ipl-logo

Naomi Shahab Nye's Going Where I M Coming From

728 Words3 Pages

Naomi Shahab Nye and Maria are from completely different stories, but something not a lot of people know is how similar, but as well very different, the characters are. Naomi is from the story "Going Where I'm Coming From." In this story, Naomi and her family move from
Missouri to Jerusalem. Naomi hates it in Jerusalem, but once she leaves back to the U.S her idea of home had changed forever. Maria is from T"he Sound of Music." In that story Maria training as a postulant nun, who gets sent away to be the caretaker of the Von Trapp children of 7. At first she is uneasy about her life there, but she soon grows much love for the children, and the captain, and she becomes the mother of the children and the wife on the captain. Both Naomi and Maria …show more content…

Maria has to move from the Abbey to the Von Trapp home, and she is very nervous that they won't accept or like her. When she first arrives to the the home the kids are not very friendly and the captain is extremely intimidating, with his overly restricted rules and customs. Naomi faces something very similar. When Naomi arrives in Jerusalem she is extremely upset and immediately does not like it there. She becomes very depressed and homesick. Both of their moves to new places are rough and rocky. The way Maria and Naomi adapt to their new life is quite different. Maria tries her very best to get the kids to like her. After not very much time, the kids become very attached and close to Maria. Maria then teaches the kids how to sing, and she takes them on fun adventures all over the city making her relationship with the kids even better. Unlike Maria, Naomi does not end up adapting to life in Jerusalem. Her depression and hatred for Jerusalem just gets worse over time.
She has trouble going along with the strict rules and she stands up for herself, but that just causes extra trouble. When she goes to a new school she has a very hard time trying to understand class because it's in a different

Show More
Related

  • Comparing The Von Trapp Family And The Applewhites

    519 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Von Trapp family were very talented at singing, but they would’ve never sounded delightful if they wouldn’t have accepted Maria. Their acceptance to Maria caused their intimacy between Captain Von Trapp, and his children to become dense, and music to be conducted back into the Von Trapp’s house once again. Comparison: One comparison between the Von Trapp family, and the Applewhites is that they both took someone from the outside world, and allowed them in their residence. The Applewhite family decides to take Jake Semple, one of the main characters in the book: “Surviving the Applewhites”. Jake Semple the notorious tennanger, was kicked out of every school in his home state.

    Read More

  • Japanese Canadian Analysis

    739 Words  | 3 Pages

    The characters in Obasan seem to employ the restraint of emotions as a coping mechanism for the injustices they have to endure. Another striking fact is Naomi 's description of life in Slocan. Although she is sad at first that she had to leave her home behind (Kogwa 151), her account of life in a ghost town is not purely negative. She remembers enjoying Stephen 's music, the arrival of her Uncle, the changing of winter to spring, playing in the forest (Kogawa 140- 204).

    Read More

  • Journey In Richard Wagamese's Indian Horse

    1114 Words  | 5 Pages

    The time spend together was filled with pain and loss because of the firm hold of the residential schools. Saul was able to learn the history and beliefs of his people taught to him by his grandmother, Naomi, despite the lack of hope in his family.

    Read More

  • Lack Of Communication In Judith Guest's Ordinary People

    686 Words  | 3 Pages

    She creates stories and makes assumptions. She also prefers to talk, not listen. For example, when Beth and Calvin go to play golf, Calvin tells Beth that Conrad “needs to know that you don’t hate him”. She gets defensive immediately and starts to accuse Conrad of telling lies to his father, convinced that Conrad is against her. She shows signs of violence, including labeling Instead, she should control her stories and presume that people are basically good.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Gate A-4 By Naomi Shihab Nye

    1002 Words  | 5 Pages

    As the author spends time with the Palestinian lady, they start to know each other better. “We called up her son, I spoke with him in English. I told him I would stay with his mother till we got on the plane. She talked to him.” The quote showed that Naomi was trying to help the lady feel more comfortable bu using her own precious time to take care of the Palestinian woman.

