Law In Case 137 Sexism
Law as envisioned when it is written is different from how it is practiced. According to Ngaire Naffine as discussed by Elizabeth Comack and Gillian Balfour there is an official version of the law in which, ‘“the legal world would have us believe about itself – […] that it is an impartial, neutral, and objective system for resolving social conflict”’ (Comack& Balfour, 2004, 16). This version of the law in my opinion is idealistic. I would argue instead that the law with its illusion of being impartial, neutral, and objective is actually steeped in sexism, and homophobia. This paper will demonstrate that the official version of law hides homophobia and sexism within institutions that create and enforce laws.
In order to understand how the law
…show more content…
she was sentenced to 20 months in prison (Comack, 2004, p.38). In this example this woman’s gender becomes the center to her trial. This is demonstrated through the language of the Crown, complainant, and a second bouncer who testified. The complainant told the court “I got stabbed, the bitch stabbed me” she was then called “super- female,” accused of being “strung up on heroin or something” the crown explained to the jury “despite her size [she] is capable of causing great injury” (Comack, 2004, 39) “the force which was used to restrain her (five kicks in the back with steel toed boots while she laid on the ground) is evidence of the extent of her rage (Comack, 2004, 39). She is portrayed to the jury as a violent woman which is a common judgement for any woman who commits a violent crime to an extent (Comack, 2004, 39). The language used to describe the woman in this case focused on how she breaks away from society’s definition of a what a woman is. Which goes against the idea that law is to be disconnected from the social context as the official version of the law tells us. As a result, this fails to reflect the impartiality of the official version of law. As women who appear before a court with violent charges are already pre-judged as cruel, calculating, and cold hearted
Colored Amazons Rhetorical Analysis
164 Words | 1 PagesShe does so with court documents and newspaper articles concerning these female criminals. Of course, these documents are biased, but Kali contends with that. The fact is what these women did and the language society expressed those crimes through have deep meaning: why specific words were chosen over others and such.
Cyntoia Brown Case
767 Words | 4 PagesThe case of Cyntoia Brown is about an innocent victim, who had been punished for finding the courage to fight against the ones who had hurt her. Ultimately, this case is the greatest injustice act against a person ever yet. Her whole life, she had been facing abuse and inequity. She was only 16 when she has murdered Johnny Allen in 2004, and is now serving a life sentence, with an eligible parole on her 69th birthday. What the jury hasn’t been told about is that Cyntoia has been repeatedly drugged and physically and sexually
GLBTI
520 Words | 3 PagesWith this law, individuals can not be treated based on their sexuality, however, there is still a chance that they may experience harassment or discrimination within the workforce/place. Safety and Security There is sill a huge issue about keeping individuals in the GLBTI community away from emotional or physical violence. As a result of their sexual orientation, there is a high number of violence towards gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and intersex communities. They are still involved in hate-crimes whether is verbal abuse, or threatening emails/texts/messages.
Analysis Of Alchemy Of Race And Rights By Patricia Williams
1093 Words | 5 PagesThe piece also critically analyzes legal concepts and language as well as how those could be used to challenge or reinforce oppressive systems. In the book, she concludes that race and gender are very closely linked and connected; that this is due to societal norms and legal concepts and language. She explains how the law is significantly shaped by social context and isn’t inherently objective or neutral. As such, the law needs to be reformed but this is only possible and effective if the society is reformed as well. The last key concept she expresses is that of the importance of subject position; the way by which one’s experiences shape their view and understanding of
Examples Of Gender Disparity In Criminal Sentencing
348 Words | 2 PagesI. Gender Disparity Guidelines and Data In the context of gender disparity in criminal sentencing, some may think that having said that criminal courts are more lenient on women is just one’s opinion. In fact, a lot of researches and data suggest that there is a strong different in gender in the sentencing outcomes. Men are sentenced to longer prison terms than women. Men are 42% more likely to be sentenced to prison.
Declaration Of Independence Dbq Essay
656 Words | 3 PagesA brochure for “Reminder Day” expressed that homosexuals were often not treated as equals and that the Federal, state and local governments have shown bias towards these individuals. Although some religions would perceive homosexuality as a sin, the individuals are still human and should be given the same opportunities as the rest of the population. In the past, the Declaration of Independence promised natural rights for all men, but some rights were not realized for minority groups. Over time, parts of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution were revoked and amended so that in today’s world, all “men”, including women and minority groups, all have the same rights.
