10-15), Brutus states to the audience that he has no real reason to oppose Caesar, and that he is questioning what being crowned king will do to his ambition as a leader. Brutus fears that Caesar will become a rambunctious tyrant, doing only what is best for him and ignoring the needs of the people of Rome. At this point, Caesar had not even been crowned king of Rome by the Senate, and the conspiracy group is going off of pure speculation.
Brutus’s earlier promise of defending the general public persuades him to join the conspiracy as he believes he does the right thing, but the audience knows the letter was forged by Cassius to trick Brutus. This bad decision is based on good intent and later reveals itself as Brutus’s hamartia in the play initiating his downfall as a tragic hero in the play due to his high belief in honor he sides with the conspiracy to kill his beloved
Brutus was manipulated through Cassius’ clever planning, bad judgment calls, and his nobility. Throughout the play Brutus’ apprehension of killing Caesar is very much apparent. But it all started with Cassius planting a little doubt in his head. Cassius is a wise guy and knew just what to say to get Brutus talking.
Cassius decides to sweet-talk Brutus. Cassius tries to show that he is a nice guy he says, “Brutus, I do observe you now of late / I have not from your eyes that gentleness / And show of love as I was wont to have. / You bear too stubborn and too strange a hand / Over your friend that loves you.”
However, Brutus continually feels the need to defend his actions and justify his crime. If he is truly confident in his deed, he would not stammer to find justifications. Yet, Brutus may not want power, he may really want justice. In his mind, murdering Caesar, was the only route to go.
Cassius uses comparability manipulation; he compares Caesar to Brutus to prove his point of them being no different from one another. In Cassius’s dialogue in Act 1, Scene 2, on page 19, he tells Brutus, “What’s so special about “Caesar”? Why should the name be proclaimed more than yours?” By emphasizing the belief that Caesar and Brutus have no differences between them and what they’re capable of, Cassius initiated the plan of poisoning Brutus against Caesar. This scene from the play is crucial to exhibit how Cassius is able to infiltrate Brutus’s beliefs and trust in Caesar.
Leni Wicht GATE English 10 Mrs. Reed 9 May 2023 A Tale of Betrayal and Power “Et tu, Brute?” The famous line from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar captures the heart of a play that explores the consequences of loyalty, betrayal and power. As he is the character who undergoes the most significant transformation throughout the play, Brutus is a more complex and dynamic figure than Caesar. Additionally, naming the play after Brutus would help to shift the focus to the themes of power, loyalty, and betrayal that are central to the play, and would help to center the perspective of the conspirator.
Cassius is good at using things that Brutus would talk about to manipulate him into thinking he is better than Caesar. Over the period of the play, Brutus is manipulated and one of the first things that happened is that Cassius boosted Brutus’s confidence a
In conclusion, Brutus is not a villain. His conscience tells him that what he did was wrong and something had to be done about it, which ends in him killing himself. He shows lots of compassion throughout The Tragedy of Julius Caesar(JC) by William
Brutus’s tragic flaw was that he was naive. He trusted people to easily, especially the conspirators. They used him to make their actions seem honorable and just. When reality they just wanted Caesar dead for their own personal gain. Caesar was Brutus’s friend so it took him some convincing for him to be able to justify his actions.
When Brutus spoke about his motives to kill Caesar he said, “As he was valiant I / honor him. But, as he was ambitious, I slew him.” (3.2.27-28). Brutus honored Caesar but saw that his ambition has the potential of being very dangerous. He thought that a danger like Caesar could not be left to grow more powerful when there is a solution to the issue now.
In plays people are usually a tragic hero and cause their own downfall or they are the villain in the story. In the play The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, there is a character who plays more of a tragic hero than the main character whom the audience believes to be. The character Brutus is more of a tragic hero than Caesar is while at the sametime he plays a villain as well. To begin with, Brutus fails to see his own downfall based on how easily he can be manipulated. Cassius needed Brutus to help get rid of Caesar because of how much the Romans admired Brutus.
Emily Sigler Mrs. Korey Julius Caesar Essay Exam 1 March 2023 Throughout a tragic play, one of the main things that are known is whether there is a hero or a villain. In the play, The Tragedy Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, many tragedies occurred that contemplated Brutus being the hero or villain. Throughout the play, heroic movements were made by Brutus. His beliefs and passion made him appear as a strong and honorable man.