ipl-logo

Murray Hooper's Conviction Of Forensic Evidence

661 Words3 Pages

In its third execution of 2022, Arizona executed Murray Hooper for a 1980 crime that was never analyzed using modern forensic methods. In the days preceding his execution, his attorneys continued to request DNA testing and pursued new claims of prosecutorial misconduct based on evidence not revealed until Hooper’s clemency hearing. All challenges to his conviction and death penalty have failed.

In an investigative report published the day before Hooper’s scheduled execution, Liliana Segura of The Intercept reviewed the issues of race, misconduct, and innocence that have been central to Hooper’s legal challenges. In an interview with Segura, Hooper continued to protest his innocence and wanted his story told even if he was executed. “Even if …show more content…

The prosecution alleged that Hooper and two codefendants, William Bracy and Edward McCall, were hired to kill Patrick in a plan to take over his graphic design business. His conviction relied on the testimony of government informants and the eyewitness testimony of Marilyn Redmond, Patrick’s wife, who was injured but survived.

While Hooper was awaiting trial in an unrelated Illinois murder case, Marilyn Redmond was brought to Chicago to identify him in a lineup. Despite conflicting descriptions of her attackers, Redmond picked Hooper out of the lineup. Hooper was sentenced to death in the Illinois case despite his allegations of police brutality that led to a false confession. Eventually, the judge in the Illinois murder case would go to prison for corruption, police officers in the case would be implicated in a pattern of police torture, and Hooper’s conviction would be vacated because of discrimination in jury …show more content…

When defense attorneys sought relief because this withheld evidence supported earlier claims about the unreliability of eyewitness testimony, the prosecution claimed that a mistake had been made and that no photo lineup existed.

Defense attorneys had also pursued DNA and fingerprint testing of items at the crime scene, citing a recent Arizona law expanding access to testing in old cases. All requests for testing were denied.

At Hooper’s clemency hearing, defense attorneys continued to focus on his innocence claim: presenting testimony about unreliable eyewitness testimony, the misconduct throughout his case, and the absence of any physical evidence linking him to the crime. Hooper’s advanced age (76) and his lack of disciplinary issues while in prison were also

Show More
Related

  • David Eulitt's Case Summary

    464 Words  | 2 Pages

    This story comes to us from the little town of Olathe Kansas via the Los Angeles Times. However, this story was also on the front-page of The New York Times. Our author, David Eulitt, leads with the defendant telling jurors he didn 't care what sentence was handed down. The author continues, Johnson County District Attorney Steve Howe had urged the jury to recommend a death sentence. The jury convicted 74-year-old Frazier Glenn Miller Jr. of capital murder for the April 2014 shootings, Eulitt notes.

    Read More

  • Testimony V. Nealy: Lack Of Physical Evidence

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    However, the jury in Mr. Nealy trial heard the entire case, including both eye-witnesses’ and found their testimony to be credible. Mr. Nealy is very ardent in his believe that he is innocent and consistently throughout his trial argued with his attorney about how to proceed in the case because he did not feel that his attorney was going about his defense properly. Those arguments are on the record. In fact, in a pre-trial hearing Mr. Nealy moved to have his trial counsel dismissed. However, the court denied that motion and Mr. Nealy trial counsel was very active during the trial, objecting often and making several extensive arguments at bench conferences on behave of Mr.

    Read More

  • Georgia V. Gregg Case Study

    1054 Words  | 5 Pages

    This case helped clarify that the death penalty (capital punishment) is constitutional as long as the charges brought on by the conviction and the judicial proceedings do not violate the 8th amendment and in this case, the death penalty does not automatically violate. The penalty cannot be “excessive” and cannot be completely inappropriate for the severity of the crimes, and in this case, the crime itself was murder. The main impact was that the state of Georgia’s decision on capital punishment was constitutional as long as the procedures involved in the decision of the case didn’t violate the constitution (and the crime being tried was a severe crime in itself and that the penalty was not excessive in comparison to the crime committed) and in response, 35 of the state’s legislatures changed their death penalty statute, so that their state’s procedures could carefully and judiciously help aid in a jury reaching a decision on the death penalty following this case. Gregg was the first criminal tried by both state and supreme courts whose death sentence was upheld and not

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Jason Stockley Murder Case

    806 Words  | 4 Pages

    Judge Wilson had been judging the DNA evidence and had decided that it was inclusive even though the state’s evidence says, although Smith’s fingerprints are not founded on the gun allegedly in his car, it does not prove that he never handled the gun. Judge Wilson’s final statement was that the court has come to conclusion that an urban heroin dealer not in possession of a firearm would be an anomaly. The newspaper feels that the term “urban” is frequently used as a racial code word and that Wilson expects a black heroin dealer to carry a firearm. Smith’s history of drug dealing should not be pre-judged by Wilson to make his final decision on the murder case. They say there is a biased ruling in favor that a white police officer who killed a (very likely unarmed) black man and that no justice is served to the victims, their families and any American who is fighting for greater racial equality in the justice system.

    Read More

  • Miranda V. Arizona Case Study

    893 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Miranda v. Arizona” is a case that was presented in the high court in the United States of America. The case addresses four distinct cases that may be considered identical. Each of the four cases involved defendants who were interrogated by the police officers, prosecuting attorney or detectives where they were forced to give information about various crimes committed as they were identified as the suspects. Miranda, who was a Mexican immigrant, was identified by a Phoenix woman as one of the perpetrators who kidnapped and raped her. This resulted to an arrest that was followed by a police interrogation that was carried out for two hours (Vander, & Kamisar, 2013).

