ipl-logo

Michael Sandel's 'The Politics Of Public Identity'

1326 Words6 Pages

Work Together Cheyanne Yendrey POSI 3334.251 March 12, 2017 Michael Sandel wrote “The Politics of Public Identity” critiquing John Rawls and Robert Nozick’s idea of liberalism while advocating communitarianism in his response. Sandel describes communitarianism as an efficient process where individuals will be able to function better and can achieve reasoning if they were properly unified into communities. This goes against Rawls and Nozick’s idea of liberalism, where the individuals act on their own and rule themselves. Rawls and Nozick both admire liberalism, but disagree about what constitutes liberalism. Robert Nozick focused more on a realistic concept where he acknowledges the unlikelihood of living a life where an individual …show more content…

Sandel is a huge advocate for the government to restore integrity in the communities. He also expresses that in communitarianism, the government provides an education process that will educate the citizens to be vigilante. Robert Nozick believes liberalism should only exist to protect the individual rights. The government’s role is very limited, and can be seen as unjust if intervened with any further issues. Communitarianism lets the government exist further to help the communities restore all …show more content…

Both Nozick and John Rawls admires how the system promotes individuality and pluralism. The government also is limited to the merely protection of individual rights. However, the disadvantages outweigh the advantages, granting communitarianism to be the best system out of the two. Michael Sandel’s communitarianism is a practical system where communities rule together. Individual rights would be more significant if they were united. Progress would not continue if change cannot occur. This would also be an issue if government gained too much control or the wrong power. Communitarianism designs an education process that will promote good citizens, which will allow the political process to function with society. The government’s role would also be genuine once the education process is reformed. Michael Sandel applies communitarianism well with the influence of restoring individual rights within

Show More
Related

  • Comparison Of Flaws With Collective Governments In Anthem And Catch-22

    599 Words  | 3 Pages

    The two authors describe a similar conflict between the main characters and the hierarchical systems that control them. The novels Anthem by Ayn Rand and Catch-22 by Joseph Heller demonstrate the flaws in the collective system of government, with its closed ruling body that emphasizes equality yet ultimately restricts citizens’ rights to

    Read More

  • Comparing Collectivism In Anthem And Harrison Bergeron

    827 Words  | 4 Pages

    In America, citizens are granted their own individual rights and freedoms. Therefore, it is difficult to imagine if one's own personal liberty no longer existed due to the fact that their only concern was the betterment of their society. One's self worth was no longer determined from within, but by one's peers. Many believe that the solution to the selfishness which plagues society is Altruism.

    Read More

  • Individualism In The Milagro Beanfield War

    458 Words  | 2 Pages

    Often time, political power can be focused solely on the individual. People associate power and ability to accomplish change in the political arena to an individual or a select few. However, people often forget that collectivism, a community coming together, holds just as much strength as a powerful individual. John Nicholas' The Milagro Beanfield War illustrates the strength of collectivism as a formidable political force. Audiences often believe that the most critical protagonist of the novel are individual people, and they often overlook the most crucial forces, communities.

    Read More

  • Common Sense By Thomas Paine And The Virginia Declaration Of Independence

    1365 Words  | 6 Pages

    Rousseau presents this question “How is a method of associating to be found which will defend and protect-using the power of all-the person and property of each ember and still enable each member of the group to obey only him and to remain as free as before?” Thomas Paine says that “Government, on the other hand, is an institution whose sole purpose is to protect us from our own vices.” In order to grow and protect itself people join a society. For a society to have order and justice and remain equal, laws must be put in place, such that protect the individual rights of these people that they were born with. Equality is another belief that all these philosophies shared.

    Read More

  • Comparing Collectivism In Harrison Bergeron And Ayn Rand's Anthem

    704 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today, the debate that perplexes society is whether collectivism provides answer for simplicity amongst a civilization. True collectivists believe in altruism, and these altruists believe the only way to bring a society together is by destroying individualism. Democracies believe that individualists remain the only way to keep society 's bonds intact. The stories “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut and Anthem by Ayn Rand draws the line between the so-called perfect utopia versus an imperfect dystopia. One can see there are many similarities between “Harrison Bergeron” and Anthem.

    Read More

  • Roosevelt Rhetorical Analysis

    862 Words  | 4 Pages

    He claimed, “Let both sides explore what problems unite us, instead of belaboring those problems which divide us.” Previously, he supported his claim using causal inference that explained the benefits of freedom and peace over war and oppression. He said, “United, there is little we cannot do, in a host of cooperative ventures. Divided, there is little we can do. For we dare not meet a powerful challenge at odds, and split asunder.”