    Read More

  • The Mighty Miss Malone Character Analysis

    882 Words  | 4 Pages

    The novel The Mighty Miss Malone ​is a beautiful story about a normal family living during the great depression, Deza Malone's family has the motto "We are a family on a journey to a place called Wonderful" and Deza is consistently marked in her school as someone who is sure to go far in life. However, when the Great Depression hits Deza's hometown of Gary, Indiana, her father loses his job and must travel abroad in order to find work. Her mother uproots the family and goes out in search of Deza's father, with Deza and her brother ending up in a Hooverville outside Flint, Michigan. As life continues to go on, Deza's brother Jimmie leaves the camp in the hopes of becoming a performer while Deza and her mother try to carry on in the hopes of

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The West Side Story

    1841 Words  | 8 Pages

    Anita and Maria are the female lead actresses in the West Side Story. While Anita was described as fiery, intelligent, and bold, Maria is described as a naive young woman from

    Read More

  • Hardships In The Glass Castle

    882 Words  | 4 Pages

    Overcoming advers requires being brave and noble. Also, being able to look on the positive side in life in tough situations. Overcoming illnesses, disabilities, or disfunctional families can be very hard to deal with. Sometimes you just need to keep going and not look back and by doing so a lot more opportunities may appear in life. Christy Brown in My Left Foot, Bethany Hamilton, and Jeanette Walls in The Glass Castle are all examples of people who had to deal with great hardships in order to push them to become the successful and mature people that they are today.

    Read More

  • Half Walls Between Us Analysis

    454 Words  | 2 Pages

    First, Maria thought of the stereotypical views of a desert and living in a hut until she found out living in the desert is completely different. Living in the desert actually accomodates of half built, crowded homes. The streets are different from America, as Said says, “ At any hour of the day, one could look out onto the street and see a camel in midstep, a child with a finger in his mouth, a local tribesman carrying baskets suspended from the ends of a pole laid across his bony shoulders,” to describe the streets, but as any American knows that is not normal in the United

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Friendship In Recitatif By Toni Morrison

    805 Words  | 4 Pages

    At first, Twyla is not too keen on being roommates with Roberta, but as Twyla 's memory went on it showed the girls had more in common that she thought. Both girls were eight years old, they were not very good in school, and their mothers were still alive. This is what separated them from all the other girls

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Karen Cushman's Catherine, Called Birdy

    1239 Words  | 5 Pages

    Even though she is going to be taken from her home, she knew in her heart that she would always be at home. Catherine also says, “I realize that Shaggy Beard has

    Read More

  • Education In A Thousand Splendid Suns

    1130 Words  | 5 Pages

    Mariam longed to place a ruler on a page and draw important-looking lines”(Hosseini ). Mariam is an example of how women are banned from an education and whose life could have been changed by education. Instead of being educated, she is sheltered by her mother and lives the rest of her life without high expectations of herself. Nana teaches her that an Afghan woman has to endure the life that is chosen for her because she does not have a say. Nana even says "There is only one, only one skill a woman like you and me needs in life, and they don't teach it in school.

    Read More

  • Satire Scene In The Bell Jar

    1244 Words  | 5 Pages

    Shubkaran Kaur 100129968 Professor Crystal Hurdle English 103-02 March 18, 2018 Why Might the ‘The Bell Jar’ be Dubbed as Black/Dark Comedy? ‘The Bell Jar’ is a classic novel by Sylvia Plath which revolves around the character Esther Greenwood who falls into spiral of craziness and loses control of herself while she is in the pursuit of establishing her career. Her depression in the novel and struggle to explore herself not only makes the novel effortlessly interesting, intense and gloomy but also hilarious the same time.

    Read More

  • Theme Of Motherhood In A Thousand Splendid Suns

    727 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mariam’s character as being playful to Aziza and Zalmai shows that she is like a mother to them on the grounds that she played with them to bring about

    Read More

  • A Sicilian Romance Analysis

    845 Words  | 4 Pages

    Many years passed, the Mazzini sisters grow as talented, beautiful ladies. The Marquis return to the castle with his new wife and his son Ferdinand. The new wife Maria de Vellorno was impressed by the Mazzini sisters’ apartment and ordered them to move to another apartment closely near the southern portion of the castle. Julia and her sister feel restless in their new apartment for they heard strange sounds and observed mysterious lights came from the southern apartments.

    Read More

More about Naomi Shahab Nye's Going Where I M Coming From

Open Document