Legalization of Prostitution: Annotated Bibliography Haltiwanger, J. (2017, October 09). “Why Legalizing Prostitution Would Make America Healthier, Wealthier, and Safer” Retrieved October 10, 2017, from https://www.elitedaily.com/news/ politics /why-america-should-legalize-prostitution/853340 This source, “Why Legalizing Prostitution Would Make America Healthier, Wealthier, and Safer” by J. Haltiwanger, explores how the legalization of prostitution would result in many benefits for America. This article states that making prostitution would reduce sex-trafficking, result in fewer sexual assaults and STDs for sex workers, and would produce a new source of legal tax revenue for the country. This article shows readers that this now taboo act
When sexual violence comes into play, it is a violation of Farley’s claim that free consent is body integrity. It means that a lack of consent would be do not touch, invade, or use one’s body (Farley 218). The ethical norm of free consent is probably the most controversial because it can be argued as both ethical and unethical based on the situation. In the case of human trafficking and pimping, where prostitutes have no say in the sexual violence enacted on them, prostitution can be argued as unethical. But on the other hand, if a prostitute has chosen this lifestyle willingly, it can be argued as ethical.
Martha Bussbaum argues that prostitution should be decriminalized for we everyone exchanges their body for money. Additionally, legalization of prostitution will help women who have few options. Bussbaum does not centralize her argument on morality but legality. Several professions and people have been stigmatized, stereotyped, or based off class. Opera singers, actors, and dancers have been regarded as public prostitution for illogical, emotional, and biased perceptions.
There is a vast difference in prostitution as a career choice and sex trafficking and many other situations in between. The sex trade has been happening for thousands of years. The Oxford Dictionary describes the sex trade as "the sex industry, specifically the business of prostitution" (Oxford Dictionary) and prostitution "the practice or occupation of engaging in sexual activity for payment" (Oxford Dictionary). Unlike prostitution, sex trafficking is described as "the action or practice of illegally transporting people from one country or area to another for the purpose of sexual exploitation" (Oxford Dictionary). While these two different issues are comparable, they remain different.
Marx’s theory of commodity fetishism defines the abstraction of a product’s true value with a “magical” presentation of product through advertising and institutional brand name policies. The dominance of the bourgeoisie/capitalist owner classes illustrates the power of commodity fetishism that promotes products to the proletariat/consumer in the marketplace. The fetish qualities of product detract from the physicality of the production process, which is then diluted through advertising promotions for the unwary consumer. This type of promotion is a great problem for consumers, since many of them may tricked into buying a faulty or unhealthy product through brand-name trickery. More so, consumers may become addicted to their desires in the purchasing of a product, which only alienates them from better products that may actually improve their lives.
This concludes how Cosby legitimately possessed drugs at the time with the intention to have sex with these women. The new source also provides reassurance to its readers because despite the Cosby case lacking evidence for Bill Cosby to be prosecuted, he still has a chance of facing serious consequences. According to the CNN article, “Bill Cosby won’t face prosecution for most of the rape allegations against him. But he could still face serious consequences” (1). This meaning, although Cosby will not be receiving prosecution for his crime, he is still prone to other types of punishments.
One example is Roy Olmstead, he was a Seattle Police Officer. When he learned of the opportunity to make profit by illegally transporting alcohol he took it. His business made much more than he would have made as a police officer. He also paid off the other officers so they would keep their mouths shut.” (6) Even some politicians aided the criminals, they would take bribes and stuff the ballot box or, put their money behind the candidate that the criminals wanted. In conclusion this amendment created three things, organized crime, less worker absenteeism which lead to less domestic violence which lead to less hospitalization from alcohol, and it created disrespect for the law.
This billion dollar illegal business has affected millions of lives across the globe. Many people, particularly women are victims of human trafficking. Due to fraud advertisements, they have traumatizing and horrific experiences. In “The Sex-Trafficking Victim Next Door,” Goldie Taylor discusses how in Atlanta, 17 year old Annika became a sex slave.
According to the owner of a group named Scarlet Hope that helps to bring women out of prostitution, Rachelle Starr, says that all of the women that she works with are from bad circumstances where they are told that they can go to their local strip club to make easy money to support their families. A lot of the women are trying to make ends meet and come from horrible backgrounds of abuse both sexually and mentally. The same thing occurs with those who are in the sex trafficking industry. Many are abducted individuals from broken backgrounds such as sexual abuse or foster care who are in need of someone to love and care for them. Their abductors take this chance to lure the women in by pretending to be a significant other that cares for them and will buy and supply them with goods and a place to stay.
The basic reasons for which society is against prostitution include the fact that it is seen as a dangerous business which encourages human trafficking and promotes the spread of STDs. But at a second glance into the depths of the subject, we find out that legalizing sex work would protect women from violence and abuse and would actually reduce the spread of STDs, also adding revenue for the government. In the context of this debate we should consider things from an open-minded perspective. It is very important that we understand that not everything we disapprove of must be necessarily also made illegal. For