ipl-logo

Masculinity In Giovanni's Room By James Baldwin And Beebo Brinker

496 Words2 Pages

When one thinks about masculinity it is characteristically applied to males, and when it is applied to females it is not a complement. Both Giovanni’s Room by James Baldwin and Beebo Brinker by Ann Bannon toy with the idea of masculinity. The only difference in the way they use masculinity is the bodies they chose to apply them to. Baldwin chooses to apply masculinity to the typical man, and Bannon applies to a female character. Baldwin applies masculinity to the character of David, and by doing this it causes David to match the ideals of heteronormativity. David spends most of the novel trying to demonstrate his masculinity as a way to please his father: “all I want for David is that he grows up to be a man. And when I say a man, Ellen, I don’t mean a Sunday school teacher” (Baldwin 15). David is attempting to fulfill his father’s desires for him to be a man. In doing so he has to prove his …show more content…

She takes the ideals of masculinity and applies them to a female: “he tried to take her wicker case to carry it for her, but she pulled away, offended as if his offer were a comment on her ability to take care of herself” (Bannon location 67 in ebook). This is one of the first impressions we as the reader get of Beebo, and her masculinity. She refuses to play the role of the weak woman in distress instead she makes it clear that she wants to be seen as strong and power, both of which are seen as masculine traits. Beebo does not enjoy letting anyone perform any kind of masculinity over her either: “It evidently bothered her to let him perform the small masculine courtesies for her, as if they were an encroachment on her independence” (location 129). Beebo does not want to be seen as unable to take care of herself and this queers her, because she is not fitting into the role society has put in place for females. Beebo is not a feminine character and this causes society to view her as queer and out of the

Show More
Related

  • James Baldwin

    1362 Words  | 6 Pages

    Hate: The Life and Works of James Baldwin “I imagine that one of the reasons people cling to their hates so stubbornly is because they sense, once hate is gone, that they will be forced to deal with pain” (Baldwin, 2012/1955, p. 745). James Baldwin is one of the most thought inducing writers of his time. Marked by his experiences in the realms of racial, sexual, and religious struggles Baldwin’s life and works have opened the eyes of the American people, as well as many others, to these sensitive subjects that we have struggled with. James Arthur Baldwin was born James Arthur Jones in 1924, in Harlem, to Emma Berdis Jones.

    Read More

  • Sex And Temperament Analysis

    742 Words  | 3 Pages

    Critique of “Sex and Temperament” and “From Undoing Gender” Margaret Mead’s “Sex and Temperament” is an essay to explain how there are differences between genders everywhere but they are not the same throughout the world. While Judith Butler’s excerpt from “Undoing Gender” is about the existence of gender normalities effects on how people are viewed in society. These two essays are very similar because of the similar presentations of ideas and the similar ideas of the two women. I chose to compare these two because of the similarity in their topics and how they presented them. Such as the ideas of gender differences, their research is based on analysis of different situations , and the effect the idea of gender norms have on society and they way we view others.

    Read More

  • Masculinity In Macbeth And The Mask You Live In

    1300 Words  | 6 Pages

    Masculinity has been a heated debated topic over the past years. Not just america or europe, but our whole society. Men tend to think that entering manhood is a good thing, but most don’t know it can be just as detrimental to our society. Men have certain characteristic when it concerns to masculinity and when doing so it can have a range of effects. So, how do men identify themselves masculine and how do they define themselves that way?

    Read More

  • The Altar Of The Family Analysis

    1242 Words  | 5 Pages

    “At Seventeen” and “The altar of the family” are constructed to make you agree that being masculine doesn’t require conforming to male stereotypes. Both authors use characterisation, point of view, descriptive language and conflict to convey this opinion. Characterisation in both texts help push the idea that manhood isn’t just about being strong, emotionless and almost robot like. David from The Altar of the Family completely flips masculinity on its head by being a “damn grown boy playing with dolls” this quote tells us that David is different than his normal male counterpart but also asks the reader the question of what defines manhood and if playing with dolls is a non-masculine thing for a male to do. David also is insulted

    Read More

  • Masculinity In Busby Berkeley's Gold Diggers

    288 Words  | 2 Pages

    The individuality of man is affected by the economic crisis and changes the way how men as a whole view themselves. Busby Berkeley’s Gold Diggers of 1933 shows how men’s economic difficulties deeply affected their masculinity by exposing the real “fall” of the man (Rubin 75). The “My Forgotten Man” number shows this by presenting the passive nature of the men throughout the number overall and emitting a reaction from the women. Notice the first stanza of the number sung by Joan Blondell: “I don’t know if he deserves a bit of sympathy, forget your sympathy, he’s all right with me….. I was satisfied to drift along from day to day, till they came and took my man away”; it exemplifies the emotional toll the Depression took on their masculine temperament,

    Read More

  • Exemp 3.07 Week 1 Discussion 1

    1215 Words  | 5 Pages

    According to Judith Butler, masculinity comes from sports (football) and other culturally influenced activities. She states that biologically a man is a man, however a man is taught how to act through activities. For example, Butler used football saying “teaches men, both young and old, how to act like men, and women, both young and old, what to expect from them” (McBride 130).

