“I knew it was my mother even though I had not seen her in all my memory”(Tan, 1988, p.44). This quote from The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan shows how An-mei’s mother emotionally distanced herself from her and was not a large part of her life. However, the families such as this one in the stories are defined by blood. That is where this starts, as An-mei picked up a lot of characteristics from her apathetic mother, which is why their relationship is the way it is. Within Amy Tan’s cherished story of the Joy luck club which goes into the life stories of each member of the club, the central theme is family and it focuses specifically on the bond between mothers and daughters. Tan repetitively uses the stories about mothers and daughters to portray …show more content…
Popo said to An-mei in the vignette “scar” of the Joy luck club, “Even your mother has used up tears and left. If you do not get well soon, she will forget you”(Tan,1988, p.47). This quote shows how her mother is known to be someone who does not show a lot of emotions because it is saying how it's rare that her mother will shed a tear. It also conveys how her mother doesn't hold onto her past and does not get attached to anything, even her own daughter. To summarize another quote that An-mei’s aunt revealed in the same vignette, An-mei’s aunt lost her temper and told An-mei that her mother had run off to be with a man named Wu Tsing and she was going to be his fourth wife. This says a lot about the values of An-mei’s mother because she doesn't value family as strongly as a lot of the other characters in the Joy Luck club do. This leads to An-mei and her mother having a unique relationship since her mother is a very flighty person who doesn't have morals when it comes to family, which leads her family to be displeased with her. In fact, Popo stated in the very same vignette “scar” that An-mei’s mother was referred to as a “ghost these days”(Tan, 1988). This meant that it was forbidden to talk about An-mei’s mother. Overall, the relationship between An-mei and her mother is very different from the relationships that other characters have with …show more content…
This is clearly disclosed in the vignette “Magpies” by a quote from An-mei herself; “I was taught to desire nothing, to swallow other people’s misery, to eat my own bitterness”(Tan, 1988, p.215). This proclaims how her mother has had an impact on her even though she wasn't around much to raise her daughter. An-mei probably looked up to her mother a lot which is why her mother was able to have such a great effect on her as far as morals. She influenced An-mei so strongly that An-mei was referring to those same morals when her daughter Rose was going through marriage trouble. An-mei feels that Rose should assert herself in the situation instead of doing nothing and feeling sorry for herself. To summarize the quote that describes the lesson that An-mei’s mother learned and is still relevant to An-mei, it is useless to cry, for tears only feed someone else's joy. This goes to show that even though An-mei’s mother wasn't around a whole lot, she definitely had an effect on An-mei’s personality and
cries Auntie An-mei with disbelief. ‘How can you say? Your mother is in your bones!’” (Tan 16). Jing-mei little by little understands her mother's ways after her passing.
According to Campbell, An-mei’s mother is a hero because she completed the hero’s journey: departure, trial, fulfillment, and return. She fulfills the hero’s journey when her status as a first wife was taken, faces an unhappy life for her daughter’s future, resolves it by taking her life to give her daughter a better one, and gets her status returned to as a first wife.
Although An-mei later learns to speak up and assert herself, she fears that she has handed down a certain timidness to her daughter Rose. An-Mei never knew her mother very well, and she didn’t want to be the same mother to her daughter. Growing up An-mei lived with her grandmother Popo. An-mei says at the start of her story, “When I was a young girl in China, my grandmother told me my mother was a ghost.
She then uses these “new thoughts” and ideas to state that she “won’t let her [mother] change” her into the person she seeks her daughter to be. When Jing-Mei experiences a realization that she is her own person and not simply another part of her mother, she can embrace the comfort of knowing that she will not change for anyone, and is simply extraordinary for having her own thoughts and feelings. This reflects how Amy Tan can understand her thoughts and feelings about the hardships in her relationship with her mother as a way to connect more closely to her characters and make them more realistic in her writing (“How Amy Tan’s family stories made her a
Just stop it” (Chua). The tone in “Jing-Mei Woo: Two Kinds” is angry and even hateful In this passage, it does not seem like Amy Tan, the speaker and daughter, shares the same affection with her mother. She even screams “Then I wish I weren’t your daughter, I wish you weren’t my mother” (Tan). Which the mother then replies “Too late to change this”
Kai Foote Martinez Sophomore Honors English 25 January 2023 The Sacrifices That Come with Love in The Joy Luck Club Amy Tan ’s novel The Joy Luck Club is about the hardships of relationships with different cultural beliefs and expectations and how they influence people. There are numerous examples of the hardships and sacrifices that mothers make for their children; these sacrifices teach and influence all the daughters to help them have a better understanding of the world and their expectations.
