Motive Profiles Of Leaders And Followers
Understanding Personality and Leadership
Leader Appeal, Leader Performance, and the Motive Profiles of Leaders and Followers: A Study of American Presidents and Elections by David Winter examines the types of traits which are common in leaders and their followers with a look at three specific motives. With an examination of achievement motives, affiliation-intimacy motive, and the power motive one is able to analyze the terms of some of the greatest and not so great American Presidents.
The article starts with an introduction into what is considered the Weber-Freud model of leader characteristics and appeal. The idea that Max Weber had was that the charm a President had was related to the leader’s appeal to his followers. The leader is considered
…show more content…
There was a mix of previous data from Donley and Winter (1970) and Winter and Stewart (1977) which were “mixed together and newly scored by two trained and reliable scorers” (Winter 198). The other portion of this study is that of American society and this was taken from the work of McClelland (1975) who took documents from each decade, took 10 or so lines, and scored on the motives. This then allowed the comparison between the Presidents and American …show more content…
Every President when they run must have a social motive, whether they have it in the front or back of their mind. The most accurate line from this article is this: “Indeed, among American presidents it appears that the greatest presidents were those who were least congruent with the followers of their society” (Winter 201). This is an accurate statement which allows me to make the generalization that society does not always know what is best, as well as certain types of leaders are going to be better for the country than others. All leaders are different, but according to this study there is a general trend which connect the best with a different motive than those who are considered secondary leaders. Winter’s results were much in line with those of other studies he used as framework to build his analysis. Without the use of other studies, the explanations and use of his own data would have made his powerful conclusion of power motive leaders as the greater leaders inaccurate and unconvincing. While reading through the article and seeing how personality can affect ones’ social motives or leadership appeal and performance one can think back to the basic psychology principle learned in a Psych 101
Pros And Cons Of Truman
1507 Words | 7 PagesPresident Harry Truman was a successful president by definition. He was thrust into power as the thirty-third president of the United States after the rapid decline of President Theodore Roosevelt's health. This paper is organized around several major successes of President Truman, but mainly focusing on his twenty-one point plan of reform, also known as The Fair Deal, and the Manhattan Project. In regard to Richard Neustadt’s terms, a president should be evaluated on his or her ability to persuade. Put simply, it does not matter if any adversaries disagree if you are able to persuade them otherwise.
Ronald Reagan Ethos Pathos Logos
1799 Words | 8 PagesVargas 1 Ronald Reagan: America’s Leading Man Ronald Reagan, only movie actor to become president, was recognized for his conservative republicanism, fervent anticommunism, policies contributing to demise of the Soviet Union, appealing personal style, skilled as an orator which earned him the title “Great Communicator” (Britannica). However, Reagan did not get this recognition easily, he worked vigorously to obtain it. Reagan attained his start in politics in a televised 1964 address, in it he makes a sweeping critique of liberalism, big government, and federal payments (Encyclopedia). In this speech, known as “A Time for Choosing” Reagan used logos, pathos, and mood to invoke people’s feelings about making the right choice when choosing
Office Of The Presidency By Thomas Cronin And Michael Genovese
799 Words | 4 PagesWe want a down-to-earth and caring president, but also one that is ruthless or cunning when it is required. This paradox captures the situational leadership we expect, with a leader who can flex his or her style and skill when the situation changes. We admire presidents who are above politics, but it is a paradox that being president means that the person in the office is highly political. It is clear that the president is concerned about maintaining his office and helping his party, but we hope he puts the country ahead of politics.
Ronald Reagan Rhetorical Analysis Essay
1096 Words | 5 PagesReagan had faith in his ideals and requested advisors not mention the political risks of an action when advising (Sloan, 1996). One of, if not the most recognizable acts Reagan’s leadership integrity was when Reagan addressed the nation and took responsibility for the Iran Arms and Contra Aid controversy (Garrison, 2008). Even though he had not authorized the action, he did take responsibility for his administration’s officials. Positive charismatic leaders are seen demonstrating traits such as a socialized power orientation (Howell & Shamir, 2005). Socialized power orientation essentially states that the leader does not delight in their own personal power but instead prefers to share power among and with their staff.
Was Ronald Reagan A Liberal Or Conservative
570 Words | 3 PagesPaper 1 Ronald Reagan was and still is a very dynamic figure in American politics. Brought up on the values of the New Deal, Reagan underwent a major transformation in the 1940s and 1950s. His acting career dwindling to a series of guest roles on television shows, and a new conservative family chirping in his ear, Reagan would be heavily swayed by anti-tax and anti-government rhetoric. This shaped the cocoon for Reagan’s ideological metamorphosis and his entrance into the political spectrum.
Ronald Reagan's Advantage
150 Words | 1 PagesThis helped President Reagan because, as noted by Edel (1992), American people “form their judgments” mostly on what they see on television (p. 263). For the most part, peopled formed positive opinions about Reagan based on what he
How Did Warren G Harding Affect His Election
931 Words | 4 PagesOf the forty-five presidents the United States has witness, the one that has received the least amount of attention and recognition would be Warren G. Harding. During Harding’s short-lived presidency, Harding took part in scandals and affairs that decremented his reputation as a leader. The Harding election was the result of a much needed end to highly popular party boss politics that had great influence over the campaigns (Faykosh). Party Bosses were responsible for the corruption, fraud, and propaganda that took place during the elections. The problems that Harding faced during his election have shaped the foundation of our current political system and have allowed for presidents to learn from his mistakes.
