ipl-logo

Nozick's Ethical Hedonism

1000 Words4 Pages

What Matters to Us? Ethical Hedonism explores the maximization of our pleasure and happiness as a fundamental obligation for morality; but Nozick’s experiment demonstrates that pleasure and happiness doesn’t only matter to us. This essay argues that Nozick’s thought experiment, the “experience machine” exemplifies the weaknesses of Ethical Hedonism, as perfecting the machine illustrates that to truly live our lives; we must value other matters besides pleasure. Firstly, this essay will discuss Nozick’s thought experiment “the experience machine” and what the experiment reveals. Secondly, reasonable objections to why I wouldn’t enter a machine that promises me maximal pleasure as Nozick identifies several issues exposed by the thought experiment. …show more content…

Primarily, he proposes that we “aspire to do certain things” (Nozick, 1974; pp 43) not just experience them. For example, I don’t just want the pleasure of consuming a cold ice cream cone; I actually want to eat one. The process of actions or its completion brings satisfaction and enhances our pleasure, which the machine robs us of. Moreover, as much as doing certain things creates pleasure and happiness, we “aspire to be a certain way” (Nozick, 1974; pp 43). We describe ourselves in terms of attributes; for example, am I caring or am I ruthless. Descriptions of ourselves or others are reflected in our individualized experiences and actions. Plugging into the machine hijacks our individual experiences of happiness and without these individualized moments, we lose what renders us who we are. Defining who we are is important to us and therefore, the machine makes us lose who we are. Finally, Nozick proposes that “plugging into an experience machine limits us to a man-made reality” (Nozick, 1974; pp 43). By placing ourselves in the machine, we attain no “real” contact with other people. The experience of virtually living cannot be compared to “living” life in reality as virtual reality doesn’t provide us with the same quality of “living”; since we’re social beings and instinctively we need other people in our lives to make them feel worthwhile. Therefore, these shortcomings, define in addition to pleasure what really matters to us leading to one rejecting to enter the machine, weakening the argument for Ethical

Show More
Related

  • An Open Letter To Coates Summary

    670 Words  | 3 Pages

    He expresses his beliefs about self-cultivated moral character, where he stated that if an individual look at him/herself as a victim he/her is failing to him/herself. It is not America failing the individual because the individual is not living the

    Read More

  • Summary Of Franzen's Liking Is For Cowards

    957 Words  | 4 Pages

    Franzen’s article Liking Is for Cowards, go for what hurt, compares the concept of love with techno-consumerism. It argues on how the grit of love is still better than the perfection of an elegant piece of technology which is also referred to as the perfect erotic relationship. The piece’s primary purpose is to make people understand the contrast between consumer related technology and real life and how this techno consumer relationship allows its user to control pretty much everything giving people a false sense of power while what love gives us is grit but it helps us become a better personas proven in the bird anecdote given by franzen. I agree with franzen in entirety and believe that the new tech-consumer world has us “working in jobs we don’t want to do to pay for the things we do not need”.

    Read More

  • Gratification In Brave New World

    942 Words  | 4 Pages

    Today’s society is one of instants: Instant downloads, instant messaging, instant shipping, instant oatmeal, instant movies, instant gratification. For many, the idea of having the world on a whim is a thrilling human achievement. For others, such as Paul Roberts and Aldous Huxley, this instant gratification is their nightmare. In Robert’s case, he theorizes that humans are designed to work hard and to struggle. By taking away any sort of effort and hardship, humans are being numbed, dumbed down and destructive.

    Read More

  • Technology In Rainbows End

    1065 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the novel Rainbows End, author Vernor Vinge depicts a futuristic world that is almost completely dependent on digital technology. Taking place in the year 2025, this “Digital Age” is home to many innovative advancements. Digital technology has become so omnipresent in the world Vinge creates that it has found its way into all aspects of daily life. The idea of a virtual reality where people no longer have to rely on their imagination has now become a normal part of everyday life. Scientific developments in areas including medicine are also a vital part of this society, and have a great impact on the novel’s characters.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Feminism

    968 Words  | 4 Pages

    It can be seen that cyberfeminism looks at technology as a agent for the separation of gender and gender inequality, as well as a way in which to join the body with machines. In a modern day society in which civilization is absorbed in technology and technological devices, culture slowly begins to get more adapted through technology, and modern day ways of thinking about the role of women in technology and society become more acceptable. " The virtuality of cyberspace is seen to spell the end of the naturalised, biological embodiment as the basis for gender difference. The internet is expressive of female ways of being, and thereby creates manifold opportunities for changing the woman - machine

    Read More

  • Essay 'Should We Let Computers Get Under Our Skins?'

    728 Words  | 3 Pages

    Moor: “Should We Let Computers Get Under Our Skins?” In the argumentative essay, “Should We Let Computers Get Under Our Skins?”, Moor argues that the era of cyborgs-part human and part computer-is coming whether we like it or not, but we should accept a policy of “responsible freedom” along with it. He argues against the thoughts of not allowing cyborgs. He thinks that instead of trying to fight and go against this coming of computer help, we should accept it but be aware of the things that come along with it. We should approach it with having the freedom to be able to decide whether we want computer implants or not, but also by being responsible in knowing the harms that could come with it.

