Medical Malpractice Cases
Medical malpractice is a legal offense that occurs when a medical professional fails to perform his or her medical duties due to negligence, thereby causing injury or death to a patient. Therefore the purpose of this essay to highlight how medical practitioners can be negligent by not informing the patient about the inherent risk of the medical procedure such as in the case of Rogers v Whitaker [1992] (hereinafter Rogers). Additionally Cranley v Medical Board of Western Australia [1990] (hereinafter Cranley) will also be investigated to demonstrate how medical practitioners can be alleged to be found for conducting improper professional conduct, and why this improper conduct was overturned by the courts.
Failure to disclose the inherent risk of a medical procedure
…show more content…
In handing down their judgement Mason CJ, Brennan, Dawson, Toohey and McHugh JJ stipulated that:
A reasonable person in the patient 's position, if warned of the risk, would be likely to attach significance to it; or if the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that this particular patient, if warned of the risk, would be likely to attach significance to it.
(Cica, 1995)
The standard of care required by the law, in respect of the provision of information about risks inherent in medical treatment, therefore is determined by the court with reference to the 'needs, concerns and circumstances of the patient,.’ It is not determined by reference to the standards or practices of the medical profession - the court has 'simply no occasion to consider the practice or practices of medical practitioners in determining what information should be supplied, The reason given by the High Court for this conclusion was that 'no special medical skill ' is involved in disclosing information to a
Cleveland V. Perry: A Case Study
1223 Words | 5 PagesTo show that a breach of professional duty occurred, there must be the concept of standard of care. Standard of care generally refers to that care which a reasonable, similar professional would have provided to the patient. Morissette writes “to establish breach of a standard of professional care, expert witness testimony becomes essential since a jury of laypersons cannot understand the distinctions of medical care.” (2014, p. 134) An emergency room doctor would be an exceptional witness to show that the inactions of Dr. Perry greatly reduced the chance of his patient surviving. In addition, the Learned Hand Formula should be applied in this case, by checking Michael’s vitals, Dr. Perry would have reduced the risk of harm and possibly death because he would have realized his misdiagnoses and would have given Michael a greater chance of
Jane Medical Abbreviations
415 Words | 2 PagesMedical professionals are liable for malpractice and could face consequences such as a lawsuit against them or being fired. These errors can be minimized by being more
How Does The Nhs Constitution Affect The Practice Of The Ambulance Crew
842 Words | 4 PagesA piece of legislation was created in 2005, with the purpose to allow clinicians to make decisions for the patient, when it is deemed that they haven’t got the ability to think clearly or understand information that is being presented to them, whether that is permanently or temporarily. Whilst this is the case, different levels of capacity are required for different decisions, so a patient cannot be “deprived of their liberty” (SCAS, 2010, 5) and all decision made in the best interest of the patient must be the “least restrictive alternative” (SCAS, 2010, 7.1). This means that these decisions cannot cause the patient to feel uncomfortable, embarrassed, or be detrimental to their health. Until proven otherwise, everyone is assumed to have capacity to make a decision. There are a variety of reasons that affect a patient’s capacity; neurological conditions (eg. dementia etc), head/brain trauma (eg. concussion etc) learning disabilities, effects of hypoxia, the effects of alcohol or substance use, amongst others (SCAS, 2010, 7.1).
Malpractice Case Paper
532 Words | 3 PagesIt is interesting the different cases that can be presented at a board meeting from practicing without a license to malpractice. It is also hard to be a board member, I would assume, because they get multiple stories and excuses and sometimes it can be hard to determine the best course of action. Take for example a case that was discussed at the September 2015 board meeting. A hygienist received two extensions, one till 02/15/2015 and one till 06/22/2015. This hygienist had also received prior extensions in the past.
Supported Decision-Making Analysis
1750 Words | 7 PagesAlthough there were numerous beneficial experiences for the Consumer through the supported decision-making process, the deterioration in mental state and the concern relating to exposure of vulnerability and openness to manipulation by others could not be overlooked (Office of the Public Advocate Systems Advocacy, 2014). Dignity of risk relates to the Consumers right be able to make decisions that can involve a level of risk, however the duty of care of the primary nurse and treating team was to ensure that safeguards are in place to minimise risk of harm to the Consumer and/or others that may be effected by the decision made (Victoria Government Department of Human Services,
Informed Consent Case Study
1397 Words | 6 PagesVal Jones (2012) notes that the idea of the informed shared medical decision is “as old as the Hippocratic Oath”, but its widespread adoption would “create an extra layer of bureaucracy” (Jones, 2012). In order to understand the validity of this claim, it is recommended to take a look into the innovation. The main idea underlying the informed shared medical decision is that patients should be informed by independent consultants who would help them to make more accurate decision regarding medical interventions. It is suggested that experts hired by a health insurance company or government agency are more objective in their recommendations, when compared to doctors who are familiar with the nuances of an individual’s case (Jones, 2012). Despite the apparent validity of this assertion, the shared medical decision has a number of limitations that make informed consent a practice harmful for health care institutions.
