Noble Lie Research Paper
Is the Noble Lie Noble? In The Republic, Socrates suggests a way to make his fictional utopia Kallipolis more just: systematically deceive the populace into thinking they are born in the Earth and have one of gold, silver, or bronze mixed into their composition. His idea is that this physical difference will lead the three sects of the populace to become (and stay) convinced that they must lead separate lives from each other, and not interfere with each other’s work, thus leading to a more just city. He calls this a “noble lie.” To avoid confusion, I will call his lie concerning metallic composition the “Noble Lie” and will refer to the idea of a good or useful lie as a “noble lie.” In this paper, I will argue that a noble lie does lead to …show more content…
Consider the fact that the question of this paper is whether a noble lie leads to a more just city (not the Noble Lie in particular). To answer this question, we need to know what a “noble lie” is in this context. Socrates divides lies into “real lies” and “lies in words”, saying “Aren’t there times when [lying] is useful, and so does not merit hatred?” (63). He goes on to conclude that Gods, being perfect, have no use for such contrivances, but he does not rule out usage by humans (64). Such a lie seems to be what Socrates considers a “noble lie”: a useful lie, presumably useful for some noble purpose. And a useful lie, as any other useful contraption, is useful to the extent that it achieves the purpose it set out to do, and the purpose of Socrates’ Noble Lie to Kallipolis was getting people to do their work and no one else’s work, indefinitely. Note that we also stated that the city is just to the extent that people do their work and not anyone else’s work, but there are potentially many things that contribute to this behavioral pattern in a city. That a noble lie is useful does not imply that it alone makes the city just, merely that it helps. However, we set out to ultimately prove that a noble lie makes the city more just, not infinitely just, so this is sufficient. Thus (2) is trivially true, and the argument as a whole is
Theme Of Self-Deception In March Of Folly By Barbara Tuchman
87 Words | 1 PagesThe act of self-deception is prevalent in common human activities and has been throughout many generations of societies. Barbara Tuchman conveys such act in the March of Folly, and recites, “Wooden-headedness, the source of self-deception, is a factor that plays a remarkably large role in government… it is acting according to wish while not allowing oneself to be deflected by facts.” Although not every decision made by man is due to this stolidity or “wooden-headedness”, it occurs frequently not only in governments, but in daily human
Socrates Argument At 50a-B Of The Crito
1118 Words | 5 PagesSocrates compares the relationship between a citizen and a city to that of a child and a parent. Athens has nurtured Socrates in body and mind, given him an ideal environment to raise his own children in, to give him a platform to exhort people to be virtuous (Crito, 51a). As any child benefits from the protections and provisions of a parent, he must also obey the parent when it requires something of him. So, Socrates considers it his civic duty to obey Athens wishes since he has benefited from his citizenship. Socrates reaches a conclusion that defies a common-sense understanding of
Rhetorical Analysis: The Ways We Lie By Stephanie Ericsson
710 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Most people tend to believe that lying is a way of life, that without it the whole world could crumble and fall. While some tend to believe that any form of lying is a sin and there should be consequences. One author, Stephanie Ericsson, wrote “The Ways We Lie” published in 1993 she talks about how we all lie, it has become an everyday chore to make life easier. She begins by trying to strengthen the bond between the reader and writer showing how they are one of the same. She does this by referencing past experiences, adding informed opinions, and using quotes from other well acknowledged authors, her argument is strong throughout the whole article that lying isn’t just evil, it can be used for good when used the right way.
Deceit And Lying In Homer's Odyssey
694 Words | 3 PagesLies are, whether detrimental or advantageous, are a staple of most civilizations throughout history. Deceit and Lying allow the furtherment of goals and the ability to cast ourselves as someone who may not be. Lying in Homeric Society was as prevalent as it is today, and many characters take full advantage of the ability of deceit. In The Odyssey, Odysseus and others take advantage of homeric social norms of lying and deceit in order to get what they want; furthering their quest and goal through their trickery.
Summary Of Trail Of Tears By Ta-Nehisi Coates
965 Words | 4 Pages“If I was not innocent… then they were not innocent. Could this mix of motivation also affect the stories they tell? The cities they built? The country they claimed as given to them by God?” (Coates 30 ).
Sir Gawain And The Green Knight Deception Analysis
1719 Words | 7 PagesIn the play Sir Gawain and The Green knight there are many different times throughout the book, that involve characters using different forms of deception. However; I think the biggest use of deception is when Bertilak uses his wife in order to test Sir Gawain’s loyalty, but also to achieve his motive, which was to cause Sir Gawain to feel as if he was a failure. Bertilak’s wife enters Sir Gawain’s bedroom on a mission to make Sir Gawain fall into temptation, and of course the first thing Sir Gawain really notices is Lady Bertilak’s beauty. “Her Face was sweet, Her skin was white and Pink; she spoke like birds, Singing, and her small lips laughed” (Page 95). This makes the point that beauty can be very deceiving, explaining why Bertilak would use that to his advantage.