    Read More

  • Jackie Robinson's Use Of Gender Roles In The Movie 42

    254 Words  | 2 Pages

    This is an example of gender roles because he wants to be seen as a strong masculine

    Read More

  • A Letter To My Nephew James Baldwin Analysis

    839 Words  | 4 Pages

    In A Letter to My Nephew, James Baldwin, the now deceased critically acclaimed writer, pens a message to his nephew, also named James. This letter is meant to serve as a caution to him of the harsh realities of being black in the United States. With Baldwin 's rare usage of his nephew 's name in the writing, the letter does not only serve as a letter to his relative, but as a message to black youth that is still needed today. Baldwin wrote this letter at a time where his nephew was going through adolescence, a period where one leaves childhood and inches closer and closer to becoming an adult.

    Read More

  • Internalized Homophobia In Giovanni's Room

    1236 Words  | 5 Pages

    In “James Baldwin’s Giovanni’s Room: Expatriation, ‘Racial Drag,’ and Homosexual Panic,” Mae G. Henderson postulates that David’s “internalized homophobia...is a consequence of social sanctions that pathologize or criminalize homosexual identity and activity” (310). David’s internalized homophobia serves as the greatest hindrance to accepting his same-gender attractions. During his initial encounter with gay men in Paris at Guillame’s bar, David’s observations suggest his repulsion towards the men’s feminine presentations: “I always found it difficult to believe that they ever went to bed anyway, for a man who wanted a woman would certainly have rather had a real one and a man who wanted a man would certainly not want one of them” (27). David implies that “real” men need to perform the typical gender roles expected of a straight man in order to be appealing or desirable and that under these circumstances, there is no way for two men to be equally masculine in a sexual

    Read More

  • Benjamin Button Gender

    531 Words  | 3 Pages

    Men and Women Are presented in very different ways in "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button". Women in many cases are shown to be purely extensions of a man, in such the case of Elizabeth Abbot, whose purpose at the hotel was merely because her husband was there. Men, on the other hand, were portrayed as more capable then women for most jobs that promote masculinity, where the women had jobs such as working in a nursing home or being a stay at home mother. Gender is socially constructed in the movie is shown in several ways.

    Read More

  • Essay On The Chrysalids

    1018 Words  | 5 Pages

    This shows the change David has made with his views and choices. In the beginning of the book, David wished for extra arms as a harmless joke only to realize that making that joke costed him and got beat by his father. David then kept quiet as he didn’t want to express his own feelings due to trauma he has suffered. By the end of the book, David runs away with his friends in protest to his father’s rules and to express who he truly is. From the beginning of the book to the end, David has shown examples of him changing who he is as a person for the better.

    Read More

  • The Beetle Gender

    1149 Words  | 5 Pages

    The novel goes into depth exploring these in comparison to the approaches of the Victorian man. Said approaches actually demonstrate plenty about the fundamentals of our own culture in respect to our ethnic customs and our outlooks on gender roles. The Beetle completely turns around gender roles by depicting a leading dominant woman who is rather frequently mistaken for a man. An abundant amount of the gender swapping is enforced by the entrancing of the Beetle who forces its powers on Marjorie Holt, the New Woman. Holt’s feminism is compared to her transgender dominance by the Beetle.

    Read More

  • Toxic Masculinity In The Lord Of The Flies

    794 Words  | 4 Pages

    Unfortunately, toxic masculinity plays a role in every society, therefore many people, mostly men, put on a “mask” to hide behind in order to make a false impression of their best selves. No matter who it is, everyone has a way that they want people to know them by, which is why it plays such an important role. The book Lord of the Flies is a fiction text about a group of young boys whose plane crashes after it was shot down during a war. The boys turn from civilized to savages on their long journey on the island as they become less and less of a society. Toxic masculinity affects society in more ways than one and often is used to get ahead or to be seen as superior.

    Read More

  • A Literary Analysis Of James Baldwin In Giovanni's Room

    1642 Words  | 7 Pages

    This literary analysis will analyze James Baldwin’s intention of locating the “outsider” in the context of homosexuality and African American expatriation in the novel Giovanni’s Room. The article by Abur-Rahman (2007) defines Baldwin’s intention of locating a place for the “outsider” through the context of homosexuality and African American expatriation in European life. Baldwin’s own experiences as an American exile in France are defined through his own identity as a homosexual male, but also, as a racial minority seeking a place of sanctuary outside of American culture. Abur-Rahman (2007) defines Baldwin’s intention of depicting the white characters in the novel as a counterpoint to the alienation of homosexuals, as well as the increased burden of racial identity he had to carry in life. Giovanni’s Room

    Read More

  • Patriarchal Society In King Lear

    1987 Words  | 8 Pages

    In the 16th century, not only in England but also almost in all the countries, all the families were “under” the patriarchal society. A patriarchy, from the ancient Greek patriarches, was a society where power was held by and passed down through the elder males. When modern historians and sociologists describe a "patriarchal society," they mean that men hold the positions of power: head of the family unit, leaders of social groups, boss in the workplace and heads of government. Unfortunately, this fact still exists, even today in the 21st century in many countries, especially in the Muslim countries where women have restricted rights. Patriarchal society, manhood, and the sense of masculinity, in my opinion, raise two main issues: the issue

    Read More

More about Masculinity In Giovanni's Room By James Baldwin And Beebo Brinker

Open Document