Master Narrative Analysis
Remembering the Alamo through Master and Counter Narratives Introduction Throughout my education, I have learned about many historical events, heroes, and social issues within history. As I got older, I started to realize that many of my textbooks seemed to repeat the same stories. I decided to visit the Alamo museum in San Antonio, Texas, and take note of the master narratives and the counter narratives being represented in the museum about this significant event. Master Narrative As I first walked into the Alamo, I was amazed to see architecture that has remained from the building. The first area that I entered was the Church. This particular building was filled with artifacts that were left behind by the people who lived within. In the …show more content…
Travis, and James Bowie. The exhibits took into account passages written by these men on their views and experiences during the war. Throughout the museum, the stories that were being told were solely focused on the defenders of the Alamo rather than the Mexican army’s point-of-view as well. The Alamo primarily focused on the battle and the tragic events that evolved around the city of San Antonio during this time. It was a very one-dimensional experience that lacked background information about the people who we call “heroes” of the Alamo. It portrays these men as being famous for only their aid to the battle, instead of analyzing any other contributions these men may have made, or what their character was like outside of the Alamo. Counter Narrative Counter narratives are stories that go against the textbook norms. These narratives allow students to hear stories from a perspective that they may not …show more content…
Native American’s roamed the missions and lived at peace amongst the land, being silent witnesses to a stream of events that occurred in San Antonio. Also along the walls were images that talked about and displayed every day lives of the Tejano (Mexican Texan), prior to the battle. In textbooks much of the discussion around the Alamo consisted of the Mexican army and the defenders of the Alamo. These are just some of the counter narratives that many are not aware of due to the repetitive concepts that are being taught within Texas
Battle Of The Alamo Essay
809 Words | 4 PagesA. The Battle of the Alamo wasn’t the only battle between the Texans and Mexicans. 1. The first battle was the battle of Gonzales. 2.
La Malinche Or Our Lady Of Guadalupe Rhetorical Analysis
234 Words | 1 PagesOne of the questions brought up in class was how the soldaderas related to La Malinche or Our Lady of Guadalupe, and the idea that came to my mind was that both the soldaderas and Our Lady of Guadalupe both pushed the Mexican culture forward. An example that Salas points out is the issue regarding the food that the soldiers ate. Salas states that the American soldiers would eat food that the cooks would make in mess halls. The Mexican soldiers refused to eat the food and soon the United Statians realized that the soldiers would only eat the soldadera’s Mexican food. Had the soldaderas not been present in that scenario, it is safe to assume that the soldiers would have eventually given into eating the food the US gave them.
How Did Antonio Lopez De Santa Anna A Bad Guy In History
505 Words | 3 PagesEver wanted to learn about the bad guy in history? This person made a major effect in history. He was the Mexican leader, he lead 4000 Mexican troops to invade the Alamo, one of the most protected pieces by the Texans. This person in history is, Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna or Santa Anna for short. Santa Anna was born in Jalapa, Vera Cruz, on february 21, 1794, he was the son of Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna and Manuela Perez de Lebron.
Galveston: A History Summary
1030 Words | 5 PagesIn his book Galveston: A History McComb, tries to address the issues of how technology plays a role in transforming Galveston away from the way the European explorers encountered to the grand tourist attraction that it is today. In the book Galveston’s history is also told through using maps, pictures and phrases that describe.
Battle Of Peace River By Cynthia Ann Parker
1104 Words | 5 PagesCynthia Ann Parker was born in Illinois between June 2, 1824 and May 31, 1825 and moved to central Texas by the age of nine with her family. Cynthia Ann Parker makes her mark on history on May 19, 1936; this would be the day she and four others including her brother would be kidnapped by Caddo, Comanche, and Kiowa. Parker was approximately ten years old when she was snatched from the only home she knew “Fort Parker” with her parents and siblings and force into Comanche life (Lone Star). “Fort Parker was built for protection against an attack, built walls around the settlement and established a base for Texas Rangers” (Cynthia). Fort Parker was meant as a safe haven for the whole family, but little did it protect against what it was built for.
What Role Did The Alamo Play In Pre-American History
798 Words | 4 PagesKevin Lukaszek Mrs. Elia US History 1 H 4/16/16 Originally called the Misión San Antonio de Valero, the Alamo has always been an influential landmark in the history of North America. The Alamo and the Southern Texas region have always played a vital role in the in the history of America. Whether in pre-American times, during Spanish Rule or the Mexican Revolution, the Alamo has been a part of it and was a focal point of conflict.
Lan Bible In The Eyes Of The White Texaan Analysis
53 Words | 1 PagesAlthough Mexicans was illogically portrayed as unworthy and filthy in the eyes of the white Texan, there was no doubt that the Mexican worked hard for cheap labor than anyone else in the state. John Weber mentions Colonel Sam Robertson as he explains how the Mexican and Mexican-Americans worked harder than any race,
The Comanche Empire Summary
966 Words | 4 PagesIdentifying the common comparisons in the reviews allows the reader to analyze the structure and arguments in the monograph. A strength that three of the reviews recognize is the depth of research that Hamalainen provides on the Comanche. Recognizing the text’s detailed research, Flores states that its precise history makes it the leading text on the Comanche. Minor writes that Hamalainen’s thesis allows detailed research into the three eras of the Comanche. The rise, peak, and fall of the Comanche, Minor claims allow the readers with a comprehensive understanding of the expanse of the Comanche’s power in the southwest.
