ipl-logo

Minority Report: Free Will Vs Determinism

691 Words3 Pages

Does arresting someone before they commit a crime remove the perpetrator’s free will? What if they changed their mind? These topics are discussed at length during the 2002 film Minority Report by Steven Spielberg. The plot of Minority Report centres around protagonist John Anderton, the chief of a futuristic police department, that uses “pre-cogs”, humans who can see crimes before they happen, to arrest the perpetrator before they have committed the crime. This polarises audiences, who either believe that they have a right to arrest someone for planning a crime, and those who believe that everyone is capable of changing their mind, before committing the crime. One major theme in Minority Report, is free will vs determinism. Minority Report shows how quickly and easily, society can lose free will when trying to drastically change how law functions within a large population.

Characterisation is an important feature in Minority Report, used to emphasise the …show more content…

The example on the left is from Minority Report when Danny realises the truth about Lemar and is killed. In this scene, Danny is shown to be higher than Lemar, symbolising that Danny is judging this information, in the same way that a Judge sits higher than the rest of the courtroom. Danny is exercising his free will vs determinism by determining whether or not the information from Lemar is correct. Danny is also shown above Lemar because He has the moral high ground.

Minority Report by Steven Spielberg effectively uses characterisation and cinematic techniques to reinforce the theme of free will vs determinism. John, Agatha, and Lemar all reinforce this theme. As do the cinematic techniques, over the shoulder camera angle and framing characters. Steven Spielberg has clearly put a great deal of thought into how Minority Report will comment on free will vs

Show More
Related

  • Kira Peikoff

    426 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the article, “Beware the Biomarkers for Criminal Behavior,” Kira Peikoff analyzes the expanding use of brain imaging and biomarkers to predict criminal behavior. She describes the expansion of these technological advancements as a possible violation to an individual’s basic civil rights of innocent until proven guilty. Piekoff expresses that with these growing advancements in this technology a fine line between science and morality should be explored with caution. Our society today may consist of individuals with mental defects, but where is the line drawn in depicting a future crime without infringing on an individual 's basic civil rights. Peikoff provides three distinguishable premises in her article.

    Read More

  • The Brief Wondrous Life Of Oscar Wao

    754 Words  | 4 Pages

    Oscar understands that he is not bound by his embodiment of multiple histories and cultures; thus, it results in Oscar strong resistance to the burden of simplistic historical and cultural models. Even though his decision costs him his life, his decision benefits future generations of his family: they are free to be who they are, and they are not bound by predetermined cultural and historical boundaries of their

    Read More

  • Minority Report Vs Machine Bias

    535 Words  | 3 Pages

    (Angwin, et al.) What John, and Holder really means is the system of predicting future crimes, and who might commit them has many flaws, from accusing the wrong people, to basing predictions off biases. In conclusion, “Machine Bias” by Julia Angwin, et al. and “Should Prison Sentences Be Based on Crimes That Haven’t Been Committed Yet?”

    Read More

  • The Impossibility Of Free Will In The Other Wes Moore

    3797 Words  | 16 Pages

    BSTRACT All humans have the idealization of freedom and of choice. The given reason any person has this is their own free will. Giving them the option to say “yes” or “no” to whatever they please. There are no limitations to that, only obstacles and temptations. In Literature throughout history there is proof that free will can be taken away.

    Read More

  • Free Will In Opening Skinner's Box By Lauren Slater

    612 Words  | 3 Pages

    You see twenty dollar's fall out of a person's pocket, are you going to keep it for yourself or give it back to the unknowing person? The decision is your to make...not quite. In Lauren Slater's book, Opening Skinner’s Box, Slater studies B.F Skinner's experiments on reactions. In Slater's own research she meets Jerome Kagan who believes free will exist and even jumps under his desk to prove it. However, I disagree with Kagan's claim that by diving under his desk he is proving he has free will because he overlooks the fact that he was trained by his society to do so, people react based off operant conditioning and finally, determinism.

    Read More

  • Fate Vs Free Will Frankenstein Research Paper

    710 Words  | 3 Pages

    For centuries, scholars and philosophers have debated whether chance governs our lives, or our choices rule our destiny. History provides a multitude of stories of protagonists following the stars as well as others who decide their future. Beowulf battles enormous monsters, knowing his future is predetermined to win. Whether it be fate or free will, the main character always needs the guiding hand of a wiser individual. In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, the monster’s crimes are a direct result of his horrid circumstances.

