ipl-logo

Giovani And Lusanna Analysis

1284 Words6 Pages

Although the story of Giovani & Lusanna takes place over half a millennium ago, human interaction and relationships has only evolved marginally. This story escorts the reader through the court case of Giovanni & Lusanna’s marriage dispute, but during this story the witnesses and their descriptions paint an image of the social structure of Italy during the early modern period. The most vivid descriptions presented by witnesses are that of class relations, marriage, and social traditions. One core element of this case is that witnesses appeared to be highly biased in their testimonies toward their individual party, but it is in the details of their stories that most likely present an honest representation of Florence during the Renaissance. Class interactions are a key foundation to the Giovani & Lusanna story; their inherent separation in class contributes to the separation and ultimate course between the couple. Yet, it is not just this couple that faces class tensions on a regular basis because class separation is ingrained into Florentine society in this period. Often those in the lower classes only interacted with aristocrats during “special occasions, baptismal feasts, or …show more content…

The court case is inherently hypocritical because Lusanna is trying to present her legitimacy in societal practices and force Giovanni to continue in their marriage, while their marriage is based on an affair. The witnesses define this dynamic, while presenting the couple’s societally ambiguous interaction regarding class relations, marital practices, and social standards. Oddly enough, this story could be placed into modern day and would continue to fit rather well, pointing to the similarities in social traditions and human nature even over 500 years

Show More
Related

  • Friar To Blame For The Death Of Romeo And Juliet Research Paper

    421 Words  | 2 Pages

    The tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare’s renowned play, frustrated countless audience members over the years. Although the ending could have been avoided by any means, there is one person that makes sure it ends tragically. Friar Lawerence, although trying to help the two houses, only exacerbates the situation by marrying the two. However, the Friar can’t take all of the blame. The parents of Romeo and Juliet play a big role in ensuring the play ends tragically.

    Read More

  • Giovanni And Lusanna Love And Marriage In Renaissance Florence

    1366 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the story of Giovanni and Lusanna Love and Marriage in Renaissance Florence written and researched by Gene Brucker, Lusanna di Benneto a widow of the artisanal class, has taken her alleged husband Giovanni to court, due to their marriage’s circumstance. The story starts out with Lusanna being married to another man named Andrea Nucci who eventually grew interest in the wealthy young Giovanni who came from a noble social class. As time wore on they eventually fell in love with one another and enjoyed all of its pleasures for a couple of years. It was later claimed by Lusanna that Giovanni had promised to marry her in the event of her husband’s death.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Gene Brucker's Court Case

    762 Words  | 4 Pages

    Gene Brucker offers insight into the lives and minds of 15th century Italy through a court case about Giovanni and Lusanna’s involving the legality of their marriage. He utilized several primary sources to provide a descriptive narrative of this case. Even though Brucker used primary sources, primarily notarial sources, these show clear evidence of bias, and in turn these biases are reflected in his work. To begin with, Brucker’s primary material falls into the legal category, notarial sources, from Ser Filippo Mazzaei. Although these legal works supply the evidence and court battle that occurred, these don’t provide a clear voice to the defendant, Giovanni, nor the plaintiff, Lusanna.

    Read More

  • How Does Gene Brucker Respond To Love And Marriage In Renaissance Europe?

    1654 Words  | 7 Pages

    In the book, Love and Marriage in Renaissance Europe, Giovanni and Lusanna, written by Gene Brucker, a historian who researched and studied about love and marriage during the Renaissance time period, analysis how social classes in marriage are defined by wealth. He also explains the treatment of men that has an upper class status and how bribery is utilized in the decision making process. Brucker presents an account of a marriage agreement that took place according to Lusanna, but Giovanni denied those claims. The city of Florence was ruled by the Medici family for generations, which held an enormous amount of power beginning with Cosimo, who “dispensed favors to his allies, clients, and creatures in the form of offices, loans, remission

    Read More

  • Martyrdom Of Saints Perpetua Analysis

    285 Words  | 2 Pages

    The values and traditions that women were expected to hold changed extravagantly in the 700 years between the deaths of Lucretia and Perpetua. Through their respective documents, “Rape of Lucretia,” and “The Martyrdom of Saints Perpetua and Felicitas,” we can see the change of ideals in the form of expecting Roman women to do chores and stay at home, while the Roman/Christian women are expected to hold their faith and Christian values dear. Both of them are portrayed in different light, but in the end it is done to argue for a cause. Lucretia is portrayed as a humble individual who holds honor of the family higher than herself. Perpetua is demonstrated as a stubborn individual who won't turn her back on her faith, even for her family.

    Read More

  • Women In Giovanni And Lusanna By Gene Brucker

    1071 Words  | 5 Pages

    The charges against her were eventually dropped; but even though all evidence concludes they were married, Giovanni still prolonged the case. Lusanna won because the court identified their marriage as valid, and found Giovanni guilty for breaking the law with his second marriage. But, because of his status he was only fined to pay for the court case’s fees and 1,000 florins. Lusanna’s witnesses were not respected enough by society to have a valid and truthful opinion.

