Meritocracy Inequalities And Elitism
Meritocracy is defined as a system in which power is only given to individuals according to their differentiated caliber. The maxim for meritocracy advocates would be “equal opportunity for all”. However, it is not always the case, as that would mean turning a blind eye to differences in genetics, social class, wealth, parental legacies and other educational opportunities. This gives rise to the many failings of meritocracy. Among them, the most serious problems associated with meritocracy would be inequality and elitism. This essay will address the individual issues and seek to find ways in which education can address these problems.
Before jumping on the bandwagon of pointing out the negative effects of meritocracy, it is necessary to
…show more content…
This is dangerous because the elites forget that their family background, together with luck and other factors play a huge role in bringing them to the position that they are in today. These elites become a set of specialized experts to whom key decisions are made through them (Hayes, 2012). Is it true that if social disparities and unequal rewards did not exist, those with capabilities and expertise will have no incentive to give to the society? One would think that that is a question that needs to be addressed by the elites …show more content…
One way to address the problem of inequality is to discourage competition. Competition breeds and highlights inequality. Young (1958) promotes the idea of an advanced meritocracy in his book ‘The Rise Of Meritocracy’ as one that avoids competition. The increase of formative assessments, where students progress with the help of qualitative feedback whose desired outcome is to remove ranking and numerical grading, is one such example. In Singapore, policies have been put in place to reduce high-stakes examinations and summative assessments in Primary 1 and 2. However, it is still probable that parents would enroll their children in external sports or performing art classes in a bid to secure placements for their children in the elite schools. Even though it is challenging to ascertain that parents do not send their children for additional lessons, with a reduction of competition and the rise of personal formative assessments, students can learn to become industrious self-improvers, accepting and implementing external goals (Allen, 2011). Using Finland’s education as an exemplar where there is only one major examination, students can benefit from being given more time for their examination so that the weaker students can also do their best. When considering examinations in a competition-sense, it often involves time and accuracy. However,
Common Core Standards Argumentative Essay
748 Words | 3 PagesThis is a key part in schools today because it’s enforcing a higher bar of achievement for teachers and students (Catapano, 2018). Implementing standards into a school system that are internationally benchmarked means all states and countries have a way of measuring their academic performance. They can use this also as a tool to compile scores and understand the weaknesses to improve students’ knowledge. This provides teachers with various ways to assess their students more frequently through observations and informal assessments to understand the student’s comprehension level of the lesson material. It will help the teachers to strive to improve her test scores by adapting lesson materials to the needs of each
Cutting Through The Hype Chapter Summary
1269 Words | 6 PagesHis goal, to close the achievement gap in his classroom. The consistent thoughts throughout chapter three is that the way to close the gap is to provide adequate funding. I am in complete agreement with David and Cuban that if policymakers continue to believe that the achievement gap can be closed by setting high standards but not providing the means to attain these standards, then the gap between white and black, high and low, poor and rich, English speaking and non-English speaking will remain! Summary Chapter three of “Cutting Through the Hype”, discusses not only the history of the achievement gap but also, where the idea of closing the achievement gap originated, what problems closing the achievement gap would solve, the question, does focusing attention on closing the achievement gap work?, and the solution to the achievement gap in their eyes.
Inequalities In The 1954 Brown V. Board Of Education Cases
171 Words | 1 PagesInequalities have always existed in society. These inequalities are often perpetuated through education. While the United States Supreme Court supported desegregation of schools and struck down the idea of “separate, but equal” in the 1954 Brown v. Board of Education cases, there still exists many inequalities within the United States educational system today for minority races and people of the lower economic classes. Ann Ferguson in her article “Bad Boys” discusses punishment practices in schools and the detriment these practices provide as they resemble incarceration. Conley in his article “Education” discusses education acting as a sorting machine and the tracking of students.
Theme Of Inequality In Of Mice And Men
1010 Words | 5 PagesThe main factor of wealth that causes trouble is the inability to create a better life. Most want success
Horace Mann Research Paper
1173 Words | 5 PagesMeritocracy has good intentions such that progress is based on ability and talent rather than class privilege or wealth; however, meritocracy cannot be practically implemented into school education due to social differentiations. Our society has and will continue to consist of a myriad of races, ethnicities, and minorities. Immigrant students who are from an Asian cultural heritage will be accustomed differently than children born and raised in America. Therefore, when schools implement standardized testing via the sorting-machine model or the high stakes testing model, there may be disadvantaged
Hidden Intellectualism Summary
762 Words | 4 PagesLevine claims that schools are starting to expand the quality of the student body by the rate of the students standardized test (22). Colleges are not looking to get students who do not apply themselves, but also, colleges are making it harder for the poor students that are trying to better their education. Along the same lines, Graff reminds us of the competition of comparing test scores in school (249). Graff explains, in school scores are made up by one’s reading ability, instead of, like in sports, the actual competition itself or arguing (249). Overall schools are using test scores as a way to compete with education instead of looking out for the best interests of the
Diane Ravich Solutions Start Here Sparknotes
933 Words | 4 PagesBy doing so, we can rely on assessments that allow students to practice and apply material in order to foster retention and mastery (Ravitch 261). Ravitch discusses Finland and how they completely reformed their educational system into a structure that has students take zero standardized tests until they reach the college application process, a method that was enacted to promote teacher accountability and place a stronger emphasis on the noncognitive aspects of individual development. A component of the basis for the argument, Ravitch states, is that while standardized testing may be effective when it is administered fairly, it often impairs students’ abilities to critically analyze information and leaves them practicing how to guess the “right answer.” Addressing this issue is a responsibility that falls on administrators and policymakers; they must be held accountable and required to make changes that best meet the constantly evolving needs of the students. In this case, completely modifying the concept of standardized testing is a necessity.