    Read More

  • Comparing The Red Scare And West Memphis Three

    1167 Words  | 5 Pages

    When the quiet Arkansas town was perturbed by the murder of three young boys, a scapegoat was necessary. The town had never had to deal with any terrible situation of such degree before. In order to ensure someone was punished for the murders, the prosecution pursued a group of three boys who “fit the part” so to speak. Simply because they were unintelligent or wore black, they were prosecuted and, perhaps, wrongfully convicted for twenty years. It is impossible to say whether the conviction of the boys was wrongful, and therein lies the problem.

    Read More

  • Executed Black Ladies Summary

    665 Words  | 3 Pages

    This article analyzes the systemic abuse of executed Black ladies from the most punctual periods of American history. The most reliable consider Black female executions all through U.S. history is criminal equity specialists ' executions of Black ladies to a great extent for testing gendered what 's more, bigot abuse. This article also promotes our comprehension of the crossing point between gendered prejudice and the death penalty in the U.S. criminal equity framework by inspecting the relevant eccentricities offering ascend to Black female executions since the most punctual times of American history. From the times of servitude in which dark individuals were viewed as property, during that time of lynching’s and Jim Crow laws, the death penalty has dependably been profoundly influenced by race.

    Read More

  • The Outcome Of Eroy Brown's Trial

    1493 Words  | 6 Pages

    Eroy Brown was a convicted murderer who faced several trials throughout his life. The outcome of his trials was influenced by several factors, including the evidence presented in court, the jurors’ biases, and the actions of the prosecution and defense. One of the most significant factors that influenced the outcome of Eroy Brown’s trials was the evidence presented in court. In some cases, the evidence was conclusive and left no doubt as to Brown’s guilt or innocence. For example, in one of his trials, Brown was convicted of murdering a fellow inmate based on eyewitness testimony and physical evidence found at the scene of the crime.

    Read More

  • Two Convictions: Did Sam Sheppard Get Away With Murder?

    2967 Words  | 12 Pages

    Lady Houk was also named a suspect in the death of Marilyn. Cooper et al. reports, that during Eberling’s Testimony he tells the police that Sheppard told him that lady Houk killed Marilyn in a fit of jealous rage. He claims once the Sheppard’s guest left, lady Houk and her husband snuck over. Lady Houk intoxicated witness Marilyn and her husband hugging and went crazy.

    Read More

  • Felony Murder Rule Research Paper

    1805 Words  | 8 Pages

    (2014). The Trayvon Martin Trial - Two Comments and an Observation. The John Marshall Law Review, 47(4), 11th ser. Retrieved February 21, 2018, from https://repository.jmls.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://scholar.google.com/&httpsredir=1&article=2086&context=lawreview.

    Read More

  • Innocence Project Thesis

    1227 Words  | 5 Pages

    Out of the 337 cases where innocent men and women were wrongfully imprisoned nearly half of the true suspects were identified and convicted. The racial heritage of those who have been exonerated is fairly diverse, consisting of “206 African Americans, 104 Caucasians, 25 Latinos, and 2 Asian Americans” (The Innocence Project). (Transition) Although The Innocence Project has changed the lives of many who others would not afford them the opportunity to prove their innocence, they would not have been able to do so without the recent

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Just Mercy

    668 Words  | 3 Pages

    Stevenson closely examines the role of racism in the criminal justice system showing how America’s past still haunts the present. Through his experiences as a lawyer, he recognizes

    Read More

  • Example Of Annotated Bibliography Essay

    883 Words  | 4 Pages

    Annotated Bibliography #1 Working Research Question:     Should the U.S. Judical branch take action to prevent wrongful convictions and improve police investigations, or should the government spend its time and resources on other things? Bibliographic Entry: Hunt, B. Problems in the Criminal Justice System. Retrieved September 22, 2017, from http://mtabolitionco.org/issues/problems/ Source Summary:     This article is all about the issues in the U.S. criminal, from the outdated technology through racism. Also it talks about the origin of why and how all of these issues came about and potential ways to solve the problems.

    Read More

  • The Struggle Of The Black Community In Just Mercy By Bryan Stevenson

    1142 Words  | 5 Pages

    Walter McMillan was guilty of one thing and one thing only: having an affair with a white woman. At the time, this was seen as very scandalous, the Civil Rights Movement had ended but the deeply ingrained racism in the South had not. Because of this, Walter McMillan, known by many as Johnny D., was shunned and mistreated to the point that when a murder he didn’t commit was pinned on him no one thought twice about whether or not he could have done it. The Justice Department handled the case poorly by not fact checking witness testimonies, illegally moving the prisoner to death row without a conviction, intimidating a witness before a trial to convince him to lie, and so much more. One day Walter McMillan and several other prisoners get a visit from an upstart lawyer named Bryan Stevenson, a man who had just started a federally funded program known as the Equal Justice Initiative to help men like Walter.

    Read More

  • Annotated Bibliography On Death Penalty

    1145 Words  | 5 Pages

    Another issue that was discussed is the inequality of death penalty in practice. There have been serious issues with racial discrimination. For reference in cases with white victims and black defendants convictions occurred twenty two percent of the time while with black victims and white defendants with percentage dropped to a measly three

    Read More

More about Murray Hooper's Conviction Of Forensic Evidence

Open Document