Lamb to the Slaughter Essay
Written By: Hiba and Misha
The punishment for homicide against individuals with mental disorders and illnesses varies in different places; sometimes the case gets excused because they are incapable of thinking at the moment, or they are sent to jail or a rehab centre because they are not exempt from being criminally responsible. Mary Maloney killed her husband. This fact is clearly shown in the story "Lamb to the Slaughter." This also means that Mary Maloney is guilty of murder. Mary had never planned to kill her husband, but the piece of unknown information that her husband, Patrick, gave her prior to the murder was just a big trigger for rage, which does not exempt her from being responsible for her husband's
…show more content…
In this case, Mary didn't do it for herself; she was six months pregnant, and if she were caught, she would have to give birth while in custody. After Mary kills her husband, the story reads, "All right, she tells herself. So I’ve killed him" (Dahl, 3). There is clear proof from the quote that Mary Maloney killed her husband and has no remorse for doing so. Mary knew exactly what she did to him, which means she was completely sane while this scene took place. A big reason why she killed her husband was probably because the unknown news that he told her would affect their future child. Right after the whole incident happened, she took the evidence of the leg of lamb and began to cook it in the oven, so it didn't look like a relevant murder weapon but rather just another meal. This would mean that the police would not be able to find any evidence or possibilities if she murdered Patrick Maloney. She also lied to the police while dealing with Sam, the grocer, to make herself an alibi. She made sure to practice acting to fool Sam and have a witness in her favour, which then convinced the police officers that she had an alibi and that she was still devoted to and loved Patrick. She had this whole strategy prepared that would work to her advantage. Mary knew what she was doing when she was covering up this …show more content…
She committed this murder for the safety and wellness of her baby, which does not exempt her from being criminally responsible for homicide. It is also proven that Mary Maloney wasn't insane, but she was angry. She also covered up her murder and showed no remorse or pity for her husband, who was seen as the most important person and male figure in her life. Patrick Maloney made a probable mistake but wanted to move forward with it. Mary didn't like the thought of that, so she sought instant revenge. But even if Mary was temporarily insane or mentally unstable, she shouldn't have the right to take someone's
Lamb to the Slaughter Mary Maloney’s actions were against the law. She killed a ma, only because he wanted to divorce her. She was definitely shocked and she had had a couple drinks, but in the end she was the one to kill him. She also sort of got the police officers to eat the murder weapon and that’s against the law. Right?
Upon returning to the Maloney residence she acted as a distraught wife who had just found her dead husband. Mary Maloney then continued to cook dinner after the officers arrived, she told them it would calm her down, when in reality she was cooking the murder weapon. Mary Maloney does not stop there, she then begs the officers at the scene to eat the leg of lamb, telling them it would be doing her a favor. “ ‘Please,” she begged.
Mary continued to exhibit behavioral problems from behind bars; there was a documented escape, which led to Mary capture three days later. This and many other of Mary's behavior problems lead to the suspicion that Mary have suffered from the same mental issues that plagued, her mother. Mary seemed to be screaming for attention in many ways. At school, she attempted to alert school tears to no avail. If there were a little more attention given to Mary's behavior and temper, the murders may have been
She will say anything to keep herself from being accused of witchcraft, such as naming others to get in trouble instead of herself “That she sometimes made a compact with Lucifer, and wrote her name in his black book with her blood.” (Miller 852). Fear has made Mary do things that got others in trouble, and she doesn’t take the blame for what she has
Mary Maloney is not guilty for the murder of Patrick Maloney. At around the time of Patrick’s murder, Mary was out at the store. Sam the worker at the grocery store stated that Mary was “Very cheerful, wanted to give Patrick a good supper, and it was impossible that she” could have been the one to murder Patrick. If Mary was getting food for the supper at the time of the murder, how could she have possibly been the one to have killed him. Mary was happy and cheerful, no one would be acting like that if they had just lost their spouse.
Of course not. I’m not agreeing that murder is okay, because it most definitely isn’t. In Mary’s defense, her husband whom she loved, was happily married to, and pregnant with their baby, came home and announced that he was leaving. I can’t blame her because she was overwhelmed. Mr. Maloney should have prepared her for his.
Instead of going to the police and turning herself in because she knew what she did was wrong, she decided to fabricate a lie and manipulate the police into believing it. If Mary Maloney was truly “just in shock” or “good at heart but made a bad decision” she would have turned herself in, not lied to the police, and to add more to my claim, just after killing Patrick she starts thinking about the “penalties” not what she had
First, let’s start with the prosecution witnesses. They called a neighbor, police officer, and professional psychiatrist. The neighbor was called to attest to Mary’s character and party life style. It helped show that she made bad decisions and had poor judgment at times, but it does not equate to murder. Not everyone who drinks kills their baby.
Mary Maloney 23 years married. Accused of killing her husband Mr. patrick. The particular reason for the crime was that he wanted to get divorce. He was murdered by a piece of lamb that could be extracted very easily later, in the most ideal manner. Additionally, Mary presented herself as the very last person who could have committed the crime.
After Mary slaughtered Patrick from this anger, caused by the truth of the affair and her pregnancy, she couldn’t deal with herself, so she left to get potatoes because of her reaction due to Patrick’s death. Though, when she came back to the murder scene she committed, she started to cry from realizing what she had done. Mary Maloney, is guilty of 2nd degree murder. The first piece of evidence that supports this claim is, Mary Maloney had been filled with anger from being told Patrick had an affair and from her pregnancy.
The opposing side of the argument may say Mary planned on the death of her husband though evidence says otherwise. When Mary went down to the freezer she “took hold of the first object she found” displaying how Mary didn’t deliberately grab a weapon to use on Patrick’s death and his actual killing was not clearly thought-out by Mary, proving diminished capacity and not murder. Mary Maloney deeply loved her husband and her child, through Patricks’ violence push her to her limits. No criminal intent was for sought when Mary’s state of mind obscurely went after Patrick. All in all Mary wasn’t in her right mind whyen all of this took place.
She had gone out to get groceries, and when she had come back, she saw her husband lying on the floor, dead. Mary Maloney had said “I was just out to get meat and vegetables, and when I came home I saw Patrick dead on the floor! I immediately called the police.” Detectives have not found the weapon used to kill yet.
Though a lot may disagree, Mary Maloney deserves some sympathy for killing her husband in Roald Dahl’s Lamb to the Slaughter. Mary Maloney deserves sympathy for killing her husband because, although murdering him would not have been the most reasonable way to deal with the betrayal of her husband Mr. Maloney was still a cold man. Patrick's brutal Diener is presented in the fact that Mary Maloney was six months pregnant and waiting for her husband to come home she states her favorite part of the day was to see him.
One may assume that she was not responsible for her actions. However, she did consciously try to cover up the murder, knowing that she would be blamed for it. She made the excuse that she went to the grocery for vegetables and found him dead when she came back. If she had confessed to being temporarily insane, she could’ve gotten away with her actions unharmed and unaccountable. She did try to hide it by calling the police in a sort of intense sadness, though.
What did they do? Mary didn 't know and she certainly wasn 't prepared to take a chance. ”So this means that Mary Maloney is a very ruthless person.