ipl-logo

The Early Purges By Seamus Heaney: Comparative Essay

1924 Words8 Pages

Comparative Essay “Midterm Break” & “The Early Purges” By Seamus Heaney Seamus Heaney was an Irish poet, who grew up on a farm. He writes about his childhood, nature, and in two particular poems, explores the theme of growing up. Whilst the two poems, titled “The Early Purges” and “Midterm Break” are both sad and thought-provoking in equal measure, I think “Midterm Break” portrays this the best in its symbolism, and the tragedy of it. Midterm break is about young Heaney, aged only twelve or thirteen years old, coming home from boarding school for the spring midterm break. However, instead of being greeted with a happy welcome from his family, he is forced to grow up very quickly after the death of his very young baby brother. Told from young Heaney 's own perspective, this poem is absolutely heartbreaking in the way it explores the theme of growing up, as well as the theme of, of change, and of death itself. I am fond of this poem, and prefer it to “The Early Purges” because of how Heaney deals with the theme of death, showing effectively how it strikes at any time, striking anyone, with it simplicity and finality, which Heaney further compacts using the punctuation and poetic techniques in this poem. …show more content…

It opens with a disturbing image of a six-year-old Heaney witnessing the brutal death of several young kittens, drowned by Dan Taggart, a farm hand on the farm where he grew up. This is a harrowing image, and shocks us as soon as we see the opening line. While this is beyond heartbreaking, and a very sad poem, I simply prefer Midterm Break, due to the fact that the death of a child, a sibling, a close friend, is far more distressing and more relatable to more people, due to the fact that sadly nearly everyone will experience loss of a

Show More
Related

  • My Papa's Waltz Syntax

    690 Words  | 3 Pages

    In stanza 3 states “But I hung on like death,” uses simile. It benefits the cause of alcohol that soon becomes tragic for the son. He’s gotten used to it that being abused, death can affect him. Additionally it touches people's ideas to illuminate the true meaning of the poem and to create a negative picture in the reader's mind that is shown by the son of an abusive father. In stanza 13 through 14, “You beat time on my head with a palm caked hard by dirt.”

    Read More

  • Halo That Would Not Light

    491 Words  | 2 Pages

    The title used by Lucie Brock-Broido “The Halo That Would Not Light” gives the initial thought that the poem will involve something about an angel that has lost their purity. The theme surrounding a fallen angel is hinted with the word “Halo,” as it is commonly associated as a ring of light above a holy figure. “The Halo that Would Not Light” is a short poem about the progression of a child’s adventures from the time the stork, or in this piece “raptor,” drops the child in the carriage through our years of imagination, and abruptly ends with, “is done,” death or maturity. Brock-Broido makes some darker word choices when referring to things of childhood such as “the raptor beak.” Most of us know the nursery story of a stork, symbolizing birth,

    Read More

  • Literary Analysis Of Louise Erdrich's 'Captivity'

    957 Words  | 4 Pages

    From here, a uniform mood and tone is set throughout the poem and can be seen heavily in not only the choice of words but, also the plot and structure of the poem. The theme of sympathy is really conveyed through Erdrich’s melancholic tone. Throughout the poem, we see a very gloomy and melancholic tone set by the events happening. “Until I could no longer bear / the thought of how I was” (51-52), these two lines portray her battle after she is rescued and how instead of her relief she is feeling a longing to be back with her captors. Lines similar to these two lead embody why the tone is so gloomy and sad especially when readers see the battle she is experiencing because she is safe now, away from her captors but, she doesn 't really want to be.

    Read More

  • Civil Rights Violation In The Poem 'Dago' By Sharon Olds

    1087 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the poem “there are things worse than death” where Sharon Olds choose to have a block of twenty three lines without any stanza break. In an effort to present the victims of such heinous act of torture to listeners effectively the speaker substitute herself and her son for the mother and son who are being tortured in front of each other 's eye by the Chilean government. Her empathy is real. She would like her listeners feel, and believe what she herself felt and rise up against such

    Read More

  • Symbolism In Trethewey's Elegy

    943 Words  | 4 Pages

    Trethewey immediately uses imagery to set the scene inviting your senses to help illustrate the image she has already relayed. This helped depict a more in-depth image of her poem “elegy”. After reading this poem several times, to build understanding, and break down literary elements; I came to the conclusion that Trethewey emphasizes the struggle to find balance. The balance between metaphor and symbolism, increasing throughout the entire poem showing battle between connotation and detonation. The struggle in which she used to connotation to portray the bigger picture, but also balanced out by denotation to show the subliminal messages of the relationship shared between the narrator’s father and herself.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of 'Ceremony' By Leslie Marmon Silko

    954 Words  | 4 Pages

    Introduction is a decisive part in a novel since it may introduce important key facts about the work to the reader. “Ceremony”, by Leslie Marmon Silko, opens with a compilation of poems, some larger than others, but all equally important for the novel. Poetry is found throughout the whole novel, however the introducing poems are the most powerful ones because they foreshadow what the novel is going to be about. They prepare the reader for what is coming next and introduce the major themes of the novel. This essay will analyze the first three poems and explain their importance in the novel’s foreshadowing.