Rhetorical Analysis Of The Way We Lie
1221 Words | 5 Pages“The Ways We Lie” Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Stephanie Ericsson, The author of “The Way We Lie” is a thought-provoking essay that challenges the moral values and ethics of society. Ericsson’s “The Ways We Lie” exposes the various forms of lying that are prevalent in society and employs rhetorical appeals, strategies as well as devices such as Logos, Pathos, and Ethos to get her point across to her audience. The author argues that lying has become a part of everyday life, and it is not only acceptable, but it is also necessary for individuals to succeed in life. Ericsson uses many rhetorical appeals as well as rhetorical devices to get to her audience to really understand her argument in the essay and purpose. Ericsson’s purpose in the essay
Socrates Definitions Of Justice In Plato's The Republic
1169 Words | 5 PagesAccording to Socrates there are two types of justice, the political justice and the justice of a particular man. As we know, city is bigger than a man. Socrates believes that it is easier to find justice at the political level which means in the city, thus he tries to define a just city from scrap, and will see in which stage justice enters. Also, Socrates tries to find justice in the city before finding justice in the individuals because individuals are not at all self-sufficient. We humans have similar needs such as food, clothing and shelter and in order to accomplish these goals human beings form unions, where each and every individual specializes in a field.
Socrates And Crito Argumentative Analysis
1382 Words | 6 PagesSocrates believes that justice benefits the just, but also benefits the city (other people) too. He is faced with a seemingly simple choice, escape Athens or remain in prison and be sentenced to death. Socrates’ central argument against escaping his circumstances is twofold. First, Socrates argues that “one must never do wrong.” (49b)
Comparing Othello And In The Time Of The Butterflies By Julia Alvarez
846 Words | 4 PagesDeception always has many perspectives; the truth, the fabrication, and how it is interpreted. An individual’s ability to deceive defines their effectiveness as a perpetrator. Within Julia Alvarez’s In the Time of the Butterflies and William Shakespeare’s Othello, the antagonists of each convey themselves as divine, therefore attempting to distract from their misconduct and represent themselves sincerely.
The Noble Lie In Plato's The Republic
1355 Words | 6 Pages“And if their [gold or silver] very ow offspring turns out to be touches with bronze or iron, they won’t in any way feel sorry for it, but instead accord it the honor its nature
The Ideal Political State In Socrates's Kallipolis
1504 Words | 7 PagesPHIL 243 First Essay Dogachan Dagi In the Republic, Socrates substantially argues that under right conditions Kallipolis which literally means ‘the ideal political state’ can be created. He presents very reasonable arguments about how to achieve and preserve the Kallipolis throughout Book V. However, this essay will strongly claim that Socrates’s Kallipolis is mostly not achievable, and if somehow achieved simply not sustainable. The main problem about his ideal city is the fact that too many regulations go against individual liberties and human nature.
Philosopher Immanuel Kant That Lying Is Immorally Wrong
704 Words | 3 Pages(Text.pg.116) Lies are morally wrong, for two reasons. First, lying corrupts the most important quality of being human: your ability to make free, rational choices is deprived of you the moment you tell a lie. Each lie you tell contradicts the part of you that gives you moral worth. Second, lies deprive others of their freedom to choose rationally. When your lie leads people to decide other than they would have had they known the truth, you have harmed their human dignity and autonomy.
Plato's Concept Of The Noble Lie
2004 Words | 9 PagesThe concept of the Noble Lie is presented by Plato in the Republic. In Republic, Plato is engaged in creating an ideal political community, through the noble lie. The Noble Lie, ironically, despite being a lie, is still recognized as ‘noble’ by Plato since it aims to promote social welfare and harmony amongst the citizens. Plato’s idea of the noble lie led to the division of citizens into three distinct categories, namely, the rulers, the auxiliaries and the workmen . This paper will argue that Socrates principle of the Noble Lie must be considered justifiable under circumstances in which it intends to achieve moral ends.
Lying Is Always Wrong Essay
1959 Words | 8 PagesLying is against Deontologist school of thought because it is irrational when following the categorical imperative and it hijacks autonomous decision making. The maxim followed is: “Lying is always wrong”. We must consider what this means for an argument - when is it attractive to lie, but we still must refrain? It is attractive to lie when we feel like we are trying to help the situation by skirting around the truth.
More about Noble Lie Research Paper
Theme Of Self-Deception In March Of Folly By Barbara Tuchman
87 Words | 1 PagesSocrates Argument At 50a-B Of The Crito
1118 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis: The Ways We Lie By Stephanie Ericsson
710 Words | 3 PagesDeceit And Lying In Homer's Odyssey
694 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Trail Of Tears By Ta-Nehisi Coates
965 Words | 4 PagesSir Gawain And The Green Knight Deception Analysis
1719 Words | 7 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of The Way We Lie
1221 Words | 5 PagesSocrates Definitions Of Justice In Plato's The Republic
1169 Words | 5 PagesSocrates And Crito Argumentative Analysis
1382 Words | 6 PagesComparing Othello And In The Time Of The Butterflies By Julia Alvarez
846 Words | 4 PagesThe Noble Lie In Plato's The Republic
1355 Words | 6 PagesThe Ideal Political State In Socrates's Kallipolis
1504 Words | 7 PagesPhilosopher Immanuel Kant That Lying Is Immorally Wrong
704 Words | 3 PagesPlato's Concept Of The Noble Lie
2004 Words | 9 PagesLying Is Always Wrong Essay
1959 Words | 8 Pages