Outline:
Prescribed question: Which social groups are marginalized or excluded within Never Let me Go and why?
My critical response will
• Explore why are the clones the social group marginalized and excluded within Never Let Me Go
• Comment on how the isolation of the clones concludes on an exclusion from society and why.
• Comment on how the clones are not labeled as human, which excludes them from any human rights.
• Comment on the reason why clones exist and explore in which ways their existence marginalizes their reality.
________________________________________________________________________
Marginalization, by definition, is “the treatment of a group or concept as insignificant or peripheral.” [1] And “The exclusion of
…show more content…
Clones are stripped from a life to live and are used to serve the sole purpose of organ harvesting. The society created by Ishiguro recovers from the Second World War and therefore is not willing to fall back into a post-war health crisis; these people are aware that their organs derive from other living things and gladly accept them. “And for a long time, people preferred to believe these organs appeared from nowhere, or at most that they grew in a kind of vacuum.” [5] Which concludes with the global, or at least national, exclusion clones have within this society. People reject the existence of clones and are completely fine with living with the knowledge that they may, or may not have a body part that used to belong to another creature; a creature born and grown for the sole purpose of an organ donor.
In conclusion, the clones within Never Let me Go are marginalized and excluded through a variety of ways. Ishiguro shapes the world in which his characters are feared and thus, marginalized from the human society while, society itself, rejects the idea of them existing, twisting their moral compass and stripping the clones from basic rights; allowing them to live in exclusion from their surroundings for the purpose of living for someone
In the movie “The Island” the people of the world are not aware of the way by which they are being cured. The solution that is trying to be met is to have a way to cure anyone of disease or complication such as old age. The goal is met by the doctor in charge of the company making the clones, Dr. Bernard Merrick. He uses deceit to sell his clone/ product to people, while the people are unaware of how they are being cured (Source F) This as well as causing mistrust and isolation is an example of immoral and unethical behavior because Dr. Bernard attempts experiment all the products, which are somewhat human. Macbeth in the play Macbeth after murdering King Duncan feels isolated from everyone else (Source E).
Brianna Sauve Mods 7-8 English Research Project January 21,2015 Cloning is a topic discussed by many people. Cloning is controversial because there are both good and bad things about it. There are issues with the technology used in cloning. There are also scientists cloning embryos, animals, etc for research when that is not allowed. Cloning is tied to the story The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot, because it was mentioned in one of the chapters.
Acceptance is something Matt Alacran struggles with and he needs a lot of it. Matt the clone is low on strength because no one will accept him being a clone, except for a couple of people. Matt finds out a “dirty secret” from Tam Lin his bodyguard says that there is no difference between a clone and a human. Celia his adoptive mother loves and accepts Matt because she believes that Matt should be treated
What about this society has made them all like these clones? Well for starters the individuality. The books represented more than books they represented their own opinions, secondly how technology has affected connection. They replaced everything by advanced technology that were all programed the same. Lastly the information that was given to them was all given by the people of higher power and some government.
This narrative is about human clones, particularly, Kathy, Tommy and Ruth, and their experiences that are based on their fate. Human nature displays the repercussions of inevitable fate, psychological manipulation and uniformity in both dystopian novels. Human nature are general views that are colored by the influences of people an individual is surrounded by. In Never Let Me Go and 1984, fate is inevitable.
Sociology Analysis Paper Sample Analysis: The Breakfast Club The Breakfast Club is a film detailing a Saturday intention involving five very different students who are forced into each other’s company and share their stories. All the students are deviant in their own way and eventually are able to look past their differences and become friends. The film also offers detailed observations of social sanctions, peer pressure, control theory, and the three different sociological perspectives. The first principle seen in the film is a stigma, which is an undesirable trait or label that is used to characterize an individual. Each of the characters is associated with a stigma at the start of the film.
Never let me go, a movie directed by Mark Romanek, was based on a book of the same name written by Kazuo Ishiguro. It is set in an alternate reality where a breakthrough in medicine made not only human clones possible, but clones specifically designed for organ donation. The story follows the growth of Kathy H., a clone, from her childhood in the boarding school, Hailsham, to The Cottages, and through her career as a carer. It is revealed throughout the movie that the future of all clones is grim and inevitable, giving away all their organs until they go through “completion” at a young age, which viewer eventually learns is a euphemism for death.
In fact, the guardians were the ones that actually wanted to give the students a normal life. They didn’t want to treat them like clones. By giving these children normal lives they can tell that the clones actually do have souls and not treat them differently because they’re different. However this is not the case in ‘Frankenstein’ when Frankenstein rejects the creature because his is different going so far as to call him a ‘wretch’. A wretch is somebody that is regarded as mean and despicable.
In addition, Ishiguro utilizes the clones as a reflection to human morality. All humans face adversities in life that are inexorable, death being one certain source of trauma. When Tommy, Kathy’s boyfriend, must donate his vital organs and face death, he compares life to a “river” where “the current is too strong” and they will inevitably “drift apart” (Ishiguro 282). By comparing life to a fast-moving river, Tommy realizes that tragedies like death is unavoidable. Therefore, Tommy and Kathy cherish the time they have left together rather than anguishing.
That power trip in humans can lead to an unhealthy obsession. Scientist who create clones will have too much power, which will lead to them becoming so obsessed with their work that that is all they care about. In “The Birthmark,” Aylmer became obsessed with just the slightest flaw in a perfect woman, to the point where “when they sat together at the evening hearth his eyes wandered stealthily to her cheek…” (Hawthorne 2). Even when Aylmer was sitting, enjoying time with his wife, he was thinking about the birthmark.
In Frankenstein, Shelley wrote a story of how unintended consequences of science led to dire results. To support this notion, Shelley wrote a story of suffering in the scientific subject which is Frankenstein’s monster. This element corresponds with the idea of the neanderthal and human cloning. The neanderthal will likely face a very similar problems that Frankenstein’s monster faced. As mentioned above, the neanderthal clone will likely suffer from unforeseen health problems, and it will also likely endure a life doomed to be considered a freak by humans like Frankenstein’s monster experienced through.
Thus, the company are aware of the fact that the clones function much like humans do but refuses to look at the
Modern society has been able to come up with ways of cloning people which is similar of the idea that Huxley had while writing Brave New World.
Marginalization means the act of being relegated to a position indicating no importance. It is also the act of being confined to a lower social standing. In defining the term, "marginalization
The book, Brave New World, by Aldous Huxley introduces a theoretical world where life is simple and content. The new world is made up of human beings that are conditioned for predestined roles in what is called the World State. The World State uses a cloning process to create clones that are conditioned to perform identical tasks at identical machines. This process is one of the tools used to implement the World State’s motto: “Community, Identity, Stability.” This motto and world tend to resemble worlds of utopia, where everything is perfect and there are no highs and lows in life.