ipl-logo

Michael Prestwich's Speech In Medieval People

899 Words4 Pages

Michael Prestwich in his book Medieval People courageously attempts to encapsulate in few pages the early life, as well as the contribution of the Pope Urban II in the reform of the Catholic church and the creation of the first crusades, yet he fails to quote the Pope himself with regard to his speech with the reference to the Christian Holy War against Islam. Such an important missing element demonstrates his prejudice toward Christianity.
In particular, Prestwich begins his brief chapter on the life of the Pope Urban II by recalling his contribution to the Crusades. Also, he provides an incisive background of the expansion of the Muslims and the Byzantine empire before the creation and the rise of the crusades. Specifically, he states that …show more content…

Even though that was not the case as he can be defined as the flame that lighted the hate between Christian and Muslim population. Specifically, Prestwich-based on his perspective of Christianity excludes such a significant element in order to hide the hypocrisy of the church, as such a preach was against the Christian doctrine. "But I say unto you, love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you." (Mathew 5:44) Parallel, it prevents the explosion of the church’s negative feelings toward Islam that are rooted even before the Arabs take over territories of the Holy Lands. The manipulation the Pope derived, easily tricked the Christian mass and lead them to a violent outbreak that suggested a hidden version of Christianity that would ultimately overtake the pseudo-compassion principles of God’s community.
In addition, Prestwich’s inadequacy to report the motifs as well as the people who influenced the pope in order to declare the Holy War, create uncertainty with reference to his capabilities as a noble historian. Also, it born questions of how credible is the historical data he has encountered throughout the

Show More
Related

  • A Different Outlook On God's Battalions By Rodney Stark

    558 Words  | 3 Pages

    He also evaluates the pope’s speech declaring the crusades in depth, which he explains that the crusaders truly believed that they were fighting for god; they were fighting in “God’s battalions”. A major point Stark wants the reader to take away by the end of the monograph is that the Muslims did not hold a grudge on the Westerns because of the crusades. There was originally no hatred for the Christians and Westerners after the crusades; the hatred did not develop until later on. He provides examples from many historians saying that the Muslims hate Western Christians countries because of the crusades. Starks explains that the Muslims did not seem to pay much attention to the crusades when they were occurring and for centuries after.

    Read More

  • Why Did Pope Urban II Call The First Crusade In 1095

    1292 Words  | 6 Pages

    Why did Pope Urban II call the First Crusade in 1095 When Alexius I appealed for aid in the Council of Piacenza in March 1095, it wasn’t surprising that the First Crusade occurred only a few months afterwards, as it was considered by historians “premediate” and resulted from the long-existing opposition to many factors. Building up towards 1095, Christendom was perceived to be threatened both externally by heretical military expansions and internally by the destructive knightly class and the concern for Jerusalem, while Urban was resolute to maximise the papacy’s power, and his own success, through setting the Christian agenda. Since 9th Century, Christendom had been threatened religiously and militarily by heresies, providing Urban in 1095

    Read More

  • Christian Crusades DBQ Essay

    555 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to (document E) Life in the Middle Ages “ Was insecure, violence was everywhere and poverty was widespread.” The troubling experiences were so overwhelming that the Holy Roman Empire felt that it was necessary the Crusades. By promoting the crusades people would be able to focus their violence and energy to a greater cause. In addition, the

    Read More

  • Fourth Crusades Dbq Essay

    613 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1095 on November 27 in Clermont,France, Pope Urban the II called for a Crusade to help the Byzantines and free the city of Jerusalem. The official start date was set as August 15, 1096. This order little did he know would be the cause of a battle that turned into 9 war’s that last for nearly 200 years. This event in history clearly has a outcome that is way more negative than positive. Have you ever imagined being in the middle of a 200 year war people dropping like flies just because of an argument over one city?

    Read More

  • Were The Crusades Dbq Essay

    746 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pope Urban II called upon all Christians into this war, calling those who don’t believe in God Heathens and providing reason to take control of Jerusalem again. Also assuring that the soldiers of this war will get an admission into Heaven. (Document 1) Christians, no matter the empire or region were being united by the Crusades through their love of Christ. (Document 2) French and German crusaders invaded a Jewish City, killing people for sanctification of the Lord. (Document 5)

    Read More

  • The Crusades Dbq Essay

    706 Words  | 3 Pages

    Introduction: Provide background information on the Crusades, restate the DBQ question, state thesis with reasons. (include academic vocabulary and underline) The results of the Crusades was probably more negative than positive. In “Doc 4”, It states that “Moreover, the assault of one Christian people on another, when one of the goals of the Fourth Crusade was reunion of Greek and Latin churches, made the split between the Greek and Latin churches permanent.” The Crusades had a lot of hatred to the religions, and by 1204 the Crusaders had lost some of their appeal because the knights agreed to attack the Byzantine Capital instead.