Ronald Reagan Leader Analysis
1621 Words | 7 PagesRonald Reagan has to be an active leader both locally and internationally. He creates a foundation for this paper where I choose to critically analyze his achievements and his leadership drive and qualities. He has to be a motivation for many young leaders and the upcoming generation. He had the zeal to facilitate both peace and development in the United States. It is, therefore, important to note that Ronald Reagan will be the central focus for this leader analysis paper.
Rise Of The Plebiscitary Presidency Summary
438 Words | 2 PagesHis power of persuasion failed to succeed. Although Neustadt is correct when arguing that the power of persuasion is key, Rimmerman is correct when fiercely arguing that presidential power cannot dominate. One person cannot run this country alone, and should not be the only one making decisions that influence the lives of every single
James Barber's The Presidential Character: Predicting Performance In The White House
1558 Words | 7 PagesCritique of James Barber’s The Presidential Character: Predicting Performance in the White House Kristen Reicks Wartburg College February 14, 2023 When reading The Presidential Character, I saw a common theme: James Barber tried to implement various predicaments on how a president’s personality could impact his job at the White House. Patterns in personality from a person’s character, view of the world, and style were the overall themes that Barber examined in this book, although letting the readers understand these themes through scientific angles. I was hesitant to venture onward because of how he wanted to dissect past presidents’ personalities and what they achieved in Office.
Skowronek Pursuit Of Presidential Power
1781 Words | 8 PagesSuddenly, in the 1950s, Richard Neustadt revolutionized the established, constitutional view by breathing life into the presidency, disclosing the fact that much about Presidents were “off the books” and “behind the scenes” to the public. This new lens forgoes the constitutional viewpoint, and redefines the presidency in one phrase: “the pursuit of presidential power… is good for the country as well as for him” (Nelson 2010). It is now the person controlling the office rather than the office dictating and constraining the man within it. Moreover, he emphasizes the notion “presidential power is the power to persuade” (Nelson 2010). This concept is seen when one consider President Obama, the professor who sought to explain complex policy to
Richard Nixon Rhetorical Analysis
938 Words | 4 PagesOn August 8th, 1974 at exactly 9:01 pm, Richard Nixon--former President-- gave a speech that would affect both United States history and the american people. Richard Nixon’s argument and claim lay within the textual aspects, in other words, his tone, attitude, and the strategic ways of presenting to his audience. In this historical speech, Richard Nixon broadcasted his character, past decisions, and future advice to the people of the United States in order to justify his resignation from the presidential office. The rhetorical stylistic tools were effective and instrumental in backing up the argument. Recognition of audience was important, because it will determine his attitude and tone, which was innocence.
Leadership Theory: Leadership Thought Prior To 1900
760 Words | 4 PagesThose individuals who were believed to have these inherent skills were people of very influential status, wartime heroes and those of great wealth. The people who emerge or are most picked to lead have distinctive drives and character profiles (Nicholson, 2013, p.16). Leadership Thought Development from 1900 – 1970 The thought of leadership evolved from the Great Man Theory to Trait Theory and Behavior Theory. The trait theory focuses on identifying distinctive personality traits and characteristics that are associated to successful leadership.
Donald Trump's Leadership Style
1924 Words | 8 PagesIn spite of the fact that’ leadership analysis’ is the art of breaking down a leader into basic psychological components for study and use by academics and practitioners, a sound leadership analyses
Self Reflection Paper On Leadership
1818 Words | 8 PagesThis paper will examine the three leadership theories, identify how they apply to my practice, and explore how these theories interact with each other. The Trait Leadership Theory is based on the belief that a person is born with special traits contributing to natural leadership abilities. Studies of famous historical leaders have been used to identify various traits for this theory. Although the list of traits differs from study to study, there are five major traits that are consistent throughout most studies.
More about Motive Profiles Of Leaders And Followers
Pros And Cons Of Truman
1507 Words | 7 PagesRonald Reagan Ethos Pathos Logos
1799 Words | 8 PagesOffice Of The Presidency By Thomas Cronin And Michael Genovese
799 Words | 4 PagesRonald Reagan Rhetorical Analysis Essay
1096 Words | 5 PagesWas Ronald Reagan A Liberal Or Conservative
570 Words | 3 PagesRonald Reagan's Advantage
150 Words | 1 PagesHow Did Warren G Harding Affect His Election
931 Words | 4 PagesRonald Reagan Leader Analysis
1621 Words | 7 PagesRise Of The Plebiscitary Presidency Summary
438 Words | 2 PagesJames Barber's The Presidential Character: Predicting Performance In The White House
1558 Words | 7 PagesSkowronek Pursuit Of Presidential Power
1781 Words | 8 PagesRichard Nixon Rhetorical Analysis
938 Words | 4 PagesLeadership Theory: Leadership Thought Prior To 1900
760 Words | 4 PagesDonald Trump's Leadership Style
1924 Words | 8 PagesSelf Reflection Paper On Leadership
1818 Words | 8 Pages