ipl-logo

Marcia Lieberman's Criticism In Fairy Tales

1981 Words8 Pages

Furthermore, in the article, Joosen references, without analyzing the veracity of her claims, Marcia Lieberman, a feminist especially concerned with some of the patriarchal features - supposedly - common in all of the Grimms' tales. Joosen quotes Marcia Lieberman's essay "Some Day My Prince Will Come" emphasizing three of the most relevant points of criticism in fairy tales: "the so-called beauty contest" (132), "the typical constellation of characteristics in fairy-tales women" (132), and "marriage as the ultimate reward for being beautiful" (133). Nonetheless, Lieberman's critique, so extensively used by Joosen, only concerns itself with a narrow spectrum of the Grimms' tales. In fact, part of the stories collected by the two German brothers …show more content…

For example, when the sorcerer kidnaps the girls, he just "touches [the girls] and [they] jump into his basket" (Grimms 193). The lack of articulated spells is even more blatant when the third sister finds her two siblings chopped to pieces and she brings them back to life solely by "gathering all their body parts and put[ting] them in their proper places" (Grimms 194). Therefore, even though Tatar affirms that "the spell, curses and charms in the Grimms' collections are the most obvious example of the power of language" (Tatar 60), "Fitcher's bird" shows how even traditional fairy tales recurrently lack spells that "create a real physical change" (Tatar …show more content…

Indeed, the ending of the story is based on the three girls concocting their escape through their intelligence and the cleverness of their words. For example, the two sisters - after being saved by the third girl, who also convinced the wizard to carry on his back a basket full of gold in addition to the other two sisters - repeat twice, from their hiding spot "I'm looking out my little window and I see that you're resting. Get a move on." (Grimms 195) in order to prevent the wicked sorcerer from resting. Similarly, the third sister - while dressed as Fitcher's bird - deceives her bridegroom and the guests by replaying twice the same conversation - which is, arguably, the most meaningful example of the power of language in the

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Cinderella By Grimm Brothers

    1631 Words  | 7 Pages

    In “Cinderella”, by the Grimm Brothers, the authors utilize a multitude of fairy tale genre conventions such as frequent usage of rhetorical devices, magical creatures, and the classic “Happy Ever After” fairy tale ending, to emphasize the importance of genuineness and the dangers of pursuing superficiality. The authors use several rhetorical devices such as symbolism and juxtaposition

    Read More

  • Examples Of Figurative Language In Dust Tracks On A Road

    244 Words  | 1 Pages

    For example, she uses personification when she says, “Her heart must have stood still when she saw the sow in there, because hogs have been known to eat human flesh”. (Paragraph 3) The phrase, “heart must have

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Briar Rose And Night

    857 Words  | 4 Pages

    On whether you are Rumplestiltskin or the Queen.” (B pg 106). This quote compared the Jewish people and the Nazis to the fairy tale of Rumpelstiltskin and the Queen. The comparison is inappropriate because something as serious as the Holocaust should not even come close to something as light as a fairy

    Read More

  • Grimm's Fairy Tales: A Literary Analysis

    740 Words  | 3 Pages

    “The Hero’s Journey”, Grimm’s Fairy Tales he talked about a little story name:Snow-White and Rose-Red. Well in the story all they showed about was that if they had some things to do all around them, but as in the story what on Snow-White would always do to Rose-Red and to show that there is a point where they would had some issues, “He held on to all the reeds and rushes, but it was of a little good,and he was forced to movements of the fish,and was in urgent danger to being dragged into the water.” So in Snow-White and Rose-Red, Grimm’s Fairy Tales,uses one aspect,to define, strengthen, and to illustrate the elements of work...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Brothers Grimm: Fitcher's Bird

    184 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Brothers Grimm, Fitcher’s Bird is told in a third person’s point of view and a past tense and an active voice. The characters in the story does not have names or an specific characteristics, but only have a title of what they are. Which the characters is just a she or he doing their things. The story have long sentences because majority of Brother’s grimm sentences are conjunction and compound complex sentences.

    Read More

  • Feminism In A White Heron

    1276 Words  | 6 Pages

    Most of the children read about many fairy tales, especially Snow Whites, Sleeping beauty, and Cinderella when they grew up. It is a surprising fact that to discover a hidden, unexpected political intention in the simple plot of fairy tales. That is a feminization of woman. The fairy tale world suggests a male-centered patriarchy as an ideal basic society and impliedly imply that man and woman need to have a proper attitude toward this opinion. However, Jewett’s A White Heron describes a new perspective of fairy tale’s plot.

