ipl-logo

Not Justified In Andre Dubus 'Killings'

475 Words2 Pages

In Andre Dubus’ short story, “Killings,” a question of morality is brought up, can killing be justified. Richard Strout in an act of passion kills Matt Fowler’s son. Fowler plans his own justice by killing Strout. Are either of these killings justified? What are Fowler’s consequences for his actions? When these two killings are compared, the main difference is that Fowler planned and prepared for his murder while Richard acted in the heat of the moment. In the laws eyes that makes Fowler’s killing worse because it is premeditated. Each of these killings has a clear motive or reason but that does not mean they are justified. The legal definition of murder differs depending on where you are, but is best defined as follows, “the killing of a human being by a sane person, with intent, malice aforethought (prior intention to kill the particular victim or anyone who …show more content…

The fear of getting caught will also haunt him to the end of his days. This fear will even separate him from his living children for their knowledge of his actions could put them in harms way. The strain within the family does not end with his children but is compounded by his wife. She realizes what has happened and takes pleasure in the act that haunts him. This strain is not just emotional but also bleeds into the physical realm when Fowler becomes impotent, “She was holding him, wanting him, and he wished he could make love with her but he could not” (Dubus 1136). In an effort to fix a wrong doing against his family Fowler has exacerbated the situation. The killings in the short story, “Killings”, are murders. There is not justification for murder. The killings therefore are not justified. Not only is Fowler’s murder of Strout not justified but instead of bringing peace and closure to a grieving family, it inflamed an already infected

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Killings By Andre Dubus

    595 Words  | 3 Pages

    Plot Killings, written by Andre Dubus, is an example of a short story that closely follows Freytag’s pyramid. The story is largely focused on love, murder, and revenge. The exposition gives some background information on the Fowler family. This section explores the minds of Matt and Ruth Fowler as they try to cope with the death of their youngest son, Frank Fowler. In addition, Matt meets with his friend, Willis Trottier, and they discuss the murder of Matt’s son.

    Read More

  • Brenton Butler Trial

    753 Words  | 4 Pages

    Murder on a Sunday morning is a documentary assembled and directed by a French filmmaker Jean-Xavier de Lestrade. The documentary presents a case of a young boy who was wrongly convicted of a crime he didn’t commit. Brenton Butler, a 15-year-old boy, was charged with shooting and killing Mary Ann Stephens, a 65-year-old tourist woman, in a parking lot in Jacksonville, Florida on May 7th, 2000 (De Lestrade, 2001). In an attempt to protect their image and not scare away tourists, the Jacksonville police officers carried out a hasty arrest which led to the prosecution of the wrong suspect. 15 minutes after Mrs. Stephens was shot dead while walking with her husband, the police hurried and picked the first black suspects who happened to be available.

    Read More

  • David Herold's Murder

    981 Words  | 4 Pages

    No one deserves to die, and no one deserves death. Some executions are justified, but David Herold’s was not. Herold was a skilled and talented man who was deprived into a corner to help a killer. James L. Swanson’s novel, Chasing Lincoln 's Killer, a diary entry, “Last Diary Entry of John Wilkes Booth,” and an article, “Lincoln Writ of Liberty” contain evidence that proves Herold’s innocence. Herold did help a murderer; however, he is like everyone, in that he is susceptible to violent threats.

    Read More

  • Humanity In The Veldt And The Lottery

    1067 Words  | 5 Pages

    Although murder is the worst crime a human can commit, the stories reveal the true dark side of humanity when characters are able to justify murder

    Read More

  • Irony In The Tell-Tale Heart And The Lottery

    471 Words  | 2 Pages

    The demonstration of the narrator's imagination unconsciously leads his own thoughts to grow into a chaotic mess that ultimately ends in a death. By murdering, it’s his own way of finding peace. He is portrayed as being a sadist, sick man with an unnatural obsession for

    Read More

  • Murder In The Outsiders By S. E. Hinton

    635 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the novel The Outsiders by S.E Hinton, Johnny Cade is being charged with manslaughter. He and his friend Ponyboy were caught up in a tragic predicament in which they fought five drunk Socs. A lot of people say, “Johnny was in no case to predict what would’ve happened. Ponyboy Curtis was surrounded by five drunk Socs. It was self-defense.”

    Read More

  • The Slaughter By Matt Wolff Summary

    590 Words  | 3 Pages

    Matt Fowler, a man who cared about his children dearly, was the man who had to do the unspeakable, bury his own child. After his son was murdered in cold blood by the Richard Strout, the man whose Frank’s new lover was married too, we see how Fowler handles the brutal murder of his son. In the beginning Fowler reacts how any person would when it comes to the death of a friend or family member, mourning. He does nothing but sit around the house with his wife Ruth and cries, denying his friend’s plea to go drinking with them. Then he finally succumbs to the invitations when Ruth tells him to go out and take his mind off the situation.

