The author’s of these sources have similar opinions on the subject of later start times for high schoolers. The author of source one, Michelle Trudeau, believes high schoolers should have later start times, and focuses on the benefits of this. The author of source two, Dan Weissman, also believes that high schoolers should have later start times, but chooses to focus on how changing school start times will be difficult in some school districts and communities.
In source one, Michelle Trudeau writes about how changing school start times to later in the morning will benefit students. The article starts off with a claim on how high school students aren’t getting enough sleep, and she points out some specific negatives of starting school early
…show more content…
He starts off similar to Trudeau, giving scientific information about teenager’s sleep. He lists some problems of sleepy teenagers, including that they are more likely to crash cars, not do as well in school, and even become depressed. It sounds a lot like the guy supports the idea of later start times. But he moves into the main point of his article, which is that introducing later start times for high schoolers will be tough, and expensive. The overall point of the article is that later start times are healthy and beneficial, but it will be awhile before they are possible. In the beginning of the article, Weissman states, “The American Academy of Pediatrics has joined a chorus that’s been growing louder for years: The school day should start later for teenagersbecause they aren’t wired to go to bed early — and they need their sleep.The AAP says this is a public-health issue: Sleep-deprived teenagers are more likely to crash cars, get depressed, and become obese. Also, they may not do as well in school. However, early start times aren't going away quickly, and probably won't, because of the costs.” This quote from source two explains Weissman’s opinion on later school start times for high schoolers. Look at how much positive information he gives on the subject. It is a very large amount, too large to have a negative opinion of later start times for high schoolers. If you read his entire article, you may think it sounds like he does have a negative opinion of later start times. It is only like this because that is what he chooses to focus on, the negative, or the opposing side of the
Web. 8 Jan. 2018. McKeever, Pamela Malaspina, and Linda Clark. " Delayed High School Start Times Later Than 8:30 Am And Impact On Graduation Rates And Attendance Rates.
Should School Start Later? Will it actually be a huge advantage for students to attend school later in the day? This has been a rising argument over the years, and the health of teens, because of their increased tiredness has been an increasing concern of parents, and teachers and supervisors. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has been urging schools to start at later times such as 8:30 to ensure that students get adequate amounts of sleep every night (Source 2).
Later School Start Times “‘I’ve gained an hour of sleep,’ she said. ‘I definitely feel a lot better. I find myself waking up around 7:30 without an alarm because it’s a natural time. It’s a great, great feeling.’” Says Lily Grey Rudges, a high school student in Seattle(At these schools, later start times get an A-plus for youths needing more sleep).
School should start a lot later because it can improve mental health and the well being of the students attending; it can increase overall attendance and grades; and it can recover a student's mood and ability. Parents, students and teachers often argue, with little evidence, about whether U.S. high schools begin too early in the morning. In the past three years, however, scientific studies have piled up, and they all lead to the same conclusion: a later start time improves learning, and the later the start, the better. When a student is forced to wake up earlier than required, it can cause stress and ruin someone's entire day. But, when you wake up later it not only improves your mood, but also your ability to perform well.
Now the strengths of our position include ,Not only will this help prevent car accidents, later start times improve better grades and overall health (according to University of Minnesota) A three year research project using data from more than 9000 students attending more than 8 schools in 3 states shows a rise in school attendance, test scores, and academic performance improved in math, english, science, and social studies with later start
It stated reasons of why school start times should be pushed back and it also stated reasons why it should not be pushed back. The reasons of why it should have outweighed the reasons of why it should not have. The main reason why it was said school start time should be later is because as teens they stay up later and while they are in school they are tired and sleep through class all year. More sleep could lessen depression, make grades become higher, makes the students have better focus, and prevent sleeping in class. In the article it was said that "Over time, sleep deprivation leads to serious consequences for academic achievement, social behavior, and the health and safety of our nation 's youth.
School days should start later for junior high and high school Students because it can cause problems for teens. Doctors have figured out during the ages 13-18; students bodies start to release a chemical in the brain that causes them not to able to go to sleep at times before eleven o’ clock. Which can cause a numerous problems with health which can effect students especially at school .They also found out during theses age groups they need nine to nine and a half hour of sleep to be able to function in school; 60% to 70% of teens in America suffer from Sleep deprivation which can cause heart disease, diabetes, strike, and heart failure ,ect.