    Read More

  • Mass Incarceration In America

    993 Words  | 4 Pages

    The US abides by the motto of “Tough on Crime.” Citizen and political leaders believe that by employing incarceration as a persistent threat it will invite people to conform to social norms and discourage in engaging in illegal behavior. Although data shows that high incarceration in neighborhoods results in a future increase in crime. The perpetuation and reasons of mass incarceration come from prejudice ideologies and attitudes that are ingrained into the fabric of society. People of color are targeted, arrested, and punished for crimes.

    Read More

  • Greyhound Bus Beheading Theory

    1058 Words  | 5 Pages

    The classical theory of crime says that people make rational choices when they commit crimes. “Individuals have the will and rationality to act according to their own will and desires. Individuals will calculate the rationality of the crime based on the benefits of the crime versus the consequences of the crime” (Robinson, 2014). This theory discuses that how people think about the negative and positive outcomes before they commit crime. Even though they realize it is not right, they still continue to commit illegal offence because they believe that what they are doing is for the greater

    Read More

  • Freewill And Determinism By Saul Mcleod

    669 Words  | 3 Pages

    The question of if humans are truly responsible for their own actions has sparked a debate in humanity throughout history. In the non-fiction article, “Freewill and Determinism” written by Saul McLeod, he compares the different aspects of freewill and determinism. Throughout the article, McLeod explains how freewill and determinism, while very different, go hand in hand with each other. To go with that, in the play Macbeth, written by William Shakespeare, many of the explanations in the article as to why people do what they do can be helpful when trying to figure out Macbeth's poor decision making. To begin the story, Macbeth was a trustworthy and loyal warrior for King Duncan.

    Read More

  • Crimes And Misdemeanors Themes

    1603 Words  | 7 Pages

    Philosophy in Literature and Films (HS3033) Assignment Sashank K EE11B124 3 November 2014 1 1 An Introduction to Moral Philosophy and some of its Theories Most humans judge the moral consequences of what they and others do. They classify everything as good or bad. Thus, ethical philosophy is a branch of philosophy which is relevant at some level to even laymen, who are not philoso- phers. All of us make moral judgments based on some preconceived or preexist- ing moral principle.

    Read More

  • Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Essay

    701 Words  | 3 Pages

    (2016). Imprisonment Inertia and Public Attitudes Toward "Truth in Sentencing". Brigham Young University Law Review, 2015(2), 257-305. Siegel, L. J., Schmalleger, F., & Worrall, J. L. (2015). Courts and criminal justice in America (2nd ed.).

    Read More

  • Fate And Free Will In The Matrix

    1133 Words  | 5 Pages

    Fate and Free will are both two ideas that have a questionable outcome. Whether one has free will or fate the outcome for both is unknown until the end. In the Matrix, the computer generated world which humans "live" in, it appears that fate is key. The computer system is prewritten, predesigned, and already programed. However, free will starts to take place in the minds of the individuals who begin to escape.

    Read More

  • Free Will In The Truman Show

    765 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Truman Show’s plot revolves around the average, mundane, daily life of Truman Burbank. As Truman goes through his seemingly normal life, he is unknowingly being observed by the vast majority of the earth’s population in the form of a television show. However, Truman does not know that his whole life is a lie that is being perpetuated by the creator of the show, Christof, who controls the outcome of every situation Truman is presented with. Truman becomes somewhat aware of the idea that his life may not be what it seems when a girl attempts to tell him the truth. Eventually through a number of discoveries, Truman finds that it is in fact true that his whole life has been contrived by Christof as a form of entertainment for the masses.

    Read More

  • Determinism Vs Free Will

    1777 Words  | 8 Pages

    Determinism, free will and moral responsibility (1681 words) Table of contents: Introduction. Blatchford’s view on determinism, free will, and moral responsibility. Schlick’s determinism, freedom and responsibility. Hospers’s position.

    Read More

  • Essay On 12 Angry Men

    557 Words  | 3 Pages

    12 Angry Men, although produced in the late fifties still offers a great slate for any viewer. The special effects and quality can easily be guessed by the black and white silhouettes of the film. The intensifying conflict of this film easily overshadows the lacking up to date criteria expected from a film. Many viewers expect a well-developed plot and characters with an accompanying use of special effects and coherent scenes. This courthouse drama has assigned twelve men to juror duty which will make this murder case mystifying by involving the viewers in the underlying theme of prejudice in the film.

    Read More

More about Minority Report: Free Will Vs Determinism

Open Document