    Read More

  • How Does Thomas Paine Create An Innate Society

    1100 Words  | 5 Pages

    Thomas More had an abundance of revolutionary ideas for his time, many of which he penned down in his famous work Utopia. More’s greatest focus in this short book is placed on exploring the possibilities and benefits of a new kind of government. His views on such things as freedom, community, and the innate nature of man were all considered when creating what More views as the epitome of a successful government. It is baffling to realize that, using these same principles of freedom, community, and the innate nature of man, another author could come to a conclusion in direct opposition with More’s outcome.

    Read More

  • Essay On Robert Nozick

    857 Words  | 4 Pages

    In a short piece he wrote, Robert Nozick discussed the possibility of a machine that people could plug into and experience different events. They would be able to experience anything they chose, and they alone would be in control of what experiences they would take part in. Nozick strongly opposes the idea of living our lives and experiences through such a machine by bringing up several logical arguments. The first argument Nozick uses to oppose such an idea is the fact that we as people want to do things rather than just experience them. We want to be able to actually do the things we long to do rather than just have the experiences which, Nozick argues, is fundamentally different.

    Read More

  • Racism And Mass Incarceration

    1487 Words  | 6 Pages

    This piece of work is mainly about the social analysts position to the issue of racism and mass incarceration and also how the various principles of distributive justice can be applied to different positions in our issue of focus. It is quite evident that the main work of the social policy analysts is to identify current problems, evaluating them and coming up with solutions regarding to it. Once they discover the problem they try to check for the causes that may leading to that problem and also other problems that may be related to it. However, different social policy analysis’s have differing views regarding a certain problem and also

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Our Declaration By Danielle Allen

    1892 Words  | 8 Pages

    A solution to the issue would be to take ideas from both and combine them. A reformation in education which both promotes active participation in government paired with concepts that weaken the barrier between demographics of people would be the ultimate solution. If political education addresses these exclusionary practices and promotes a more inclusive and democratic vision of citizenship both authors' desires would be answered. This critique of the current system of citizenship is an important addition to Allen's argument, as it highlights the need to address the structural inequalities that

    Read More

  • Equality 7-2521

    745 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ayn Rand once said, “Collectivism holds that the individual has no rights, that his life and work belong to the group (to ‘society’, to the tribe, the state, the nation) and that the group may sacrifice him at its own whim to its interest.” In Ayn Rand’s novella, Anthem, she depicts an anonymous, communist city in which no individual has any rights, they only exist for their “brothers”. Equality 7-2521 is a very venturesome and curious character that wants nothing more than to be an individual and live with no limits. The complication with Equality 7-2521 wanting to be his own individual is the rules and controls that comes with his collectivist society.

    Read More

  • Rights Of Man By Thomas Paine Analysis

    864 Words  | 4 Pages

    America, the land of the free, was founded upon the standards life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. In America’s early years, Thomas Paine, in his book Rights of Man characterized this country’s government as functioning in unison with no difficulties. When you break it down and look at the big picture, some people will argue that increased diversity has brought the nation to an all time peak, in terms of unity. Meanwhile, others maintain the idea that Thomas Paine’s assessment is mistaken for what is to one day be achieved. Yet while we would like to believe in his visionary, it unfortunately does not hold true today regarding both our modern politics and social principles.

    Read More

  • Identity In Brave New World Essay

    631 Words  | 3 Pages

    Modern Society and Brave New World Community, Identity, Stability. These are the ideas that are thrown at you from the very beginning of Brave New World by Aldous Huxley. However, it is quite ironic that this is the motto chosen to represent the world state. Community is understood to be a group of diverse individuals coming together as one, yet in brave new world they predestine their citizens and sort them into different castes. Identity is understood to show individualism, yet the caste system limits anyone’s capability to be an individual.

    Read More

  • Totalitarianism In The Maze Runner

    1086 Words  | 5 Pages

    Totalitarianism is a political and social concept that explains a form of government where the state has all control over the civilians. Such government assumes full power, without any limitations. As put by Juan Linz, a totalitarian scholar, the three main factors of a totalitarianism government are “a monistic center of power; an ideology developed, justified and pursued by the leadership; and mass participation in political and social goals encouraged and even demanded by that same leadership” (Silberstein 42). Throughout the 20th century the manifestation of totalitarianism was an extreme measure of harsh political occurrences.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Sociocultural Complexity Without The State: The Indus Civilization

    1563 Words  | 7 Pages

    (Young 2014:19). In addition, this framework implies that sociocultural complexity is the striking feature of the state – or, at least, characterises social groups that are in the process of becoming one. In his paper, Possehl goes against this view by

    Read More

More about Michael Sandel's 'The Politics Of Public Identity'

Open Document