ipl-logo

Construction Of Orientalism

1352 Words6 Pages

This chapter introduces the methodology and theories used for the research of this thesis. Firstly, some aspects of the methodologies used during the research are mentioned to get a grasp on the direction of this thesis. Secondly, more information about the primary and secondary is provided. Thirdly, the theories are introduced, mainly focusing on Edward Said’s notion of Orientalism and the notion of discourse introduced by Michel Foucault and applied to the museum by Eileen Hooper-Greenhill. Lastly, this chapter aims to provide an explanation of why other theories are not used.
As mentioned above, the methodology used to conduct the research is mentioned first. With a qualitative approach a more in depth knowledge can be obtained. Qualitative …show more content…

He stated that “Orientalism is a style of thought based upon an ontological and epistemological distinction between ‘the Orient’ and ‘the Occident” (Said E. W., 1978, p. 2). In his eyes, the construction of Orientalism presumed a static Orient, strange and different in the eyes of the West, which was a relation of power differences (Said E. W., 1978, pp. 1-96). This construction of otherness “… serves as a constant reminder of difference” for viewers of art when the presentation of the objects follows these orientalist discourse notion (Jordanova, 2000, p. 245). Edward Said’s book has been criticized as well for only proving a binary and for constructing a similar timeless, unchanging and essentialist image of the West (Macfie, 2002, pp. 65-66; Salvatore, 1996, pp. 459-482). This binary notion that Edward Said applied by seeing the West as a binary as well, is a method of order and truth specific for its time according to Timothy Mitchell (Mitchell, 1998). Edward Said’s notion of Orientalism as a hegemonic system, whether it be a more moderated version or not, had and still has a significant impact on many discourse within the studies of Islamic art. Although the notion of Orientalism can be applied to different fields and aspects of Islamic lands, only Orientalism in relationship to the visual arts and architecture will …show more content…

Texts focusing on Islamic art historiography, as well as introductions in Islamic art survey books and museum catalogues, frequently mention definitions and concepts of Islamic art. These definitions can rank from a short paragraph to more elaborate definitions and criticism of the concept. Definitions and concepts of Islamic art may say less about the artifacts and more about the surrounding environment. Conceptual Analysis is a theory that could certainly have been applied to the concept of Islamic art as it certainly travels and breaking it down could provide more information. Unfortunately the size more than the scope of this topic limited the use of theories and Conceptual Analysis as used for example by Mieke Bal (Bal, 2009) will not be used in this research. This research will also not cover any theories related to education, audience or participation. Even though education and audience are important aspects of museums, the focus of this research would be too broad to include these features as well. Therefore, the knowledge transfer theory by Eileen Hooper-Greenhill will not be used as well but is certainly a point of interest for further research as some museum professionals of Islamic art are working with this theory (Weber, A Concert of Things: Thoughts on Objects of Islamic Art in the Museum Context, 2012a, p.

Show More
Related

  • Dbq Museum Collection Analysis

    477 Words  | 2 Pages

    She writes, “The standard apology for museum sales activities, ‘Because we need the money. ’”(Source D). This describes the gift shop aspect of the museums and how it is not well regarded among both museum patrons and art connoisseurs alike. Even though this system of earning money is not what the public would like to see, it is still essential to running the

    Read More

  • Whydah Gally: An Example Of A Museum

    712 Words  | 3 Pages

    The purpose may be to inform, to challenge, to persuade, to argue or all of these. ‘Museums are not representations of the Other, but can be read as referential indices of the Self’ (p. 365). Museum is a representation of how one interprets the other. The maker of the display has made choices and exercised

    Read More

  • Rimland Rules Eurasia In Fahrenheit 451 By Ray Bradbury

    2705 Words  | 11 Pages

    (Bradbury 28). Museums are typically a documentation of the lives and morality of society. The changes and shifts in human perspective and creativity are juxtaposed through works from the renaissance and the depression periods verses from the golden ages and modern day. This documentation is a means of showing the desire to progress and value creativity, but if that desire gets snuffed out it reflects a society that is blank and poreless. This is furthered as Clarrise says, “No front porches.

    Read More

  • Navy Jack Flag Artifact

    834 Words  | 4 Pages

    For people, especially younger children, a way to feel a strong connection to the past is through objects that representation of that time in history. For example, after my grandmother passed away, I received one of her many rosaries, allowing me to remember our bond and the influence she had in my life every time I hold her heirloom. In today’s world, one of the only places in which a person is able to see historic artifacts and feel the connection to the piece of history that it represents is a museum. With the vast amounts of electronics available to the public, people, especially of a younger age, find less time to visit a museum and to learn about their heritage. The results of nationwide poll conducted as a part of the survey of public participation in the arts shows that “21% of adults in 2013 visited” an museum, which is drastically lower than previous nears and is predicted to continuously drop

    Read More

  • Berger's Lens

    501 Words  | 3 Pages

    The mere action of exhibiting can transform anything into art, which is termed the “museum effect”. The very placement within the museum context grants the object importance and validity. Who has the authority to define what is art? What mediates the relationship between the object and the museum visitor? How do we interpret the interesting assertion by Professor Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett—"[in the museum] objects are not found, they are made"?

    Read More

  • Dbq Essay On A Museum

    633 Words  | 3 Pages

    Museums are located all over the world. They contain pieces and artifacts that are intriguing and educational. Everyday people visit museums and embrace everything it provides. The process of retrieving artifacts, representing culture and running a museum is difficult. There are many factors that go into the the exhibits and picking the right pieces.