    Read More

  • Just As The Calendar Began To Say Summer Mary Oliver Analysis

    539 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the poem “Just as the Calendar Began to Say Summer”, Mary Oliver analogizes two distinct tones. The first tone of voice Oliver uses reflects her negative ideas about the regimented school system. At the beginning of the poem there is a strong sense of what the speaker is going through. Oliver states, “I went out of the school house fast and through the gardens and to the woods,” (ln 1-2).

    Read More

  • Religious Allusions In The Raven

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    This assonance begins the poem by setting the scene. We are able to interpret that the unnamed narrator is in a terrible mood, is fearful, and his anxiety is skyrocketing. This is set at midnight, which gives a feeling of uneasiness. These dark terms are emphasized by the assonance to give the

    Read More

  • Human Condition In Gwen Harwood's Poems Father And Child

    527 Words  | 3 Pages

    The narrator’s changing understanding of the inevitability of death across the two sections of the poem illustrates the dynamic and contrasting nature of the human

    Read More

  • Ghost Dance Summary

    798 Words  | 4 Pages

    Realizing this allowed for me to analyze in much more detail what historical events and ideas some of the lines and the entire poem were referencing which made the poem more powerful to me. Being able to connect the different lines of the poem to things that I had previously learned was interesting to me. All of these factors were what made this poem interesting enough for me to choose this poem over some of the other poems that I had been considering. This poem delves into not only the meaning of the Ghost Dance and why it was used, but also the aftermath and reflection of it in the later stanzas. To fully understand this poem, the reader must have some historical context of what the Ghost Dance was and

    Read More

  • Stylistic Analysis Of The Poem Staying Alive

    1040 Words  | 5 Pages

    This poem has an apparent rhyme scheme. The last word in each line rhymes with the last word in the line directly under it. This lets the reader almost sing through the poem. There is a very nonchalant tone and feel to the poem. The lack of detail in the poem lets the readers imagination create the situation in which the person dies.

    Read More

  • Poem Analysis: Nothing But Death By Pablo Neruda

    1000 Words  | 4 Pages

    The poet compared the graves like a shipwreck that is the death will take the human go down and drowning to the underground like the dead bodies in the graves. The last line “as though we lived falling out of the skin into the soul.” is like the rotting of the dead bodies. The second stanza there is one Simile in this

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Heaney's 'The Grauballe Man'

    870 Words  | 4 Pages

    A Heaney Commentary Heaney’s collection of poems, North, solidifies the connection between myth, history, and the modern conflict in Northern Ireland. As a native from Ulster, the county where the conflicts spurred, Heaney feels responsible in trying to cease the violence of the ongoing war through paper and pen. The poet delves deeply into the history of his people with hopes to find redemption for his ancestors’ sins, and an epiphany to the violence enclosing him. The Grauballe Man, a literary composition from North, meticulously scrutinizes the iconic ‘bog body’ on display and presents his response towards the violence and chaos revealed in the piece of artifact. Exposure, the final poem from the collection, seeks to answer the fundamental question about the adequacy of his poems as he retires to Wicklow: was his attempt to impact the ‘The Troubles’ enough to hold the line against the violence and brutality of what is happening in Ulster.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Grauballe Man By Seamus Heaney

    1075 Words  | 5 Pages

    To convey the brutality and animosity of “The Troubles”, Seamus Heaney expressed his thought-provoking opinions in the form of poetry. His collection of poems called “North” specifically portray the violent and hatred of The Troubles during 1968 to 1998. The Troubles refer to the sectarian warfare and division between the United Kingdom and Ireland. During this time period, political infighting occurred and caused conflicts that eventually lead to a bloody and brutal war. The North collection utilises various historical context while also stylistically allude to the bygone era of the Vikings and the discovery of the bog bodies of the Northern Europe in order to emphasise the endless occurrence of brutality and violent events.

    Read More

  • Issues In Dead Poets Society

    718 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mr. Keating breaks the students out of their shells and they come alive. The students also become engaged after starting “Dead Poets Society” they begin to express themselves through poetry. 4. How do changes in the immediate situation affect the

    Read More

More about The Early Purges By Seamus Heaney: Comparative Essay

Open Document