    Read More

  • The Princess Paradox Ponniewozik Analysis

    684 Words  | 3 Pages

    He states that rather than believing they must solely prove their independence girls recognize that they can “have the girly dream of glass slippers and true love, these films say, as well as the womanly ideal of self-determination and independence” (Poniewozik 324). Poniewozik explains how a previous generation of women simply aspired to have the ability to do anything a man could. In this new generation, however, he states that choosing the fairytale ending does not debase a woman (Poniewozik 324). A quote from Marlo Thomas, a feminist author, included in the article says, “What women have tried to achieve for other women is choice in every step of their lives” (Poniewozik 324) Through including specific movies, such as Ella Enchanted and The Prince & Me, in which princesshood and feminism blend together to form empowered women who choose to be princesses, the author of this article begins gathering his support for the claim that girls have been affected by this recent transformation in the movie-making

    Read More

  • The Princess Bride Movie And Book Comparison Essay

    710 Words  | 3 Pages

    The fantasy is about Buttercup, a milkmaid, and Westley, a farm boy, who fall in love and have to face many obstacles. The story mainly develops the themes of true love and revenge. However, in the book, The Princess Bride by William Goldman, the story develops the theme of revenge and true love in more depth compared to the movie. First of all, the book provides a detailed past of each main character which makes the reader sympathize with them. For example, in the book, the author has dedicated four to five pages to understand Inigo’s and Fezzik’s past.

    Read More

  • Fairy Tale Vs. Perrault's The Sleeping Beauty In The Wood

    1025 Words  | 5 Pages

    In Margaret Atwood’s poem “There Was Once”, Atwood uses irony to point out the societal problems within the genre of fairy tales. Charles Perrault, the author of the short story “The Sleeping Beauty in the Wood”, writes about fantastic creatures, magic, and love, following the generic conventions of fairy tales. When compared to Perrault’s short story “The Sleeping Beauty in the Wood”, Atwood’s poem both compliments and contrasts Perrault’s. These two texts, although similar, offer different views on the genre of fairy tales. Margaret Atwood’s satirical poem, “There Was Once”, aims to disrupt the generic conventions of a traditional fairy tale.

    Read More

  • Ruth Panttaja Cinderella Not So Morally Superior Analysis

    922 Words  | 4 Pages

    Conner Brosmer ACP Comp. Mr. Albonetti 02/21/18 “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior” Critique Essay Fairy tales indicate to entertain as well as provide an underlying moral lesson to its’ readers. In the tale of Cinderella, the lesson is that if you keep a positive attitude you can overcome any obstacles and achieve your dreams.

    Read More

  • The Morality Of Fairy Tales In The Black Cow

    1690 Words  | 7 Pages

    Many families have many traditions, but one tradition that is common among all households is that they read fairy tales to their children right before they put them to sleep. They do this to fill their minds with good positive thoughts and leave them with something to think about. Religion dictates the characteristics of familiar fairy tales as religion provides a moral and ethical framework for having a good life, an ideal goal parents want their children to have. On the whole, fairy tales are constantly changed to adhere to cultural or social beliefs that are deemed important by diverse people in a community.

    Read More

  • Symbolism In Ashputtle

    597 Words  | 3 Pages

    Short Story Essay When I was younger, fairy tales were always my favorite movies to watch. From Cinderella to Snow White, I was glued to my TV screen watching them all day. As I have gotten older I have realized that there are certain patterns that show up in every short story. In “Cupid and Psyche” and “Ashputtle” one narrative pattern shown is things that come in threes.

    Read More

  • Paper Bag Princess Stereotypes

    494 Words  | 2 Pages

    Princesses’ in Disney movies are tied down to a recurring theme: the princess that must be saved from the evil woman by the charming prince. A significant contrast to the usually weak and easily persuaded figure of the father. Even though the women are portrayed as weak, nobody stops to think how strong they have to be to carry the responsibility of an entire household on her shoulder, while the men always seem to be traveling or ill. Fairytales are based on a patriarchal way of thinking and as time passes by, it’s proven to be detrimental to society Women and men are constantly being bound to a series of stereotypes.

    Read More

  • Gender Stereotypes In Disney's Cinderella

    1880 Words  | 8 Pages

    Similarly, Disney’s Cinderella presents a cruel and ambitious stepmother who attempts to arrange marriages for her ugly, foolish, and somewhat comical daughters. In the film, we see their miserable attempt to sing opera, (supposedly in order to appear more feminine) as the mother proudly oversees. In one of the last scenes, she desperately urges them to make the glass slipper fit, and while she doesn’t downright tell them to cut off their toes or heels as in the original (Grimm 119), the comic scene in itself seems to have a subtle layer of tragedy. While these examples prove that female ugliness in fairy tales and their adaptations corresponds to wickedness, and the latter is equivalent to ill-temper, the question of female independence still

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis: The Brothers Grimm

    1880 Words  | 8 Pages

    The Brothers Grimm, Cinderella - Critical Analysis Description: This dark version of the many original Cinderella stories is by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, better known as the Grimm brothers. Cinderella is about a young girl who sadly loses her mother due to some kind of sickness, her father marries a woman who has two daughters, shortly after her mother’s death. The daughters are referred to as Cinderella’s “false sisters” due to their evil and wicked tactics during the story and also because they are not related to her by blood. Her father gets completely brainwashed by the stepmother and begins to treat his own daughter the same way they do, like a pest.

    Read More

More about Marcia Lieberman's Criticism In Fairy Tales

Open Document