    Read More

  • Matt Folwer's Murder In Andre Dubus 'Killings'

    1233 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Worst Crime: Matt’s or Richard’s “Killings”, written by Andre Dubus, illustrates how the death of a loved one may lead to dire consequences for all the parties included. Matt Fowler’s son, Frank, was murdered in cold blood by a jealous soon-to-be ex-husband, Richard Strout. When the death of Frank sunk into the lives of the Fowler’s, Matt believed he had to retaliate in some sort of fashion. The sort of fashion he chose was to seek revenge and kill Richard for his wrongdoings, which he did. Some people believe that the murder committed by Richard Strout can be considered more serious because of his act of passion and his lackadaisical style of living without worrying about his future.

    Read More

  • Brief Summary Of 'Killings' By Andre Dubus

    1141 Words  | 5 Pages

    “Killings” written by Andre Dubus is focused on the main character and protagonist Matt Fowler. Matt is the father of three known children in the story, Cathleen, Steve, and his youngest, Frank. Matt had his children with his wife and business partner Ruth Fowler. In the beginning of the story Matt is laying his youngest son, Frank, to rest in the cemetery after he was brutally murdered by the story’s main antagonist, Richard Strout. At the time of his death, Frank was in school and majoring in economics (63) and had a very bright future ahead of him, after all, he was only twenty eight years old.

    Read More

  • Why Is Jay Ison Wrong

    585 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the court of law, everyone is guilty until proven innocent. Thus, Hobart Ison was guilty when killing Hugh O’ Connor. Though by law Hobart was a murderer, many question that very decision. Though a killer, locals of urban Kentucky would argue that his actions are justifiable. Elizabeth Barret creates Stranger with a Camera as a tool to look into those justifications and see the reasons Ison murdered O’Connor.

    Read More

  • Revenge, Morality, And Justice In Killings By Andre Dubus

    834 Words  | 4 Pages

    Andre Dubus, short stories contain a common theme of revenge, morality, and justice. In “Killings” published in 1979, Andre displays the theme of revenge and justice through the development of characters, the title of the story, and the thrill of the suspense. Dubus neglects to take sides with the characters in the “Killings”, which leaves it upon the readers to make assumption whether the killings were justifiable. Dubus has a very unique style of writing, the main characters in “Killings” were given a choice that could’ve led them to a completely different outcome. Dubus keeps the readers on their toes because the opposite usually ends up happening.

    Read More

  • Daisy Buchanan Selfish Analysis

    776 Words  | 4 Pages

    He no more deserves to be shot than Myrtle deserves to be struck by a speeding car. Get mixed up with the Buchanans, and you end up dead” (Donaldson, On Possessions &

    Read More

  • Love In The Short Story, Killings, By Andre Dubus

    802 Words  | 4 Pages

    Mr.Fowler went out and ended up murdering the man who murdered his son. While reading the story the audience dominantly takes Frank 's father 's side on the situation rather than feeling the same way about the two murders. People seem to sway towards Mr.Fowlers side of the story because they say it was out of love, Richard Strout deserved it, and Frank was innocent unlike Mr. Strout. Love is the key to all relationships throughout the world. Love is what carries and drives people everyday to keep going.

    Read More

  • Suzanne Barakat End The Hate Analysis

    1329 Words  | 6 Pages

    By following her suggestions on how to end the hate, individuals can make a significant impact on their community. Suzanne begins by talking about her brother Deah and his wife who were shot along with Yusor’s sister Razan. Their neighbor knocked on their apartment door and after Deah answered it, the neighbor started shooting them. Suzanne was devastated because of the loss of her family members, but soon got upset when the police didn’t question the shooters confessed reasons for murdering them.

    Read More

  • To What Extent Is Killing Justified In Of Mice And Men

    508 Words  | 3 Pages

    Killing another seems very unjustifiable, which might be the case but when someone takes another 's life and sent to prison, death row or capital punishment is needed to put that person were they belong. People like that deserve to die because of their mistake of killing another and it deters other people to not kill others, showing them what would happen. In the case of Capital Punishment, Hunting for Sport, or George and Lennie, killing is a justifiable act. In the case of capital punishment killing is justified and needs to be done. For example, “Some crimes are so inherently evil they demand strict penalties up to and including death”(McClatchy).

    Read More

More about Not Justified In Andre Dubus 'Killings'

Open Document