Michael Godsey's Article Inequality In Public Education
174 Words | 1 PagesEducation is a noticeable social establishment used to sustain the overall estimations of a general public. Many of us believe and expect that, education should be an engaging procedure that permits and assistants kids to build up their interests, basic considering, critical thinking, empathy, and introduction towards smartness for favorable activity. The article Inequality in public school by Michael Godsey, the U.S. department of education mentioned that, “equality in education is vital because equality of opportunity is a core American value” and integral to the country’s economic strength (P. 71). As I believe that everybody has the privilege to get the education and there ought to be equivalent open door for every one of the general population
Michael J. Sandel's Justice Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesAs previously stated, America’s current state caused the formation of a caste system that prevents talented, hard-working people from attaining success. In a just society, all people are given equal access to education and opportunities that they don’t get today. Our current system tries, and fails, to accomplish this through Affirmative Action, busing, sdfljgsad;g. This results
Private Ownership In The Movie Antz
893 Words | 4 PagesThe elites are responsible for all societal inequalities. There is a major power struggle
Examples Of Racial Inequality In Education
733 Words | 3 PagesMartha Peraza SOC 3340 Inequality in Education California State University, Bakersfield Abstract In the United States, there exists a gap in equality for different demographics of students. The factors contributing to educational disadvantages include socioeconomic struggles, gender of students, language or culture, and particularly for the scope of this paper, race.
Racism And Classism In Schools
1327 Words | 6 PagesRacism and classism management in schools today What if you were not offered the same opportunities based merely off of the color of your skin? What if your peers thought lesser of you because of how much your parents made? It may seem like something of the past, but these manifestations of racism and classism continue to lurk among the depths of schools across the globe. These forms of discrimination are still common within school systems, and continue to affect the lives of many students(Expereiences of racism).
Essay On Income Disparity Among African Americans
542 Words | 3 PagesAccording to the 2011 ACS, (Automated Collection System), the median household income of Dane County’s African American families was $20,664, less than 1/3 the median income enjoyed by White families ($63,673). These statistics showed the problem of income disparity between black and white families. This income disparity might have negative impact in all domain of the black population life such as education, healthcare, etc.…. Years ago, United States (U.S.) Public School was one of the best places that gave opportunities to children from different background and race to come together and be educated. However, with the occurrence of income inequality among Americans, the education system has changed profoundly in the way that today there is
Essay On Meritocracy
1403 Words | 6 PagesTHESIS: As a product of society’s “equal” meritocracy, we must find a scale for our actions by comparing our successes and failures to others, creating status anxiety, resulting in our idea of success being relative to our peer’s success. We base our own self worth and value too much on the outside influences and how others view us. We can no longer look in the mirror and see ourselves as we are, we unconsciously compare ourselves to what is “perfect” is based on ideals from our friends, family, and the media. We are constantly being presented with the image of perfection and the steps and rules needed to achieve it.
Social Class And Social Inequality
1443 Words | 6 PagesSocial classes are a form of social stratification that refers to the existence of structured inequalities between individuals and groups in society. A social class is a group of people of comparable status, power and wealth which are usually classified as upper class, middle class, and lower class. For each class, there are some specific opportunities available that influence their social life. We can understand about the particularity of the chances through unequal distribution of these opportunities between individuals in social classes. In here belonging to a social class seems to be an obstacle for some individuals to obtain equal opportunity, unlike upper class people.
More about Meritocracy Inequalities And Elitism
Common Core Standards Argumentative Essay
748 Words | 3 PagesCutting Through The Hype Chapter Summary
1269 Words | 6 PagesInequalities In The 1954 Brown V. Board Of Education Cases
171 Words | 1 PagesTheme Of Inequality In Of Mice And Men
1010 Words | 5 PagesHorace Mann Research Paper
1173 Words | 5 PagesHidden Intellectualism Summary
762 Words | 4 PagesDiane Ravich Solutions Start Here Sparknotes
933 Words | 4 PagesMichael Godsey's Article Inequality In Public Education
174 Words | 1 PagesMichael J. Sandel's Justice Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesPrivate Ownership In The Movie Antz
893 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Racial Inequality In Education
733 Words | 3 PagesRacism And Classism In Schools
1327 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Income Disparity Among African Americans
542 Words | 3 PagesEssay On Meritocracy
1403 Words | 6 PagesSocial Class And Social Inequality
1443 Words | 6 Pages