A piece of evidence to support this is from “Support for Sleeping in? Half of parents favor later school start times for teens” by Mental Health Weekly Digest, it states,”Twenty-seven percent of parents said they would only support the later time if it didn 't impact school budgets…” That piece from Mental Health shows that for schools that are deciding on whether or not to start school later, this shows that they shouldn’t transition from an early starting school to a later starting school because they would be spending huge chunks of money that would be useful in other ways other than just being used for the school to start later. Since, school budgets are hard to maintain as a result of the vast majority of bills they need to pay, it would be best that they don’t spend another couple million dollars on transportation to school and possibly after school at a later time. If the schools could find an alternative way for the schools to start later without any financial issues and other consequences that could affect the students academically, then the twenty-seven percent of parents that dislike the start time change would reconsider and possibly approve of the change.
She cites a study that found that students who start school later have higher grades and test scores than those who start earlier. Additionally, students who get more sleep are more likely to be engaged in class and retain information better. By allowing students to get the sleep they need, schools can help them perform better academically and set them up for success in the future. Thirdly, Snyder provides examples of schools that have successfully implemented later start times and seen positive results.
Imagine the benefits of having later start times for high school students. This controversial subject has been discussed by professionals over the past few years, some argue the start times are too early for teens while others tend to disagree. High school students should have later start times because it benefits their grades, their amount of sleep, and also provides advantages for the parents and School Board. By delaying the start times of the school, studies have shown improvements in grades and performance in teens. A study done by the University of Minnesota shows that by setting back start times for school showed an increase in grades 10th-12th.
So, they can improve the odds of adolescents getting sufficient sleep so they can thrive both physically and academically. I agree with this source, starting schools later could enhance student’s school performance academically and athletically. Starting school too early are preventing many teenagers from getting the sleep they need to start off their day. I aim to using this this source to support my claim as to why students need more sleep and how it would affect them throughout the school day. This will benefit my essay by forward explaining why school should start later in the morning and why doing this will be better for the students’
In the article “The Pros and Cons of Starting School Later,” the author said, “Most districts already have staggered start times for the schools and they report that delaying the high school start time would have a domino effect on all the schools that could pose a logistical nightmare” (Morin). A later school start time affects everyone and creates problems that may lead to a complete change in all school start times. According to USA Today, many districts with later school start times have flipped the pickup times for elementary school and high schools, which allows high school students to receive more sleep and younger students, who generally wake up earlier, to go to school sooner (The Editorial Board). Although a flipped bus schedule, benefits the students in the morning, it creates problems for students in the afternoon. Many parents do not come home until late at night, meaning younger students who come earlier from school are not supervised and properly taken care of.
I feel that school should start later in the day. In my next few paragraphs I will talk about, the acceptable things about starting school later in the day and the crummy parts about starting school later in the day. Starting school later in the day could help with test scores, seep, and absentees. Kids with more rest can think better since their minds are not so focused on sleep, and they more focused on the work that they need to do which would help with tests. If kids receive more sleep their bodies could fight off more diseases and bacteria.
Waking up early affects teenagers’ social life, mentality, physical being, and academic career. A study has proven that lack of sleep will affect a teenagers’ life in a negative way, “Overtime, not obtaining enough sleep can hurt student’s healthy, safety, social life, and school career.” (National Sleep foundation 1) Due to teenagers naturally not being able to fall asleep till later in the night and forcing students to wake up severely early in the morning for school, they are exhausted. A recent study shows that students are tired throughout their school day, 60% of children under 18 say that they are tired throughout the day (National Sleep Foundation 1)
School Start Times: Waking Up to the Truth Imagine staying up until the wee hours of the morning to finish the homework that had been accumulated during the day, only to have to get up a few hours later to catch the school bus, knowing that succeeding in class the next day would be short of a miracle. For many students, this scenario is not only feared but a reality they must face. The American Academy of Pediatrics states, “About 90% of high-school-aged adolescents get insufficient sleep on school nights…”(“Early