    Read More

  • Romeo And Juliet Dbq Analysis

    700 Words  | 3 Pages

    Romeo and Juliet have shown that they have intense love for each other, that becomes apparent when we see that they would die to be with each other. This couple shows and opens the eyes of their dearest ones to stop fighting with one another and open their hearts to one another. In the beginning of the story we are introduced to “two households both alike in dignity.” (document A), The Montagues and the Capulets.

    Read More

  • The Renaissance James Corrick Chapter Summaries

    960 Words  | 4 Pages

    In The Renaissance James A. Corrick introduces the reader about the period of time when a cultural movement was introduced first in Italy and marked the rebirth of old Greek and Roman culture and society. This led to the advancement in science, art, technology, education, economics, and politics. The Renaissance began in Italy in the 1300s, throughout much of Europe during the next three hundred years. The author’s purpose is to inform and entertain the reader about the amazing accomplishments that many people achieved during this period of time. He is not refuting or showing the reader a specific viewpoint, but he produces a straightforward factual explanation about the past.

    Read More

  • Love And Marriage In Renaissance Florence By Gene Brucker

    1783 Words  | 8 Pages

    The narrative questions preconceived notions about how men and women behave while examining gender, power, and social standards. Brucker explores the complexities of gender interactions in historical and political contexts. Lusanna's unorthodox conduct, which was not following cultural standards, portrayed a suboptimal reputation that reinforced Giovanni's accusations of her chastity and alleged seduction to coerce him into marriage. In Giovanni's testimony, Lusanna's neighbors attested to several male visitors during her marriage. The allegations have merit considering Lusanna's relationship with Giovanni began while she was married, which conflicts with the notion and her claims of chastity.

    Read More

  • Castiglione: Are We Courtiers And Ladies?

    558 Words  | 3 Pages

    Are We Courtiers and Ladies? Castiglione was a polished courtier that immersed from the surroundings of Italian nobility. Living and breathing the life of a courtier, Castiglione wrote an etiquette guideline for both men and women in hopes of grooming others in the likeness of a proper lady or courtier. The Book of a Courtier distinguished characteristics that both sexes were to acquire and attain. In this handbook, Castiglione states that men should be rugged, protective, and soldier-like; yet possess qualities of scholar and well-manner.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes: The Competition Between Male Aristocrats

    168 Words  | 1 Pages

    For a male aristocrat, court life revolved around the public sphere. Being bound to this sphere meant he frequently attended court to maintain and enhance his status. According to scholars, as active members of the court, many male aristocrats competed fiercely for status and prestige because their social, political, and economic life depended on the position they occupied in the highly rigid hierarchy (Morris, 1964; McCullough, 1999; Hurst, 2007a). This competition that ensued between male aristocrats was important because they developed an acute sensitivity towards their status at court. Within this status-conscious society, in particular, a male aristocrat was continuously under the gaze of his peers which required them to display qualities

    Read More

  • Treatment Of Women In Medieval Times Essay

    2250 Words  | 9 Pages

    Women of the Medieval Times Women have always had a significant role in history even though they were treated horrible in most cases. During the Medieval Times was really the first time women were allowed to become more than just a house wife. The fight for equality has always been a struggle and even in today’s society is still an ongoing battle. Although women of lower and middle class were treated poorly in the Medieval Times, some powerful women held great responsibility and were looked up too by both men and children; despite being admired, “men were thought to be not only physically stronger but more emotionally stable, more intelligent, and morally less feeble” (Hopkins 5). “The position of women in the Medieval Society was greatly influenced by the views of the Roman Catholic Church” (Heeve).

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Marriage In Romeo And Juliet

    746 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet, the young couple gets married when Juliet is fourteen years old. In the fifteen century, during Romeo and Juliet’s time, marriage at a young age was extremely common, whereas in modern times many people get married close to thirty. Age is not the only wedding custom that differs today. Unlike the fifteenth century, in today’s society people are able to marry anyone they choose, people marry for much different reasons, and what is expected from the couple’s families have changed. Romeo and Juliet shows that marriage in the fifteenth century is between a man and women, and must be approved by the two families coming together in matrimony.

    Read More

  • Did Women Have A Renaissance Essay

    653 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the essay, "Did Women have a Renaissance?”, Joan Kelly-Gadol, presents a feminist insight into women's role in society during the Renaissance and how women did not have a Renaissance. While Margaret L. King, who wrote, “Women and High Power”, offers the roles of women and learning from 1300-1800 and argues that women did . The question of, “did women benefit from the Renaissance?”, is an extremely loaded question. Like every argument or question there are two sides to every story. One way, like Margaret L. King to look at this argument is that women experienced the Renaissance just like men did.

    Read More

  • Feud In Romeo And Juliet

    1281 Words  | 6 Pages

    The Feud in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet The aim of this essay is to define the nature of the feud in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet and to discuss its function in the dramatic development of the play. The conflict between the families of Montagues and Capuletes is presented as the outcome of an ultimate expression of patriarchal society in Verona which promotes virility at any cost and obscene sexual innuendo targeting women. However, the love of Romeo and Juliet comes to prove the young people’s indifference towards the feud but at the same time the patriarchy’s tremendous power over them. Finally, the family’s feud combined with the contribution of fate makes the timing of events such, that a tragic resolution cannot be prevented.

    Read More

More about Giovani And Lusanna Analysis

Open Document