    Read More

  • How Did The Crusades Contribute To The Rise Of Anti-Semitism In Western Europe

    1396 Words  | 6 Pages

    It is also clear that the Crusades played a pivotal role in intensifying this sentiment. However, due to contributing factors, we can conclude that the Crusades were not a direct cause for the increase of anti-Semetisim during the eleventh and twelfth

    Read More

  • The Crusades Dbq Essay

    823 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Crusades were a violent series of battles that Christians fought against Muslims in order to gain back the holy land, Jerusalem. The Christians felt threatened by the intimidating rule of the Islamic Empire, and their response was the first Crusade. These attacks continued and grew unsuccessful throughout many years, and are often due to the intense bond between Christians and God, however there are other influences, like wealth and power. Some argue also that the actions committed during these events were not necessarily “barbaric”, considering the historical time period. The Crusades should be remembered as a series of attacks with a variety of motives and influences that were violent and barbaric.

    Read More

  • First Crusades Dbq

    1247 Words  | 5 Pages

    The speech of Urban II at Clermont in 1095 was the special moment, when he promised and guaranteed that any person who will join to the campaign would get Holy land and place in heaven. At that time believe in God and Holy land was very popular, so Urban II mostly affected on moral of the people. The effect was stunning; people from all parts of Western Europe started to think that moving to Jerusalem is their duty. Actually the main purpose of Urban II was to unite all Christians in Europe and to achieve his aim completely he reminded people that their lands are poor, while Muslims live in Holy lands under good conditions. Citizens were now strongly motivated and ready to invade irreligious opponents.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Pope Urban II's Speech At Clermont

    582 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pope Urban II’s speech at Clermont in 1095 was a call to crusade given outdoors to the nobles, commoners and church leaders of the Western European Christians (the Franks). The people were moved by this speech and it changed history, launching the first crusade to capture Jerusalem from the Muslim Turks. After hearing Pope Urban II’s speech, thousands of Western European Christians were moved to embark on the dangerous journey and fight in the crusade. I believe the main reasons they were moved and persuaded to fight was; 1) they felt it was their Christian duty, 2) Pope Urban promised them absolution for their sins and 3) they felt compelled to defend Christianity, their holy land and the Eastern Christians.

    Read More

  • Fulcher's The First Crusade

    740 Words  | 3 Pages

    Fulcher's claim that European Christians should have been protected from Muslim occupation and fierce persecution. As the Roman Realm disintegrated and the papacy lost power and power, moves in governmental issues and religions started. The papacy, under the direction of Pope Urban II, started the battle for more power and power. Amid the time preceding the Main Campaign, the Christian confidence "overwhelmed and directed regular day to day existence to a degree that can appear to be practically unfathomable to a present day eyewitness receptive to the states of mind and biases progressively secularized contemporary society. This religious enthusiasm sustained the "mind-boggling uneasiness: the threat of wrongdoing".

    Read More

  • The Benedict Option I. Annotation Analysis

    790 Words  | 4 Pages

    Mahmud 1 Sharoze Mahmud Mr.B AP Lang and Comp March 17th, 2016 Columnist Assignment: David Brooks, The New York Times Article 1: The Benedict Option I. Annotation Author's Purpose: This is a critical review of the ideas expressed in Rod 'Dreher's book, The Benedict Option. Dreher sees the cultural wars over new realities (such as LGBT) as a threat to Christian faith, and suggests the option of St. Benedict (sixth-century monk) during the fall of the Roman empire, i.e. withdraw from the mainstream and establish

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Byzantine Empire And Medieval Europe

    829 Words  | 4 Pages

    This paper aims at differentiating and matching the medieval society in Europe and Byzantine Empire. Among the major similarities between Byzantine Empire and the medieval society in Europe was the existence of a dominant religion which was Christianity. At the time of the rule of the Romans, Christianity was legalized by Emperor Constantine. This outlawed torment and punishments for those who acknowledged Christianity as their faith.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The Crusades

    1018 Words  | 5 Pages

    In spite of that time-frame, the relations between the Middle-Age Empires and the Roman Catholic Church prior to the

    Read More

  • Church And Politics In The Middle Ages

    2225 Words  | 9 Pages

    The Church dominated politics throughout the Middle Ages. It is clear from reading numerous primary sources that the Church was the sole guidance of people throughout the Middle Ages. This essay will discuss the factors and events that led to the rise of the Church in the Middle Ages and the change in politics from this time. It is evident from reading various sources from the course that the Church and the State were closely linked and that this bond was formed from the early outset of the Middle Ages, at the time of the Roman Empire. The object of this essay is to research primary sources from this time to demonstrate the progression of the Church and politics in the Middle Ages.

    Read More

More about Michael Prestwich's Speech In Medieval People

Open Document