Incarcerated Women In Erin George's A Woman Doing Life
526 Words | 3 PagesAs she was a middle class mom, who was arrested and charged with her husband’s brother, she consciously did not mention her crime because this may divert the attention of readers and they may start focusing on other details that are rather unimportant. Another reason for not discussing her own circumstances may be that it may make the opinion of readers biased towards her. So whether she was innocent or not, but her purpose of writing was to focus on the lives of those women who are forgotten by society as well the policy makers. Erin George made a fair attempt to make higher officials think about improvements in correctional system for women and highlighted the areas which need many improvements and can be improved if higher authorities consider them
Anti-Discriminatory Practice
476 Words | 2 PagesThe impact of a national policy initiative that promotes anti-discriminatory is the Age Discrimination Act 2006 and since this act was passed, it has been unlawful for employers and others to discriminate against a person on the basic of his/her age. This applies to jobs, promotion, training and employment. The difficulties that may arise when implementing anti-discriminatory practice in health and social care settings, which could be that someone could try and override the national initiatives as they feel their own personal issues which could be homophobia and they need to be more educated to know what is the right way to deal with it and that way it will be dealt
Why DD NOT WE Knew By Basil Borutski
814 Words | 4 PagesOn September 22, 2015, three women, Anastasia Kuzyk, Nathalie Warmerdam and Carol Culleton were killed by Basil Borutski in one day. Through this film, it reveals the harm caused to women by the tendency of domestic violence. The Canadian judicial system should pay attention to this and re-regulate such phenomena. The film reflects three situations in the Canadian justice system about female violence: biological
Gender Disparities In The Criminal Justice System
1377 Words | 6 PagesThere are many indicators of the huge impact in disparities in sentencing women as compared to men and more so when it revolves around minorities ( race and class). Though there are lower crime rates among women as compared to men, there are significant disparities which tend to show favouritism to women. Research has shown that men get 63 per cent longer custodial sentences than women. In addition, it is twice more likely to have women get non custodial sentences even after conviction. However, as mentioned the disparities are more profound when issues of race and class are intertwined in the sentencing.
The Use Of Language In Sexual Assault Law
452 Words | 2 PagesSexual assault laws have been amended and created over time to ensure the criminal justice system remains sensitive to the tribulations involved in rape trials for the victim. However, the connotative capacity of language used in evidentiary testimonies in rape trials can defeat the purpose of these reforms as ‘language is not merely a means of putting forth evidence in a case, but it in fact transforms the nature of evidence itself, thus influencing the outcome of the case’ (Maheshwari 2014:1). As theorised by Bourdieu (1982) symbolic power as ‘the power to create reality through language’ (Matoesian 1995:38) is successfully employed in rape trials to instil patriarchal and legal domination over the victim. The use of language in courtroom
Social Injustices In Susan Glaspell's A Jury Of Her Peers
935 Words | 4 PagesThroughout “A Jury of Her Peers” by Susan Glaspell a noticeable power struggle between the women and the men occurs. “A Jury of Her Peers” exposes the social injustices that women faced during the turn of the century. In the story Mrs. Wright lashes out against her husband as result of built up anger and societies social pressure. In the essays “from Silent Justice in a Different Key: Glaspell’s ‘Trifles’” by Suzy Clarkson Holstein and “from The Case of the Battered Wife: Susan Glaspell’s Trifles and ‘A Jury of Her Peers’” by Lillian Schanfield embody the theme of social injustices among women. The social gaps between men and women in “A Jury of Her Peers” and “Trifles” helped drive the plot and allowed a unique outcome to be achieved.
Equal Treatment Hypothesis
1313 Words | 6 PagesGender should not depend on how people get treated differently from the opposite gender. If someone commits a crime regardless of their gender, they both should have to face the consequences regarding the crime they committed. A male should not be treated different than a female after committing a crime just because he is male and visa versa. Gender discrepancies play a role in everything in our world today. Whether it be in crime, sports, school, or even careers, males are typically punished much harder than females, and also get the most credit when it comes to sports, school, and their careers compared to females who excel in the exact same thing males do, even if the females are better than the males in any of those fields.
Barbarian Girls
1826 Words | 8 PagesThe fact that she not only is a woman, but is also disabled—blind with mutilated feet, she cannot see very well and has much difficulty getting around, makes her more in need of someone to depend on. By no means am I saying that she must rely on someone, but it is more than likely to her best advantage to do so in this particular situation. How does the complex relationship of the girl in the magistrate relate to women and economic rights and problems today? It relates to women today very strongly—financial and economic abuse is a very real and sadly uncommon occurrence. I am led to believe this because of observation and interviews via Facebook.
Persuasive Essay On Gender Equality
877 Words | 4 PagesIn our advanced 21st century, it is hard to imagine our society as anything short of perfect. After all, we have come a long way from our seafaring ancestors. However, the reality is that despite how we may sometimes avoid seeing it, our society is anything but perfect. A very prevalent issue today is that despite laws being set in place to enforce the equal treatment of men and women, women all over the world today still face poor treatment and discrimination. Because of how deep and long this problem has run, revising discriminatory laws may not abolish discrimination and legislating laws that endorse gender equality may not necessarily create equality.
More about Law In Case 137 Sexism
Colored Amazons Rhetorical Analysis
164 Words | 1 PagesCyntoia Brown Case
767 Words | 4 PagesGLBTI
520 Words | 3 PagesAnalysis Of Alchemy Of Race And Rights By Patricia Williams
1093 Words | 5 PagesExamples Of Gender Disparity In Criminal Sentencing
348 Words | 2 PagesDeclaration Of Independence Dbq Essay
656 Words | 3 PagesIncarcerated Women In Erin George's A Woman Doing Life
526 Words | 3 PagesAnti-Discriminatory Practice
476 Words | 2 PagesWhy DD NOT WE Knew By Basil Borutski
814 Words | 4 PagesGender Disparities In The Criminal Justice System
1377 Words | 6 PagesThe Use Of Language In Sexual Assault Law
452 Words | 2 PagesSocial Injustices In Susan Glaspell's A Jury Of Her Peers
935 Words | 4 PagesEqual Treatment Hypothesis
1313 Words | 6 PagesBarbarian Girls
1826 Words | 8 PagesPersuasive Essay On Gender Equality
877 Words | 4 Pages