Night and Maus represent Elie’s and Vladek’s (Artie’s father)historical perspectives through the time of the Holocaust. Night focuses heavily on memories from the concentration camps, especially Auschwitz… one of the most notorious concentration camp. Maus focuses on life throughout the Holocaust outside of the concentration camps and measures taken to avoid being caught as a Jewish. Elie’s relation with his father is similar to Artie’s relation with his father during the beginning of both stories; both relations were distant. Though, both relations have differences. Elie and his father grew closer after suffering trauma through the concentration camps. Artie and Vladek never exactly grew closer; their relation grew more shaky. Elie’s relation …show more content…
Throughout the horrific experiences in the concentration camp, Elie and his father had to learn to look out for each other even when it was everybody for themselves. Towards the end of Night, Elie, his father, and other prisoners were on a “death” march to another camp to avoid being liberated by the Russians. The march was extremley gruesome, mostly because everyone was in such poor physical shape. When they had been resting at a small town, Elie’s fatehr kept making sure Eile didn’ fall asleep… falling asleep would risk dying from exhaustion. After arriving at the new camp, Elie’s father fell ill with dysentary. Elie would constanly try to take care of him, sharing some of his own portions and running to his side everytime he was called for. But, Artie and his father’s relationship was extremely different. Towards the end of the book, we see an old comic drawn by Artie showing his emotions after his mother’s death… showing his perspective of what hapepned after her suicide. Artie was displayed as a “prisioner”, showing how he was trapped in a state of pain and suffering from ignoring his mother. Even in the comic, we see Artie’s father constantly moaning and crying but never actually conforitng his son, pratcicially expecting his son to comfort him with him expressing in the comic, “We went home… my father had completely fallen apart!... I was expected to comfort him!” (92) Even throughout the book they slowly grew closer, at the end, Artie grew extremely upset with his father. Artie’s father had burned Artie’s mothers diaries, all of her memories. Artie would call his father a murderer for killling all remaning traces and anything left of his mother. To Artie, his mothers voice was forever silences, all her experiences in trauma erased from history. Afterall, to Artie, the diaries were her legacy. Furthermore, we see the difference in the relations; Elie and
When Elie was separated from his mother and sister at the beginning of the book Elie was only left with his father. When things got tough, they continued pushing for each other. They made sacrifices for each other and always made sure the other was ok. Elie had lost the rest of his family so his father meant the world to him. At the end of the book this is also taken away from him.
Elie and himself are becoming more apart as a result of his lack of involvement. Because Elie's father never engages with him, their relationship suffers and they are not exceptionally close. In conclusion, their distant relationship is caused by Elie’s father not spending enough time with
After the horrors Elie encountered, his relationship with his father changed drastically. Early in his journey, his relationship with his dad was distant. After being deported to Auschwitz, his father was being beaten while Elie thought, ”What had happened to me? My father had been
Elie questioned and changed both relationships with his fathers when facing immense hardship. The difference between the deterioration
Elie had been captivated with making sure he had remained with his father. He had not wanted to be alone and at any cost wanted them to remain together. By the middle of the novel, his father had weakened and their relationship
In the beginning of the story, they lean on each other as their situation in the camps gradually worsens. They share rations, comfort one another, and Elie even makes sure to keep his father from the verge of death by not allowing him to sleep in the snow, which would have inevitably lead to his death. However, as the book progresses their relationship deteriorates when the brutal conditions of the concentration camp forces them to prioritize survival over their previous bond. Elie starts to emotionally withdraw as he grows more detached and distant from his father. The loss of hope and the overwhelming despair of their circumstances takes a heavy toll on their relationship..
Furthermore, Elie’s relationship with his father worsened as they spent more time at the concentration camp. In this scene, Elie’s father is extremely sick after having been in the concentration camp for a long time. After his father is gone in the morning and assumed to have been sent to the furnace because of his poor condition, Elie expresses to the reader how he did not necessarily feel sad after his father got sick and died. While explaining his emotions surrounding his fathers death,
Elie has every reason to believe his father would be taken. Elie is becoming much weaker and is unable to work as effectively, yet he no longer regards his own safety as his utmost priority. This is the same Elie who had disobeyed his father’s orders in the past, the same Elie who felt that his father cared more about the community than him. Even after all this, he grows to have his father as such a massive priority for him, that he no longer thinks of his own survival as his number one priority. Elie desperately clings to his father as the last vestige of his former life.
Elie grew up without the same bond that many have with their fathers, and this resulted in him not being very close to his
This puts a big strain on their relationship. Elie is forced to take care of his father and make sure his dad is taken care of enough to survive. Elie gets very frustrated with his father for not being able to take care of himself. At one point, Elie even thinks about leaving his father behind to save himself. In this quote, "I could have screamed in anger.
On the train to the new concentration camp one guard commands everyone to “throw out all the dead … [ then suddenly Elie] woke [up] from [his slumber and] threw [himself] on top of his [father’s] body” to wake him up from his feeble state (104). This shows his commitment to his father because it showed what he was willing to do for his beloved father. This represents the choice of family commitment up to this point. His love for his father made him burst from his nap to protect his father from any harm, even though it went against the guard's order Elie protected his father, causing their bond to strengthen even more. Once they made it to the other camp their bond would become even more defined.
The main person Elie relied on while in the concentration camps was his father. Elie’s father was described as a very strict and unemotional man. Elie's father rarely showed emotion, even towards his own wife and children. “My father
When they first arrived at Auschwitz Elie and his father looked to each other for support and survival, Sometimes Elie’s father being the only thing keeping him alive. In their old community Elie’s father was a strong-willed and respected community leader, as the book went on you could see how the roles were becoming reversed he was becoming weaker and more reliant on Elie to take care of him. Their father son bond had always been strong and only grew stronger with the things they had to endure. “My God, Lord of the Universe, give me strength never to do what Rabbi Eliahou’s son has done” Elie was disgusted when he saw Rabbi Eliahou’s son abandon his father to help improve his chances of his survival he prayed he’d never do such a thing, but as his father becoming progressively more reliant on Elie he started to see his father as more of a burden than anything else.
When in the hospital, Elie got told the SS guards were going to mine the camp or the hospital patients will be finished off. All he could think about was being separated from his father. “I had made up my mind to accompany my father wherever he went” (82). Elie suggested to leave, because it seemed like the safest one of the choices. Later in his life, after the liberation of the camps, Elie learned that the Russians freed the people in the Buna hospital.
Comparison: Maus and Night are two books that share some common themes but approach them in vastly separate ways. Both are written in the form of memoirs and tell the story of the horrific experiences of their protagonists during the Holocaust. However, while Night takes an intensely personal approach, Maus is more of a graphic novel, told from a third-person, fictionalized perspective. Maus focuses on the relationship between the author Art Spiegelman and his father Vladek, exploring the complex emotions of guilt, shame, and horror that he and his father feel for their experiences. The novel is drawn in a cartoon-like style, with Jews represented as mice, Nazis as cats, and Americans as dogs.