    Read More

  • What Are The Ethical Issues In The Smithsonian Board Of Regents

    1065 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Smithsonian Board of Regents and the boards of many other western museums are facing a crisis regarding the ethics of our collections. With public sentiment towards art repatriation growing increasingly positive and countries and people groups calling for their cultural art and artifacts to be returned, museums have to face this issue head on. The Smithsonian Board of Regents, as the group responsible for overseeing the Smithsonian Institute, will have to tackle issues of repatriation as well as handle the need for more diversity within museum leadership. The Institute as a whole has already begun the process of repatriation throughout its museums. Recently, the Smithsonian authorized its constituent museums to begin returning items from

    Read More

  • The Trouble With (The Term) Art By Carolyn Dean

    791 Words  | 4 Pages

    While reading “The Trouble with (the Term) Art,” written by Carolyn Dean in the summer of 2006, we are taken through an array of different scenarios that lead us to questions what art really is. Dean explores the idea that the word “art” is used far too often and too habitually, and that as we study the non-Western cultures we need to use much more discretion regarding what we call the different pieces of their culture. Throughout the essay, Dean supports her thesis that we too often categorize non-Western pieces as art by using different examples of how certain non-art pieces were deemed as art throughout the course of their history. Dean does this by using four key examples of how these ancient pieces are inappropriately called art to successfully support her thesis and avoid biases.

    Read More

  • Summary Of No God But God By Reza Aslan

    1449 Words  | 6 Pages

    The book deals with the history of Islam and provides arguments over the liberal interpretation of the religion. The book puts the blame on the Western imperialism and the self-serving misinterpretations of Islamic law by the past scholars for the controversies which are taking place within Islam. The work by Reza Aslan challenges the clash of civilizations. The book

    Read More

  • S. Buck's The Good Earth And The Possibility Of Anti-Orientalism

    1841 Words  | 8 Pages

    ‘The Good Earth’ and the Possibility of ‘Anti-Orientalist’ Orientalism In 1931, American author Pearl S. Buck published The Good Earth, an English-language novel depicting a peasant’s life in rural China. The novel was immediately a financial and critical success; after selling millions of copies, it would win the Pulitzer Prize in 1932. Buck’s writing was praised for its evenhanded and insightful portrayal of Chinese culture and society. Retrospectively, however, many scholars have criticized it as a well-intentioned but reductionist and Orientalist treatment of China. Using Said’s conception of Orientalism as an analytical framework, this essay examines and evaluates charges of Orientalism in The Good Earth.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of My Name Is Red

    1411 Words  | 6 Pages

    The book My Name is Red, published by Turkish writer Orham Pamuk in 1998 and translated into English in 2001, presents a story set in Istanbul during the reign of Sultan Murat III in the 16th century. Covering a timeframe of about nine days, two main events set the story forward: the murder of the renowned illuminator Elegant and the return to Istanbul of Black after being in exile for 12 years. Instead of telling the story from one single point of view, the plot is narrated by multiple people who are identified in the title of each chapter. Pamuk also examines the cultural tension between the East and the West by centering it on two different theories of art. On one side is the Western style of portraiture and on the other the Eastern miniature tradition.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes In Not Without My Daughter

    968 Words  | 4 Pages

    It is an ideology fabricated by the West, Its main factors are the "periodic exclusion of the East from the Western gaze and the continual repudiation of the East in favor the moral and cultural coordinates of the West (Martin & Koda, 1994, p. 9). According to Said (1978), orientalism is a product of the imagination of those people who come to know themselves, their culture and territories as European and later as the West. Said (1978) defines orientalism as a style of thought based on " ontological and epistemological distinction between the 'Orient ' and the 'Occident ' (p.3). According to Martin and Koda (1994), the West 's failure to achieve full comprehension of the East is the reason for the inscrutability attributed to the East.

    Read More

  • Islamic Art Essay

    1005 Words  | 5 Pages

    Art is the mirror of any culture and its worldly views. The art of Muslim world mirrors its social values and uncovers the way Muslims see the spiritual domain and the universe. Muslims all over the world embrace the identical system of belief and each one of them is well familiar with the spiritual connection regardless of nationwide, racial differences or conflicts. They consider themselves to be Muslim as a matter of paramount importance. This strong sense of identity and stability inclined en route for a high level of societal and richest artistic traditionalism.

    Read More

  • The Arab World Edward T. Hall Summary

    1443 Words  | 6 Pages

    Edward T. Hall was more than just a writer; he was an American anthropologist, and had researched and written on cross-cultural issues for many years. Hall received his Ph.D. from Columbia University in 1942 and taught in many American colleges such as the University of Denver and Harvard Business School. Hall also worked in many areas and field work throughout Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. Edward T. Hall had many other books such as “The Silent Language”, “The Hidden Dimension”, “Beyond Culture”, and “Understanding Cultural Differences-Germans, French and Americans”. Having so much experience and knowledge in this field gave Hall the authority and credibility to write about such a topic.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Quantitative Content Analysis

    1827 Words  | 8 Pages

    Methodology In my thesis I utilized the quantitative content analysis method. There are many definitions of this research method from different authors. Most of the definitions include similar principles. The research should be systematical, objective, quantitative and replicable.

    Read More

More about Construction Of Orientalism

Open Document