Summary Of A Line In The Sand The Alamo In Blood And Memory
1221 Words | 5 Pages(pg. 345-348) This book shows that there is much more to the “story” of the Alamo than what is flashed onto the big screen. Many of the details surrounding the main events have now been combined together in an eye-opening way.
End The Mission Fairy Tale Summary
1641 Words | 7 PagesEnd the Mission Fairy Tale "When a white army battles Indians and wins, it is called a great victory, but if they lose it is called a massacre," - Chiksika, Shawnee. Native American writer and poet, Deborah A. Miranda in her online articled “Lying to Children About the California Missions and the Indians” published in March 23, 2015 addresses the topic of the “Mission Unit” that 4th graders are required to take and claims that the false story that is taught should be put to an end. She supports her claim by first providing a brief story of the missionization of California, then by explaining what the Mission Project consists of, then by including book examples on how people are taught the false stereotype of Native Americans and finally by
Territorial Expansionism
524 Words | 3 PagesDue to the empresario system hundreds of slave-holding farmers settled into Mexico’s northern territory and by 1836 the population ratio in Coahuila y Texas was ten whites to every one Spanish-speaker. This caused some conflict because slavery was against the law in Mexico, yet there were hundreds of slave-holding families settled on Mexican territory. This conflict caused the Texas Revolution and the creation of the “Lone Star Republic.” But Sam Houston, the first president of Texas, wanted the United States or Great Britain to annex Texas in order to assume the debts of Texas. As a result,
Personal Narrative: The LA Plaza De Arte Y Cultura
1004 Words | 5 PagesGetting to the museum was difficult because it was hard to find them. My husband and I decided to park our car, walk, and just ask someone for directions. We walked around Main Street and looked at all the things local vendors were selling in the street. They had clothing, food, shoes, purses, and other nick knacks, that represented our Mexican culture. There were many vendors dressed in red, white, and green and were very friendly, some even spoke English.
Texan Cultural Beliefs
783 Words | 4 Pagesweb sites” (p. 85). The stories, key points and portraits are the subjects of the heritage websites study in this research. This study will focus on how Texan cultural values are shown in the presentation exhibit on these sites. Thorough explanation referring to narrative accounts shown in the heritage museums to their guests expresses the dominant cultural values of Texan society. This study for the most part concentrates on the stories since they constitute the majority of the data furnished by the heritage sites.
Who Is Angelico Chavez: What Caused The Pueblo Revolt?
611 Words | 3 PagesOne of the most historical moments of the Pueblo Revolt, was when the pueblos met up to try and stop the Spanish colony and the Franciscan missions, but instead 21 friars and multiple Spanish families were killed in one day (Weber 84). Angelico Chaves states the Naranjo is a representation that the definition of a Pueblo was changed in the years before the revolt, and a different culture had come about. Due to the revolt in people and culture, Chavez states that the revolt was successfully “planned and carried out” not just by individual leaders, but the main person of Pohe-yemo. In the second essay selection, Spanish Missions, Cultural Conflict, and the Pueblo Revolt of 1680, Henry Warner Bowden argues that the cause of the Pueblo Revolt is due to religion being the heart of the Spanish and Pueblo cultures (Weber 21).
Mayan Influence On Maya
843 Words | 4 PagesOther major form in keeping the culture alive is by teaching our young ones embrace their history. Today, Children of Mayan school of Tecpan are able to draw pictures of temples of Classic Tikal and hieroglyphics that they have learned. Another form of cultural heritage is the oral history of local memory, such as the history of the last king of Iximche’ known as Tecun. Who is regarded as national hero that fought the Spaniards and died on direct combat with Pedro de Alvarado, leader of the Conquistadores. History is written that Tecun attacked Alvarado horse because he view Alvarado’s horse as part of the human body; therefore, the Spaniards were able to kill him.
More about Master Narrative Analysis
Battle Of The Alamo Essay
809 Words | 4 PagesLa Malinche Or Our Lady Of Guadalupe Rhetorical Analysis
234 Words | 1 PagesHow Did Antonio Lopez De Santa Anna A Bad Guy In History
505 Words | 3 PagesGalveston: A History Summary
1030 Words | 5 PagesBattle Of Peace River By Cynthia Ann Parker
1104 Words | 5 PagesWhat Role Did The Alamo Play In Pre-American History
798 Words | 4 PagesLan Bible In The Eyes Of The White Texaan Analysis
53 Words | 1 PagesThe Comanche Empire Summary
966 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of A Line In The Sand The Alamo In Blood And Memory
1221 Words | 5 PagesEnd The Mission Fairy Tale Summary
1641 Words | 7 PagesTerritorial Expansionism
524 Words | 3 PagesPersonal Narrative: The LA Plaza De Arte Y Cultura
1004 Words | 5 PagesTexan Cultural Beliefs
783 Words | 4 PagesWho Is Angelico Chavez: What Caused The Pueblo Revolt?
611 Words | 3 PagesMayan Influence On Maya
843 Words | 4 Pages