Julie Thao's Medication Attack Case Study
541 Words | 3 PagesThere were specific situations that led to the cause of Julie Thao's actions of medication error and the death of Jasmine. The situation could have completely been avoided had Julie followed the code of ethics and avoided shorts to provide proper care for the patient. The state claimed that Thao's mistake was caused by actions, omissions and unapproved shortcuts, however, there were other factors that played a role in her carelessness as well. While failure to comply with procedure has been a factor in the medication administration error, other factors contributed as well. For example, failure to properly use the information system, or to ignore alerts or warnings have also resulted in preventable errors (Nelson, Evan, & Gardener, 2005).
Summary Of Tomcik V. Ohio Department Of Rehabilitation
1010 Words | 5 PagesThe court found the “Defendant's care of Claimant fell below acceptable standards of practice” (Stashenko, 2015). In 2009 a former inmate of the Hawaii corrections department was awarded close to $1 million in damages for an incident in 2003, in which the physician’s failure to give the correct type and dosage of antibiotic for an infection in his scrotum. This resulted in 6 subsequent surgeries and the removal of his scrotum, rendering him
Informed Consent In Research
733 Words | 3 PagesPatients have a right to privacy and non-interference. The healthcare professionals are obligated to give needed information to patients and relate the risks, and the benefits of a test/treatment. The detail information given will allow the patient to make the best decision on what he/she chooses to do. Hiding information about a diagnosis or not revealing the potential complications because a patient may refuse care seems unethical. Patients have the right to know about their health to make informed
Dr Anna Pou Case Summary
639 Words | 3 PagesIt It f It frustrates me what Dr. Anna Pou had to go through with the lawsuits of the Memorial Medical Center incident. As Healthcare professionals, being sued for making the rightful decision for the patient and the hospital is unjust. Healthcare professionals like Dr. Pou, have taken the Hippocratic oath, and one of the promises made within that oath is “first, do no harm”. Hospital’s should not be so quick to make such an important decision of pressing charges to their faculty; more trust should be placed in them. In addition, she made it clear her intentions were just to ‘‘help’’ patients ‘‘through their pain,’’ on national television.
Tort Case Study: Health Care Law
1368 Words | 6 PagesHealth Care Law: Tort Case Study Carolann Stanek University of Mary Health Care Law: Tort Case Study A sample case study reviewed substandard care that was delivered to Ms. Gardner after having sustained an accident and brought to Bay Hospital for treatment. Dr. Dick, a second-year pediatric resident, was on that day in the ED and provided care for Ms. Gadner. Dr. Moon, is the chief of staff and oversees the credentialing of all physicians at Bay Hospital.
Medical Malpractice Research Paper
749 Words | 3 PagesMedical Malpractice Everyone makes mistakes, but some are more deadly than others. Malpractice is the illegal or negligence, professional activity or they’re working out of the their scope of practice. Medical malpractice is one of the top causes of death in the United States. With this being said, insurance for medical practitioners would be considerably higher.
Clinical Negligence In Medical Practice
1947 Words | 8 Pages1. Introduction: Radiologists recently have been advanced because of radiology expanding practices in many sensitive medical cases. Recent charges against radiologists have brought new obligations and liabilities, making them vulnerable to higher degrees of legal cases against them. Negligence legal proceedings in radiology naturally appear as a result of failure to diagnosis or poor consultation and thus failure to react medically in a timely manner.
Health Care Practice Guidelines
233 Words | 1 PagesThe employees of this hospital had followed the health care practice guidelines according to it was written. As a healthcare professional, our duty is to follow all the guideline and policy that have established from the facility. These guidelines should be followed as it was written. Any deviation or any non-compliance from following a clinical guideline can result to a potential litigation as evidence of negligence can lead a court system. “Regardless of the strength of the evidence, it will remain the responsibility of the practicing clinicians to interpret their application” Broughton, R. & Rathbone, B. (2001, P. 3).
Negligence In Criminal Law
3226 Words | 13 PagesEven after adopting all medical procedures as prescribed, a qualified doctor may commit an error. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and the Supreme Court have held, in several decisions, that a doctor is not liable for negligence or medical deficiency if some wrong is caused in her/ his treatment or in her/ his diagnosis if she/ he has acted in accordance with the practice accepted as proper by a reasonable body of medical professionals skilled in that particular art, though the result may be wrong. In various kinds of medical and surgical treatment, the likelihood of an accident leading to death cannot be ruled out. It is implied that a patient willingly takes such a risk as part of the doctor-patient relationship and the attendant
More about Medical Malpractice Cases
Cleveland V. Perry: A Case Study
1223 Words | 5 PagesJane Medical Abbreviations
415 Words | 2 PagesHow Does The Nhs Constitution Affect The Practice Of The Ambulance Crew
842 Words | 4 PagesMalpractice Case Paper
532 Words | 3 PagesSupported Decision-Making Analysis
1750 Words | 7 PagesInformed Consent Case Study
1397 Words | 6 PagesJulie Thao's Medication Attack Case Study
541 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Tomcik V. Ohio Department Of Rehabilitation
1010 Words | 5 PagesInformed Consent In Research
733 Words | 3 PagesDr Anna Pou Case Summary
639 Words | 3 PagesTort Case Study: Health Care Law
1368 Words | 6 PagesMedical Malpractice Research Paper
749 Words | 3 PagesClinical Negligence In Medical Practice
1947 Words | 8 PagesHealth Care Practice Guidelines
233 Words | 1 PagesNegligence In Criminal Law
3226 Words | 13 Pages