In the story, An-Mei has been badly burned in an accident perpetuated by Popo and An-Mei’s mother. While Popo is trying to give An-Mei motivation to heal and come back from “the other world” she says “Your dying clothes are very plain.”. . . “Our Morning time for you will be very short.”. . . “Even your mother has used up her last tears and left. If you do not get well soon, she will forget you.”. . .
“For unlike my mother, I did not believe I could be anything I wanted to be, I could only be me.” (Tan 24). With this statement you can see that she does not agree with her mother. Jing-Mei’s Mother was raised in Chinese culture, therefore she is very strict and demanding to Jing-Mei to do what she wants. From doing a chore, to hobbies or even Jing-Mei’s passion.
Tan expresses the life experiences of Chinese immigrants to the United States and attempts to depict the relationship of a mother and daughter through her significant piece of writing ‘The Joy Club’. Therefore, all these authors somehow portrayed their early struggles and their view point towards life from their literary
Jing-Mei’s American upbringing hindered her ability to understand her mother’s perspective – which was based on Chinese heritage – resulting in strong differences of opinion that led to arguments. In addition, since Jing-Mei and her mother failed to communicate effectively about their different perspectives, they became frustrated and upset with each other. The relationship between Jing-Mei and her mother was harmed by their emotional distance from each other. The absence of verbal affection between them translated to increased resentment and disappointment. Positive emotional connection between a parent and child proves vital in maintaining a healthy relationship in the face of
Thesis Statement about theme of literary work- In Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club, expressions of love and hatred are shown in multiple mother-daughter relationships resulting in negative impacts such as pain, bitterness, and regret because of their differing opinions. Support Point #1- Suyuan Woo guiltily leaves her twin daughters on the ground in China as she walks away in tears.
“After losing everything in China…She never looked back with regret. ”(Chunk 1 ¶3). Jing-Mei’s mother is a Chinese immigrant with the typical ‘everything is better in America’ mindset. Jing-Mei, being raised in America, had more of an American mindset. “You want me to be someone i’m not…I’ll never be the daughter you want me to be!”
Throughout the story, Jing-mei’s feeling toward her mother change in critical ways. As a young child, Jing-mei wants constant attention from her mother, going so far as agreeing to become a child prodigy. In the story, Jing-mei commented, “In fact, in the beginning, I was just as excited as my mother, maybe even more so” (Tan 221). This was before her mother becomes highly adamant about wanting her child to become a prodigy. As time went on, she wanted Jing-mei to become the epitome of a child star.
As a whole, while the story was very depressing at times, it still has an underlying tone of family ideals, as the relationship between the mother and daughter still remained despite the arguments they had. In my opinion, I think the author’s message that she wished to convey was that despite any event that may occur, family members will always be there support you. This is shown in how, despite Jing Mei’s failures at becoming a prodigy, her mother still supported her and did not give up hope on helping her daughter becoming a successful person. As such, it strengthens the idea that “family will always be there for you”, no matter what hardships come their way. In addition, it helped to add a sense of togetherness in the short story, as it inadvertently revealed how much Jing’s mother actually loved her, despite her tough exterior.
Tan expresses the changing connection between the main characters’ mother-daughter relationship through the use of metaphors. This is shown when Rose Hsu Jordan talks to her mother about her recent divorce with her husband, Ted. Tan illustrates this with the quote, “And below the heimongmong, all along the ground, were weeds spilling over the edges…” (Tan 220). The weeds spilling over the sides were killing the heimongmong plants, which was a metaphor for Rose’s confusion.