    Read More

  • Always On Sherry Turgle Summary

    1375 Words  | 6 Pages

    Always On In this chapter Sherry Turkle discusses how new technologies have shaped the manner in which we interact with other individuals. Relationships have changed. In this new technological era, where one can remain online all time through various devices, Turkle wonders if being “on” effects the way we perceive others. Since our time is spent looking at screens, we are absent from what is happening in the real world. Instead of being aware of our surroundings, many are consumed by the many different possibilities that the Net provides.

    Read More

  • Illusion And Reality In Ayn Rand's Blade Runner

    972 Words  | 4 Pages

    The concept of simulation continues to boggle the mind as the morality of artificial creation versus the natural world spark debates among humanity. The interpretation on what makes up the philosophical search for the meaning of existence. Blade Runner provokes its audience into difficult assessments on the interpretation of reality, contemplating various themes on the struggle to identify one’s perception of humanity as well as the factors of distinction that separate illusion and reality. The nature of existence is, in fact, a byproduct of one’s subjective experience of that singular existence. Blade Runner showcases that the experience of one’s existence rests within the individual subjective experience of the simulation, emphasizing a manifestation

    Read More

  • Summary Of The IRL Fetish By Nathan Jurgenson

    1332 Words  | 6 Pages

    The rapid expansion of technological growth is immersing our culture. The Nathan Jurgenson’s “The IRL Fetish”, argues that people have weird obsessions about the offline. Technological advances allow people to experience the online, but Jurgenson realizes that people are also fetishizing the movement against the online. People and novelists who complain the online world laments, “Writer after writer laments the loss of a sense of disconnection, of boredom (now redeemed as a respite from anxious info-cravings) …” (Jurgenson 127).

    Read More

  • A Thing Like Me Analysis

    913 Words  | 4 Pages

    In “A Thing Like Me” by Nicholas Carr, even though it is not written, the author suggests that tools and technology are replacing human interactions and directly result in separation from the outside

    Read More

  • A Brave New World Essay: Truth And Happiness

    427 Words  | 2 Pages

    Truth and happiness are two things people desire, and in the novel, an impressive view of this dystopia’s two issues is described. In this society, people are created through cloning. The “World State” controls every aspect of the citizens lives to eliminate unhappiness. Happiness and truth are contradictory and incompatible, and this is another theme that is discussed in “Brave New World” (Huxley 131). In the world regulated by the government, its citizens have lost their freedom; instead, they are presented with pleasure and happiness in exchange.

    Read More

  • Into The Wild Ethical Analysis

    826 Words  | 4 Pages

    Chris McCandless, whose story is analyzed in Into the Wild, by Jon Krakauer, is a young adult who decides to leave his known habits and material belongings behind and live a completely self-sufficient life in the wilderness, a choice which ultimately leads to his death. In doing that, he also forfeits his family and friends. With that in mind, a question can be posed regarding the ethics of said behavior. As a childless, single and financially independent man, Chris McCandless has absolute ownership of his body and thus his decision to continue doing a sport that he knows can kill him is ethically defensible.

    Read More

  • Charles Fourier Utopian Society Summary

    839 Words  | 4 Pages

    He wants to create a utopian community with as much diversity between its people as possible. He says that the population within this community should consist “of from 1500 to 1600 persons of graduated degrees of fortune, age, character, of theoretical and practical knowledge” (193). In doing so will create a “greater number of variations either in passions or the faculties of the members” and in doing so will create a harmonious society.

    Read More

  • Utilitarianism In Business Ethics

    1685 Words  | 7 Pages

    The hedonic calculus has seven different criteria that must be considered to evaluate the balance between good and evil. This appears practical and easy to use in any situation; however, it has its issues. For example, Bentham suggested that all pleasure and pain should be measured equally. This causes a major problem when put into the context of business ethics, as it suggests that the pain experienced by a child forced to work in a factory is equal to a shareholder in a business gaining a little more profit – surely, this is unethical. J.S. Mill noticed this issue, introducing rule utilitarianism, in which he recognised the differences in different types of pleasures.

    Read More

  • Ethical Issues Of Technology Essay

    957 Words  | 4 Pages

    New technologies that people had never imagined a decade, or even some decades ago, are now expanding and changing all our lives. Taking smartphones as an example, people in old time had never imagined that small, tiny box could enable people to bring smart computer to everywhere. Yet, smartphones are now completely embedded into our lives and changed how we communicate. Technology lets us live simply, more conveniently, and more easily, but at the same time, it creates complex debates and controversies of ethical problems. In this world, where humans cannot live without the benefits of technology, it is impossible to ignore ethical problems.

    Read More

More about Nozick's Ethical Hedonism

Open Document